BukhariGate Part 2: Sahih Bukhari is NOT so Sahih -Mufti Abu Layth

let's go to party gate what do you say so buddy gate is me part of this whole expose on showing that Sahil Bihari is actually not so sorry and it's not actually very reliable in its authenticity of being traced back to Amman Bihari so the most likely seems to have had a lot of hands which have doctored it along the way and they've added to it and they manipulated it and then then through like you know you know the game you have like Chinese whispers I know that's in a racist way but we

used to call it Chinese whispers I think it's called telephone as well things like that they play a role in there you have things like how memory Bartlet's study of memory how memory is actually an active agent and reconstructs it's not a passive agent so if you read the study of Bartlett's and other psychologists memory people used to think is just a passive activity like I'm just recalling they realize that memory is actually a creative element you're actually creating as you're going along so these kind of things all added and the truth is it may have a lot of things in there that are spot-on but

there's a huge question mark on how do we know so what we can do is we have the principal first of all Islam has already been conveyed through the living tradition which is fair secondly right so and this is not a denial of Sunnah we embrace the Sunnah Imam Malik said the hadith is not sooner so nice from the Prophet a hadith is a one-on-one transmission in my Malik's famous statement elephant an elf a thousand from a thousand the living tradition is you Dean he said this one on one will

snatch the Dean from in front of you the words of Imam Malik he said he said why he don't and why it's a yahoo dude he said say Youngjae or demon Benedict he will snatch the Dean from in front of you hence Imam Malik in his water brings a teeth and says we don't act according so right so I'm not moon kill hadith I'm accepting hadith first of all I'm accept I'm embracing Sunnah and even hadith I'm accepting them but by their standards of the Maha Devine so the Maha theen have generally said in theory three standards that it cannot let me by in Al Markkula can not go

against reason lamu hardly filmin Allah cannot go against the Quran and transmitted sources like the Quran authentic so now Wellum you not that Allah cannot approach an Islamic principle so as long as these things it's fine we can accept it is it certain that it's from the Prophet it's not certain but it's it's workable we can work with it that's fine so if you find a hadith on giving charity on helping people on being kind these things fit in with the greater parameter of Islam that's fine you can use these things you know you find something interesting it fits in hamdulillah you find something odd

clashing with these things it's on this one big problem my friend so so on that note and bihari seems to solely be transmitted really with because our taking of hadith has to be Biss Simha it has to be motto sanam miss sama has to be connected through teaching that only comes through one man Muhammad in the use of al saraburi [Music] remember that name people al farabi no February robbery this one dubious

character robbery robbery that's where I think the problems began nobody that knew thoroughly in his lifetime ever vouched for him as a reliable person in hadith so we are taking all of this from one guy who nobody vouched for and the people who vouched for him came like like several generations after him that between like almost 200 years after him and that - did they even vouch for him this doubt furry that's doubtful what's definitely clear people who came three four hundred years after him vouched for him what the hell

is that about how can I vouch I oh yeah that guy used to be really nice to have a good memory do you know him no no no do you no no no no oh he was from 300 years ago oh nice so so let's take a look at some of these things in Bihari people now people say I mentioned some of these previously because what is this book that way defending so I want to mention a few others today just to kind of let this body get settling I have challenged people come discuss the scholars or people are calling out on this

authenticity of Bihari with me no the truth is most of them don't even understand this topic right so let's take a look at these people this this woman this one sahih bukhari you know this one forever you know so look at this hadith hadith kitab you shahadat al bukhari hadith - 2006 - 6 5 5 ok 2,655 a hadith transmitted that the messenger allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam heard

somebody yo creo feel masjid he heard a man reading the Quran in the Masjid fuck-all rahim allah he said may allah have mercy on him la Cotte F Quranic Arabic essa I attend a Scott - who named in Surat ek the vachetta he said may Allah have mercy on him this man just reminded me of such-and-such a verse which I had forgotten the Prophet had forgotten and I had dropped them from this surah look the Prophet had

forgotten the Quran the Prophet had forgotten the Quran he heard a mind-reading and said oh oh masha'Allah you know my love mercy on him he reminded me me about that verse which I've dropped from the Quran I forgot that was in the Quran this is inside Bukhari look since I in vihari two six five five right so okay interesting right so this is this is the kind of thing we're speaking about check this out on this walls way

on this speaking about the Quran there's a hadith in kitab omaha Rabine a book about rebels and like what we'd call today terrorists and stuff like this right so in this chapter hadeeth six eight-30 it's a very long hadith about stoning very lengthy but in it first problem is there's something interesting side point here interesting side point but the person says well like I said no Omar was about to say something lobby Allah on and the person says he will say

