Recordings › Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth
Monday Nights with Mufti #179 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth
salat salaah namaz salaat namaaz as-salah al-salah salawat zakah zakaat zakah al-mal zakat al-mal obligatory charity hajj haj hadj hadeeth ahadith ahaadeeth hadees ahaadith saheeh saheeh hadith sound hadith malik ibn anas malik bin anas imam maalik imam malik ibn anas al-bukhari imam bukhari sahih al-bukhari sahih bukhari saheeh al-bukhari saheeh bukhari imam al-bukhari imaam imams prayer leader ka'bah ka'ba kaabah shari'ah shariat sharee'ah maaliki malikite malikiyyah qiyas qiyaas hukm ahkam hukum hukam ahkaam halaal permitted lawful haraam mubah mubaah fard farz faraid fard ayn fard kifayah fardh sunna sunnat sunan prophetic practice dalil daleel adillah adilla ribaa sood usury isnad sanad isnaad asanid hasan hadith hasan li-ghayrihi hasan li-dhatihi hasan sahih saheeh muslim imam muslim muslim ibn al-hajjaj kufr kuffar kaafir kufar kaafirun disbelief imaan eemaan eeman jahanam jahannum koran quraan al-quran ayah aya ayat ayaat aayah aayat makki and madani makki madani meccan makki surah madani surah sahabah sahaba sahabi sahabiyyah sahabiyat hijrah hijra hijrat migration khalifah khalifa khulafa khilafah khilafat caliphate khilafa mecca makka mekka madinah al-madinah madeenah yathrib ahl al-sunnah ahl as-sunnah ahlus sunnah ahl al-sunna sunnis shiah shiite shi'i twelver ithna ashari salafism wahabi wahhabism 'alim aalim ulema ulamaa shaikh sheik shuyukh shaykhs dawa dawat da'ee invitation umma ummat community nikkah nikaah nikah nama nikahnama talaaq triple talaq talak hijaab hejab hijabi alhamdulilah al-hamdu lillah alhumdulillah alhamdulillaah hamdulillah salam as-salamu alaykum assalamu alaikum assalamualaikum salaams salam alaykum wa alaykum as-salam greeting niyyah niyah niyat niyya niyyat shukr shukar shukur amanah amana amaanah amanat al-din ad-deen ad-din ibadah ibada ibaadah ibadat rahmah rahma rahmatlive stream · 3:01:06 · 20,000 views · 24 Aug 2020 · 40 segments · Open on YouTube
40 segments
machine40Each block is a segment in time order. Click to open it.Latest answers · the most recent segment on 1 topic
Earlier answers and other segments · in time order
Transcript
machineauto-transcribed, may contain errors · source: youtube auto · click a time to seek · dotted terms open the glossaryall right all right all right in alhamdulillah foreign what
is going down wrong day yeah i thought you know technically this still makes monday doesn't it it's monday nights but it's the other night oh i'm too confused people what it is is that i wasn't going to be able to do it tomorrow night plans people plans
you have to uh you have to understand so i thought why not then what is going down um what's going on with the youtube people what happened with gangut delhi hi we're going to talk about that just a little later on today of rise somebody says okay tell us what plans
yeah oh i can't be telling people all my plans and things i gotta keep people in the let there be mystery people let there be mystery it's sunday yeah it's technically monday now you see so this is why i thought you know what let's push it to monday let's let it go past midnight and then i'll start so what is going on people what is going on so much to uh to cover
so many things some somebody said did you pray [Laughter] uh it's amazing isn't it the preoccupations people have with other people with other people's kind of like worship right so what is who is getting two live streams are there two live streams
ah let me take a look there shouldn't be two live streams how is there two live streams going on can i see anything from here let me go back into manage uh live now it should just be one really [Music] um same one yep i take it yep so i i can only see one on here i don't know right so people
clear you're doing it you're doing it with the stars on facebook let me bring up uh usually tune in tuesday morning right so i will be speaking a bit about uh i will be speaking a bit about david woods as well so what i'll be taking a look at today i'll look i speak a bit about the whole david woods uh i i mean i can comment on some shaman as well the whole muhammad hijab thing um that whole flare up and david woods tearing up the quran
thing i'll take a look at uae and israel people israel the the the neo-nazi state [Laughter] right who have no uh dignity or humanity left to the um you know just left but i'll be taking a look at that uh commenting on the what do i think of the whole new relations what is my analysis on it jello since everybody's giving an analysis i might as well give one as well
in addition to that gangutili we have to look at gangutili um a bit about the charities as well but taking your questions people so let's begin as always and i know last week for some reason there was an issue with the sound when i was playing a video so let's take a look at that let's go to uh as always initiate with the people and let's see if it's coming
through [Applause] [Music] foreign
[Music] [Laughter] people's peoples so you can see from the okay the sound's playing fine that's good good too good to know that is important and those of you that ain't familiar with the latest uh i did upload
and i'll be speaking a little bit about this later on foreign and the aftermath we'll take a look at that but let's come right back what have we got here let me just adjust this youtube chat it's taking up some that's better all right so right what is going on somebody asked um is music permissible
oh music yeah you're still stuck on that [Laughter] yeah you're still stuck on uh music huh you know the thing is this look people of course first of all of course music is permissible but you see look how mukta how
just summarized our time in this dunya is really when you think about it now from a perspective i understand qualitatively may it is still a long time but i'm just saying when you look at it you think whoa is that it allah has placed you in this world to enjoy it doesn't mean you see yeah i understand people will say oh does that mean no it doesn't mean that there are certain rules of course but you see you'll be surprised to know
that allah has not made nowhere near as many things haram for you that you yourselves have made haram upon yourselves as allah mentions in the quran that it was bani israel who made the things haram upon themselves and it was not and then because of that they were then stuck with them so people they make these rulings they follow this kind of like sectarian talk they get stuck they're not allowed to disagree
they live an entire lifetime like that i look at music music is it is the nourishment of the soul people allah for a person to have deprived him or herself of music their entire life only to you know maybe at a later age in life maybe when the 60 70 maybe to realize that you know
to realize that maybe what i've lived my whole life has been a lie in the words of khalif that you know that a day of such a regret is in and of itself so regrettable so people do not you know limit yourselves to the to the bizarre limitations placed by sex
and certain clergymen use use that in there and i want to say that i um i watched a a clip of our one of our beloveds the jar with a small d but i watched this clip of sheikh yasir khadi and in it he's uh he's trying to justify himself and you know i'll tell you something this is a sign of insecure men insecure people
they often go far and beyond over and beyond in trying to justify themselves you know you need a bit of like backbone to you you understand when you like i understand in certain context you justify something but to over express a justification always you know you're always seeking and like the forgiveness
you know have some dignity man but so anyway watch this clip but in this clip it's not like he was uh seeking compassion but maybe he was but he was shaykh was saying that oh you know i've and he was trying to explain to the public it's on youtube i saw it last week actually he says you know i i've in my entire life teaching life of islam i've only ever followed positions that like of of ulama
and i've never come up with a position uh myself ever and you know from one perspective people might say you know [Music] [Laughter] from one perspective you might you might think you one has to ask are you see basically what you're saying what you're saying
is you have never had an original thought in your entire life to do within this faith which you've never ever nothing has occurred to you originally ever [Laughter] what have you been studying for why don't you just you know if all right so if that's been your studies in islam as a teacher of islam remember this isn't a student like this is a teacher of islam because this
got a bit blurry ah that's better right so then you might as well just pack up sharp and i don't know you might as well just open a fish and chip shop basically what you're saying is i've never had leadership qualities ever in my islamic profession i am nothing but a follower and as humble as that may sound it just you know it's a complete disservice to people their own training and profession so i
feel sometimes look tikka everybody has to blag a little bit you know keep it cool man keep it cool so right let's take a look at some questions what is going on samuel e man you're doing it with the super chat is that you though is that you must do do you oh no that's a different question he sends a super chat i'm reading somebody else's question why don't you think bank interest is riba
well sami that is a good question why man what to say man look i've got a very detailed video i'm not gonna do it justice right now um watch my video i'll say something in summary but watch my video it's about 45 minutes or something so you'll get an explanation by the end of that if you search riba mortgages loans keywords it'll come up now
the quran does not address interest today to be ripper the question isn't why don't i think this interest is very bad the real question is why do you think it is because when you start to look into it you start to realize well where does your definition of rebar actually come from and it's incredibly confusing the moment you begin riba in essence just means something extra you know so allah says that this that this it will
something just to increase something that ribba in arabic now really that would mean giving anything extra would be haram but then you realize oh in islam it actually doesn't work like that you know i could i could swap you one phone for two phones identical this is what is this s10 i could give you an s10 for two s10s is that now river no party in islam say riba
i could give you one house for two houses one car for three cars ah this one big problem so the question is hmm what is rebar you say oh but it's for the same product you got me but then i say okay in that case if i borrow some sugar from you today as a neighbor you know those people remember those people who don't do this are no
good so if i borrow some flour from you or some as neighbors do some especially in rural parts of the world or borrow some sugar tomorrow i just return a certain amount of sugar i take some i say i'm gonna return it so i take two scoops let's say whatever that is tomorrow i give some scoops are they the same amount [Laughter]
the question is then is why is that not revised now the same same thing we're talking about same product um food as well you might say oh but reba okay what if it's to do with dates [Music] then i say to you okay but what about the hadith of the uh of the harass you say what's that and where the person uh comes to the prophet the harassum the people who would estimate so they would say so you've got a bunch
of dates you need them to be sold today but you you know you've got more in the trees uh date trees but you haven't got the time to take them off so you say to someone look i'll tell you what you just do a quick trade how about these baskets of dates for you know you you give me these you can take mine on the trees now the question is that's permissible wait wait a bit extra bit extra what do the [Â __Â ] say up to an entire
third can be off so you have a margin of error for up to 33 percent [Laughter] big problems [Laughter] i want to know you know here everything seems to be permissible [Laughter] so river is just on money [Music]
[Laughter] ah and the irony is the hadith actually doesn't it's stressing that it's not on money it's more on the products anyway watch my video hope that helps right people right inaudible much appreciated for saying uh those people tuning in this is why yeah i should make let me there you go here there you go look at that it has been upgraded
right you got mod status there you go let people know anybody asking right when will you bring ismael kasam saying mufti when will you bring ahmadis on mine trap now yeah sure why not why not now okay bye my right so right there's a question on there was a question on consciousness there's super chat have i missed it let me see i can see it here handsome hound
you're doing it some people define intoxication as an inability to differentiate night from day in other words loss of consciousness how is it different from psychedelics whoa there's a few super chats i haven't seen here wait here let me oh let me come back to that question i want to talk about it so a woman women want a divorce from cheating husbands is it automatic no he's not contactable for over a year and hola cost money yeah i mean unfortunately there are
processes for aid the lock where a woman goes through they are granted but you you're right they will cost that is you see the problem with because we live in a day and age of documentation you see it won't usually masjids at the time of future nikkas will ask you if you've been married before and if you state yes they will ask you for proof of your talaq so they will ask for a certificate
um now not having that in most masjids would mean that they won't conduct any care it's like asking for your proof of id you know they will ask for have you got proof of id and i understand these things do cost unfortunately but uh yeah that uh there's not much i can really add to that it is um fortunate i guess g hey but it is the way it's like when people get married they get a nikka certificate and they pay so much to do a nicara and but these things on the on the flip side these are not things that you will be doing so often in life
you will probably do this maybe once in your entire life maybe twice it's not actually something that's so repetitive generally speaking some e has super chatted you do and it you do and it is a quick question related to that is a decree absolute enough no it isn't usually so a civil divorce is not an islamic divorce and a civil marriage is not an islamic marriage per se they can have overlaps but they're not uh technically uh by default they do not cover it they
