A Response to Yasir Qadhi on Miracles | Mufti Abu Layth

right okay so I'll tell you what let's move to chef Yasir Qadhi alright so those of you that have just tuned in people click like click Share we will now be addressing Chevy a so called e right bismillah a bucket a jelly kya tuna um goby mousse awesome job there's an

older poet he says Oh divine speaking to the divine kind of I suppose it means lightning but in this sense it's not just the kind of divine manifestation he says do you take us to be here see the old poets they were very daring in the expression says do you take us to be like Moses hum this is Mayor Naheed Oh Joel John job chahiye Maccabi that says

I'm not Mount Sinai that I will collapse whenever you want manifest yourself just by dilgar major who have cheese mocha Bielema joy manzil kill a dog on channel or saman Amundson oh joy says it's all down to the passion unbridled passion people says if you have that you will achieve anything all you have to do is

take two steps towards your destiny and your destiny will be the destination in front of you Allah Allah right so let's all right so let's move to our call the judge our judge friend yes he'll cavite Allah Allah Allah the zombie destroy our people the zombie slayer sure yes sir

aka the the zombie slayer so what is going on so chef yes it bother you what I'm gonna do is tell you a bit of the the backdrop and then a bit of the controversy on him taking a few digs at me yeah me yeah upon up on up and pay attack so what is this about the contradictions in his statements we're gonna take a little look at them so those of you just tuning in you may like and share and spread

spread the love people spread the 15m facade so right so what's the backdrop the backdrop is that not so long ago chef here sir Bobby Walt's going through his behind the scenes this okay this part is my perspective that he I feel that chef yes ed hardy may be going through a bit of an existential crisis obviously I don't I'm not so sure that he's admitted to that or maybe he has

but I feel that he wants to break away from I feel that Heath does not believe in a lot of the things that he's he's actually expressing right he's just not being true like many people you see the thing is that even hypocrisy is he should be done with standards you know it should be a person should still have integrity that's [Music]

as the poet says maybe shower for a bee who touch say Mohammed Nagar you know that I don't make them say Mohammed Nagar that something that I am my he says I'm a fraudster I'm a fraud the person openly admits he says that I by profession deceive people I'm a Romeo con artist madam say Mohammed carnies that I can't I can't

I'm incapable of truly loving at least he's being honest he is he's being honest in what he says what he is an amazing line in that poem where he says he says Misaka Tahoe Mucha Tom said nahi Alfred he says I say very clearly to you that I don't have any true connection or

feelings with you love see Martin here he says these are only superficial words metal pay money he said he says I can't die there's a a kind of an admirable quality in the brutal honesty that the poet betrayed that he portrays in maybe shovel for a be home Muhammad carnies anyway coming back to

this discussion the problem is that many people they have these double standards you see so they struggle to they preach something but they can't really believe in that thing themselves so I feel that Sheriff Adi has also reached that kind of a stage in his life now recently he he had some discussion not so long ago we he spoke about you Jamaat and he expressed that how he is now incapable of accepting a literal understanding of ya'juj and ma'juj or

the traditional if I let me reword that the traditional understanding of ya Georgia module so what is yet do Jamaat Jude yeah Georgia Matich are nobody's truly sure I guess if you take a very the perspective of scholars coming through the ages whether these were some kind of human-like creatures that will emerge at the end of time that they may be trapped behind some kind of a barrier and when they do emerge they will you know wreak havoc on earth that they will

completely destroy the earth and they will be from the signs of you know the apocalypse of the end of time right now so share the acid body now there are verses in the Quran referring to you Jamaat Union yadu Jamaat Jude doesn't actually mean something like it's not um it's it's not a clearly meaningful word in Arabic so it's not quite sure what the word means it seems to be a ya jus Jam attitude so people weren't sure this is why it was like an elusive term

it seems to have been an Arab sized term so it's not perhaps not Arabic in origin so some people felt maybe these were two tribes of people and then there's this story that maybe they were these ancient crimes that were trapped behind a barrier by this person called little Canaan and these people every day try to escape from this barrier they are incapable of doing so however towards the end of time and they will finally overcome this insurmountable barrier and they will be unleashed on the earth were humming had Amin yeah until as the quran says and they from all

