Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 125

and just share this from here [Music] oh there is a raah I see myself yes alone

almost done yeah Rai said done that's done Oh wah in alhamdulillah wa kafa for salat wa salam o allah rasool allah Mustafa well I bet in Ladino Toba Oh mommy hotel mr.

the Bobby a 30 al madina tougher bad for salam wa a little comb aluminum become Muammar heaven running lights bienvenidos a todos susharma d people bajalia and swagatam right so Allah Ibrahim Allen doing it doing it more Simon Navid I don't know Salim become a domicile and sham animus Adnan assalamu aleikum mostly Sahib how to March a

tourist who bust who bust it's very well it's very well right come visit NYC why not why not spread spread the love and with it the fittin and facade but why not so what is going on people what is going on Oh Salim Dona this fittin facade I log on to social media and I'm seeing these

expose days after exposes body these calamities tsunamis afflicting people yes Salam and end of times any cuz the end of times right so this on one hand you've got great great buddy-buddy celebrity scholars being hounded and pounded and on the other hand you've

still got the hasanat saga going on you've got God what is going on all right so this well I suppose welcome to the world of Muslim drama that's that's the thing people that's the thing smart oh yeah I bought this I thought let me check it out it's one of those if it meets versa I think it's called I thought sure no big thing let's let's see let's see what what goes down with this thing all right IRA you know here's

something I was speaking to somebody last week and he said to me he said you know I've been speaking to some he's been speaking to different Imams and darts and people like that over time and he said some of them they said you know Mufti there's no way on earth looking at him that he could have this kind of knowledge so first of all that kind of massaged my ego B while I people while I

you know release I love honesty that's so they said well you know how can it be that this movie look just look at him there's no way on earth somebody looking on a Kim could have this kind of knowledge of the Deen so the only way this is happening is because Shia theme like the actual jinn are whispering to him so the jinn give me this kind of knowledge so I can deceive people [Laughter]

lah-lah and part of my pact with the jinn this is this is legit this is this person actually believe this I mean he was telling this person related to me that part of my pact with these jinn is that I do the devil sign so this one's going out too my gin homies out they keep it real keep it real keep the knowledge coming keep it coming yeah could you all be without tell me some some interesting gossip I'll do

more of these signs God hilarious hilarious yeah why is it just you know the Muslim culture or not all not all but much of many aspects of the Muslim Muslim culture why is it just so dumb am I the only one that feels this so is this like a mutual feeling out there I don't know but it's so it's like so bottom set if either special needs kind of Sen group you have like I don't know

what sets they are now it's so much like that isn't it and it's like what I call the sunshine group just crayons and it's okay just give them crayons and don't worry I'll explain this must I lie to you today we're gonna color in the word Haram Haram less color in everyone yeah that's the capacity at which so many religious people operate they just

operate at oh you know it's like somebody said I might as well begin this gonna cut up gigantic right so some I might as well begin by addressing you know some people they picked on this issue so I posted one or two because I can see my reflection I mean in my

mirror image that I've got that at that on so I might as well on side I've obviously not taking it off this week so I've got some photo up on Instagram where somebody a few people objected that look Musti sob they said most eSAB this one not nice you know this one they said the earring thing for men tata hearing in men instantly the image becomes blurry and I only see female anatomy

so they said only you become a woman if you wear an earring I thought ah it's a Hanukkah is that how it works I'm new to this you know i i'm i naive simple sad sad to keep us under login i thought is that how it works a charm right so when i put that on I've got to i've assumed don't assume my gender i'm i can now just walk into the

female toilets sir can't you tell so people kind of commented saying so I'm assuming that must work the other way around as well Deborah's asking that yes I suppose if somebody takes off the earring that must clearly just be a man it must be like mmm no your ink gotta stop cardi sup up is that you carries up

in the dock so this is this is the level at which people are operate that's like full optimum that's like Einstein level at the religious community level you know that's like they operating full Einstein capacity they that so I thought cello why don't I answer the question for them let's take a look right right let's see this

what is this issue of earrings or jewelry for men jewelry in general some people you see it's quite interesting that I said to people let me begin by saying this jewelry is absolutely permissible for men or women it's absolutely permissible let me just begin with the default you know the just I'm just this is this is what I'm selling this is the product people so jewelry is absolutely permissible it's not Haram definitely not Haram and it is

permissible men or women now let's develop the argument slightly now the thing is that different cultures Oh in different communities over time have celebrated the adornment they kind of jewelry's in different ways so whether that be male or female so they've done it differently so if you went back I mean if we take a look at things like necklaces now I don't know maybe for during certain centuries women

wore necklace necklaces more than men arguably one could say that if you take a look at things like bracelets or bangles let's say bracelets whatever you want to call them I would say that arguably there was a period of time that maybe that was definitely equal and men wore as many kind of bracelets bangles if you take it right back to even the Roman times and things like that you can see from the kind of the history that they would weigh these kind of straps and things like this and even throughout the different cultures that you had and

yes there's been some communities where maybe women have worried more and some maybe where men have worn these things more and the same thing goes with earrings and stuff like this so this is really just a community coach issues that all it is now people would say did the Prophet with this now of course the Prophet didn't worried but that's not to say it's Haram okay you know just because the Prophet didn't do something does not make it Haram okay that's the that's the proper Sen

the bottom set level of arguing that all but did the Prophet do it but did the Prophet live in England right but did did the Prophet eat fish and chips did the Prophet you know so it's not this is not how you argue okay I understand that they arguing at their best capacity but they've gotta up the game evolution has already taken place and you know Homo sapiens have developed so the the argument is that did the Prophet

prohibit did he say these things are Haram in Islam now because you have many hadith with the Prophet refrained from certain things so for example there is something known as a kind of like a desert lizard it's not like a small lizard is this reptile which some of the Arabs used to eat so you have a hadith with some of the Companions are sitting down eating it and they offer it to the prophet and the Prophet says no I I won't eat it

so the companion says a Haram one who is it Haram and the Prophet says he says later and me lamb I did who they are the home either except it's not Haram it's just that where I grew up people never ate it and he said for a Jaden er fool so I find like I have a strong distaste like I find myself aynd it quite nauseating almost but it's not Haram so taste is a different thing but terrine the Shriya is a different thing so when you look at the evidences you see allah

mentioning in the koran for example enticing men by saying that look why don't you strive for a paradise and in this paradise in this jannah we will give men a cell where i mean that we will give them bangles and bracelets made out of gold so the one question here is that well if bracelets or bangles are haram for men let's say then is God cross-dressing men in Jannah is he giving them is he making them dress up as women because that doesn't make any sense now you could say well the