you see saying that but when he did the civil divorce he had the intention of talaq and thereby it triggers would now be dependent contingent to his upon his declaration that he did that and then there's other problems you see because husbands talks this is another thing that sometimes people don't know they are that means they can revoke them and cancel them and they can do that without telling the other party so this is why it is always better to get objective talks like that sharia councils give because
they give what are in which are irrevocable you can they cannot be cancelled right so moving on um some e you're doing it you're doing it right with the super chat are the ah hadith right are the ah hadith in general
you see i'm not so sure that they're against the absence because the hadith actually mentioned that the mahdi's army i'm pretty sure they mentioned the mahdi's army will be coming with the black flags so i don't think they would have served auntie uh if anything they were part and parcel of the abbasid propaganda because horace is where um abu muslim and all you know the great abbasi revolution begins
in and he emerges abu muslim and these other people they they emerge from there um that and then later on often is the story by the way often often often that they are later betrayed by their own by their own leaders and killed off because they seen as too talented [Laughter] this is like you know when they say you're too qualified for the job so what they would do in the past is they would just kill them off afterwards
uh because they're too too this one too talented so this uh this is a danger as well sometimes being too talented is dangerous [Laughter] right let's go to the next question some people write okay now abdul r has super chatted you do and abdullah much love right so um mufti can you speak about soul mates and
twin flames what are twin flames yeah twin flames calculate [Laughter] right those terms are really common now i've not hmm maybe i'm just not in uh i i'm too too old now i'm just a relic it's like [Music] as gangutely says he's ended my career [Laughter]
we're gonna come to that later on so is the sticker thing what sticker thing is the sticker all right it's gone i've lost the uh my twin
twin flame right so mufti when you say music is halal because there is no sahih hadith to make it haram however what of the living tradition would that not indicate prohibition no not necessarily in fact what's interesting you see what's interesting is even though imam malik i accept he didn't like music but there's a difference you see people not liking something is based on their temperament but what is interesting is medina was known
for people having an inc a proclivity an interest in musical instruments in the city of medina after the prophet's life it was known for that in fact the saying was that it became proverbial that a proverb that do not ask that people that disagreed with it said do not ask madina on music because they will just say it's halal and do not ask about alcohol or the other the nabeed because they will just say it's hala this became a saying so it's interesting you mentioned the
living tradition thing chad man you're doing it you're doing it henna as always you're doing it all right ismael p are you doing huh drop in the p the super chat i have tried dmt and it was amazing welcome welcome to a different caravan
but i'm wondering what the islamic view on psychedelics is and you are open to trying it and your opinion so i'll i'll take this question now because it joins in with the other super chat that was sent by uh handsome hound so both on psychedelics so as far as my personal thing what i'm i'm let me just forget about my personal thing
let me just tell you my general uh teachings on this i say that these things are illegality so obviously keeping the legality in into in mind but in certain parts of the world they are not illegal so i'm speaking not from a legality perspective that people can look in their own you know localities regions parts of the world wherever they are i'm speaking from a religious perspective i am a keen advocate of psychedelics
i feel that as entheogens i refer to them as entheogens things by which one can connect to the divine and discover aspects of the which i feel is consciousness by taking a portal into dimensions that exist but you would never know that they exist and they exist in ways that are more real than this very world that exists in front of us but what i'm saying now just sounds crazy that's all i can say is
[Laughter] you see this it would sound crazy but that's that's like socrates coming back into the cave you see and he tells the people that you know outside the cave there is this world and this is nothing there is a real world there is real light so those of you that ain't familiar i'm sure all of you are familiar with the allegory of the cave but those of you that ain't let me share it with you briefly so plato relates that socrates taught them he said that he gives an allegory this kind of like a
metaphor story metaphorical story he says that there are people that are trapped in this cave they have just lived and died and you know had children and they've just grown up lived and died in this cave they've all they've ever known is this cave and what they do is they are kind of enslaved or whatever they are in prison but they're held up to face this wall and behind them is a large fire but they can't see the fire they can just see that you know they they can see this light
around them and they can see shadows that are casted onto the wall in front of them that are their shadows and the shadows of the flames but also between them and the fire there is like a bridge on which workers are passing by so they're going this side that side and they're carrying objects so these are casting a an illustrious kind of shadow on the wall so
what the people of the cave they become they have their games but they're not games but their world where they become so talented at defining these shadows and they can even predict now they have certain formulas in which they can predict what these what the next object will be and some of them are right and some are better than others and they can say well the next object will be like this and he'll have this thing and he'll have that and what happens is one day one of these men breaks free so they kind of held up pinned to only look forward
so he breaks free when he turns around he sees a fire and he's kind of almost blinded and shocked by this fire because these people don't know that those shadows are coming from a fire that's all they've ever known he then just about escaping gets out of the cage and then is a cave sorry and then is blinded by the sunlight after his eyes acclimate acclimate after they adjust to the sunlight he sees that there's a world outside
and this cave is really that's all it is so he comes back in to tell his fellow companions that there is actually a world outside these shadows don't even have a reality they are not real objects they are shadows being casted by people walking on bridges on the bridge now people mock him and they call him crazy and because his eyes haven't truly adjusted to the dark yet he's no longer good at the game of detecting shadows so socrates
in plato's version is that man who's telling them but anyway see like the allegory of the cave i tell you that i tell you people [Laughter] it's also us right so that this psychedelics is i feel if done well not you see i'm not interested in these things as recreation as kind of oh having fun and it's about them opening up a portal to discovering
reality so i'm a huge advocate of that i don't feel it's haram and yes it does alter certain your states of mind you see to me it's not altering although i understand that's how some people would argue i would feel it's more about opening expanding your reality it's about having this portal so we it's we view things differently put it like that so yeah dmt of course is you know the is the daddy
the spirit molecule cool so and yes some one may argue that oh if that's the case then you know oh if a person was experiencing something then they couldn't praise salah like one could argue i mean firstly i think you could praise a lot to be fair uh but okay on certain things you couldn't i suppose it feels a very lengthy ayahuasca kind of thing but then pray your salah before we'll pray after
you have to pray then [Laughter] yeah but that doesn't make it haram automatically the fact that you um the fact that you can't you can pray your salah i feel but the fact that you don't want to be praying your salah or you're not at an optimum pace to be praying your salah let's say is not the problem that's like getting sleep you know when you're sleeping you can't pray so it's sleeping you know it's a it's ridiculous just because you're doing something which takes a while
uh it doesn't mean that oh now oh if it was salah time at this then going to work oh but i go to work and that let's say some people you know they can't pray at certain times so or anything that is going to prevent a certain time so you just work around that it doesn't make that thing automatically haram just because if it coincides with prayer time it would preclude block let's say prayer time or your capacity to pray or your ability to pray doesn't necessitate that it's a haram thing per se intoxication this is not intoxication
it's not in toxic i disagree that i i mean people can disagree with me but i i won't see this as an intoxication alcohol is a depressant it is not psychedelic alcohol anybody who says that hasn't actually studied psychology they haven't studied the chemicals they've got no idea what they're talking about alcohol is a depressant it is not a stimulant and it is not a psychoactive element psychoactive elements are different they act differently on the brain okay so they are not depressants and they are not um but anyway this isn't a lesson
on cello let's move on right so what is going on are you doing the debating are you doing the debating man we're doing the debating man is this the guy who says you saying you nothing not alcohol is a drug you can't change what's haram period i agree but you show me where it says uh that these things are haram where it says
uh things like mushrooms or things like um dmt's haram you show me where it says that it doesn't say that in the quran doesn't say that in the sunnah now you're going to say oh but i want to use an analogy so you want us to go by your brain ah i thought you said the book of allah is complete it's complete but there's a few appendixes appendices that we have to kind of add
ah so what happened to the verse tibiana li kulishi was allah kind of hinging that verse on your understanding and then in that case why should i go with your understanding why not my own after all i'm going to be asked about me i'm not going to be asked about you so in my understanding it's fine there you go what what more [Laughter] yeah so what do you think about chef hasan farhan al-maliki's current position or what right now
okay google show us shaykh farhan's current position [Laughter] what's his current position i don't know what that means what what does that mean right so let's go to some there's some super chats uh lil saf has super chatted you doing it little stuff you doing why do mulvey say beating saves them from punishment of hell yeah that's a dumb
absolutely dumb that is stupid i'm not going to let you get the chance [Laughter] right so that's what movies come up with oh you know wherever you took beats from the mulvisab uh the fire of jahannam will not touch that spot a cha cha did your dad like the fire of jahannam that it's going to obey you [Laughter] fire of jahannam ah the way these people speak it's like they feel
they act as though they have this is you know it's it it's like as if it's their personal family legacy islam that is absolute nonsense okay it is not you're not allowed to beat people like that and you know something people say this is now so you know you could go back who is the and in that time like think about it 1200 1100 years ago yeah things would be horrific one could imagine 1100 years ago people not talking about like just 20 years ago
thirty years ago eleven hundred muhammad ibn has a book on adam he has a book on the etiquettes and the rules of teaching and he does in that day and age you can imagine there was disciplining that people used to do that culturally he speaks about how to even in those cases these were extreme measures and something slight he says but anything forceful and so on to a child he declares then to be haram and look how
ancient that is this is categorically wrong the way they beat the hell out of the children it's it's horrific you know it's not if you if you've ever witnessed it [Laughter] it's like where where i did heath of the quran boy they used to beat the hell out of the students man honestly to break sticks on them i mean thank god they never ever hit me like i just i don't know how i would have reacted
because um it's utterly unacceptable i mean they never ever did to me i suppose i was they saw me as uh quite senior even though there were other people i suppose my age but they maybe it was the fact that i came from the uk or plus because i'd studied in damascus i used to speak arabic with the other teachers and the teachers used to refer some of them referred to me as sheikh for example even though i wasn't a sheikh at that time but just because of my arabic and stuff like this so maybe because of all of that they just
kind of had this i had this kind of aura of respect uh so they never ever treated me disrespectfully uh even when they got really angry with me i remember a teacher flipped once um at me but even then he never he just was really you know he just said something to him but he never tried anything with me to to hit me or something but i used to see what he used to do in the class man he would break the sticks and he used to say that like let's say it was a wednesday he would say so they've got it's like saying like
sunday markets wednesday so in that part of town they used to have a special like a wednesday markets market kind of day or like we have sunday markets here so he used to say that and you just go around wow bang boy the stick would break give me another stick bang bang bang whoa it was crazy man and it's categorically haram these things all right so what is going on
is it forbidden to hit your children if they don't pray you see i would say that this hadith if you're taking if you try to take that hadith literally you have misunderstood the prophet sallallahu alaihi um and i find that very disappointing that a person over faith would attack their own child that's to me so absurd it is the antithesis of faith to attack your child because of your iman [Laughter]