directions pour forth now and this havoc and chaos on earth now Ange the traditional perspective was that they were the strange looking kind of people or whatever they were a lot of people some people felt they were humans maybe slightly deformed and some people felt they were maybe some other kind of creation some people felt there were the Turks random and some people felt they were the Chinese which is so stupid right so nevertheless sheriff yasser

called the recently discussing this came out with with just being true to himself said look I can't accept that it doesn't make sense because there are no millions and millions of people or billions billions on earth that are undiscovered our contemporary geography has uncovered has mapped out the earth for us there is no great barrier behind which these people stand therefore we can't accept this the way it is he then went on to give some interpretations he said perhaps this could be a metaphor for just chaos on

earth it could be as some people have said maybe it was the colonialism things like this and and and I've said as well in the past that that does hold a very strong interpretation for me for being the kind of colonial phenomenon that humans went through oh and then he gives the southern interpretation where he says okay I'm I didn't come up with this but I was having a discussion with these students of knowledge and they came up with this and even though it sounds really strange but it ticks all the boxes they could be

zombies I don't know what kind of box is they that tick like in need of psychiatric chaotic mentally handicapped take just escaped from a psych ward take suffering from severe delusions tick what kind of box is that ticked [Laughter] desperately in need of mushrooms take

eligible for eligible for special benefits and welfare tick right so I feel that this is on YouTube by the way I think it is on YouTube so you had a lot of people a lot of selfies came out attacked him including our good old friend Abu Abu Ibrahim The Exorcist

right so if you remember a wall back the Exorcist or he did a refutation of me in which he quoted a by for the and I got him you know I catch him out you know I said bye it's so fun to catch our hobby using life hadith it's so fun that makes my day that I'm like just like a kid with a new toy like I'm just so ecstatic

I'll be like my look right so so yeah so even what is even a boy Rahim has a YouTube video refuting ship yes and are the on this whole zombies thing and several other people have refuted in people said what the hell and said to him you've lost the plot and and then ever since sure he has a card he has been trying to justify this one you can't justify yeah this is one of those

things you can't justify you know just disown it now have you seen that me mother some guy where he's he's speaking and he just he's just kind of thoughts it's like some kind of I don't know it's in another loud I don't know whether it's Swahili or oh it might be Somali you I don't know what language it is he's speaking in a language and he just thoughts in between it's a viral clip and he just says al hamdulillah he's like well damn he's like well I'm just

gonna own it now but anyway all the you know this one justification so so ever since he's been trying to justify this he's been like bending over backwards and doing all these backflips and gymnastic aerobics and trying to say well oh well I didn't quite mean it like I meant you know come on these zombies

ain't that bad zombies for God's sake let me get this right let me get this right people he said this subhuman all humans being trapped behind a berry on earth due to our contemporary knowledge of science and geography demonstrates that that's nonsensical therefore it is more likely plausible that

it will be zombies Oh God cha-cha-cha me and Yusuf me and you survive me and Yusuf you know the good old anecdote of the guy that everybody feared you some major scholar of Islam and he approaches and everybody oh they're the movies alike quickly sit up straight do this dude and then when they ask him to introduce himself he says he says my

name is he says people call me me and rusev not use of Jusuf like a cha cha cha cha cha so they're just kind of Carol relaxed again that attach hides me intrusive charts not geographically fathomable and it's not rational so ah so it's zombies [Laughter] no no drugs bad you no no no no

marijuana today today heroin this this one he's not taking the make out the listeners you know so yeah yes Adi he's been trying to justify since so anyway he he then decides to have a he does a podcast which is just on I think this last week with the madman loops so they

have a podcast and this podcast now you see what he's trying to do is he's trying to also reassert that I'm still very traditional yeah eyes on of Yulia eyes I have me home it's me and her right so the thing is he's he's trying to reassert himself as guys relax it's still me yes right so he's trying to justify and he's going through all these