tonight something he's never said since he's been the Calif what caller for uncle Elias or the person listening to that said no don't be silly ma aceite Aniyah all ma aceite in your own which is actually grammatically not that right it ought to be ma I saw in your food ma I said and you have to look so first of all but I know it's reversed camera but even in the footnotes they highlight it ought to be ma si in your cool so grammatically it's not spot-on

it's not the biggest error but it's not spot-on it's supposed to match it's not supposed to be mad a SATA and your holy supposed to be Marisa is about third person but you know this one relate this one slide you know there are no big problem then Sedna Homer says let me tell you he gives a speech in the speech he's saying in the car I look in the car alone lucuma Carla but oh dear Ileana allaha la RA la ilaha and he begins his whole speech and he says wallahi in allahabad as a muhammad Allah sent Muhammad bill haughty with the truth ones Allah al al khattab and

he revealed with him the book if I can am in my unzila ma Angela law and from that which Allah revealed ayat origin was the verse of stoning people to death now there is no verse of stoning people to death in the quran quran aha and we used to read it well and we used to understand it what were I know huh and we used to comprehend it Felisa roger maris ooh-la-la Waregem nevado and that's why the messenger Allah stoned and we stoned after him so

according to this said no omen attributing it to omen look disrespecting or mark attributing to Omar that he is saying that oh they used to be this verse in the Quran and we used to read it wish to know it in another hadith Omar says if it wasn't for people gonna say this and this about me I would show them that way this used to be read in the Quran right so this is disrespectful to - Omar is disrespectful to the Quran is trying to say that what is saying the Quran has changed this is

what is trying to say now check this out disrespectful to the prophet salallahu alaihe salam yeah now this is a hadith from prior to prophethood it's inside Buhari it's under the chapter the discouragement of being naked in prayer cara here - tarifa sala hadith re6 for in this hadith it's speaking about when they were moving the stones to build the Kaaba rebuild the Kaaba at this time the Prophet is carrying a stone and he is

told by a bus for parallel Abbas is uncle Yabba ah he'll oh hello is Arak you know the Prophet the Arabs used to wear an Azad which is like a sarong like wrap it round like they never used to wear trousers like that and a stylist Winnie's are so it's like wraparound kind of a bit like a Dorothy that we have in like Auto style or look a bit like the longer but the longer is usually all tied all round it's just a loop that you get into this was open like a sarong kind of thing so a burst says to the Prophet why don't you take off your his arm put it on your

shoulders and you can carry the stones like that so he does that though it says for challah who so the Prophet opens his arm and he puts it on his shoulders and then for socket among Chien he falls unconscious former ruia but Italica rhiannon after that day he was never seen naked again this is hadith 364 Wow that is this is how we are repaying the

our profits with respect that is nonsense and then do you know the scholars will do Jim acrobatic kind of gymnastics too oh no he never you know I never got naked like it was just a bit of his thigh they saw a bit of he says he was never seen naked after that day the chapter heading is discouragement of being naked right so let's see look at this describing disrespect this once

again well let me show you people right now okay here I'm just looking at which one to go through okay here's a hadith in Qatar boo but I'll Hulk this is the beginning of creation it's hadith number three - four - okay the Prophet is saying Abu Hurairah

saying that we were with the prophet and he said Baena and anion whilst I was asleep rah atony fill Jenna while I was asleep I saw myself of being in paradise I was in paradise I was kind of walking around and and he says farm to table a large animal I saw I saw this woman doing voodoo at the side of a palace so I said lemon heart al pastor whose is this palace Khalu they told me it's honorable kebabs it belongs to Omar so the prophesied for

the car to Vera Tahoe oh I remembered Omar is very like he has this kind of jealousy like Leila is like translated as in like he doesn't want that that kind of jealousy especially to do with women like I don't want you talking to my women folk I don't want this I don't want that like so you I the prophesied for I remembered Omar and his era and for one lay too much barren so I turned away basically from this woman like he turned away and then it mentions Omar cried and said yara saleh would I ever be jealous of you like what do you mean by that

so look at this so this is the Prophet like this this is how it's describing the Prophet like Oh like he's seeing this woman and then saying oh and seeing this palace or who's oh oh Omar oh yeah he's jealous about his women and places so I'll just turn away and look what light its casting upon our beloved prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam now let me tell you what else so apart from the profit forgetting the Quran and the Prophet look how they described now listen to this this is a

very famous hadith this one the Prophet on his final deathbed this is incredible mahadji the book of to do with war fee and stuff like that battles and it's hadith number four four three one that the Prophet this I'm not a bass says that Yamagami is on on thursday or on this day i mean there's some difference I mean generally they're going with human he says the day is called your mother means right now on this day the prophet sala allah salem became very ill the pain like the pain is feeling a lot of pain so he said for Allah Oh Tony