since god had given you so much iman if he gave you a little bit of akal as well intellect that would have helped so that's ridiculous if your faith makes you beat up your own child you see these things were just trying to teach you the the kind of important something hard that you would inculcate the the hopefully the passion for something the love for something
that they will children emulate their appearance anyway you know when parents pray children pray they do stuff and if they don't they don't they will start praying later on you know and if they do but to teach them through look this is what we do to express gratitude is the way to encourage to show it's dear to you because children especially when they're young they want to the parents to be pleased with them and they like what the parents like so but to to kind of scare them into that i think it's it's ironically so childish
and if anything the antithesis of islam somebody said they saw my nanaji show you're doing it you're doing it i did uh write i did uh uh some of my jokes were slightly i think uh adult version so he i think he edited i did say to him look i think these jokes might be a bit too much so you can edit them i think he did in the end he was like uh uh drop that
will you invite mahareen bake to your podcast mahareen bake is that the uh one from that muslim show the queen marine is that her or is this a different one yeah who's a teacher or something sure i mean i'm not quite sure what she does now and what we chat about but message me let me know what she's up to and yeah why not you can ask her
right so super chat otherwise i want my my super chat a new with my super chat i can't see my super chat oh there it is rock black says mufti regarding zakat there is a specific amount you until you are obligated to pay the card but shouldn't it be on every country a different amount um
that's interesting never really thought about it like that i suppose you could okay look i'm gonna share something with you right you know zakat in all honesty the laws of zakat especially when it comes to money the monetary side of things they weren't really laid out so clearly in islam because the arabs although they had obviously gold and silver but they heavily traded with livestock
and with uh they bartered now gold and silver were not their main commodities so where you have a lot of teachings about you know in every five camels you give one sheep and you do this and for this many cows one can give this or these kind of a hadith that you will you will find
the you don't really the hadith to do with things like how much nissab what is the the kind of the trigger amount the kind of the the uh the trigger switch for zakat so once your savings reach a certain amount it is triggered as the cut now becomes applicable so people will say you know 20 dinars which was 200 dirhams because in the prophet's time a dinar is a gold piece and it comes from the roman dinari or daenerys and dirham was a silver piece and
ten silver pieces equated to one golden piece so and the dirham comes from the persian sassanids drachma because they were more in they kind of had more of the silver thing so now this this teaching that oh in 200 dirhams or in 20 dinars your zakat starts you know the nisab starts and so on you'll be surprised that there is no real sahih hadith to do with any of this stuff um it in fact all the hadith are weak but the scholars just accepted it
because they needed a system and it was better than nothing because otherwise they would be totally inventing it so one could argue they you know somebody may have even invented that because it's a weaker these but it's just a system that was needed so yeah otherwise it seems to be that although zakat obviously is important about giving it's difficult sometimes from the pure quranic literature sorry the pure quranic
reading it's difficult clearly discerning zakat from charity just giving in charity it's difficult because even the verse of the quran is the verse used what that people say this is where zakat is given and it's it seems to because zakat means a purification so what you definitely see in the prophet's time there is this understanding of an of obligated charity giving in charity
but the specificities are still slightly vague in some things they're not that clear and certain people are giving zakat um but is everybody giving it in the prophet's lifetime it definitely doesn't seem so um later on it solidifies so in a wakka radilla who's time it definitely becomes the you know the livestock and all of this definitely becomes a thing that everybody is now mandated to give and then within the generations that come the money thing becomes a thing because more money
appears people start it becomes a more important commodity but it didn't really there's no sahih hadith for so it's interesting to know that but i agree with you that these things should be con region like they should be relevant to your own region yes so somebody says give zakat it's mandatory no of course it is but what i'm trying to say is at some level of reading in the quran it's difficult discerning like delineating demarcating
like drawing a line between charity and zakat like is it just one and are they the same thing does it just mean giving charity now i know the general understanding is it doesn't and i'm not saying it does mean just giving charity i'm not saying that there is this thing of zakat i'm not denying zakat i am saying it is there but to be fair in all fairness if we're just being fair in the quran the quranic reading of it's it's difficult discerning are they the same it's not that clear
and in the prophet's lifetime itself because zakat is only one year before the prophet passes so in that year how many things were established for zakat you know you think about it it's it's the prophet only receives zakat one year that's it and then in fact within so many months it's not even a full year within so many months he passes away so how many rules of zakat were established and how many people were paying zakat to the prophet definitely definitely not all of them i would argue maybe you know out of the whole of the arabian
peninsula i would assume maybe about 40 percent were paying something like that they weren't i would assume that the majority of arabia was not paying um but or maybe 50 50 percent was but it becomes difficult again distinguishing between what they were giving as gifts and the cut because so yeah it's a complicated topic really but yet okay that's the raw material then you've got you fast forward a couple of generations um like let's say 150 years uh after the profit and you've got set systems in place okay with this you know
this is going to be like this you've got camels you've got wheat we're going to do it like this we're going to do this we're going to take it from here we're going to do that if you've got gold we're going to do this this is what triggers the circuit there's complete systems in place fully developed systems i'm not saying the systems are problematic i'm just saying we must remember that a lot a lot of these systematization part is really man-made it's just done by scholars to set a system because not having a system meant they couldn't control things whereas if you have a system you know exactly what to ask and you know exactly what to record
so that's what i'm saying okay so based on that making adjustments with zakat uh like somebody saying look shouldn't it be more regional shouldn't it be like this that makes sense to me i'm just saying it does make sense to me okay cool let's see that's my had this throat sore throat people so could paying taxes cover the obligation of zakat yeah and sami shukran for the super chat i i do believe that paying taxes could today
if a person paid taxes and throughout a year made it a practice a personal practice to give charity sporadically on different occasions just in life that they do give charity they make it a personal aim i feel that suffices for zakat but if a person doesn't give any charity um then i would um i think now i think the person should there is an obligation to give uh be involved in chat at some points throughout the year it doesn't have to be like every week every month every month if
it'd be nice if it's every month but it doesn't have to be a soul huge but they could give a certain amount certain amount here but they are they do have an art of giving to them that is in my understanding and if you pay taxes it would suffice for zakat sore throat is there a fever loss of taste and smell no no no i've had my coronavirus in the beginning right so right what's going on what's going on people people people what's the
i was gonna cover a few things actually i can't see anyway i can't see it cool must have scribbled something i can't mufti your view on giving sadaqah's protection against something bad sure sure why not why not i mean look always think of it like this the better you are as a person you will in that sense
betterness will come to you okay if you give allah will give you you know so you know have compassion on people and mercy on the earth and the one above will have mercy on you so i feel that of course and i have at times i personally experienced this and i think charity begins at home you know in that sense although charity is used in english as a almost as a dirty word sometimes you know oh my god charity case or give charity but
you know it's not like the the the beauty about the arabic word sadaka is it's not a negative word it's not a it comes it's linked with the word sid truthfulness it's linked with the word you know friendly a friend sadaka friendship you know it's it's a very positive word and sadaka begins at home it begins with the with the family i would say if you if your family members or you feel that they are in need begin with them help them financially and then pan out you know like you can spread out other
things people maybe you see things like this uh help people and i've seen at times that you know i might be like oh something's happening and i'm thinking oh my god and i've given in a state of you know like in a hadith it says that you know is like kind of like like kind of this kind of greed or this kind of uh it's not greed is a bad word but like this kind of you'll fear sorry
uh that you you're fearing poverty in the sense that you could have like let's say i've got all these finances to cover and and now i've got you know let's say an opportunity to to give some money and i'm thinking oh but i don't know because right now i've got all of this and i found that sometimes when you give in those situations and it's kind of testing of your character it's testing you i have seen and it's you see i can't demonstrate cause and effect here but i can just say that you feel it that what comes to you
suddenly and you know unexpectedly is so much so many times more um honestly i would definitely say that so uh yeah there's a whole art to this and so i would definitely um support that right uh rojan mahmood what are your thoughts on nowadays muslim scholars completely lacking secular education yeah but even yeah of course and then sometimes they don't they have the secular education if i uh have a clip here example
of i think some muslims can have doubts about the last how many brothers is the muslim world and the brothers in the west are asking one whole world not one by the way how do we get muslims to accept homosexuality and the gay and trans lifestyle the answer to this question is clear for them because they have used a strategy to get america and europe to accept lgbt two gay media strategists marshall kirk and hunter madsen [Laughter]
you know daniel is somebody who is educated in secular studies he's been to harvard i believe or so yet he is a prime example of somebody so obsessed i don't know what it is with the americans you know some americans are so obsessed with the lgbtqi whatever the initials are right they're so obsessed with them like oh my god islam is the last bastion the final frontier to stand to withstand
homosexuality muslims have you been to any muslim countries [Laughter] oh my god trust me they have long embraced this tradition i'll tell you you've got no idea don't know what kind of a cuckoo world you're living in right so because it's it's so i don't know what he's on about saudi arabia bloody hell it's a gay haven you know it's this is what is he on about i don't know what these countries are ridiculous
you know the taliban afghanistan the whole bachabazi thing you've got in many other muslim countries the most sought searched after porn the most porn searches for gay porn comes from places like pakistan and saudi arabia and you know some of the most hardcore islamist kind of uh people and ideas and cultures where they where they are in that sense that's where you're gonna find this i don't and okay but that's not my point
of discussion my point of discussion is why are these people so obsessed you know everything is like ah the lgbtq are after us the lgbt just calm down calm yourself [Laughter] look to me the way i see these things look people who are gonna be gay are gonna be gay okay it doesn't look they're here and they're here to stay now they if that's their way of life then as
imam malik said that's the way of life who are we to interfere what's our problem at the end of the day if somebody wants something done to them in a particular way you know this was the arabic poem it says
hahaha that aptly fits here it says and people have in you know in matters of what they love their ways but madahim is also a kind of place you go so it kind of fits a bit better here but the point is yeah so look just because let's say 10 people there are gay i'm not gonna it doesn't make turn you gay
i don't know why people are so worried they're like oh my god this is it must be contagious it's like calm down they're going on going on going on always just you know just just like every single time just ranting on and on about people being gay it's like this is you know in just psychology 101 this is symptomatic i'm just saying from a psychoanalytic perspective of people who actually are most likely to be themselves homosexual that that are that
you know rattled by i hate to say that but anyways [Music] because anyhow after all of this if anyhow after all of this danny boy comes out of the closet and says something like he's gay i'm just saying i'm not saying if you're watching this i'm not saying you are going to do but anyhow you do that
this one not nice my friends right so let's but you're right this rujan said what about people who are the opposite they completely lack um somebody said it's not uh projection yeah you see what it is is that in psychology they will find that people who um what they tend to do is they are chastising their inner demons so people often hate something strongly