things and part of you see when you wish to reaffirm reassert yourself so what do you do doctor me dig I'm a bigger man what do you do people tell me what you would do to reaffirm your position amongst the people what position would you assume what position would use you the usual Salafi Wahabi position that I know let's bash a few other people the

usual thing let's declare a few other people heretics so then obviously I've assumed a position of power I've assumed a position of orthodoxy by condemning other people as heretics so what he does is they have this discussion and they start saying well you know nowadays there's a lot of people you know they're struggling to accept miracles in the Koran I'm sure they like not accepting

miracles in the Quran okay how are you why the gas pressure coming out from that side you trying to figure out that what is going on here likewise so and then the other guy on Matt mom look says to him he said sure you know this he says sure you know there's mostly Abu layth who says my name you know my name you mentioned my name

you mentioned the devil and yeah you know so I had to obviously so people say oh have you sob have you heard what these people are saying so I'm like no way so I I go - sorry check this out now and I can't bloody find the damn thing because I honestly I can't be bothered to listen to the whole it's that long but anyway somebody shokran know just gracias por T they sent me the exact location so about I think it's one hour 13 minutes into it

he he says old people like musty Abu layth they deny certain miracles and they deny things like the virginity of Maryam Ali asana look at that saying it like that like you know that just sounds so scandalous doesn't it even I was like oh what is going on I was like whoa oh whatever nice the virginity of money that just sounds so like I'm saying something so

grotesque so anyway and then he says oh and they denied this and they deny these certain things and so what do you have to say about this so sure judge judge dredd haha so Judge Dredd yes I'm called the Sahib he says well you know he says look I'm just gonna be he says look I know I'm I like to you see we have to always look at the Quran Osuna know this one this one not nice he says Quran was not very clear you know

very clear so he says look why he doesn't and he does he doesn't use my name but he says why doesn't he all these people my kind you know what them your kind right why don't they just declare themselves why don't they just say that we're not sue me why don't they just basically say we're not from Orthodox Islam we're not from Sunni Islam and we

are mozilla which is an older deviant extremist sect why don't I just declare myself from that and then we wouldn't have an issue he says you know this is how you would and then we don't have an issue with these people I was like a hungry cat or humper attack at our Shasha me and rusev all right so I was like wait a minute

Justin Bobby G to start off with first of all first first point last time I checked let me check again yep this are not your dad's thing you know last time I checked this wasn't your dad's thing I'm a disco cha ha nickel via like let's check him out let's check him out let's check him out this was uh this isn't Yasir Qadhi stance dean is it no okay

second second point second point second point let me check the record we checked the record and interestingly chef Yasir Qadhi himself is a Wahhabi what hobbies according slfe which our hobbies according to the majority of the smoothly or not sunny and it's only people it's people like me they say now no guys or everybody these all should be kind of sunny just let them

it's only a few the minority and amongst at minorities me that says no Salafis too should be park should be considered part of the Sunni majority of Muslims but the majority of Muslim Sunnis do not consider wahabis to be sunny ah ha ha ha

this are intriguing so it's like one he's a hobby is telling somebody else to not declare themselves from me so you're thinking ha ha - come food you know they used to say in some parts of India and Baxter they said you know there's a slogan sunni-shia by by a Sunni and Shia brothers so they said they say Sunni Shia bye-bye yet this region McCarthy I that hated this third

category come from of the Wahhabis now not me I'm actually quite inclusive I say the hobbies as well are under the Sunni spectrum but most Sunnis no way most Sunnis categorically the a shoddy is do not consider our hobbies to be Sunni Muslims so to start off with this is such an irony ok let's put that aside of course I'm so me - you know this thing of somebody asked here question about Martha silly just to define that

Martha city is an extreme extinct sect from early Islam it emerged on extremist grounds that anybody and this is what this was the pillar of the creed that any person who commits a sin is no longer a Muslim but he's not a kaffir they came up with a purgatory state they believed that there was this thing this purgatory state called Zillah banal manzil attain any muslim who commits a sin is in that limbo state forever until they don't renew their faith they would chuck them out of Islam

but they wouldn't declare them kaffir but they wouldn't accept them as Muslims either this extremist sect that began with this as the core belief so they have five key beliefs and this is number one that you must believe this to be martyrs II write this sect and then they developed other you know that God is bound by certain structures and things like this so just because later theologians write later theologians write when they got into certain debates with Martha Zilla so some of the martyrs