gold aspect first of all I I know I've got a separate clip on YouTube where I explain cold is not Haram but let's say if you did believe gold was Haram then that makes sense you could think well okay he's giving the bangles or bracelets made out of gold so the gold aspect but if bangles per se were haram for men it was something only women wore then the men would feel really awkward kind of cross-dressing in paradise that why are we being dressed up as women that's like saying to men I know gold is Haram but don't worry when you get to Jannah will give you high yields made

out of gold and the men would be like [Laughter] [Music] this so the issue is that it doesn't make any sense okay so you have in the Quran seems to intimate that things like bangles and bracelets men did with them and they were not Haram the gold discussion is a separate discussion with the made of gold the next issue you see is the famous story that the Prophet said to Soraka he

said to him that look Soraka how will you be on the day when when you received the bangles the bracelets from kisara the Persian king as the dynasty collapses so he you can see that and then in the time of Omar when Persia the Sassanid Empire collapses Omar actually makes him with him he gives them two men he says I'm the one I want to actually place them on you so was Omar or the Alon cross-dressing him was that is that what's going on so you see these arguments completely fall

apart then you have a fatwa of Imam Malik where he's asked about young boys wearing earrings made out of gold so he says the parents shouldn't make them wear earrings out of gold now if the earrings themselves were Haram then Imam Malik would have said they shouldn't make the children way with the boys because speaking my boys the boys wear earrings full stop why say out of gold right so that's another argument you have so you have all of these kind of arguments another thing is that a lot of these people who assume these things are Haram they going by an

uber an ultra mega generic statement that the Prophet didn't like he didn't like the men who were pretending to be women and he cursed them he said that those men who are pretending to be women and those women who are pretending to be men so this is the hadith that a lot of these people use and so they now extrapolate and extrapolate based on culture and then extrapolate based on those extrapolations and say well anything we deemed to be feminine let's say in our culture whatever that may be

we will then deem that to fit in this hadith but let's just take that argument for a moment let's let's run with it you have in in the prophets time many of the companions and many people in the Arab culture they the men walk ahead in the eyes you know Surma least and they still do many Arabs and even many Pakistanis for example in Pakistan they were sort of my religious people because they think it's unknown although Imam Malik said it's not something that obviously correct in the majors go but still they think it's

honor but they were God in their eyes now I would say so which is eyeliner and they feel that there's no issue with wearing men wearing eyeliner I mean in this society that would definitely be deemed something that women do let alone the fact that men weigh a thought now in the West most people see a thawb as a frock they do they actually think that's like a dress like a woman's dress like a frock they so they they understand that Arabs wear this in the Gulf they wear

this kind of frock but so but that's that kind of frock dress is what women we I mean men don't usually walk around in the West wearing a frock but yet men are happy to kind of wear a frock soap and they're happy to wear eyeliner and then they say that that's absolutely fine but god forbid should somebody have a bracelet on or something they are

clearly a woman and you think well okay my friend you think it's time for your medicine this this this this clearly doesn't make any sense so I saw an answer that just to show I'm not saying people need to do these things but these things are not Haram and I present an open challenge open challenge you know these people who object to it take it to your machine you know be Taji take it take it to them

and ask them bring me a verse of the Quran or a clear hadees hadees clear hadith bring me one I ask you for the second bring me one that says it's Haram and and I can clearly challenge this is a challenge from me that you won't even be able to bring one not a single hadith you won't even be able to make one up will be I'm buckling it that will catch out as well so bring me just one hadith

and the fact that you can't you see me I refuse to blindly follow the words of men but others are welcome to do so if you want to you can blindly follow your nose michype that tell you it's Haram I have no objection it's your life leave it as blindly as you like but as to me I asked for compelling conclusive evidence if you have it presented cool so Allah Allah somebody said I just can't imagine

him being the man well I'm not any man problem solved obeah yay Mustafa who wants to be an imam I don't want to be any man I'm very clear look there's no this is the thing all these great people you think of in the past let me just pause pause pause all these great scholars that you think of in the past Imam Malik Imam Abu Hanifa Imam a chef a imam bukhari all these great Imams none of them were ever Imams

in their entire lifetime never could they be an imam in a mosque ever Mali Imam Malik didn't even go to the mosque for 25 years he didn't I mean the last 25 years of his life heat and refused to go to the mosque but the other Imams who did used to go to the mosque not a single one of these Imams who you guys all everybody has heard their names let's say able to tell me even though he's not I mean I don't okay he's a scholar I don't consider him an imam but you know let's say whoever all these famous Imams not a single one of

them was an imam in a Masjid ever serve a lenient thought they would never have been allowed they were never allowed the Masjid Imam was always set by the state and that that's as simple as it was these people never let a single German their entire lives right so you know when you talk about these great magnificent Imams and these great people they never let a single Gemara in their lives ever so I mean it's don't get me wrong those people were Imams I respect them I think they're doing a great job may Allah bless them preserve them but I

have no aspiration to become an imam it's not my style I don't want to become an imam so saying that you know I can't picture this guy being any mom he's cool there's no no contradiction hadith right let's take some questions what method do you suggest for finding the true hadith right you've got Matt Matt I know masala and Shirin Allen walaikum A'Salam right so the hadith discussion is incredibly

interesting you see like I said you've got to understand something that hadith is a consider hadith like a reservoir a kind of a source of raw material but not all of the raw material that even the ones they consider sahi or actually is actually usable or is it of any value okay a bit like I don't know like finding diamonds I guess you're gonna find many things but as you come across

them in nature much of it is you can't really use it it's just you know it's unusable so it's in a similar way hadith works in a similar way we have this reservoir of hadith now I do not reject hadith I do believe that hadith do you have truths in them but we have to sift through them the hadith must must match up to this criteria of the three criteria the golden criteria which is that it cannot clash with reason it cannot clash with the Quran

and it cannot uproot an established Islamic principle so my lamb your lamb you are a delmar cool walamu you by an ill man or Whalum you not idle 'soul so these three things that it does not go against that is incredibly important another thing to understand and I've got this whole thing I've got a video on youtube if you haven't seen it please take the time out and see it it's called Buhari gate Sahil Bihari is just a regular book of Hadees it is not on the standard that people have placed it ok so hello Hadi has many mistakes in it

