Reply to Abu Ibraheem (Salafi)- By Mufti Abu Layth al-Maliki

so a Salafi and known Salafi as in these is on YouTube known it cool refers to himself as I think The Exorcist so he's has something called diaries of an exorcist and his name is abu hast name I mean he's from Birmingham City from where I'm from and he's done this video so a few people sent it to me so I watched this video and it's the videos titled should we follow should we follow nifty Abu layth I thought nice could it be that this is a genuine

question about following me good and and then I slapped myself back into my senses and thought hell no of course not so I watch this i watch this video it's about an hour long right it's dedicated to me so I thought come on I owe him that much to at least watch a video dedicated to me [Laughter] so let's take so he goes through the clip and he says that look should we follow Mufti Abu Lane move T

he puts it in speech marks but I'm going to be fair let's be fair right he was an overall rude overall there were some digs that he made at me he referred to me acting like a clown or being a clown or a joker or things like this and and he made a statement like he has no knowledge okay which which I kind of I thought okay if you say so share Oh Stan I lamented there her surprise puppy who also if you say so so I thought that was a

dig but generally throughout his whole thing he did refer to me as Mufti and he didn't generally insult me or go for personal attacks so I give him credit for maintaining that kind of some-some sense of decency in in addressing me so okay so um rocky this Rocky's Exorcist a bow has name right now so he begins this thing by telling people he plays clips from my Monday

night with multi and then refutes them and he says that this guy is an absolute deviant I'm an absolute deviant and I'm a Shaitaan like I myself admit to being a Shaitaan and he says that he is just miss guiding people all he does is he reaffirms their whims and desires based on two things based on reason and based on science so he says that these two things and then sorry a third thing he finds some opinion within Islam to justify their

wishes for them so he says these three things are what this guy does and then he said that he has a big following I was like really I gotta say that pot played well into my ego while I people I would lie and act all humble but lying is Haram so he massaged my ego a little bit me I was like you know tea no tea you teasing me nothing so let's take a look at some of what he

said yeah so he begins by saying that look his beliefs are completely deviant and he called to a topic that I've discussed a question I've been asked in the past and the question is is the Quran created uncreated and I said that this the whole discussion is absurd which I stand by today and I say it's absurd so he he then pauses this and no sorry and in the clip I say that look there's been a difference of opinion people this discussion has no meaningful

outcome and skull is like show can you have said look it doesn't matter what a person believes because this discussion does can't even truly be understood nobody even understands what they're saying and I said look this discussion is just absurd leave it alone so he then follows up with his commentary and he says stuff and the guy's got a really long beard I'm not mocking the brother but it's probably about this long to be honest with you it's really long right so he's got like a really long beard and like a bald head I'm not mocking him but I'm just describing him

just so you got pictures right now he says that a star for the self of this Ummah they sacrificed so much for this belief I'm ready now and the tambourine in the sahaba taught them will you say it's absurd to the companions will you say it's absurd to the companions so I'd like to pause this here pause pause

companions did the companions say to you because the companions never even discussed Ikeda they never ever discussed that either so I'm going to first of all ask you can you bring me with the companions discussed that the Quran is created or uncreated

there is no such discussion people ever ever the quote he brought was the turba he's saying that the quran is the kalaam of allah the speech of allah nobody denies the quran being the speech of allah this discussion is to do with whether the Quran was created on created it was a useless discussion that was a political discussion that began in the time of Matt moon right it was useless it had no I mean it was just absolutely useless from in the time of Matt moon Madison and motivic him this is it the three

caliphs it was I had no outcome people didn't even understand if the Sahaba had spoken about this issue they wouldn't have been a discussion because people would have settled this the hadith the discussion over so they would be no discussion Imam Malik never spoke about it Abu Hanifa never spoke about this discussion didn't exist in their lifetime the seller of all the the Companions this the turban in their students and then these students at a better bring people like Imam Ali people like in my Mohammed who we love and respect are not from the sellers okay they are not from the set