that subconsciously reminds them of something within them this is often like jungian analysis and psychoanalysis and other things often will speak of this this is nothing new really and people will project and then chastise that demon so something i hate i may project it on to somebody else who has it or see amplify it and then it's not that i'm projecting the thing because in this case the other person is already gay he's not projecting the homosexuality on them but what he's doing
is he's chastising his own demons vicariously virtually okay ah right so so what is going on people what about pedophilia we normalize that too well i hope we don't um that that is just absolutely utterly unacceptable and discussed in that i've got a clip here actually uh a discussion if i
can see it ask did prophet muhammad beast upon him marry a child was this a normal practice 1400 years ago what was the wisdom behind it according to authentic sources prophet muhammad peace be upon him married when she was six years old and the man i would like you to take a look at this however it is important to understand things in their historical context for instance it would be silly to ask what kind of milk did they drink 1400 years ago or to ask what kind of engine they used to have back then therefore one must understand that things 1400 years ago were very different from now time have changed and so human have fourteen hundred years ago it
was very common for women to marry at a young age it is a historical fact that girls from ages 9 to 14 were married off in europe asia africa and america for example sam augustine 350 a.d he married a 10 year old king richard ii 1400 a.d he married a seven-year-old henry viii 1500 a.d he married at six years old right so as you can see they're saying king richard ii king henry viii and blah blah blah right what is utterly absurd and so
ridiculously stupid about this is people thinking they are doing islam a favor by saying well do you know king richard ii did this do you know king henry viii did this well he chopped the heads off so many of his wives or whatever right why on earth it is blasphemous i feel as a muslim to be comparing the prophet to king henry viii or king richard ii or whoever it is why are you comparing
these people why are you to the prophet and that makes it okay just because king henry viii did it who the hell is king henry viii just because king richard ii did it the this you know what is so dumb i'll tell you this is so stupid and it gets on my nerves they think this is some kind of a legitimate argument like i'm going to get into a debate with an islamophobe and he's going to say oh oh your prophet was a pedophile because you're saying and i'm going to say
well actually king richard ii and king henry viii they'll be like i don't give a rat you know they'll be like i don't give a damn about king henry viii they'll be like well he was a pedophile as well the point is they don't care this is not your you see this is where muslims are so dumb sometimes in they're so used to muslim bulimics so in muslim debates the way they win a debate is they uh what they'll do is they'll try to quote
a an opinion of that imam so somebody trying to debate me is going to try which they do all the time ah but a maliki scholar said oh you're stuck now because you're maliki this is a maliki scholar so imagine i'm saying something i'm maliki i followed the maliki school the school of medina they're going to say oh but you know let's catch him out imam malik said this ha caught you out caught you up so when people are debating salafis they will say sometimes oh even a tamiya said this hahahaha caught you out caught you out now you can't come back so the muslims get so lost in this dumb
bubble they think the world operates like that okay okay news flash nobody gives a damn about your stupid bulimics because in the real world nobody plays that game okay that's just you and your two loser uh muslim friends in a corner sitting there just playing this stupid game of how to debate that's not how it works in the real world okay here by you trying to say ahahahaha but you're english so there was a person in english history who did this ha
and they're thinking you want me like sorry are you drunk like i don't give a damn if somebody 300 years ago in england did this it's wrong they're not bound by these stupid little by rules that you guys have made these in-house rules so first of all this is the dumbest most stupid attempt to ever save face for the prophet by trying to compare him to richard ii and king henry viii right that is as far i personally find it blasphemous and an insult and an affront to the honor of the prophet
sallallahu alaihi sallam that you're trying to redeem him by trying to say oh but look at king henry viii because nothing to do with king henry the eighth okay and nobody claims king henry viii was a prophet from god and people that may admire let's say rich king richard ii they don't say he was a prophet from god they don't say he was infallible they don't say oh he couldn't make mistake you know whether they murdered people people will just say yeah okay they murdered people and so i just want to get that out the way the other thing is the prophet did not marry isis at such a young age
you need to get off your stupid horse whatever it is that you're so caught up on just because your sectarian scholars won't from their position right you need to think for yourself see the evidence and realize that look it's true this hadith is fabricated it's been fabricated by hisham all the people that transmit it are iraqi all the people that are transmitting this hadith at a lower level where the people from the books of the books get it from
are all iraqi how is this ashara the allah never lived in iraq where is this it's all coming from hashem and then they are some of them are projecting their chains they're making them up it is unex how can this be like you tell me were they not muslims in makkah and medina 200 years after the prophet of course they were why is it by when this hadith starts to get popularized about 200 years after the prophet every single transmitter
is just an iraqi how how does that make sense that's like there's an incident in let's say there's an incident in you could this is how it is almost because back then see travel wasn't as easy so you could take the example to be like this let's say there's an incident that occurs in in germany in berlin but yet generations later people want to find out about it and the only people let's say there's 50 people that speak about it there's a hundred people that speak about it but the hundred people that speak about
it are all from birmingham uk all of them no german 100 years later is speaking about it no you know somebody closer to germany everybody as far you know as distant as the uk and birmingham this particular place particular region this is who the transmitters are everybody they could be 100 of us but we're all from here now are you stupid not to see that wait a minute alarm bells should be ringing how can that be right so 200 years later the only people who
seem to be know this story all happen to live in iraq a cha-cha you know this is the this is the problem but the the reason they don't accept these is because if they accept this the salafis the wahhabis and the the kind of like um you see like the kind of neo-wahhabis as well the kind of like the theophandies the problem with them is they would have to admit that the hadith literature is corrupted and that is a problem because to them that could
then cause later problems now yes some other sects like the railways don't openly criticize it either but that's not because you see they're so worried about the hadith literature that's because they don't feel they have the competence to criticize hadith because groups like the sects like the brilli sect are just usually very poorly trained in hadith so they feel that this forte is too it's above our pay grade to speak about bukhari and stuff like this because they're not even known for their studies on bukhari so whereas the deer when these are
the selfies are but they are invested in that project so to them it's like well it's not worth it so they will never do that um they will never turn away from their project i tell you they will for the love of their teachers to not disagree with their teachers and their sect they will throw the prophet under the bus and they will just make up some oh it doesn't matter she was a little it doesn't matter oh it's okay but they will not for once say their own teachers were wrong this is the kind of blind the
blind hearted following that they do their hearts are sealed i'm telling you these people they will not have the courage to say that their teachers have got it wrong but they will in essence except that the prophet is hello you know he he was doing it it doesn't you know look at that like they prepared to not compromise the honor of their teachers in this sect but the honor of the prophet isn't that important to them they'll just justify they'll just be like yeah so this is where i you know i i tell people that look when your
scholars tell you this completely ignore them they are chatting they're chatting it absolutely nothing but blind dogman just they're just sheep in this statement they are just sheep to their own sect and scholars they will never disagree never um so yeah i hope i had to kind of say that because these things just disappoint me whenever i see them i think yeah but you can you can just take a look at it and you see it hmm
every single person iraqi come on a cha-cha-cha iraq where was the prophet where is he rock a cha-cha yeah so right so uh what's going on some questions have i missed some how can she claim aisha's imagination then i don't know what that means
uh right so right what is going on somebody saying confused right my guns are out you're doing it zebra you're doing it right people do not be speaking nonsense in the comments please no kind of uh insults right so what else is there right let's go to um i did have here if i can get to it
with my [Music] [Music] foreign [Music] foreign
[Music] foreign [Music] [Music]
[Music] [Music] [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music]
[Music] [Music]
[Music] you know i i always i feel that poets are the last bastion in the muslim world for human compassion and ethics seriously and and kind of free thought without restriction it really lies in the it's the dominion belongs to the so absolutely allah
right people but what i was going to speak about um is actually this so we've got here if i i'm trying to so i don't know if you've seen um seen the david woods i'll try and refresh it you feel
yeah so you can see here this is what happened do you really do you really think that's the quran you really do you really think that you want to go this route now i will say that i i i found that utterly uh disgusting despicable
um and it's a shame because i was just asked last week and i did comment about this on twitter i was asked last week about david woods and i said look i haven't really watched much of him but i've seen that he's been respectful to me and i respect him for that now within a couple of days i saw this clip and i was really honestly if anything i was just disappointed these things you know ripping the quran it doesn't look me as a person it doesn't hurt me like offend me like
like as muslims i don't feel we should get kind of like enraged but we it's if anything it just disappoints it hurts from the angle that it disappoints you that you know because look you can you can tear the quran it's not going to destroy it's not going to harm a single here or a single it's not going to harm an atom of islam islam has stood the test of time it is here and it is here to stay now the quran does not
it is not protected in the sense by it is not protected by just being printed it is not it does not reside or exist relying on print although obviously that's you know a huge part of how we access the quran the quran is memorized by people literally millions around the globe have memorized the quran it's not it's something that we hold obviously dear to us constitutionally yeah so whether people know the ins or outs of the quran is a different discussion whether they know the individual verses
but the quran as al-kitab is held very dear now if somebody takes a mushaf and says ah i'm going to set it on fire tiger you know okay you're gonna do that like it doesn't harm me it doesn't harm the ummah it doesn't harm islam what we should not do what we should not do and anybody about to or reacting in that way this is my words to them first and foremost do not ever become enraged with these things okay anger is the most predictable of all human emotions
okay do not allow yourself to become angry if anything disappointed okay that you because you see and why it was disappointing for me is because these things kill dialogue then because you realize that there's no respect left now you know that this is uh so based on that it kills like it ruins any bridges of dialogue and communication and in all honesty we wouldn't burn any book like uh you know i wouldn't just
i could have a storybook i wouldn't just rip that and tear it up and do stuff like this it wouldn't you know what point is is that and then why would this is obviously a sacred book so and i do want to be fair look i said last week that i always advise people and this is how i've been taught as well that we respect religious symbols with respect and dignity now somebody did say to me yeah but you have satirized certain things and certain beliefs and certain peoples and i have but i'm speaking about symbols like actual like if somebody
was to say this isn't but let's say this is the torah for example or this it happens to be a something of a hindu scripture book or something like the actual symbols that people have it's akin to the way in this day and age let's say we might take the mick out of a certain country you might say oh this country's weird it's like this or look at america he thinks he can do this hahaha or look at russia is like this or you might say oh look at pakistan oh my god it's
like then he's taking the mick out of it now firstly i feel that humor has no pounds and a person can take the mick out of whatever they want i do accept that but you see that's saying one thing and then if i let's say i was to take the mick out of pakistan or to take the mick out of russia or america or china but then imagine somebody was to burn the flag these are two separate things they're not perceived the same it is seen as a very like obviously these are seen as symbols
of actual things that the people like when you're taking the mick out of a country people will not like you for it and some people might and they'll understand you're trying to be funny or you're trying to do this or whatever but they will still see a huge difference if you between that and you taking a flag of that country and setting it on fire it takes it to a whole new level so i just want to clarify that look i i mean i absolutely