Allah mocked some of the theologians for being thick so as their defence instead of taking them you know taking the bull by the wounds some of those theologians this is hundreds of years after the Prophet by the way this is like four hundred five hundred years after the Prophet some of these theologians instead of saying no let's clap you know you bring your idea will meet idea of an idea they started to say oh you're mocking us because what we say stupid oh so you're using your uncle you're using your intellect hahaha

so because some theologians started to do that it created a problem which we're still dealing with today that some Muslims believed think that maybe the intellect is bad which is the dumbest the dumbest thing anybody could say right so okay let's put that argument there let's leave that day let's return to judge dredd Mia and Joseph RB right so Mia Jessica V he says that okay people like me for questioning certain interpretations that exist today should

be deemed a heretic this is his words that I am truly essentially by my essence I am a heretic and I should not be part of mainstream Islam this was his view in the same discussion and I plead with you all to watch this just in case somebody thinks I'm making this up or I'm exaggerating in the same discussion he goes on to say well he goes on to discuss the yeah jutsu my judge now let's just pause

before getting into that he attacks me for saying that oh because I questioned certain things like let's say was Jesus born of a virgin birth now all I said was that no way the Quran does it explicitly say that Jesus was born of a virgin birth the early Christians did not believe that Jesus was born of a virgin birth this was something that were later Christians believed and it was made doctrine by the third century after Jesus so this was not even early

Christian belief and you know the thing the Bible Bible mentions no such thing and this thing about the prophecy in that I think the Gospel of Matthew refers to the the prophecy of Isaiah where he says that the maiden the young maiden will be with child they translated as virgin the the actual original word alma is not necessarily a virgin so whereas Batool in the in the Jewish Bible is a virgin so that's interesting they don't use the term virgin Elma

often was a virgin but half it just meant a young maiden a young lady a young woman that's what it meant so now coming back to this in the Quran it does not explicitly anyway mention that Jesus was born of a virgin birth and I've got a detailed video explaining that if you watch that and they have been many great allama of Islam especially of recent times that have spoken about this they've revisited they've looked at in in-depth people like a llama the man named Andy who wrote on the topic people like Maulana Abdul Karim Allah 13 east of Syria or

what was our discusses this in-depth explaining that look there's nothing to say that that the Quran simply when the angel when the angel appears to Maria Amalia salam and says that you will have you know gives her glad tidings and she says but i've not yet but i've not been touched and he says but the Lord has decreed but the same the angel appears to Abraham gives him glad tidings when he says how but my wife has now attained the menopause and she's of an old age

and he says well the same thing to Ibrahim he appears to Korea where he says my wife is barren and and he says the same infertile and he says the same thing it did not mean that there was no natural method that took place he didn't mean that he just they were all kind of non there was no father involved in any of them so Abraham is not the father it's just only the is only from the mother but no nobody said that but with Maryam Allah Salam people took this because it was the prevailing

Christian doctrine at the time now Maulana Abdul Karim Allah 3 looks at this in depth his teacher Moroni in Ayatollah I was in Abadi L Gujarati he has a detailed book on it as well called a Yunus mhmm he will add the tip no Maryam regarding the birth of the Son of Mary where he speaks that look the Quran doesn't actually say this the Quran may one may say that it implies were one could infer that that's true you could equally infer that at the time the the husband of Mary everybody believes that Mary was married to Joseph

that the husband of Mary was just not interested in intimacy he was not an intimacy inclined individual and then he became in that he was not mad in this way but he was as part of the divine decree so he changes this was the kind of if you want to call it a miracle now my point was that you see when he mentions that oh people like like me like Mufti Abu layth are saying that look certain things go against science or go against reason now what is