of we love and respect him but he's not from the sellers so this discussion didn't happen during the sellers time so when you said so he said so many of the Sahaba taught this please bring me just one just one mwah-ha-ha-ha lake here ja ja simran ja Gigli apne zindagi go I'll wait here for you bring me just one narration from the Sahaba where they taught that the Quran was created or uncreated this dialogue didn't exist so

before you're about to refute me for calling something absurd at least to that much homework at least to them come on you can do better than you're better than that okay let's move on next point so he says that what I had to make some bullet points of what he's some of these main topics and just by the way before I move on from that topic just to explain this discussion was a political discussion it was I shared a talk in fact there's a really good book I recommend you read it's called early

inquisitions in Islam and it covers this topic so interestingly and people going on about matt bourne matt bourne the calif of the time he dies four months into this inquisition this inquisition lasts for 15 years imam ahmed is one of the early people what about the other years that goes on why was this such a big deal this debate had nothing to do really with belief this debate was to do with the fact right let me just explain this

this debate right was to do with the fact that the caliphs wanted to believe and establish that they are the greatest authority on earth they are god's shadow on earth they used to call themselves that the lorac man fell out that they are the shadow of god on earth now they there is no higher authority than them the caliphs had this kind of superiority complex just as the kings of europe called themselves divine that they would divinely chosen so somebody's had said that wait a minute but the quran is the word of God and the Word of

God is uncreated and you're a human and you are created so technically you are not the utmost so the caliphs kind of angle was that wait a minute no the Word of God which we have is also created and subject to interpretation by men and I am created and I am the authority of God the hand of God on earth so I reign supreme this is what the debate was about it was political he had nothing to do really with theological aspects and it doesn't mean anything because the must have which is a book the Koran which is a book everybody

knows that this book the must have is created you can't even understand what this debate is about that's why it is absurd ok moving on moving on right then he lowered what else does he say all right the beard the beard so this was one point point he brought up he says that look Multi appellate anything he wants to say he just brings up a quote of some scholar and he says that this color has said this so he brings my quote sorry my clip where I'm asked about the beard and I said look ah

the ER said where I'm asked about shaving the beard is it Haram and other yard said that that is not Haram in his commentary on side Muslim and I quote how many of the chef's area have said things like that as well he then says ho look huh the Prophet said huh the Prophet said grow your beard well here comes the second surprise you bring me just one hadith where the Prophet said how to have a beard just

one just one oh no oh no solamente just one my mom's asking you for one hadith the Prophet lived as a prophet for we're talking 22 to 23 years of his life teaching and preaching surely the beard is something that must have been so important allegedly bring me one hadith where the Prophet said how to have a beard not abnormal saying that trimming his beard saying I saw the

Prophet cut his beard here because many of the Arabs used to cut their beard here not just the Prophet that could have been done as a cultural aspect it could have been done as a as a personal preference the prophet's personal preference may have been to trim the beard here we did the Prophet once in one hadith teach people how to grow a beard you mean he never did that oh but I thought it was an obligate oh yeah it is an obligation but how do I do I mean do it how Schieffelin has explained

in the book how Sheikh bin baz has explained oh but but all you just quote ting scholars to me who you said I should be quoting scholars to you he not enmity you just are you doing the same thing back to me [Laughter] hamari believe hum come yellow that one so right so you're just quoting scholars back to me oh so your scholars are okay

but my skull is are wrong i cha cha cha [Laughter] this now can you see the absurdity in this Puritan East way of thinking now they say why do you why do you just quote one scholar from here or there tell me is truth a democracy do I need a numbers game for it to be true no truth can be even if one person said so why why why can that one person be

wrong why does it have to be wrong just because you claim to have a democracy why do I have to follow your democracy let's pick up another point that he said right o people music I won't go through so many just a few points music is something he picked up on he said a person is asking him and he plays my clip where somebody asks me about music and I said look there's nothing proven to categorically to demonstrate music is Haram