he has many problems inside it has many blasphemous hadith in sahih bukhari not overall overall the collection of sahih al-bukhari that we have today is about 7,700 hadith but there are a certain percentage which are blasphemous they contradict with Islam they in fact disrespect our prophet they disrespect other prophets they show our prophet scandalous there's many that they are these kind of hadith in Sahil Bihari now these are clearly mistakes that people have put in there and unfortunately the scholars have allowed them to just pass

through and that's because more than anything the scholars you see there was it depends which scholars did these things so you see there was an era that comes which is the second wave of mahadeva hadith in SCORM ahadith is a scholar concerned with hadith the second wave of the head the project of the Mojave theme so the first wave is in the first is in the second century and third century of Islam so you've got beginning with the people like imam malik and those people did they're the best people in my malik those people that sound is a pound i mean that that is the legend the epic

the heroes of this ummah after them you have this huge you know this sir this this kind of surge in these activism oh it's almost like hadith but on steroids so you have the next 100 years a you know just a these people ridiculous claims being made about hadith you know all of a sudden people now know a million hadith waited a million hadith even come from let's just be honest you know imam malik who was the dawn of

this one man he never made such a claim you know yeah corn who are these people coming a hundred years later making a claim that they know a million hadith or two generations after imam malik i mean this this kind of stuff so you start to see people exaggerating because they want a stake in this they they want to be pioneers there's a lot of human rivalry going on there's a lot of competition people want to make a name for themselves which is all human effort so this starts to take place a huge this is the huge wave so if we consider this actually let's consider this the second

wave because the first wave the emergence of hadith project is quite sincere it's very sincere I would feel that's according to me so I would feel that that like the likes of Imam Malik the likes of Allah ie and people like this at that stage sophie-anne ignoring this stage is very what I feel the first this is the kind of like the the proto stage so it's all good and pure and and kind of like mainly innocent the second wave you have which is the hadith on steriods stage that we have we all of send this a million hadith that's what we call what I would like to call the Cambrian explosion

takes place now with this Cambrian explosion you have there's a lot of people making up hadith because there's no way that all of a sudden two hundred years after the Prophet people now have a million teachings of the Prophet whereas closer to the Prophet they only had a few thousand so that doesn't add up right so that you'd you're definite that there's a lot of fabrication or manipulation and things like these are taking place there's a lot of blagging so even these so-called pious people start to do things like Todd lease and

for some reason the Haditha scholars turn a blind eye to the lease that's at least some of them like contemporaries of Imam Malik like shot by declared it Haram yet you see it's at least is when I know the person I'm transmitting from is weak but I drop him this is one type of the reason I drop him and use the other person's name because I know if I use his name people are gonna catch me out now that's just blatant like I mean that I I can say to that as that should that I consider that to be like Haram there's

no way that you are purposely misleading people about what the Prophet said yet the scholars of hadith seem to accept all these metallocene like you know these huge model listen like Qatada etana is like epic as a model is much epic modernly scene yeah what what are they like I think a few a couple thousand hadith of his in body I mean the point is that obviously people like even Asha hubzu epic model the scene of huge epic proportions

now some there's a lot of questions here why do these this wave of Mahad the theme let this go I think it's because if they didn't they couldn't it was part of the investment of the project that they're invested in because they are invested in hadith if they choked out all of these narrations they're not gonna have much to bargain with they're not gonna have many chips like this so they allow it because they too are a part of this game I'm not saying they would sincere but I feel they weren't angels the way some people make them out I feel

that they you know some of them were aware of what they were doing put it like that they weren't maybe that they justified it islamically like maybe they thought that they're doing it for a better cause so they justified it as religious people do all the time so whenever people are doing something which others might call corrupt they will justify they'll say no no this is okay because you know it's okay so I've read the other day like there's a famous statement of Imam Muhammad and I think this statement is is a tragedy I think it's one of the viruses that have infected this Ummah and that is that this statement that is

transmitted Allahu Alem if he actually said it but many of the Hannibal alike even it's a mere say see it says it sorry that this that they say for Serco Alice Sunnah that the criminals those who commit sins from Allah Sunnah or only Allah or the Friends of Allah and the at PR or the pious people of the deviance of the movie today rain right or from the enemies Adela and they are

from the like they are utterly uses so it doesn't matter how biased like what they're trying to say is that regular Sunni Muslims so long as they are Sunni they can be the worst of people but they are still the olia because they just happen to be born in a Sunni family and let's say different sects whether it's going to be the Jabari the kadhi the Shia whatever they are the different sects because they're born in that sect even if they were really pious people they are doomed and users and and forever they are the enemies of God

this statement which allegedly Imam Ahmed said this is the the seed of the problem that we are now facing you see because this sells the seeds of hatred but my point is you see when people can justify things they use religion so coming back to the hadith project you will see that those scholars may be justified these things and sometimes they may have done it on based on what they thought was good reasons I'll give you an example actually this is an

interesting case I was looking at this the other day and I'll just share it with you if I bring this up now this you see this a narration and this will give a little example of what I'm talking about [Music] right now this a narration which speaks about the oh here is its in Bihari and it's in the Muslim Ahmed now according to this narration it speaks of the

Prophet as somebody who before prophethood so if not all mod is transmitting this hadith now I want you to pay attention to this because this is really important from two angles one I want to show how false hadeeth have entered our resources and two I want to show how the hands were at play as sometimes trying to manipulate things so if you pay attention please focus at this point now there is a hadith inside Buhari that claims that the Prophet before Islam used to eat meat that was that

used to passively participate in pagan practices so it says that the Prophet used to eat the meat dedicated to us learn Latin and you would partake in all of the now what's interesting is this hadith which is transmitted by mu sigma akbar from salem from abdullah bin ahmad who says that the prophet salaallah sallam he met one day they that not written enough a who is a famous companion at this place called balda now he says and this is before he became a prophet

now the prophet at that place Adam alayhi Rasool Allah Allah lives on so Frattin fiala ham so the Prophet laid out something with food in there and gave him meat gave this to they'd reject this meat to Satan a hammer now they didn't armor forever and yeah cool Amina he refused to eat from me and he said Emil an economy matters bhajana Allah and so become he said I don't eat from this meat which you sacrifice to your idol gods your pagan this is a didn't armour telling the Prophet this this is embody right so well ah Alcala Allah min Mizuki rasmalai