absolutely advise first of all muslims and people generally that we have to always respect symbols okay it's just it's the way of the world okay this is how and and in turn our symbols are respected as well but it's just out of humanity and civility secondly my express my deep kind of disappointment at david woods for doing that um and really add apostate profit as well for laughing his head off i do believe i could be wrong but uh from what i've heard um abdullah sameer had no idea that that
was gonna happen and he didn't actually approve of it although i don't i mean i just watched that clip i don't know whether he actually expresses it on that clip or but i heard allahu allah maybe i've heard wrong but i've heard that he didn't approve of that and he didn't know that was gonna happen um and in the clip i saw i haven't watched i don't know what happens after that but the clip i saw he doesn't kind of laugh at it or anything but uh apostate prophet is kind of laughing his head off that oh my god he's ripping the quran and i feel that this is exactly the problem okay
and this is you know and then you've got what muhammad but i want to say here as well about muhammad hijab look listen part of this is a triggered reaction to what muhammad hijab has been doing so look i i want to say here that look this is growing because it's like tit-for-tat you see like you're you're kind of taunting them they're taunting you you start bringing their family into it they start you start saying to you know sexual stuff at his wife he now
doesn't know about your wife to say back to you so he thinks well what do you hold sacred to you you hold the quran sacred i know let's rip the quran you see so there is a certain responsibility coming back on you you know on muhammad hijab because you are triggering these people you know allah
that these people will then curse allah that this is because this is what you do like you i know that you're not telling them and you wouldn't ever be content with that happening but you are triggering this so i did play a speech of muhammad hijab last week some muslims can have doubts about it i don't get it but then you have muslims say i have got doubts i don't know and this can't be quiet have some guts be a man stop being a slave of your entities come on it's an inferiority complex why
some people have been calling me and giving me some uh uh emails brother i have doubts what counts man what embarrassment is that why you have doubts why so tell me now you find any manuscript in the whole wide world in the whole wide world oh you've played this last week but i think the volume was i was playing what does it do for me nothing if the heart possibly was abrogated possibly for us what what's the problem i don't understand why you have doubts what kind of man are you anyway what kind of woman are you what kind of muslim are you what kind of muslim are here just be honest about the situation putting
doubts in that one's hearts and that one's mind and this one's soul be quiet in mind this is all in our tradition we have so we we have a chain of narration yes we have a chain of narration tell me now how an orientalist has any argument against the quran the preservation of quran tell me how yes for instance you have not read anything david would you have not written a damn thing what are you reading is why all you get your information from is me i'm your teacher boy and all of you people i'm your teacher
and you know it don't pretend to be our teacher you have nothing on us you have no you know nothing don't ever don't ever come and step up to us or lie all of you and i know you're listening to me i'm shaking you need to use the toilet now i know you do now listen listen carefully and i want you to all listen i know the enemies of islam are listening to me let me take my glasses off let would be very scared just like apus was very scared many of them would be very scared because you know when we come to the truth and the haqq when we come with the truth and the hack and the and and all of the details like this what are we going to do what are you
going to do there's a company to all those people out there the christians how dead talk about preservation it actually makes me angry listen to what he said not as stupid running around the street speakers caught up talking nonsense no chain don't speak to me don't speak about islam don't ever open your mouth about islam again don't open your mouth don't ever open your mouth you have no chain and a lot of you are losing faith and you shouldn't know the christians lose faith i tell you lose faith it's better for you because it's the nonsense you have no chain of narration no change and you're comparing with all audacity
because of this so wow so my point is that look you've so somebody i read in a comment somebody's saying that muhammad hijab may have apologized for part of this i don't know if he has if he has okay good but um right the the point is that you see this is what triggers this don't trigger these people like that don't kind of attack them like that don't attack their wives and stuff like this look it's not this isn't what islam teaches anyway what i would say is
attack their arguments make them make their arguments look silly make their arguments look dumb that's that's fine but you know if if it gets like personal because all that's going to happen they're going to come out now they're going to do something stupid like silly like try and rip the quran now some idiots gonna get obviously so enraged he might you never know what he might do to them and this isn't this is not what islam teaches okay so even though that's really they need to think about their own actions they you know they're responsible if you're gonna do something so stupid you need to think about what
you're doing it's a sacrilege to what you know over a billion people hold sacred but still you know let's not trigger something like that either so cool i just wanted to make that clear um right now another topic people another topic so we've got uh right something a bit more uh unfortunately dark and unfortunate that what israel has been doing for almost you know the most part of two weeks now
it's been bombing dropping uh crazy bombs on gaza um not many people as you can see there speaking about it but amidst all of that you have got um if i we've got something uh that a lot of people have been speaking about and that is the uae and the israel deal which has been broken recently to recognize israel and with it you will see
if i can just bring up here uh right just one moment right uh trump is expecting ksa i don't know if that's true but he's expecting ksa to sign up to that deal as well pretty soon kingdom of saudi arabia that is so whether they will or not allah but um that's just to so what is going on here what are my thoughts about this so first and foremost my daughters heartfelt
my thoughts uh go out to all those people who've been unfortunately who have suffered the lot first of all the loss of life or the loss of loved ones or just harm and injury as a result of what's been going on in the past two weeks so you know may allah make things easy right as far as the uae thing is concerned a lot of people have been messaging me as well almost the you know you speak about this what are your thoughts yeah i mean first of all
i just want to say about people are going at sheikh abdullah bin bayer and they're going at hamza yusuf i do think that's a bit unfair to to be honest i think that's not not a bit that is i do think it's unfair um because i don't think in all honesty the the kind of king the ruler of uae really gives a crap i don't really think he even cares about what sheikh abdullah bin bayer has to say about anything whether he may pretend on certain things
but they don't really care i don't think they they will just have people you know hold a council on something and i did hear that this is what i've heard from sources close to sheikh abdullah that sheikh abdullah wasn't actually pleased about the treaty but he had just agreed in saying that when the king has passed a ruling then that king's ruling so the uh the uae his ruling is to be honored um not that he was happy with what the kind of details were in fact or this
is what i've heard allahu allah i don't know whatever i've just heard this but i do think okay with putting that aside i do think look the king doesn't really care these people don't care about what ulama or scholars or whatever and i don't think hamza yusuf had anything to do with it at all so i think just dragging his name into it i don't think is fair this is just my opinion as far as this actual ruling what what do i think about it well look oh look it's israel is not go right okay israel
is a at a state level it is a terrorist at a state level okay this is not anti-semitism i'm not against jewish people um i you know i'm not against people whatever ethnicity they are the truth is at a state level it has committed war crimes and this is something the un are aware of this is something people have written about many people have written about this norm chomsky so many other academics have written uh finkelstein so many people have highlighted the atrocities
that the state of israel has conducted against uh vulnerable really for the most part very vulnerable palestinians so i don't think this is going to really do anything like i understand the uae's proposal is that by presenting this we can broker some peace in the region but in all honesty if you look at since this deal has been signed what peace has there been you know there's been like almost two weeks just bombardment uh okay they claim that hamas has been
setting off these incendiary kind of like balloons helium balloons that kind of go and catch fire somewhere and and they said we're gonna fire we've now got a policy that any fire is to be treated as a rocket so we will retaliate with by any incendiary device like if you send anything with the fire over here like let's say technically it could be like okay petrol bomb if i chuck a petrol bomb let's say uh into israel if the palestinians did then that is technically to be treated any fire is to be treated as a missile
so what that means is this projectile this is a missile a flying kind of fire so it will be retaliated with a missile you know sorry it's not funny but it's the crazy absurdity that makes one kind of like laugh in just confusion of what the other person is saying here like you're like um like what are you actually just saying like did you do you hear yourself like you're saying well missile is this a projectile it's something that comes flying
and any fire that so these balloons helium balloons which come and you know they're coming they're incendiary so they cause fire so it will now be treated as a missile and we will retaliate with a a state you know state-of-the-art actual missile uh highly destructive i mean
and it is it is just a shame for the sheer loss of life and i don't know how the palestinians function honestly i can't even imagine i can't i would be lying if i said i could even imagine how they actually still function because i as a person i would assume one would just have given up on everything but yeah i don't think the uae thing is a solution i don't think so because it clearly hasn't broken any peace you know if you're going to be honest
it hasn't broken anything no peace has happened and i don't really think it matters but the truth is we there does need to be a solution that is true as well another very hard truth is that israel is here to stay i think we as muslims have to accept that that israel is here to stay and as unfortunate as it is and as you know it's like like they say you know put a stone on your heart in certain
languages the proverbial in this case to to you know to to kind of like we have to bite the bullet and take the dagger and we have to just accept that it is what it is you see israel is not going to go away and it is established and it is the so now the question is how do you move forward so i would argue that um i would actually say i know nobody would accept this because i would say the ideal thing would be to have then a two-state solution which i think would never
happen because israel in its state of mind would never accept it because they know the moment we accept that they will just oh the assumption sorry not that they know the assumption is if we give them a state where they can fly in fly out do whatever they want they will just set up so much armory and then they'll just attack us so we're never going to let that happen so that's one thing the other thing is that so ideally it ought to become two-state solution but i feel that that's never going to happen i then would argue
for a complete exile of all palestinians i would say that all palestinians should leave palestine and it should be facilitated for them sorry by palestine i mean the gaza strip and and the parts that are um kind of blocked in clearly by israel now i feel that they should be relocated and comfortably with compensation and accommodation and education paid for in different parts of the arab world
arabic speaking world so acclimatizing is not difficult for them and they shouldn't be set up as ghettos or clusters but kind of spread out and there's many arab countries in the world and i'm sure that that could even happen and israel probably would even be happy to pay for it because the amount of money it spends on even bombing them is these things don't come cheap so but the problem with this thought that or this kind of a solution is one people people will coward shame the palestinians you see
you know the way people do things like they shame one another you hear things like they i think i was discussing the other day where people will kind of shame sometimes men shaming men women shaming women there's this kind of thing of like oh you so you have these terms sometimes like [Â __Â ] shaming and this kind of stuff muslims do that to palestinians muslims do it what they do is they guilt-trip them like you guys have to stay there and you have to put up with these because this is the holy land you're defending
some somebody said like arab countries wouldn't even take them but this is what i'm saying if there was a deal to not as refugees see they won't take refugees but if they came in at a level like if if you had a middle class kind of and they were spread out spread thin so you don't create ghettos you so if if you if you had a middle-class apartment fully paid for in in in another city like let's say in tunis somewhere some and you've got compensation you've got money in the bank you can just move right in and continue to live a lifestyle like that countries would accept you if