and I think that's what I say enough and yes I add that lyrics do not make something Haram so even if the words are talking or sexual or they're talking about things like fighting or things like that that does not make something happen I understand you may not want to listen to it or you may not want your children to listen to it but God hasn't declared it huh so there's a big difference here so he says let me stuff

you see brothers you see you see the dangers of following people with no knowledge the most ease in our day and age have no knowledge brothers they declare everything they just follow the whims and desires the prophet salallahu alayhi wasalam said that music is harmed in fact there is a hadith he said that there is a hadith that music that singing brings hypocrisy in the heart brings

hypocrisy in the heart the way water gives rise to vegetation Allah let me let me pause him me pause welcome back rocky exorcist g first of all let me quote this hadith to you in arabic allatheena young bitten me come on young bit old man bubble

bye bye Adi is this hadith has been transmitted he quoted from a promise owed it's being transmitted from ignores owed to the Prophet by five narrations five chains and it stops with ignore most of on three different chains it has been brought in the books of people like if not be duniya by Dayla me but very happy in a Buddhahood in Hakim every single chain is criticized as weak Mucca Mucca it is every chain is Milan there isn't a

single sahi hadith that you can bring in this pub Allah and bring me a Sahib you're a selfie for God's sake quit wait he says I quote just random opinions is it let me see one moment one on momento por favor it's parent miss Perriman just let me see let me see people write all these hadith this is a man

choked any right in his nail or thought who is a great Mahadev a great scholar after bringing all the hadith on music what God a gerbil mucho bassoon and those who said it's permissible music is unhappy enough at the Alpha hajima I don't mean Azaria all Mauna Kea well Hannibal was Scheffer yeah he says but many people said many of the great scholars have declared all these hadees to be weak Allah what Academy makalah who even has 'm and he's brought the comments of even

a handsome waffle a Celica abu bakr ignore our beefy kitabi he Allah cam and the Don Maliki of Al Andalus right Abu Bakr rippln Auto be the legendary judge from Muslim Spain has said let me a selfie Terry me shape there isn't a single hadith that is sahi in the prohibition of music he says worker's allocate all alavés oil reserve what nanaho fill under and has early work not ahead and the great Mahad this hip Natasha right the great maja death right

who set about what we call today and say Hasset and stuff like in who Lamia said mean her - worried not a single letter from these a hadith Asahi one Murad obviously and we're talking about hadith going back to the messenger of allah otherwise nobody is an authority except God and His Messenger on matters of religion right so you bring to me what a line is messenger I have said in clear conclusive unbroken unblemished non blemished chains as I need and I will accept what you're

saying if Nizam says in whom low as Nadal hadith and were hidden if they brought even one hadith on the prohibition of music for Huai Lahiri rustle Allah they can only bring it to other than the prophet of God not to the prophet of God and he says well I heard Jaffee I had in tuna let me quote another Don Maliki al-fatiha knee whose commentary I have here by the way on right but it's all whose commentary has been brought into print and I'm waiting for his commentary on the result of it

never is a ting Maliki fake to be brought out as well soon now far kahani says lam ya'lam i do not know if iike tabulae he will have his son not a hadith on sahi and sorry Anthea her email Milani I do not know a single clear hadith or wording in the book of Allah or The Messenger of Allah his words that show that music is Haram people people people people

right now let me show some people by the way that have argued in its defense of things like music a mammal haramein says in his knee hyah what not be done that be not like it but that the they say from people have reported Abdul lightness obeyed the great Sahabi he would have many kind of he would own many kind of singing and dancing girls that would sing and dance for him now alpha Roger us Baha'i transmits from

hassan ignor hassan apna turbit that he would listen to music at four we transmits that Omar apna Abdul Aziz this is show candy bringing this by the way the great Mahad is the American Abdul Aziz can a yes ma'am in jeopardy he cobbler Halawa before he became the hail if he quotes by the way this person quotes American Abdul Aziz in his thing refutation against me look before he became Katie used to listen to music if Nizam army says that Tahu's the great turban student of it not birth so that has fine biblical Tabor Sahib all inter I'm Sahib