Ali I only eat that which is sacrificed to God alone he's rejecting the prophet's food and telling the prophet at this time the prophet isn't a prophet he's telling the prophet sallallaahu lives alone that I don't eat you me because you meet you guys are sacrificing it to pagan gods now you see this is an interesting example because this hadith is blasphemous this hadith shows that the Prophet used to partake in idol worship he used to partake in passively at least sacrificing to the

idol gods doing these things and I'll add to that in just a moment now the interesting thing is this hadith is also transmitted from the same moseyed not burn going from salim to abnormal by three other hadith supporting the exact same wording in the most environment now what's interesting his body then brings another narration in Kettleman Optum which is from transmitting from musa but this time the guy transmitting from him is a week narrator his name is Fidel apna Suleiman he's actually weekend rejected

in a marina basura Aloha everybody says this guy's major problematic for Dale his name is but fidei changes the wording you see for Dale says in his narration that he says instead of Adama Lahey rasul allah allah allah allah wa sallam he mentions but he says for good dima alayhi you see that this food was presented to the prophet and in the other narrations in most environment they say but thimerosal allah allows aid

and he adds fatima for edema and he mentions alayhi to the prophet that this food he switches he says that they presented this food to the prophet either say the banana which doesn't add up because they the muhammad wasn't pagan but that's how the wording is he kind of switches it to say no that the verb he switches the verb to say no that it's being passed to so it's not that he passed it it was passed to he kind of changes the word to show that this was passed to the prophet and the prophet

rejected it but the other narrations all seem to suggest they all na suggests they clearly state that the Prophet passed it to save Adama who then saves to the Prophet that I don't accept your meat because it's sacrificed now there's two things to see here one the majority of all transmitters transmitted it like that that the Prophet was partaking in pagan practices now that is blasphemous and he goes against our understanding of Islam because there were many people who weren't partaking in pagan practices you have people like say Tamara is an

example you have many famous Arabs signature either a very famous you know somebody who always spoke about the the Hannah fear they're the kind of demon Hanif you had many Christians and Jews that were also present you had many of these things and influences so we know that was not true generally speaking now what's interesting is some narrator is manipulating the hadith to suit our general understanding now although that's I respect that fair enough even though he's a very weak narrator but I respect that bow Hadees brought it probably because of that

reason just to kind of get a bit of a balance but what is evident is he is manipulating he seems that he's very is manipulating this text and it makes if a person can manipulate this they can manipulate other texts so that's an interesting point and you get a few more of these and I'll mention something here's just a token note Walter on this discussion you have Hisham you know Hisham even Ottawa from him Haytham is transmitting that the prophet named his children after the false gods in

jahiliyyah those who were born in J Helia so you have him saying that he says that those who say pick up the Prophet sons names worth per year been paid he says that they he says that they've got it wrong this is Hisham saying this he says they this is the names they gave them in Islam he says their names were Abdul Munna Munna was the feem the goddess like the servant of Manav and in another wire AB duchamp's or Abdul Rosa the servant of oz' the the goddess and he says the prophet named him that but that's because they were born pre

Islam now it's interesting that you see that this obviously clashes with the other nations but that's his sham the same guy who says the Prophet married Aisha at the age of six you know this is one big problem you know this this is why Imam Malik had a big issue with Hisham he said we don't accept what Hashem says you know this issue same issue from from the rewire to do with the age of Aisha so my point is that you see studying the science of hadith you can't I feel that you can't

just take a dogmatic approach you have to have a very comprehensive a very analytic evaluative approach in looking at this science in making sure everything adds up and I think a huge amount this needs to be re-evaluated problem is who will do it now people let's take let's take some other questions huh what's going on what's going on are we supposed to ask questions here oh you can somebody said some raw we use the

word for learning offal on yeah they use that sometimes to hide the name if miracles don't exist then is there any point in making Dora as Allah won't intervene he never has ie no miracles yeah but just because some said is true doesn't mean itself my mark is in the house as long silent animals that land in our mark right so right so I'm just trying to pour some of these so I can

read these questions how do you define Islamic principles okay Islamic principles are those principles that have been established by an overall what they call in is thicker a study and histogram means a comprehensive study of Islam so so many things point out that from me you can you kind of induce this principle that this is a principle in Islam so for example the principle that harm is all wait harm or to be removed now that is a principle now doral use al and now that is a principle in Islam

alma sharp are terrible tastier that hardship necessitates ease this is a principle so when you study so many different rulings this principle definitely is manifest see that oh right this is definitely a clear thing that Islam wants so these principles in the Sharia I think by and large a lot of them are agreed upon by most scholars but they disagree upon their application so they might might agree in agree on them in principle but disagree when it comes to application so

I uprooting these is an issue all right so what else is going on people what about hadith brought by man Bihari inaudible muff read however whoever is proud of mess up then let his father's private parts be cut off and then Hasan Basri through with so many chains yeah I mean these things don't seem to be valid hadith although the meaning of like people shouldn't be proud of the MSM that does come through from the teachings of the Prophet that he did

kind of he came down the whole Arab obsession with lineage in trying to say oh I'm the son of so-and-so I'm the son of so-and-so and I think this is really interesting and I mean what I was gonna say is I think what's really interesting is part of my study into Islam revisionism by looking at the claims that a lot of these modern-day Islam revisionists have been making it's forced me and this some people were working together this most America those of you that norm of the earth man

maravilla from North England he's kind of working with me we've got a collab going on this almost in my Rovia if you killed him right you doing it you doing it right so we're collaborating with one or two others on these on these matters and looking into them it's forced us to re-evaluate a lot of what we thought we knew as well and try and weigh things up so something that has clearly emerged seems to be like I mentioned before this whole thing of the Arab history pre Islam now it seems very clear that they

were there is a strong rich history Arab history pre-islamic it's important to understand in order to get to the point of Islam and see why things move forward in a particular direction but from that we come to learn that there was a huge Arab presence always in the Middle East this is something which has been heavily undermined by Islamic sources maybe not maybe not intentionally maybe some parts were done out of ignorance and some parts they just maybe some people did many people didn't know but they just didn't feel it was important I don't

know what their motives were but they didn't haven't highlighted so many Muslims think Arabs Arabia this is how it was and then with Islam Arabs spread that's actually not true it seems that they were hugely I mean there was a huge Arab presence in the Middle East from the Levant right through to Iraq right down and into Arabian Peninsula but there were many many more Arabs though millions of Arabs in the Middle East and only a few hundred thousand in the Arabian Peninsula most of the Arabs did not live in the Arabian Peninsula now that's actually something which okay may

not make so much of a difference but it's changes the picture of things so you start to see okay that's interesting and there were a huge most of those millions of those Arabs that were in the Levant which is modern-day Lebanon around the Palestine area you've got Syria around that area Iraq Jordan all of these areas that Middle East region was a huge part of it there was some I mean they weren't just exclusively Arabs but there were a huge bulk presence of Arabs they heavily outnumbering the

