Which scholars held that music is permissible, and what did Imam Malik's school say?

transmitted from ignores owed to the Prophet by five narrations five chains and it stops with ignore most of on three different chains it has been brought in the books of people like if not be dunya my daily me but very happy in a Buddhahood in Hakim every single chain is criticized as weak Mucca Mucca it is every chain is Milan there isn't a single sahi hadith that you can bring in this pub Allah at least bring me a sahi hadith you're a selfie for God's sake

I'll quit wait he says I quote just random opinions is it let me see one moment one on momento por favor its parent miss Perriman just let me see let me see people write all these hadith this is a man choked a knee right in his nail or thought who is a great Mahadev a great scholar after bringing all the

hadith on music what God a gerbil mucho bassoon and those who said it's permissible music is unhappy animal cut the Alpha hajima I don't mean Azaria all Mauna Kea will Hannibal was Scheffer yeah he says but many people said many of the great scholars have declared all these hadith to be weak Allah rocket Academy makalah who even has him and he's brought the comments of even handsome wafak ala alika abu bakr if no are beefy kitabi he Allah calm and the dawn Maliki

bandulus right Abubakar Al Arabi the legendary judge from Muslim Spain has said let me a selfie Terry me shape there isn't a single hadith that is sahi in the prohibition of music he says because I leaked a total of a soil Missouri woman ah who fell under and has early work natal here and the great Mahad this hip Natalia right the great Mahad this right who set about what we call today as he has it and stuff like in who Lamia same in her - why not a

single letter from these a hadith Asahi one Murad obviously and we're talking about hadith going back to the messenger of allah otherwise nobody is an authority except God and His Messenger on matters of religion right so you bring to me what a line is messenger I have said in clear conclusive unbroken unblemished non blemished chains as I need and I will accept what you're saying it not hasn't says in whom low as Nadal hadith and why hidden if they

brought even one hadith on the prohibition of music for hawala very Rasul Allah they can only bring it to other than the prophet of God not to the prophet of God and he says well I heard Jaffee I had in tuna let me quote another Don Maliki al-fatiha knee whose commentary I have here by the way on right but it's all whose commentary has been brought into print and I'm waiting for his commentary on the result of ignorance a din Maliki fake to be brought out as well soon now far kahani says Lam alum I do not know fee Khattab Allah he will have his

Sunnah hadith in sahih and sorry Anthea her email Mela he I do not know a single clear hadith or wording in the Book of Allah or The Messenger of Allah his words that show that music um people people people people right now let me show some people by the way that have argued in its defense of things like music a mammal haramein says in his knee hyah

what not be done that be not like it but that they say from people have reported Abdul lightness obeyed the great sahabi he would have many kind of he would own many kind of singing and dancing girls that would sing and dance for him now alpha Roger us behind transmits from Hassan Abner Hassan apna sahabat that he would listen to music at four we transmits the Omer Abner Abdel Aziz this is show candy bringing this by the way the great Mahad is the omen

Abdul Aziz can a yes ma'am in jeopardy he cobbler Khalifa before he became the hail if he quotes by the way this person quotes American Abdul Aziz in his thing refutation against me look before he became Katy used to listen to music if NASA mommy says that Tahu's the great turbine student of it not bad so that has fine big no kotoba soluble inter I'm sorry bill Intel and the Cody of Medina the great kadhi of Medina from the tavern inside it may brahim would would would say that music is permissible rouhani from the Sharia transmits from

afar that the method above imam malik is a baja Talihina a bill massive is that music and musical instruments and singing is permissible he says that a file transmits that from the Maliki method al Asad Abu Mansoor al Zahrani transmitted from Imam Malik as well abu talib al Mackey in his cultural Club and Shobha 'innahu that he would announce Emmy Attenborough and musical instruments Phoebe Tillman jalapeno a morality tale measuring the great Mahadev I'm REE Drummond howl in his sermon Haledon honor in his house he would listen he could hear musical instruments being

played about father Laban a paw here in his book on the permissibility of music shows that that there was no dispute between the people of Medina that flutes and musical instruments were permissible and then if Natasha says this is what the law here unanimously went to and after we say Islamist elephant knuckle famous battle mark that nobody is there is no dispute about the great khadi of Medina before Imam Malik right Sardegna Brahim the great coffee from the table in Ibrahim if Mossad and him listening

to music and saying it's permissible there's no dispute about that right so these are some things I bring to you people some things Allahu Akbar so look when you want to refute me by all means refute me but at least bring the sahih hadith the only you could have brought stronger hadith than the one you brought the one you brought in El Elena young bitten me [ __ ] my young [ __ ] old man and buckle in Abu Daoud and ask him and a lamian upon my malice behind me and in a very happy and these books these are

incredibly weak a Chinese look dire for me to correct the Salafi on on hadith not being sorry it doesn't not nice you know this one no nice that helps is music Haram no look at