October Kum Kee turban lentil Diliberto a burden bring me a piece of paper let me write something for you so you can never be misguided so for Tunisia oh well a young body I'm gonna be in Tennyson so they started to like argue amongst themselves and you know they start to have like a dispute amongst themselves and it doesn't it's not befitting to have this dispute with amongst in the presence of a prophet for Paolo they said this is the hell it's portraying the companions of the prophet of God for

colu Masha know what they said what's it what what's what's up with him what's up with the Prophet ah ha Jarrah is Stefan i stuffy move but a Hajj era means is he speaking deliriously like is he speaking nonsense like what's he talking about like a Hydra is to speak deliriously like you political omocha like like you you're not making any sense this is what this is what they apparently saying about the Prophet the Companions I mean look at the nonsense attributing that this this is not true like this kind of

stuff that it the way it's attributed we are doing at this the Shia always use this hadith to attack the Companions we don't do any justice to ourselves because we're allowing it we're allowing it so look at this one I mentioned this one before right right about seeking a child the Prophet Solomon hadith in kita Balaji had 2 8 1 9 that Solomon ELISA Lam the Prophet son of Dawood said tonight I will have sex with a hundred

women or in one narration 99 women right and he said they will all give me a baby the löwe give me a child who'll become a warrior and there's a few hadeeth with the same thing now he said they will all give me and somebody says his friend said to him say in sha Allah follow me Allah insha Allah he never said it so none of them got pregnant except one and she had a handicapped child and the Prophet said if he had said insha'Allah he would have been given like healthy warrior children from all of them now first of all just look at the absurdity

in that head the absurdity in that heavy let alone the fact that ok I'm gonna have sex tonight with 100 women or 90 women in this one ninety-nine one hundred in the other narration 90 I mean let alone the fact that even if you try to calculate that in terms of timings you try to say okay let's just put a time to that like how long does this take alright so even if you could let's say if that's possible so you're gonna say what like you're gonna give minimum what like I mean you like you're gonna have

to it would be impossible you would be looking I think I did it on a calculator where I said let's say 15 minutes which is no way like that's but still if you and that went into God knows like 16 17 hours or and 10 minutes if you if you said something like that it went into I think 15 hours non-stop this apart from the ludicrous II of what it's suggesting that this is a prophet of God trying to say tonight I will have sex with 100 women that will bear me a child each will become a warrior right apart

from putting the prophet of God Solomon Ali Salaam in such bad light right his friend says to him say inshallah now there's only two reasons he didn't say inshallah either he forgot or he was too arrogant to say there's only two reasons like I can't be like okay I'll change the word arrogant can't be bothered a prophet can't be bothered to say inshallah look how you're disrespecting a prophet all he forgot fine you can forget but then because he

forgot God punished him this is a punishment so God gave him a handicapped baby so handicapped babies are a punishment from God to a prophet so God is punishing his own profit for not saying inshallah either because the prophets - arrogant to say well either because the Prophet just forgot and even though you forgot God still decide to punish him by giving him a handicapped baby what the hell is that about what the hell whoa what kind of a picture is that of God what kind of a picture is that of prophets what kind of a picture why this

is the nonsense that we are seeing this is the kind of nonsense so we need to really be transparent with ourselves that look yes if a hadith fits in with with the conditions with reason if it fits in with it doesn't clash with the Quran and the general understanding of Islam and it doesn't approve Islamic principles we will accept it if it does it will go out the window and this Sahil Buhari say this is not so sorry albahari alpha robbery is not a reliable transmitter and he's the only

transmitter you have of this book right so now look at this hadith in the virtues of the companion this hadith is hadith number three three thousand three double six three it's a hadith by again once again from abulia man who says I was informed through should I push a big navvy Hamza not by the way on a site now we all know I will you man he didn't even what did I was right the legend he was even senior to Bihari say I will ya man never - he only took one hadith ever from Scheib he just took a book which was sure I was booking sorry

transmitting it but put that aside that's a side discussion in this hadith the Prophet said somebody said Abu Huraira says I heard the prophecy waltz one day venom our enemy he that there was a shepherd amongst his sheep a wolf came and took his sheep so the shepherd tried to take it back so the wolf turned to him and said so the wolf spoke the wolf spoke Arabic yes the wolf said Mandla hyoma saba lie meaning who will get this on the day when there is no shepherd

no male cell aha in Haiti when I'm the only shepherd like the wolf so not only did the wolf speak the wolf spoke eloquently La Manga right so the wolf spoke eloquently so once he's doing this another man like so and then whilst a man so the hadith seems to jump to another scenario that walls a man was one day riding he was riding a cow like he was on top of the cow riding a cow so fell tougher that's Eleison the cow into

the man I can think of some other jokes but I'm not gonna say them right so God where my humor takes me out so this guy so the cow turns to him and he says the cow says in Elam luckily hada the cow is speaking for Sierra Wikia so the cow says I have indeed I have not been created for this while lacking me who left a little health but I've been created for plowing the fields for