you came in with money and it was broken as a deal they won't accept you as a refugee because you're just a burden to them so yeah but coming back to my point that muslims guilt trip these palestinians secondly there's a lot of politics you know there's arab countries are happy that palestine is between them and israel because it creates a buffer zone because if israel was to just take over that completely then they would be the next target for israel so they would rather that the next guy is getting beaten up and they're just at a safe distance saying
[Music] as opposed to saying uh oh you know it's like so jordan and these other countries are glad that there is this buffer zone so there's a lot of politics going on here people but i honestly feel that and even this whole thing i know that's my people won't agree with me on the whole jerusalem thing but to me jerusalem was never that sacred anyway from an islamic viewpoint it was something the the real glorification like it was there as i've mentioned before it was there
uh it was associated with prior prophets but it wasn't seen as this mega the way it seemed today and the glorification of jerusalem began with abdul malik the caliph who who creates this rival city to makkah and medina to kind of especially to makkah not to medina but to distract people from um up to leibniz obeyed and to allow them to come to a pilgrimage in the rock you know dome of the rock so this um and then ever since people have you know they've added stuff and added stuff and then it's become this really holy site
but even if look let's say let's go with the argument i know people ain't going to agree with me on that and i've i've never believed that was muslim al-aqsa anyway muscle axot in my understanding would have been the farthest point would have been in the heavens because al-aqsa the farthest point is not jerusalem why is that the farthest point on earth so the al-aqsa would have been in the heavens in my understanding but even if you take it let's say you take the fact that jerusalem is a really holy site in islam let's just say it's not holy as a you don't have to do
a pilgrimage there and to be honest no matter how holy it is to us it's arguably that area is more holy and more sacred to the jewish people so if they took it they're only going to take care of it they're not going to you know they're not going to go around turning that area into a toilet or doing something like that remember it's sacred territory for them as well in fact i would feel it's more sacred for them so even though it's a different religion but tkr you know it doesn't it's only bricks and mortar you know it's not it's not life more valuable
it's you know the allah didn't send us on this earth just to preserve some bricks preservation of life trumps all and at the end of the day look they they just want to set up a temple if they want to set up the temple and they take over and they won't be killing people and it's what dedicated to the israeli prophets who by the way are all in the quran so okay but we have to just accept that this battle is this war is lost there's no point fighting a lost war because it's just what is really tragic is the amount of
people dying and muslim and i think even though muslims are making a big deal about that which is rightly so but they don't seem to be making a big deal about like they seem to be glossing over the fact that wait a minute why are we we guilt-tripping these people to put up with it we should be life comes before place like if you had if you had the choice to save a life or the kaaba the hadith teaches you that if the hadith is a muslim not even his life his honor is much more
important than the entire kaaba being destroyed rebuilt destroyed rebuilt destroyed rebuilt destroyed goes up to seven times the honor of a muslim it says here you've got entire hundreds thousands lives being killed blood being shed and people you know yeah they're upset about it but they're like yeah but the holy land what the hell is the holy land yet what is this holy land you know the holy land the holy land we need to realize that look human life comes first these people who are tyrants are not going to back off so you you know what
does allah say in the quran the prophet said that the whole earth is a sacred place for for us to to bow down we don't need jerusalem so i feel that look we it's we need to this is my understanding that we need to know when a fight is lost that this against israel is lost and you need to you know you need to just we need to kind of like just accept that and and realize that these tyrants israel is a tyrant terrorist state it is not going to back down it is going to
butcher a missile children so and there needs to be some kind of this needs to stop but how do people stop it they're never gonna it doesn't seem like they're gonna stop so this is my suggestion but you see the irony is i bet you people all of a sudden wouldn't care about the palestinians because they were they only care about them so long as they're in palestine they wouldn't care about them if oh yeah let's get them relocated and living in a another place in another nice city somewhere they wouldn't all of a sudden all of a sudden that care would just go away you'd be like
stay in stay in palestine and die ah that's my thoughts on it mine i don't know um and i'm very look and i'm this is not and you can rewind and watch what i've just said in case you've missed it i'm not saying i'm being very clear that israel is is it being a terrorist state that's what it's doing but we have to realize like if there's a person here and you know it's look i i did a while back i did escrima yeah which was uh
it was stick knife sword kind of fighting but there was an emphasis on stick and knife but i remember the teacher he told us look there's a simple rule in life yeah he said like if you ever confronted with a knife right he said look the first thing don't look he said that listen to this the first thing is run do not it's not look you have to realize that there's certain things that are not they're not it's it's no it's a handicapped thing it's too easy to be stopped
he said however if that's not an option that's where this skill comes in to try and defend to try and block to try and turn the attack but by the first means is you're not an equal option here don't try and punch the person and do like if you can get away that's because if a person a similar if person has a gun obviously now he's going to shoot he'll have to do some zigzags but the point is so actually if they've got a gun i think it's better to fight them i would actually charge them if they had a gun but i would run if they had a knife so the the point is that look
you've you've got to understand that this these people are not going to back down and they're going to butcher relentlessly and mercilessly so i would say that yeah so i hope that doesn't upset certain people but yeah but this uae thing i don't think it's done jack okay i don't think he's broken any piece and i do think that the king of uae is just doing it to kind of he just got his own deal maybe israel is paying him a bunch of you know you must definitely be getting a huge whack for doing that maybe america said to them look if you do this
will broker a deal with you so there must be so many backhanders going on with that and i think it's unfair to put the sh the the price of that on the shoulders of sheikh abdullah bin bay and sheikh hamza yusuf because i don't think they really had any hamza yusuf i don't think had anything to do with themselves even though he does kind of like sign off for the king and stuff like that but then you know he's kind of stuck as well you know you got to be honest it's not like i don't think he would be happy with that uh and no i've heard from my sources that he's not happy with
the decision either cool right all right let's uh mufti what about the kashmir issue yeah i feel that look the kashmir issue similarly if that is an option if it is an option that they were to relocate them all then fine you know but then personally i would say that it's slightly different i would see some differences because you see the difference with the kashmir issue is it's a heavily militarized zone it's not a um
it's not exactly like for like because what you have is in gaza it's not a militarized zone it's just a cut off kind of prison which they just keep bombarding in kashmir it's more that there's a military an overkill military presence who then just by their very existence will torment the the the kind of residents because they see them as different so the question here is india wouldn't really in my understanding ever be up for as far as i'm aware to kind of relocate all those kind of people comfortably i don't think they ever would
because india is indian government is like a cheap government they would never consider that yeah they might just kick them out tell them get lost they'd be happy to do that but i wasn't saying that for the palestinians just tell them get lost i was saying that i'm pretty sure they could broker a deal where they would happily pay because i'm sure they would be happy to pay so yeah but ideally for the kashmir issue i would see this is what i ideally opt for is that kashmir could just become independent um so as in not part of pakistan not part of india
just independent that i think would be the solution and i think i think it could be done if what they did is in the kashmir issue they you see a certain part of kashmir maybe not all of it certain part of it they gave it independence now whoever wants to be a part of that could then move to that part it could work like that i think because they would never give up the whole of it because then it would make pakistan too vulnerable because obviously if they gave up the whole of kashmir if pakistan gave it pakistan would never
give it up because then it would be a problem to it would be too close to islamabad and if it got infiltrated by india they would be too close so if they kept maintained buffers and just gave a certain region like the valley and certain parts they made that independent and some other parts i i'm not too you know whatever they can but these things would never happen but i wish they would right so let's move on people what is going on what else was there did i have any uh right oh let's take a few of your
questions somebody said mufti you missed a super chat let me see uh somebody asked about gangutili i'm going to speak about that in just a moment is music permissible i make beats brawl [Laughter] i do and it do yeah music's permissible music isn't haram okay so salaam alaikum could you explain the hadith in which the prophet
said expel the christians and the jews from the arabian peninsula see i'm not so sure about that hadith because that hadith just doesn't settle i struggle to see that hadith being true um because because check this out
what insignia right my knee right check this out one of the in sahih muslim one of the final transactions of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam is with a jewish medinan resident and the prophet takes certain sacks of wheat or whatever it is to feed his family and in turn he leaves with them with the person as a
um as an alternate payment kind of like pawns his uh his shield the prophet then passes away now how can this be that the prophet on one hand is saying chuck out the jews from the jazeera out of the entire arabian peninsula not even that locality or this the entire jazeera and on the other toe on the other hand
a couple of days before he's passing away he's trading with him in fact he's he's saying look how could you give me this and uh bags of wheat because look if you go to position one chuck them out of the entire peninsula see that's a very down talk like you're talking down to someone you're exhibiting power yeah in this scenario if if a be true then b is problematic because here the prophet is in a position of having to
negotiate and doesn't have the money to pay him so he's the prophet is saying how about i leave my shield and i will come back because if a be true then c ought to be true which is that the prophet actually snatches takes by force the wheat or whatever it was uh the food from the jewish person and says to him get the hell out of medina that it ought to be is that not true i mean come on like does it add like if
i told you look uh there's such a such a person who is you know i've sacked him and chucked him out and i've seized all his properties and i've done this and i've done that to him and then you see some this you get this news report somebody's saying oh i've sacked such and such a person and i've done these legal lawsuits against them and i've even tried to seize some of his assets and i've done this like some horrible things i've frozen he had his bank accounts frozen and done this and done that and then you see on my insta story
me and him uh having a laugh at a cafe somewhere cracking jokes going hey what's up so one of these has got to give it just doesn't tally like i can't be doing all this stuff to him and be like this with the person so the question is if the prophet is saying throw these people out of the arabian peninsula strip them out of the arabian peninsula remember from their homes their assets their farms agricultural territory strip that you
can't pick that up and take it with you on the other hand the prophet is saying because allegedly he said this towards the end of his life allegedly throw them out yeah but only a few days before he passes away what is the profit he's trading and he's trading from a less powerful position to the jewish trader saying oh you know okay i haven't got the money is it all right if i leave this and the person's like yeah fine yeah that's that's fine leave that this doesn't add up you see so i find this hadith incredibly suspect
i don't believe it's true this whole yahudah nasara i feel that this begins later on you see when the battles start uh when the battles during umar's time radiology when they are start to really fuel up against the byzantines against the christians and against those it's around those kind of times or maybe slightly after that these strong christian anti-christian sentiments and the anti-people of the book sentiments because the jews and christians were seen as
more allied with each other than they were seen as with muslims so i feel this is a later fabrication and that is then retrospectively projected back onto the profit yeah right what is going on what would be the motive to invent this yeah i feel that later on in in islam you do start to see um a kind of sentiment it's interesting i'm not
exactly sure what stage at what stage it mean right so this thing i just said a moment ago it could have been when the battle against the byzantines and stuff that's just i'm just saying it's slight like i'm just that's just a thought i'm just i just expressed it i'm not holding that as a firm belief but what we do see is definitely down the line there seems to be and this definitely within a few centuries this seems to be this um people seem to look down on the jews and christians some people