I want to ask you what is science or reason this is reason is the is the ability of a healthy mind to pass judgment especially based on evidence okay science is our observation of the world it's our observation of things around us whether they are forces whether they are atoms whether they are causation elements of you know laws within physics of thermodynamics or whatever this it's observation of what is around us okay

now this is what we call science yeah now keep that in mind now let's return to share yourself all the judge dredd he goes on now once he finishes that topic he goes on to discuss once again yeah to Jamaat yuge and he then says but because of our knowledge of contemporary geography geography we know that this medieval interpretation can't

be true so we need to reinterpret it way tomorrow because of our knowledge of contemporary geography or the world around us so we're revisiting an interpretation a cha-cha-cha Church model see isn't that the same thing that you just said a moment ago that this guy for saying that something goes against science or the laws of physics or

against reason it he is definitely a heretic and outside of the fold of mainstream Islam because he said that we need to revisit these interpretations ah a child but when you do it it's okay because oh you're doing it based on geography a cha cha cha cha cha cha cha cha graffiti Department well yeah at UH how cool the science department magenta

cha this is favoritism you know like geography okay science no me and you sir right so it is laughable the the hypocrisy of that discussion because Yasir Qadhi then spends elaborate elaborate kind of time and discussion he has an elaborate discussion on justifying his position in saying look

this is actually this is still fine because I'm basing it on you know because I'm not the only one he said I'm not the only one to interpret because my teachers teacher had interpreted so mighty as in shares Adi after you know chefs Adi had interpreted yeah juju Mateusz who's from the 20th century a cha cha cha cha though he'd you talk to her so these cha Chi who I quoted when I quoted Mawlana a llama - man I'm Adi who is also from the 19th century in the 20th century and when I quoted people

like share or Zira body who is from the 19th sorry going in also 20th century and Abdul Karim from the 20th century when I quote people like am not sure who was the shell islam of the 20th century when i quote these people or muhammad abdul was from the 19th 18th sorry 19th century oh you've got other scholars they're not acceptable because o because they modern a cha-cha-cha-cha my good I've got a cha shits a D when it

comes to chef sandy because he's the teacher of bimbos and we'll say mean and these people all of a sudden everything is everything is rather dandy this one my friend is not so I seriously was like wow did anybody just noticed the utter hypocrisy in that discussion because I a segment of it was just like oh these people are heretics and should be nothing to do with mainstream Islam because they say we need to revisit

certain rulings and sorry certain interpretations even though they have precedents but they have just you know 20th century and 19th century presidents okay a cha cha but my cha cha my uncle meteo this chef Zadi because he's the teacher of my teachers when he because he's interpreted HR but this interpretation it's okay to revisit

because geography geography a cha cha oh these aren't impressive you know geography where would we be people without geography science guy barman but where would we be without geography I [Music] [Laughter] want to know who Chevy Assam are these secondary school geography teacher was whoever he or she was they left an

impression and amazing but geography tells us that this interpretation we can revisit a cha-cha-cha up Quran to Muhammad and your pious and masha'Allah savior of Islam Hungary tauhara me [Laughter] what's that make a route Oh Salah what's

the but anyway so this is the whole this is the this this is the problem so the hypocrisy was just I mean our best it was laughable but it was disappointing because this is what you're dealing with and it's amazing how ah that's it maker auto Salah character delight this is the problem you see that

I'm a soft target that's the thing you know a soft spot harp you know soft that Hawk cuz they just look at me and say oh ah but look at him you know look at his goatee look at his earring look at this look at that by the way I've got a detailed video on the earring you can watch that so I'm a soft target easy target for them but i but I am Who I am openly you know I'm not hiding behind I'm not using a fake veneer pretending a because you know mush of law when I was shooting

with sitting with Chef what they mean and I was sitting with chef in bars and I was sitting with you know look first of all let me just tell you something people less less real talk real talk yeah yes today I accept that these selfies are anti-terrorism yeah I accept this but it was only yesterday that these people gave birth to terrorism this terrorism that we seen today a huge part of it is only from