Olympia and the quality of Medina the great cardi of Medina from the tavern inside it may brahim would say would would say that music is permissible rouhani from the shelf area transmits from afar that the method above imam malik is a baja Talihina a bill massive is that music and musical instruments and singing is permissible he says that a file transmits that from the Maliki method al Asad Abu Mansoor al Fulani transmitted from Imam Malik as well abu talib al Mackey in his cultural Club and Shobha Anna who that he would announce Emmy Attenborough and musical

instruments Phoebe Tillman jalapeno a morality tale mature in the great mahadji's I'm Rivermen Hal in his sermon Haledon honor in his house he would listen he could hear musical instruments being played about father lay beneath or hear in his book on the permissibility of musics shows that that there is no dispute between the people of medina that flutes and musical instruments were permissible and then if Natasha says this is what the law here unanimously went to and Anthony says left elephant knuckle famous but at work that nobody is there is no dispute about the great

khadi of medina before imam malik right sodomy I brought him the great kadhi from the table in Ibrahim if Mossad and him listening to music and saying it's permissible there's no dispute about that right so these are some things I bring to you people some things Allahu Akbar so look when you want to refute me by all means refute me but at least bring the sahih hadith the only here you could have brought stronger hadith than the one you've brought the one you

brought in El Elena young Bataan me my you meet old man and buckle in Abu Daoud and ask him and day lamian upon my malice behind me and in a very happy and these books these are incredibly weak a Chinese look dire for me to correct the Salafi on Sun hadith not being sorry it doesn't not nice you know this one no nice right let's go on let's go on

he then says okay now he brings an issue he brings a question that I'm asked about anal sex where somebody asks me and I crack a joke about it so he says that look at this person's laughing and mocking and cracking jokes and is this how the people of God are spoiled supposed to be is this how they are sophiana thorry rahim allah would say that you know any quotes of yon authority who i love by the ways of the

uh authority so first point before we go on to the main point Sophie Anatole what a person you chose voila this is a godsend you know from all the examples he could have chosen he chooses Sophie an authority Sophie an authority was so known for his sense of humor that when he would laugh he would fall over on the floor stamping his feet and that's what was known about him so thank you for quoting Sophie Anatole because I think I'm in good company here because if so the any thought he was

here both me and him would be laughing our heads off but let's sorry I digress I digress sorry sorry so sorry we're yeah let's come back to the point right so let's write so he speaks about I'm asked a question about anal sex right and as I often am asked on my live and unrestricted

huh what a pain in the butt of an issue on Raw I'm asked this question and I say that look there has been a difference of opinion on this matter right there has been a difference of opinion on this matter although the majority of so this is what I'm saying first of all I I crack a joke in a laugh because the person says instead of asking me anal sex he says I know to annul something so I crack a joke about annulling things and she's quite funny actually I have to say watching myself

back right I kind of became a true fan of myself but anyway so it was actually quite funny and I think if he didn't enjoy that humor then he must be living a miserable life I gotta say gotta say so anyway beyond the jokes I then answer the question by saying I then answer the question by saying look majority of the older model though they saw this Haram there's a difference of opinion many Maliki's did not consider this Haram other Maliki's did and there's been a debate on the matter

something I said there's narrations going back to it not all are saying anal sex is not Haram but many scholars dislike this based on Hygiene and I quote how call the yard transmits from some people and and as amongst them if you remember those of you who watched my previous episodes and I was introducing some of the books it's not here now so and I was speaking about one of the great greatest hadith scholars of Muslim Spain Abu Muhammad Allah sealy I who brought back revived Buhari in Muslim Spain and he's from the kind of prototypes of people is over a