Arabian Peninsula most of these Arabs were all Christians there were Christians and many amongst them were Jews now this is something that is not mentioned as much or talked well in our sources now once you start to understand that you then realize why and I want to mention this point so pay attention why the arguments in the Quran are so addressed to the Jews and to the people of the book because you see what we didn't realize was the Arabic speaking people or people who could understand Arabic

they were by and large the people of the book but the non Arabian Peninsula the non Peninsula law were people of the book and it seems very likely that looking at some of these arguments so for example let me share this argument with you people like Patricia chrome for example in her she she has a few books but she raises this argument and she has some in depth and these people have been doing some really solid like I mean boy these people have committed they

committed their lives to Islam I'm serious not in there a way to become Muslim but to study the hell out of it and to find all these problems that they could with the Islamic sources and they've done a thorough job and I'm telling you honestly they I mean I'm not saying that it can't be answered but what I'm saying is there are there are some truths to some things that they are saying it's not like you know it's not like an absolute nonsense like some Muslim scholars most Muslim scholars I'm not familiar with their works I'm not Haggar ism I'm not talking about

Hagar ISM by the way so Patricia chrome moved on from Hagar ISM Hagar ISM was in the seventies a movement that was like the prototype where they began by saying look let's so they kept to these principles they said we're only going to take from Islam what can be proven through facts through archaeological facts or through other transmissions or through coins or through writings inscriptions we're not going to just take the Muslims word for it that was their principle which they stood true to right till the end but Hagar ISM was this belief that Islam was actually an

offshoot from Judaism and it stayed like that and later Muslims gave it this spin of a new identity of Islam now some of that they stuck to but Patricia Crone and these and some of these are the people they've really modified a lot of that argument and people I've read Don and so it's not this simple Haggar ism like if you read the book on so for example mekin trade or other books now they have they've raised a lot of questions and they seem to have done their homework so one of the questions that they've raised is about maca and they feel that maca is

definitely made up by Muslims so this chorus looking into a lot of these things and we've been researching we're still researching this this is going on this is being spanning a little while me and like I mentioned mostly my review m12 others now our conclusion so far all that you see maca I do believe maca did exist but maca was much smaller than we think and it was not a significant tell it was an insignificant town and it only gained its significance with the rise of

Islam so and it was nowhere near as large as Muslims thought it was like I think Muslims say maybe had a population of 15,000 or something I don't think that at all I think by looking at the evidence it would have been a very small town maybe a few thousand at best and it didn't it wasn't part I don't think it was part of the trade route I think they probably used to annex themselves to the trade route somewhere close to Thoth so they would probably meet it somewhere because thought if is part of the trade route as was other places Medina yathreb

and Faber and these play is were but muck and never appears on any of these documents even the I'm talking about the non-arabic documents so it seems that Makka in my understanding did exist because I just find it very difficult to believe that it was fabricated but I do believe that it may have not been as significant of as of a town as people assumed in later times so we assumed it was like the London of Arabia it was nothing like that I think it was just a small town and hence the resistance to it because

they would have thought who's this you know who are these people trying to take a sulphur I'm trying to spread their religion so that's one thing and I feel that the muckin people when they object it to the Prophet when they object it to the Prophet they brought down because the Prophet told them that he was from this line of prophets these Abrahamic prophets and that they brought to debate him because the Prophet spends it you know a considerable amount of his life the majority of his prophetic life in macao at least 13 years out of the 23

years now they they would have brought Jewish people Jewish scholars down from the other rest of the arabic-speaking world to debate the Prophet and hence a lot of these verses that are Maquis are actually addressing Jews because otherwise people take what there wasn't a Jewish presence in my car you see because this is one of the things that patricia chrome argues she says well it doesn't make sense they weren't many Jews in Makkah so why were some of these why was some of these Maquis surahs

arguing against the Jews the other thing is she picks up on this point of agricultural ISM and she mentions that Makkah didn't have any agriculture so why is the Quran the maquis warez addressing agriculturalists so why is Allah saying things like oh don't you see this genetic model shot in Romero shot in or Falacci you know and there's all these different fruits and you have a man and you have you have pomegranates and you have z-tune and you have all these kind of four wacky but Makkah didn't have these things and then she brings the point that especially the

verse in surah and I'm with Allah says well I talked about Ramana what's a tune about about general you know what is it fruits and things like this but names then pomegranate and olives and states were at Oaxaca who yamaja Saudi and give from it the day you harvest it but the interesting thing here right right the interesting thing here is that she highlights as well that but why is the Quran saying this when there was no olives in the Arabian Peninsula and

there was no agriculture in Makkah and they definitely weren't olives in olives didn't grow in the Arabian Peninsula they only grew around the Mediterranean and up to the lower part but not in - not in the Hejaz or below and things like this they were no olives so why is the Quran saying to give from olives and addressing them when they this is not an issue and its naming olives now this would have been because the people they brought to debate the Prophet were people from the Levant and from those regions from the the arabian from the Hassan II kind of like remnant of the

dynasties and and you have the mana Zahra the lamb it's and their dynasty so these two huge major dynasties that were mainly Christian and Jewish that lived in the Middle East not in the Arabian Peninsula and there were all Arabs and they far outnumbered the Arabs in Arabia they would have most likely come to Makkah to debate the Prophet now because we know there is a link between makan the capital let's say the capital of the Lama dynasty was here which take on this Arabic script and it's the cultural capital and we know there is a

link between era and Mecca and hence you have the son in the brother-in-law of Abu Sufyan who brings first the Arabic script that we have today they were calling in Arabic I mean it was Nabataean but they brings that to Makkah so my point in this is that there's certain narrations that we find in art of Syria and you'll find in Razi stuff seed and negatives are seen that they mentioned that this surah al-anam was revealed in one goal and why because it would have been a debate that there was a debate taking place that people were coming to challenge the Prophet people who were of Jewish background who knew

the Jewish text who knew the prophets of of old who knew these things Christians were coming so these verses were reminding them that look do you even yes you do have things you have blessings from God do you even give from the harvest do you even are you even grateful for the the fruits the blessings the risk that Allah has showered upon you so that was the angle of these ayat so it's important to know some of these things I thought I'll I'll mention some and another interesting

point this is definitely worth mentioning on this that you see the argument that some of these Islam revisionists are using is that Makkah was reinvented by Abdul Malik ibn Marwan and had judge and his of the Malik son you've got bullied and and these people they invented and played that role in creating the recreation of the Kaaba in in Mecca now I would say that if that be