these wahhabis let's just be honest like realtalk share bimba's or these you know share Alberni share mock bill chef these people were part of the Jamaat or participants of salafiyyah only in the 70s this isn't that long ago 70s is not such so they used to go around they were like the Taliban going around bullying people beating people up setting up these kind of plots now they did allegedly dissociate themselves but because the group the Jamaat or martyrs were to

salafiyyah right went on to to hijack the Kaaba do you remember joy a man with was in 1979 the the hijack of the Kaaba where they hijacked and took the hell people hostage is you can sue you can type it into YouTube that movement Joe a man who they caught and killed he was nobody Joe Hema and later on they declared him to be the Madi or whatever but if you look at the founders the key people in that movement you can type it in on YouTube on on Google bring it up you you

can buy books on it now the key pioneers were people like bin baz and people like Cheryl Bernie and chef McBeal and these people were the founding fathers of that movement all this Isis these people were praising Isis now they're speaking against do you know somebody sent me this you can find this clip on YouTube yeah where you can wear a cooler embarrasses a set a Salafi cleric live on TV so

the chef I think his name's are rude or something but this this hobby chef is on life and he speaking he's condemning Isis Fairplay he's condemning them saying look these people absolute wrong deviant whatever someone's over so somebody calls him it's a live Q&A show and the person says she'll you know he says that you you're condemning Isis and everything which is good but he says but it was only you know one two years ago that you were praising them so the chef says oh and I saw a lot of big I'll be kind with you you know perhaps you've misunderstood me how the kids born what boy turn this is a lie

I would never praise hearty burhanakum bring your evidence hey you know ain't at the lead so the guy the cooler had obviously come prepared he says not a problem chef right here you want the bran and he plays the clip so you can hear the share and the clip that you can find on youtube they've actually put the other clip in that clip so he himself the shares the sell the Saudi Salafi chef is saying or you may not be Saudi but he's definitely Salafi is from the Gulf right so he himself is saying that

oh oh our brothers from Isis ninety-nine out of a hundred or decent people it's only one out of a hundred that is messed up and he's saying this he says you know these people minute the why you shortened the medulla from the dollar to Islamiyah at this hour to say in a film in 99 a hundred you know they're not that bad it's only one out of order and then he this ship says cut him off cut him off you see these people I'm not saying today they are the terrorists they're not but the

Frankenstein problem we have they have played a significant role in producing that problem why do you think chef yes and Aldi was such a hothead in the late 90s early 2000s because he was himself at that time he was fresh he was a production now I'm sure Shetty Asif Ali has moved on from these kind of fanatic ideas but the point is that these teachers that he still goes on about are still at the end of the day those very people that germinated that you know they fertilized this movement they you know it's this

firm metaphorical spur right you know and how far is the Apple full from the tree so so these things you know it's interesting how these people assume such a lofty position in Islam and the dictate to others and so yeah so I hope so these are some of my thoughts people I know I kind of went on for a while whoa is that the time guys let's wrap this up it's been awesome I hope that some food for thought I want to clarify that look yes I do feel that there are certain interpretations that have

existed for hundreds of years I'm not the only one several great scholars of our recent times have said they need to be revisited because they're not the clear expression of the Quran they were an interpretation by certain people and yes reason the voice of reason is always paramount and I do give primacy to it because through it we can understand that the deen of islam has validity that is to us it holds true and I'm not the only one that says it does does this but what I won't do is oh I interpret things but when you have one interpretation

call you a deviant and then but my own I kind of say oh but this is totally fine I'm doing this but you when you interpret you leave the fold of mainstream Islam which is just a reflective of that fanatic past you know that fanatic extremist past of of excommunicating people chucking them out of the religion or but now you're not chucking them out the religion you're just chucking them out of mainstream Islam not that it was your dad's Deen to begin with

anyway people as always it's been an absolute none I think it's an overall I'm not sure how but it is a rule if you type that in aro you are it should bring it up hopefully on YouTube or Google people let's call it call it a wrap with that take very good care of yourselves remember mean you're kind of us assalamu alaikum warahmatullah to allah oberek are two people over now salam aleikum