thousand years ago and he's like from the prototypes of people I kidnapped aboard the kind of 4runners to them now he began to teach Buhari from a fig perspective but he is also one of those scholars who considered anal sex not to be Haram but discouraged it and I mentioned how car the yard mentions these people and he says that look and this was more a hygiene kind of thing you have to remember as well the day and age they lived in and stuff like this so when I finish sorry so when I even finishes that clip and he says

josematube no Sabbat transmits from the messenger of allah salallahu alayhi wasalam that the Prophet said that if you have sexual intercourse with your wife in her anus I'm just quoting him sorry for the language people but in her anus then God will not look at you on the day of judgment and then he says Abu Huraira Rabi Allahu and says that the Prophet cursed

the man who has sexual intercourse with his wife in her anus so he says look this person I quote to you the clear words of the messenger of God and this person quotes these scholars now first of all I want us to pause here pause pause let's pause the Exorcist for a moment I just want to say here I did not say to people go about rampantly having anal sex I did not say that anyway right

what I said was there was a difference of opinion in the matter that's what I said now let's come back to his point so The Messenger of Allah said and well it looks like Wistar always stuck here are we stuck hmm let's take a little assistance oh let's go back to the great scholar of hadith amount show kami in his name oppa Oh which is by the way a commentary on

certain hadith collected by eminent a Mia's grandfather the Munter which is called moontak al akbar which was a hadith from mainly from Bihari Muslim and then other books as well but let's go to this commentary here and this discussion o josematube Nasser bit let's read the Arabic for his heavy that the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam haha and yet SIA Raja Raja who fee Dubuis had in his words that you know that you cannot have

anal intercourse and it's transmitted in the book of admit Muslim Ahmed and even imagine what I'll also tell him is that he didn't mention that by the way but I'm telling you where it it's also transmitted by Manish FA but it's chain has somebody called over it not haha Oh Omar this over ignore hey ha is not an acceptable narrator nobody knows who he is oh wait wait wait wait wait wait let me help him let me help

but there's another chain that Imam necessary brings by somebody called har me of the law maybe this will be of some help Oh nobody knows who her me is either Oh [Laughter] bye-bye fadeev oh wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait he also quoted a hadith from Abu Huraira let me quote that ADIZ Abu Hurairah said The Messenger of Allah said my own man a time rotten man a time

rotten feed uber eheh that and he's trans translated it fine that's who so transmitted in the most of ahmed abu dawood and that allah will not look at a person who does that well hmm this has been transmitted by the books of sunan and bazaar let me help him let me help oh but it's chained has Al heard al her signal mullet and if not upon and bizarre said we ain't got a clue who he is

[Laughter] wait a minute but then it's transmitted through other narrations Oh but even Adi has said is not to hold life it's not goodbye Eve [Music] [Laughter] but wait a minute if maja Jeff said we've got a stronger chain for it let's be fair let's be fair people let's be fair even a Hodja said in his car in his balloon maram we've got a stronger chain for that hadith oh no they've got a stronger chain for the

hadith oh but it's Moosa oh it's Musa morsel means it's not a connected chain which makes it life oh wait wait wait wait wait wait buddy brought a second Eddy of Abu Huraira let's help him with the second one second one yeah take the second one from us take you from us generosity our Muslim brothers take it from us from Abu Huraira whosoever has anal intercourse then he

has disbelieved in what has been revealed to the Prophet Muhammad transmitted by Ahmed and tell me the Abu Dawood okay cool have we helped him out we've helped him people we've helped him oh but who's transmitting it from a Beretta Apple to me my my oh my who is this a puta Mima oh wait a minute Buhari says we don't know that about Tommy MA has any transmission from from Abu Huraira