colonist so people said subhanAllah wow this is you know amazing for calling Nabi and then the Messenger of Allah said o Allah he I in the I bring faith on this like I have faith on this story to be true in the ottoman of italic i believe in that whatever worker whoa Omar abdul-fattah but check this interesting thing apart from the absurdity of this description of the story and the chain being so stupid as well as I mentioned but put those things aside here the Prophet goes

on to say I believe in this and Oh butter and all marble even is radi allahu anhu ma the prophet uses the words radi allahu anhu ma these words were used like this these words came much after like weave like muslims we use these words when we're gonna speak about the Companions so as you can see the Prophet says radi allahu anhu ma like mashallah so me and my companions are the allahu anhu ma like and which is

clearly made now somebody could say yeah well ok the the raw we just put that in but the whole story look at it trying to say that these wolves speaking arabic cow speak arabic cows don't understand concepts like they don't understand concepts like teleological purpose and you know there's a purpose for this and and moves don't understand also have concepts of like okay like future planning and ok what will happen on that day and animals don't think like this

for God's sake for God's sake this is okay so let's just take one to others and I'll show you something interesting now check this out people they say hadith in Bukhari hadith number three four three one once again through a boolean man saying shy Akbar nah he didn't say I had nothing on because you know this one I'm not true

he says mam M Bani Adam ma loot there is no child born from Bani Adam Allah no child every child from adam's offspring including the Prophet every child that is born no child born Allah Yama so Shaitaan ohina unit for yester hello sorry hon face the hill oh sorry honey mustard Shaitaan except the devil touches him oh he is all kind of like pinches him however here it seems to say like touches him and then the child

screams out crying so they saying this is why whenever a baby is born the baby cries because the devil touches him and there's no child born except he has been touched by the devil later except Oh mashallah so there's an exception oh yeah yeah yeah later Maryam Baba Neha except Mary Blessed Mary and Jesus Christ our Saviour so apart from them - Wow so everybody all of the prophets the

Prophet Muhammad sallallaahu lives and all these things they've all been inflicted by the touch of the devil but God forbid the the the the Immaculate Conception of Mary and the you know the the the the blessed conception of Jesus they will obviously exempt from this right so this is the the kind of stuff that people and it doesn't like look you know something we say that we have an issue why she are criticized I Cheryl de l'eau and I'm and and that's I feel rightly so like you know she was the wife of the Prophet and to criticize

her is in a way I feel to criticize the Prophet because at the end of the day she was his wife and beloved to him and the Sunnis have an issue with the Shia about this that you know the Shia go on they disrespectful to eyeshadow the alone but look here look here in Qatar bow for the homos hadith 3 104 and NAFA and Abdullah or the Aloha and that the messenger stood up one day and he gave a hoot ba and he gave a speech so I sure our network mask any Ayesha and he

pointed towards the house of Ayesha and he said uh hoon Elif it's not this is where the fitna will be and he said it three times Annelle fitna have another fitna this is where the fitna will be mean hey sue at la corniche a pond where the devil will bring forth its head Wow that's to the house of Asia what the hell is wrong with these people well this is so disrespectful to our prophet - I shall all day long on how so

beloved - Muslims generally speaking we seriously need to be questioning what on earth we're trying to push as and there were many other things you know like little things I mean these ain't big things but once again had the earth like look not the prophets went to sleep some Nadia - Amma had to another until you could kind of hear almost like snores like my old kind of snoring almost like that deep sleep kind of and then he gets up and praise and he says him well of me it's odd that he didn't do what do you

know like this is in hadith 137 my point is people that this is the issue this is why Buhari gate was so important and we have to remember this whole book transmitted on the back of one man robbery robbery gonna trolling him for every coat entomophagy the public will not forgive forever anybody transmitting I mean it doesn't have to be just for every no people transmitting this nonsense this hatred

against our prophet this disrespect saying that the Prophet Solomon and this I will have sex like this and then being cursed by God like as punished with a handicapped child saying the Prophet felt naked saying that our prophet Mary a little girl saying that our prophet forgot the Quran and was reminded by somebody saying our prophet was sitting there the revelation came down wrong they forgot to mention the the disabled people and then he got updated saying things like oh all of these things are marked on hot table saying there's extra

verses in the Quran that used to be the all of these kind of things people all of these kind of things especially things like this look just think about it the Prophet saying I forgot the Quran oh oh I forgot oh I'd forgotten that oh yeah that was the Quran wasn't it without I forgot that verse this is how they repay Oprah this is how these were hobbies honestly these filthy prop haters of our prophet honestly this is how they repay our prophet and these

were Hobby sympathizers today I like semi war hobbies as well this is how they want to repay the Prophet with this kind of nonsense and his companions they want to repay Omar like that they want to repay Aisha like that the Aisha oh you know the her house is where the devil is and stuff like this and this is what this is the nonsense