true if that be true you see my proof for why this can't be true I have looked at a lot of these evidences about Petra and things like this but the reason why this can't be true it is because if you study our Islamic history there is an early split a major split between the key protagonists of Islam you have the main body of Muslims you have the Shia you have the huar age these main splits occur very early on

during the the the Halawa are Rashida if you want to call it that during say nineties time you have this split so these sources cancel the Shia have a rich tradition which they have been passing down passing down and they hated the bunny umeå they hated the rulers of bunny Omega they hated you know all these kind of Umayyads and they considered them to be oppressors and and they've rebelled against them on certain occasions whether it's going to be in the version of Zainul Abidin or it's going to be beginning with her saying or the allahu

allah saying or IBD no imams they either whoever you want to say they they had this struggle always going on and then you had the Huaraz who still continue till today the evildea and the Shia how can it be and they transmit these people translate so many things so the she I will say Oh bunny who may have made this up they added this to the Salah they added that they they all this exists how can it be that these three sources if we triangulate them they agree that the Tipler was in Mecca you see it doesn't make any sense that they because they would have

definitely used that argument they would have pounced on that argument can you imagine the Imams of the imma of the Shia tradition Imam Jafar he would have loved that to go on about why they look they've even changed the Qibla the Qibla used to be in Petra for example but the fact that they agreed on this thing demonstrates that that couldn't have been fabricated however yes some of the other pointers do need to be looked into we need to start your value like I said like so for example the trade thing the thing like okay why were they being

addressed as agriculturalists and like I said it makes sense now because they would have been bringing these other Arabs to debate the profit these Jewish Arabs and Christian Arabs cool I hope that makes sense about that I know there's been a lot of people who are looking into this it really baffles them but cool let's take some other questions people let's take some other questions Dordogne yeah a lot of this serious a lot of this seriousness let's see what's bothering the Ummah why did most Malik here consider it a breaker of

voodoo what is it what is it somebody mentioned about the Abyssinian history I think there are some documentation about Muslims there is some documentation about Muslims that migrated the histories mahi-mahi oh mercy a church our church our brother is the question the question is about

the fluid it's a fluid question people very fluid does the multi brake messy is pre-seminal fluid right does it break the rule what I mean generally the understanding of mathy is that it happens when a person is slightly excited you know this one you're slightly excited you know so at that stage a person you see what I would say is the way Imam Malik dealt with this and the Maliki method especially through the Iraqi

transmission is that look any sexual activity just repeat your model so because it's something that doesn't seem it allows you to get back in it's a real to get back into a spiritual state of mind that's all so I would say that's fine that makes sense and usually these kind of things only happen at that stage unless it's just happening unless you just walk around it's happening it's happening people in which case it's a medical

issue so in that case it wouldn't break the world oh if it was a medical issue and I don't consider these things to be impure by the way they're not impure they just they do break the will do because of what they associated with us in the whole the sexual experience and what's interesting is it's so check this out this is so weird right it's almost impossible almost I mean you do find it but hardly seldom

discussed about women and this issue so women having vaginal moisture or in that sense kind of emitting a kind of fluid when they're excited let's say when the excitement the know thick book generally touches up on that at all I mean they just don't mention it like they don't even cover the issue very few people have actually covered it I mean I know

we'll even burgee one of the Maliki legends he had to be a Maliki huh Maliki legends he discussed the issue and you'll have like how Bob mentions it in his huge commentary in there so you've got a sift through an entire commentary to find it but generally they just don't it like so people just don't know what to do and they just like well the women can figure it out it's like well but when you're covering all these other things in the book why are you covering and most big books refuse to discovery

like they just don't and that's a really strange thing because I remember many years ago during my studies when I went on a search to find this you're like a cha does this existent in the books let's find it and it's impossible to find and then eventually I mean you can track it if you if you search real hard but the point is that it's but the issue would be I feel that that wouldn't in my understanding that wouldn't break who do

vaginal fluids or moisture unless it was associated with sexual practice and then it would be the same as for the men cool ah find what you naughty naughty well there's many myths many myths so what is going on right so speaking of naughty naughty we've got the saga continues people of Hassen at NASA not I don't know if you guys have watched his he's

his replies some of his replies on Instagram he's done some responses and back and forth with Mohamed hijab and Mohamed a chairman Ali Dawa or like I mean know each other but with him they're going at it but the strange thing is only last year Ali Dawa made a video defending but I think the the the I suppose he says he says well I don't know I thought they were genuine battling cello see the problem is so I

tell you the problem that he any problem carrier what what is the heart of the problem let me pour it out for you people let me make it very clear see the problem is you know holy people they set their standards superhuman right and the truth is they're all corrupt they're all corrupt this is the truth so you know now some more than others

arguably of course of course some more than others some are slightly less corrupt but they're all corrupt but some more than others now the problem is when you set your standards so high in front of the dunya dunya dunya when you set your standards so high then it's only a matter of time before part ah you know before this veil is shattered but ah and then when this veil is removed the

wrath damn people I have to say people on social medias sandwich they like wild beasts they like the hills of ice kind of on social media in real life they're like hey have a good day to you too on social media like like so people are ruthless honestly and I think this is this is the issue even these people look some I read somewhere there's you know there was some comment I mean we do yeah

I don't know I'm just reading what the comments are saying on social media somebody had said because I leave though I've made a video against these people and somebody said well there's an alleged documentary coming out against him nah nobody's safe huh there was the whole thing you dragged in must be mang this other scholars all these people every and the problem is what the problem is this fake piety standards if only people would just be real you know that this reminds me of moment on

Mormon religion moment on moment was a contemporary of garlic people the legend Holly and he says Omar Katia escape Bhutan man momen says Omar Katia ishq a boat on a moment that this life we've spent this life we've spent in the love of these goddesses obviously speaking moment heart mom is speaking about beautiful

women of his age he says we've spent this life in love and and the dedication to these goddesses the Omar Katia ishka bottom a moment ah reworked make a hawk muscle mom he says now that we've reached our final time like hell are we gonna become true Muslims these people this was these I tell you these legends people might kind of say all these poets and whatever but they had wisdom to them