now an interesting question is where when does that sentiment begin i haven't arrived at that point in understanding that requires a lot of research does it begin early on with these battles does it is it um does it begin later but is then kind of redirected as though it began earlier on and then you forge some of these incidents like these hadith and show it coming down is that what you do or maybe you find some legitimate
incidents in the lifetime of the prophet when you didn't get on with the jewish people and what you do is you amplify that by making it echo much louder so but i don't know exactly at what point another thing that is true is that a lot of the muslim kings including what's interesting is including the dynast but even after the bani umayya definitely but even after bani umayyad during the abbasid time a lot of the kings kept occasionally as their kind of prime ministers
or their key ministers they kept christians and jewish people because they were seen as more kind of um academic so they kept them to document stuff they kept them to so you see books are authored on the prohibition of fistic the fistic tabi ahlil kitab in fact i've got a book here somewhere about a traditional book classical where the the scholars start writing about why it's haram for the the rulers to have jews and christians
as the um as part of the administration but it's a wide practice and it happened for centuries so i do know that a lot of the clergy did have this kind of hatred towards certain jewish and christian people now remember if these kind of hadith are to be fabricated they will come from the clergy they're not going to come from outside it will be the clergymen who invent them and sometimes it's not even sinister sometimes it's just false memories it's um you know you wish something into existence
[Laughter] you know you just keep wishing it and then you're like i'm sure there was something like that there was something i heard once there is there is a teaching that's the kind of evolution of some of these hadith yes so right what is going on people right [Music] i'm just trying to see some questions people uh right more people seem to be interested in uh the female mods
i've got than they do in my show [Laughter] see this is this this is what you get there's more questions being directed at them are you kashmiri i am a kashmiri yes right so mufti is a somebody saying you secret chav a super chat you mean have i missed a super chat um
music no the the gangutili one i'm gonna come to that in just a moment yep so a lot of love ahori you're doing it you're doing it all the way from is that all the way from germany yep you're doing it youtube right um you once said that the beard is having too much focus which part of islam do you feel has not had enough focus avaroeus dude has asked that's an interesting question i said that the beard in islam seems to have had too much
focus uh what part of islam does not have enough focus uh there's uh in the words of muttanabi the arabic poet he says because you know with the beard they trim their tash and they kind of some of them shave honestly it's a it's a absolutely horrible sight they end up with but anyway they do that they completely shave their tash and they grow the beard and just looks horrible but imam malik actually said to them that you know even
if the shaitaan tried to do a number on you he couldn't have made you look more ridiculous than you made yourself look so but people do that so the poet says and that's associated with the beard usually so he said yes that he says is this the depth of your deen that you should just trim your tash he says oh what an ummah it says an ummah that other umams other civilizations just laugh at
now that's what we've become a laughingstock right right so some pashtuns look hindu too i don't know what that means right so people seem to be more obsessed right guys can you focus huh focus
[Laughter] you know i was trying to bring up a uh i was trying to bring up this comment but i couldn't find it it was so funny damn i wanted to take a screenshot when it was there and i thought i'll do it later on in the day and and i couldn't find it i was like damn somebody had asked me a question in my comment he said uh mufti is it uh before the marriage is the is the sax sax he said can one uh uh have the can one do the sacks i was like yeah this this
guy is really passionate about the saxophone yeah this i was like yeah man go for it you you played the sax before [Laughter] play the trombone [Laughter] ah the sax can we have can we i think now we should i'll be playing the sax shall we shall we [Laughter] and that's when you realize that
can you imagine as soon as the the music as soon as the class starts and everybody stands up he's like taking off all his clothes and he's standing there [Laughter] teachers like all right guys ten seconds we're going to all play the sacks and then they turn around and he's everybody's there with the saxophone and he's dead naked i thought we said we're gonna play the sax is this this is wrong this is the wrong class i come to
the the wrong class or the the right class is that a toy are we going to be using this toy [Laughter] right so i tell you now i know i don't think i can handle this toy right so yeah so what's the question on uh secret knickers hmm
well you see rather than that what i i don't advocate the secret kind of nikah thing but what i would say is i do advocate the permissibility of temporary or what i suppose if that's what people mean but there's a difference you see with i don't know exactly what people mean when they say secret because i could be picturing something else so i don't advocate the whole um you know the kind of uh you see there's things where people
will this there's certain kind of nickas that they will be like okay look here only this one person knows and this other one is on a video phone and to the woman don't tell anyone and then and then the woman kind of is in that relationship with the impression that this is going to become a normal relationship but then it seldom ever materializes and i feel that that's highly deceptive so if that's what they mean by i don't i mean i i would condemn that kind of stuff if that's what they mean by secret
nikkei if they mean by a kind of low commitment knicker then i wouldn't really call it a secret knicker i would call it like whatever like to me that's just between two adults whatever they they both are comfortable with it's nobody's business what they're comfortable with so if they said look you know this is what it is we'll just be like this we're gonna it's a it's a it's an off peak time term time only kind of like relationship whatever it's their business if that's what they want then that's you know nobody has a say in that
if they both are the understanding that look here we're just you know we've got this we're not really going on about it it's just something for convenience for them it's up to them somebody might say oh that's disgusting well that's like but it's look if they if it's between them two then that is perfectly fine and it's up to them so i i don't see that like the first one which is more ice i see as exploitation so that i'm against but this i would feel is permissible um in addition to things like temporary
uh what is called i do i do feel that that's not haram and i will at some point go into much depth once i finalize ibn azraq's book but it isn't in my from what i've understood it's not haram i think it's highly politicized yeah you know speaking about politicized i've been reading up a bit more but i won't do a full analysis here but i'll just give you a little preview i've been reading up more on this whole hadith al-ikh this hadith of the great lie
sorry not the hadith the incident of the if and the more i'm reading into it i what i feel that you see because what i found is these different narratives i definitely am inclined to the understanding that the if in the quran that is being mentioned damn that's my throat going again
wow so what i definitely do feel is that the if mentioned in the quran is referring to an incident with maria radiola not the incident to do with aisha or the allah um because when you look at it just makes so much sense like um the hadith the the incident of aisha is is attributed to this battle of banil musta which is around the sixth hijri or some say before that maybe fifth injury
i've even heard some say fourth history but suratu nur to do with the verses of if is in eight hijri maria comes to medina in seven hijri and then falls pregnant and has a baby in eighth history so it's yeah and it's really interesting and i feel that that one it ties up with the tallies with the ramifications as well some of the and i've noticed some of the shia have actually said this as well as i've been researching it i've realized some of the shia have said this although they feel that
maybe aisha radhilan i think that's a stretch i feel this is in my understanding okay i think both incidents happened so when in early you're still okay relatively early whether it's mid uh the prophet's life in medina whatever whether it's four five or six whatever when the prophet comes back from
i feel that there were rumors to do with aisha that did happen but they were resolved then and later on a couple of years later this incident happens with maria that people start saying and there's a hadith in in hakim by the way where aisha is actually transmitting about that people started to say that the prophet's child they said that he uh le siddhatti that for his the prophet's excessive love to have a child
that he claimed somebody else's child for himself and this is actually in the riwayat and the sunni books you find this so in hakim it's interesting that aisha is the one speaking she says and she uses the word if to do with maria so radiola so yeah that's my so i feel that they both happened but that one was of much more importance like as in not impo like they were both important but that one was of much more grave consequence and the verses of the quran were to do with that
but because the verses go on to not only uh exonerate the person but they also go on to claim that modesty and mentions believing that she's from the faithful later on in life when the whole incident began the splits between the shia and the sunnah when the camps became slightly anti-aisha i feel that people like you see it's possible it's very possible because you have to remember you see for i shared the allahu anha
herself in later life when she read the verses of if she could have identified with them as well so it's not that because remember an incident like that if we go with that it did happen so when you're reading it you're identifying with it even if it was primarily meant for someone else so i feel in later life she may have said that yes that does refer to me as well or people may have definitely kind of pushed it on her that doesn't this also refer to you and she um
would have owned it because she could identify with it and so it's kind of true by its meaning it refers to her but although i don't feel it was revealed for her reveal for maria and then with the zubair narrative of history maria becomes inconsequential and she becomes insignificant so they just completely move her out the picture which is another disservice that muslim scholars have really done and the muslim legacy i feel has betrayed maria radhiallahu anha
because it kind of really just uh buried this whole if story because it is in our sunni books by the way it's in sahih muslim that oh she was accused of having an affair but they don't even mention her name they try and put it off as she was a slave of the prophet they say a slave woman of the prophet um but it was you know that's not true and she was a wife and but yeah so that's an interesting thing i thought i'd just share that with you right guys we're going to start to wrap up uh you're not muslim
wallahi village to lahi i think you need to go back to your village uh hussain salafi [Laughter] all right the wobblers are here right so cool right so speaking of wobblers people yeah somebody said mario was a coptic egyptian she was there's an interesting theory as well i'm still researching that
and this was more speaking with us yes mean amin who is the granddaughter of the great egyptian historian ahmed amin right those of you that are familiar with him so she had mentioned to me and and it's got me kind of thinking i'm still researching it though but her suggestion is that it was the zohar lifestyle you know the zohar the kind of very um ascetic food dietary not restrictions but but but ro the kind of dietary lifestyle the ascetic dietary
lifestyle that the wives of the prophet had that would not then result in pregnancies and this was something she she has written about i think her books to be released next month but it's quite okay it's intriguing it's quite interesting and because maria when she came she was a coptic she came she embraces islam marries the prophet she then doesn't the wives don't like her uh one she's a foreigner and things like this so the prophet has a settlement for her outside of medina so she lives about three kilometers from madina
in the awali so because of that her dietary thing is completely different she doesn't adhere to this ascetic kind of dietary lifestyle and that then aids in the pregnancy as well so that's something ustada yes mean i mean had written it's quite intriguing it's interesting i thought hmm that's uh um that's a perspective i've got to still research more about it all right so people moving on right we've got to move on people speaking of uh we had somebody there saying uh
uh wahhabi wobbler [Laughter] right so speaking of wobblers right right so those of you that are not familiar uh there was this huge kind of meltdown that ganguteli has had where
he he's he's kind of he's gone on twitter and he's put up this kind of uh this post obviously attacking me now i don't use twitter much okay in fact in those two days i've probably used twitter more than i've used in about a year and a half [Laughter] so i i find twitter too toxic i'm gonna be honest with you and i don't use it so what i have is when i post things on let's say instagram or facebook i have the settings that it will share
it to twitter but i seldom log into twitter but anyway so i went on somebody sent it to me so i went on there and he's kind of having this whole oh mufia bullets whatever oh my god he's doing this he's just attacking me making fun of the scholars blah blah blah so it turns into this huge drama so he's like oh he's got me blocked he's got me blocked so then i have him unblocked i mean what let me just tell you what's going on with our beloved elisabeth what's going on is that you see he as i've mentioned before was behind the whole