Bazaar says hadith or Mucca Mucca by Adi Oh what does that famous debate to say when he's debating a selfie he says OHS I've had this hollow volley Wahhabi oh why why why on the Wahabis why are the selfies quoting by hadith and he doesn't feel right I have to correct you for your wickedy yeah this one not nice this on this one too

much it no feels good you know I look like I the modernist you look like the Salafi naughty-naughty you tried it lets me fail let's be fair he tried he tried it yeah gosh if only he brought me a CD if only he broke is this war I'm up against [Laughter] so

so as you can see people this is the kind of stuff when people want to do a refutation by all means refute me refute me I'm here to be refuted I'm just sitting here for you to review me by all means but know that there will be for every herself I'll catch of alcohol gababa there will be a response

and lest you are arrogant and forget the verse of God what Fokker could leave the al-amin Halim and above each person of knowledge is somebody of greater knowledge so do not be deceived by these kind of looks or this necklace so this I don't know the t-shirt and think that you can quote life hadith to me and somehow get away with it falsely attributed nonsense to the

Messenger of God have you no shame where is your love the Prophet said man Casimir I am what I am me then valia taboo mock Idaho mean enough he who attributes a lie to me let him prepare for damnation I mean that's a Sahib yes I got a say and then telling people that look oh you know he does this to to kind of for

the whims and desires of people who am I to conceal the knowledge of this theme Who am I and he says that oh he just tells people what they want to hear he's misguided his deviant he's he's astray is fallen a la la I'm fallen don't you worry about me falling that is not your concern wherever wherever I fall I

shall fall in his grace it is nothing to do with you it is not your concern Fira Mattila i shall fall if i fall so the point is look you and any of anybody else out there is most welcome to prove concepts prove me wrong but bring me categorical evidences from the kitab it was sooner and prove your point and let me respond so anyway i thought that was worth some

some some attention after all the brother took an entire hour out oh and he said about Rukia he said about Rukia that this person the mufti claims that the Quran is not a cure for diseases and he claims that these are just rituals and it is not a cure for diseases or illnesses and the mufti goes against the verse of the Quran one who knows a luminal karana

mawashi fuh have i disbelieved in the verse of the quran for a moment i got concerned but then i thought let me read the remaining part of the verse for I have once read in a hadith that the Prophet was approached by people and when they read to him they placed their hand the Jewish people they place their hand on the other verse so he couldn't

see the remaining verse so the Prophet said move your hand and read the entire he naughty naughty finish the verse I'll be I'll give heart read on ma read one Nunez aluminum al-shifa we reveal from the Quran what is the Shiva lamothe is solo for the heart for the heart the Quran is a Shiva

for the diseases the spiritual diseases of the heart that a lie saying that am I saying tawba tawba so what the what how can how can I say I would want I would want to agree with you but the Word of God yeah so not only do we see you quoting life IDs blaspheming by miss attributing them to the Messenger of Allah you're cutting and pasting the Word of God to now

chopping and pasting no no no no no yeah we had better hopes for you we had better hopes so the Quran is a shiver for spiritual not for if a person has cancer you don't say I know let's sit down and read the Quran in the cancer will go away the Prophet never taught you to do that the Prophet said in a hadith to Dawa the Prophet said that I will seek medicine go out then seek medicine

you are meant to seek medicine you're meant to medicate you meant to go and do these things this if you're not supposed to sit around and start just oh the person's got a brain tumor I know let's all recite a surah of the Quran and then check if it's disappeared what on earth is wrong with you that nobody has said that and God knows certainly as not so pleased first you miss attributed words to the prophet of God and now you miss attributed words to God himself tawba tawba

not even the messenger and God are safe from their words and misattributions so thank you so how could people like me be safe [Laughter] [Music] Josh I said toot Cargill forever pertaining here those leaves that just fly off the kind

of branches and fall we are not such in on do sacado Sarah or Pat Mary tell these storms to stay in the lane recognize recognize your worth don't aim too high

other than that nothing but love ok MA for taking the time out to address me right I am charmed right and so for that I I hope this has been helpful in me educating you and other people as well so other than that people