I tell you they these people they knew they were kind of in their own way just being at least tried to just be real as who they were whether people agree with it or disagree with it whether people but the point is they weren't setting fake standards so now hasanat has come out and he said well look so what I was [Music] and I gotta say I heard it I watched his clip today I think it was what was it yesterday I watched his clip about he said look those of you said I was an atheist I was an atheist he said and I

was doing Rokia he says so what there's a hadith in body that some of the Companions said we used to do Rokia as as a cafe I thought wow I like it I like the you know now this thing this miriamís I like but if it wasn't for the fake preaching before the fake you know the whole hey man rooks are Nagi the whole you know a couple girls the fake all that drama if it wasn't this side of is I'm starting

to like now what confidence her he goes so why father Kapaun ego so there's a hadith in Bukhari this is so it's really going back and forth and he said you see he was discussing Muhammad hijab and he said I need refers to mom with hijab is Mohammed knob then he starts calling him Nicky he says you know guys leave Nicky alone and and he keeps referring to because first I thought who's he referred to as Nicky who's Nicky then I realized a ChaCha Nicky he's he means instead of Muhammad

hijab Muhammad nakama teacher Mahmud II just proper gunning for him I'm with you to beefy he's got too emotional I think over the thing and and he's really but I feel that look in all honesty the the game that he's playing this has a not because my issue that I mentioned before very clearly was the the extortion the conning people robbing money from people falsely using

charities taking three hundred thousand in one episode taking God knows how much other funds all of these things were the issues what he did in his personal life to me as a person doesn't bother me I know it bothers other people they like you know what the hell they're like huh they like menage tois triangle cha-cha-cha the three gods three Morty Trinity but you see to me

the issue was more that they broke people's trust in in things like religion by conning them out of their wealth and sometimes you see when people give money they don't have money you know some vichara probably didn't have much money and saw the picture of that you know that dying child that she had Roxanna G had on her post and they probably thought you know what the hell I'll give this money to that child you know because mush I love me Lori Ward all those people may he shower them with infinite wealth I mean because people

get you know this there is goodness you know in the common mullein I'll tell you something in the common Muslim out there the non-practicing one there is goodness in their heart I you can see it that they you know when they see some humanitarian cause when they see these things that's that's true Iman if you ask me and these people they dug into their pockets and gave them money little do they know that they're just paying for a few bottles they're paying for their vodka and God knows what else their business class tickets and the life of luxury and chilling and you know

they're paying for that so this this this are not nice this one that leave that leave for theater clean so I feel that that that's my issue with and I think the way house not is playing it I think he's just stretching it out and he's hoping he's just gonna die it is and I think this is my theory and this is me being a theorist people I think that his rocks are edgy he his wife I don't know about the second wife Sarah but I definitely think about Omar

Abdullah I think she's not even in the UK I think she leg did a while back yes because you see I was thinking about this I was thinking hmm you know if you know like sometimes you put yourself in somebody else's shoes and you think well if I was in this person's shoes what would I do now and I thought that look it must be it's definite because they were conning people they definitely speculated this before it happened definitely guarantee that last year when

everything is as smooth as you can imagine Shh they all and and I feel all of them I feel that Sarah is just as implicated as you know she's complicit I I think maybe she's probably on the lesser end than the other two the other two I think are the main and Oksana Abdullah is 100% guilty there is this you know what I don't like is this oh she's a woman so uh you know so she must be innocent

she was definitely guilty she was in on the convict style have you watched her clip about the fake acting which is dressed up as a client and pretending to be possessed i oh my Allah and this year's Oscar nominated performance girls too so I think that last year this is my theory check this out people I think that when things were going smooth they must have discussed amongst themselves what if we get caught what would we do because that think

about it that's a rational conversation to have and I think at that time they would have speculated contingency plans and I think one of those contingency plans is to be set up abroad maybe towards the Gulf somewhere and I think as I hit the fan his wife ormaybe the lying kids are out of the country I I definitely think the last my speculation but I could be wrong you know that clip wish she's making a video that I don't believe that's her that's definitely how

did her eyebrows change in the positioning of her eyes from the center of an all changed but the voice is her I think the voice she made a recording wherever she was and sent it over and they just put it over this voiced over this this other lady in any harm making a recording I don't think she's in the UK I think she's long gone and I think the reason she's not open about it is because if they confess then that would speed up the police investigation but I think right now the police London metal probably has taken their time they're probably thinking is not priority but if they think she's a flight risk they will I'm pretty sure speed up the

priority this is my cello my brain a play yeah I mean these people definitely fraudulent but hey interesting interesting huh drama drama goes on so what else people what else is going on shall we take some other questions is there any is there something else to add to the Masada section oh there was a bit of masala hurt and that was that

somebody asked about the story of Yunus Ali Salaam in the whale I have answered that already so if you check YouTube I will actually go through the story of Solomon Alif LAAM very quickly about did he neglect his prayers and did he waste wealth and stuff like that which is a misunderstanding but I'll explain that briefly explain Abu Dawood narrated that the person who had put the evil eye on another would be ordered to do with all these hadith are not authentic

the issue is that there is no such thing as the evil eye you have to understand people that you know this Rokia thing let's let's speak a bit about rupiah this has an odd thing has been a wake-up call for rupiah I'm gonna be very clear loud and proud when I say this that's a loud and proud that the Muslim community is much themselves to blame they are just so ridiculously self entrenched in these mythologies and superstitions and look

demons don't possess people relax there is no such thing as jinn possession it clashes with the Quran it clashes with the Quran the Quran teaches you that the Shaitaan himself will say on the day of judgment in surah Ibrahim that he will say on the day of judgment that that I all I did was just insinuated I had no contraction Allah Allah come in so far I had no control over you now you know all

I did is the odor I just called you guys I like invited you why hey why didn't you do this you did it now if this is Shaitaan he can't physically make anybody do anything how can demons and share up being come into you make you do things make you kill people make you cause physical harm make you do these he's nonsense it's against Iran and it's obviously dumb anyway it's a dumb belief but I mean the point is it's against the Quran to start off with it's there isn't a single sorry sorry hadith bring me one

hadith that is not being critiqued one hadith that has not been good one right so if you bring me one hadith there isn't a single hadith that hasn't been critiqued there either all made up weak or they've been critiqued there isn't a single thing so how do you commute to Philippi so Rob anything I don't believe in gene positions but I believe in evil eye of envy Angela right now that right okay now I want to say that you see there's

no such thing as demonic possessions in the Quran it goes against the Quran he goes against the Sunnah now there's no such thing as II as magic happening to people like that magic what we call magic is basically the inability of a certain people to explain a phenomenon so if you took technology to a certain people that were primitive to that it's magic that's all magic is magic is the inability of certain people to explain a phenomenon it doesn't mean that it's actually done through magical terms so in the past what people did was either