yasir adi leaks okay he's farid leaks now because of this because he leaked uh yasir hadi's emailed to you know eventually to dawah man who exposed them this has been known in certain circles although the public have only recently started to catch wind of these so he used to be a part of a group i don't know why they call themselves sunni defense but they were actually like the wahhabi defense but they were just pure anti-shia that was their purpose and they would just make videos against the shia
now along the way he came across me as well and he tried refuting me obviously it wasn't as easy as he thought so he's like a cha cha cha right now what happens is that group the ts not standing for tsd not standing for transsexuals disguised that's not what it stands for but the tsd the ts what the ts do is they chuck him out of the group
there's no pun intended here right i know chaka also means transsexual in but so they chuck him out of this group now so he is kind of like oh like i don't know what to do so to gain relevance and to gain some attention what he does is he thinks i know i'll latch on to muftiya because surely multiple eight has many haters so this will give me some credibility amongst the diverse groups and sustain a following to me by all means
by all means if that you know if if becoming obsessed with me gives your life some some meaning some purpose go for it man go for it go for it so anyway what we had was we had this thing going on so he went and had this kind of meltdown on twitter this back forth back for he's doing all this he's mocking the scholars i'm mocking the scholars i'm doing this i'm doing that so i said to him look i tell you what he's saying i'm a jahil i'm a you know all kinds of thing
i'm a zindiq uh you know i'm a kafir zindik means a cafe a non-muslim uh so who's just he's just pretending he's deceiving muslims that he's a muslim so i said look i tell you what this whole thing you coming to defend hadith i will have a discussion with you on sahil bukhari i will have i said to him i will have a discussion with you what say you let's let's have this so he responded by this uh discussion discussion her rather rather he's like look
less than man discussion with him haha i have discussions with people who i respect that he will humiliate me he will come i'm just a child you know i'm just a heretic [Laughter] so this is what he's and there he is saying oy zindik
keeping in mind keeping in mind people that this apology yeah i said what about you know since you're so keen about apologies what about shaykh assad apology [Laughter] you know that uh when you forgot to wear the nappy and you leaked [Laughter] what about that isn't he waiting for four years he's about his apology was basically he'd been blocked by me now the point is i said to him so i offered our beloved gangutili i said to him look listen
let's have a let's have a discussion he's like discussion i don't have discussions with people i don't respect i have a debate child i will humiliate you so i said look i tell you what this is exactly my point since i'm just a child in front of farid and the zindiq why doesn't he just come live with me that day i offered him come live and just destroy me then this is you know you can obliterate you can decimate me in front of the world it should be easy
yeah because since i'm such a jahil like let's let's be real since i'm so ignorant of what i'm doing how difficult is it to come and just just completely humiliate me online just turn up i offered him so many times you know so many people said to him look even his own wobbler followers they were saying look come on you're on the huck he's unfalsehood you can destroy him please please he was like no i will only have a moderated uh
dialogue i will fly over to the uk i will fly over there i will only have a moderated dialogue i don't respect sorry sorry moderated debate oh and his point was oh in between at one point because the tweets were loads in between at one point i just said okay i should have said it because he was just looking for a little excuse so i just said all right yeah go on then since you're flying because he kept going on no i'm gonna go there i'm gonna fly there i'm i said all right birmingham this center gone turn up and this momo i said you know what momo can
just sit in as the moderator oh no uh i don't agree but now we've moderated we wanted this and now you can now i do i want this person i want dilly a cha-cha [Laughter] [Music]
[Laughter] it's interesting that you know people of that flock together of an ilk cancer i suppose just clings to cancer so i i was like look i said to him look listen cut the it's like oh listen you know stop these little these kind of little oh i said to him look cut the nonsense the drama just come live just come live now like in fact i said i never said now because that could be unfair to him i said look in a couple of hours let's go live
what are you let's do and i said look i give you my word that i you know you'll be civil since you have all the answers since i'm just a kid in front of you you're like he doesn't know anything if if i was obsessed with somebody that i stalked them i watched hundreds of hours of their videos i hated them i my mission in life became to prove them wrong and i felt they were so dumb if they invited me to alive i would snap that up instantaneously that would be a godsend because now i could go live and i could
just show them for the ignorant person they are it's like that guy who came on want to debate me on my mufti's meetup about jesus boy did he get schooled and this is it you see because they absolutely underestimate what they're coming up against and they think oh you know what what could he possibly know sits there with a necklace on and he's got a new ring and he's got a hahaha what could he know about islam i'll just go there and i'll so this was my point so i said to him on so many occasions look what say you then i was just fed up i said look i said look i'm saying this a
final time i don't need a babysitter to talk right let's talk let's not enough of your drama right oh i'm going to catch a flight catch a flight cup but [Laughter] gets booted out of ts the ts crew i'm going to catch flights to the uk to have a debate i was like look before you so proudly want to catch flight just come live just look come live with me let's have a
discussion or a debate or whatever [Music] boy and then even his own followers started saying it to him so he got so vexed because of my video you know this one he was so upset about this [Music]
so he was like i'm gonna make a video as a video coming out i'm gonna decimate i'm gonna destroy so he made a video he hyped up this video everybody was like whoa this mega video is coming even i was thinking foreign
so i was like oh no i'm stuck so he makes a video that he's destroyed my career and the video is basically some youtube comments he appealed to the youth fashionista i i'm actually flattered he called me a fashionista i don't really think that but
allah he made such a damaging video it was the most popular video if you searched abu leith monday another video abu leith is haram stay away same video different thumbnail his reputation this is how people reacted oh and this video is called i destroy double aids career i love the music though the background music abu leith is a kafir murtard
[Music] see that's an oxymoron open because you'd have to be a hidden monafic to be a monarchy all right so may allah destroy the cafe this guy is a monafer [Music] talk about the the adjectives i really think is brother
[Music] what religion does he belong to what religion does he belong to any what religion does he belong to where's my wahhabi oh my god i'm done with him this guy is utterly destroyed me oh oh my god
an atheist is more religious than muftiya might be actually fair point he's got a point i do like the music though it's very soothing although according to him music is haram [Music]
so these are the youtube comments on his own channel on his own channel yeah [Music] oh [Music] teasing me where are the defenders of this zindiq where are they they have been destroyed
[Music] you you that's my old range guys [Music] you you you you only we destroyed this career man [Laughter] they destroyed my career i don't know i think i should just take up drinking now [Laughter] that must be the first destruction in
history where nobody realized anything happened destruction viola what is it that got destroyed though [Laughter] he's actually titled that video i'm not making this up he's titled uh you know what when i downloaded it it didn't seem to have brought in the thumbnail which is a shame
he's actually titled it i destroyed abu lade's career that's the actual audacity audacity of what he thinks just check this out just quickly i'll show you guys so oh you can't really see it there but it is you'll see the the kind of it's actually called uh it's not focusing but the top one but if you type it in it's got a picture of me with a few teeth knocked out edited and he's written how i destroyed
abu leith's career fareed responds [Music] this is him
he's doing the same dance [Music] and so i i'm really so people if you're ever wondering i you know i'm destroyed so that that's the story behind my destruction you know if you're ever trying to figure out why is uh why is mufti destroyed that's that's the destruction
what was it that was destroyed this reminds me of that same story i've told you guys you know with that little little piddy bird falls down and a leaf falls on it falls down and it with its legs it holds up the leaf and it says the whole world would have been destroyed today if i hadn't held the heavens up with my feet [Laughter]
so that's uh i had to so i was saying to gangutili gt that look just come on live and let's have a discussion but you see this is the problem nothing but drama drama drama drama so yeah guys i think we should start to wrap it up now whoa it's coming up to three hours i think we need to wrap up there's some final uh advice and the advice start with a small d no this one we can say mini the giants no problem i have to share that with you
[Music] so i was actually going to share this this is some advice it's just like i think 30 seconds long it's where uh uh aka i mean called aka not mawlana but
is sharing some advice about people who who you know where you have two passengers on a bike so they call that inurdu double savari savari is somebody ride a passenger so double passengers a double sawari then you have triple savari on a bike so he's like [Music] this sandwiching is not nice you know so it's just uh
the world [Laughter]
[Laughter] people don't be doing the triple okay don't be doing the double so all right so cool i'll just try to read some comments here is ali right okay somebody's is ali mentioned really in the quran uh right okay no theolan isn't mentioned in the quran
much appreciated much appreciated the superchat right please mufti tell me are we wrapping this up i don't know what you're asking what people like please please tell me please tell you what guys let's wrap this up as always it's been awesome we've had uh been through quite a few things so but yeah remember that advice people as you go into this week this three this triangular situation complicated you know it's complex you know this different isosceles or this equilateral
these are not nice guys if you haven't already subscribed uh to my if you haven't already subscribed then god damn you go people youtube click the subscribe the notification bell yeah click the bell here yeah yeah okay uh patreon i'm on patreon if you want to subscribe i've started up uh um we're trying to set a little kind of thing it's been the
first month so i've also started one of the things with it is a resources page as well there's a there's a chat group for telegram but i've started a resources page as well where i share just anything interesting i might come across something i want to share with people so that's part of the thing as well and a lot more stuff to come as well but anyway you can check it out instagram if you want to reach out uh that's probably a good place to reach out but do subscribe and if you haven't already seen my gangoteli video then you can watch it
other than that people [Music] i don't know what are he's saying by the way but he just seemed so happy that's how happy gangutilli is that's how happy gangutili is that he's that he's destroyed my career
this is his arguments are that convincing that they're going forward to spread forth and populate his his ideas are like that and here they are this is this is him going to end my career [Laughter] people as always gotta love you and leave you take very good care of yourselves remember me in a kind of remember to smile people remember to have your daily dose of laughter to perform some kind of act of charity and
take very good care of yourselves over and out folks
Something wrong here?
Tell us what is wrong and it will be checked against the recording. Nothing changes until a person has reviewed it.
Sending a note needs JavaScript, which is off or unavailable in this browser. Nothing has been sent.
No name, email address or account is asked for or stored, and the inbox does not store your IP address. For rate limiting it keeps an unreadable fingerprint of your connection for 48 hours, and our database provider's own logs record connections as every website's do. Only your note, its kind, the page and the moment in the recording are kept, for review.
Cite this recording
Stable id, transcript version and tier are part of the citation. Every change to a transcript is logged.Mufti Abu Layth Archive, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/kwmtt2tqao0/ (accessed 1 November 2026)
- APA 7
Mufti Abu Layth. (2020, August 24). Monday Nights with Mufti #179 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth [Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors]. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Retrieved November 1, 2026, from https://muftiabulayth.org/r/kwmtt2tqao0/
- Chicago author-date
Mufti Abu Layth. 2020. "Monday Nights with Mufti #179 | Q&A Unscripted & Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth." Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Recorded August 24, 2020. Accessed November 1, 2026. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/kwmtt2tqao0/
- BibTeX
@misc{abulayth-KWmtt2TQAO0, author = {Mufti Abu Layth}, title = {{Monday Nights with Mufti \#179 | Q\&A Unscripted \& Unrestricted! 😉 | Mufti Abu Layth}}, year = {2020}, month = {8}, date = {2020-08-24}, howpublished = {\url{https://muftiabulayth.org/r/kwmtt2tqao0/}}, url = {https://muftiabulayth.org/r/kwmtt2tqao0/}, organization = {Mufti Abu Layth Archive}, urldate = {2026-11-01}, note = {Auto-transcribed, may contain errors} }