things like which they still do today like hypnosis through the power of suggestion through things like this which is still done today people do things like hypnosis and things like that power of suggestion that was one there were three angles for magic in the past that was one the other angle was using chemicals and potions to influence things so for example using natural minerals that are mood stabilizers like lithium let's say people using certain things that contain natural and they would say give this person this to drink and you'll become a better person and

because his mood stabilized he became a better person and therefore it's magic things like this for example so things which are actual they cause there was an actual causative element and the third was simply trickery and slative hand that people tricked people like the great Indian rope trick it was a trick but to the onlooker it was perceived as magic so this is all magic is there is no actual hocus-pocus like a pickup a doll of voodoo doll and I start stabbing it with pins and you over there start doing your breakdance and it doesn't work like that this is all nonsense

okay does not exist and neither did the Prophet ever have magic done on him that is so silly and ridiculous once again clashes with the Koran and disrespects our prophet that you know so so that's to clarify the magic end as far as the evil eye is concerned the evil eye simply means it's a synonym for envy right now people use it culturally and yes sometimes people because they're envious of something they may act out in a certain way to harm a person but they may not even want to harm the person but

subconsciously they become envious but they actually act out right what they don't do is it's not so as if you mean by envy and jealousy that's correct that's fine if you mean by it like I just look at somebody and go evil are you Allah evil eye and that guy gets cancer right that's not that just means that you're lacking in intellect oh because that's not how cancer is caused that's not how oh he looked at this house and the house dilapidated oh he

looked at his car and thought oh I like his car and then the guy had a car accident this although they could be certain you see there could be other links so for example a person like if there was direct communication like imagine I give an example imagine somebody said they praised something like imagine you had a like you're driving a flashy car and somebody said wow that's such an expensive car now when they say that you become conscientious about the car now because you've become conscientious you're not

driving subconsciously like you normally would you're driving very conscientiously and you may become nervous and because you're nervous you end up crashing the car now that could happen and that these kind of things do happen but that's not because the person looked at you and gave these magic rays and destroyed your car but that's because he actually had an impact by you reacting so these kind of things do happen okay so I hope that gives some explanation

yeah what else is going on let's hmm and in abandoned houses there's no you know Muslim seriously need to grow up with all these demonic possessions and magic and but the problem is people won't let go the truth is that people just will not let go it doesn't matter like you say whatever you want to people they just will not let go and they get offended that how do you how do you say

magic does not exist right and the truth is that you know all these guys that send all these jinns and do all these magic hocus-pocus they were always broke I mean like they're always themselves begging for money like the most powerful ones in Pakistan and India Bangladesh and those countries they've incredibly poor like if if you had all this power at your disposal I mean if I had jinns working for me I'd be loving it then you'd see the true meaning of corruption

let's just be honest see power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely so if I had Gina my disposal boy then people would regret it so this is the thing so these kind of things don't really happen somebody said Filby any what I seal

what kutsuna Ali Rasul Allah Himself Allah meeya refer to shut now you see first of all there's many transmissions sometimes people transmitting from imam malik and from other people in my malik in some narrations they he didn't seem to buy into all of this and other other narrations he doesn't normally comment about this magic thing beyond what a seal are so far from what i just read the i haven't read that narration but i'll check it up it's saying that look the prophet had magic done unto him and he didn't know until a sheep told him a

sheep I mean that just sounds ridiculous in and of itself a sheep came and told the prophet of God so the prophet of God Himself is so you know defenseless that a sheep can figure it out and he can't figure it out you know I mean these kind of things are stupid and they disrespectful to the prophet of God and it's embarrassing that Muslims say these things and it's even worse that they actually say them aloud best just say in your mind don't say these things out loud

they sound dumb now look first of all I don't believe Imam Malik really got involved in that kind of a debate and a lot of is Fatah was seem to contradict these things as if not sure the great Maliki legend writes that look these things don't have a reality but even if even if you found a relation let's just say you found a narration from Imam Ali that said let's see and imam malik is not God you know just because if I'm Ilyich was a person who did the best he could in his day and age which was 1200 years ago so if you're holding somebody

to account for 1200 years ago you using the best of his knowledge and maybe he thought look ok maybe like first of all I'm not sure this narration is even true but let's take it at face value and assume it's true even if Imam Malik thought look okay maybe these things exist I don't know and maybe so now because that person said maybe 1200 years ago you feel that I know let's build a religion based on you know some person who generally did the best he could yeah so I feel you know and they don't

and the interesting thing is that it's not like they take from imam malik and other things you know all the things that you Matt Miley could say that oh you reject the hadith it's not like they take his style there they don't seem to take his style in that all these other things that you mom Malik did that were very controversial for other people they don't take him in that and they find let's say some odd narration transmitted a few hundred years after him that he said they said maybe I'm not denying I haven't come across that but even if he said it so what you know we don't like I

said before I do not blindly follow the words of men others are welcome to do so I will weigh up their words in reason and because at the end of the day I'm answerable for me I have to it does it make sense to me am I just blindly following people I love Imam Malik and he's one of my heroes and I do follow his Vick I follow his principles but it doesn't mean that I blindly follow him just for the sake of him being him and Imam Malik wouldn't have wanted me or anybody to blindly follow him in fact it's it's transmitted that even you see

if he would say these things himself that and this is how his teachers taught him so you know Imam Malik himself when he was with one of his teachers and Abdul Aziz if Nabi Selma was with him and they would take classes and then Imam Malik said to the teacher oh the how come you know you say certain things to me in front of me and sometimes you don't say them in front of him or you don't say and the person and he said to Imam Malik that's because with you I know you will weigh what I say and you won't blindly accept it so I think that's quite important how to understand how to

understand risk assess sustenance according to Islam did ha root and marut teach magic to the people of babylon babylon ah right no I don't think it does mention the Koran does mention that these two figures are utamaru and most likely they were probably two rulers who were deemed to be pious they weren't angels but people refer to them as like angels this is what many people so if you read that uh Farsi remove now harsher and other people this is what they explained that they weren't

actually angels but they people used to call them angels because they thought that's how they you know were inspired by these people and they taught certain techniques now these techniques go back to this thing it doesn't say any way they taught them a magic that was like how we you're picturing magic like I don't know Harry Potter magic it just says that they taught people how you can split people up and cause enmity you follow a corner banal murder it was OG they can split up a couple how like think about it people do today the kind of tactics the kind of politics the

gameplay that people use to split people up and this is untrained people do it you know they're gossiping the set people up do this and that's the unqualified guy doing that or girl doing that imagine if you were skilled at it and and you then and you were around the people who weren't skilled where you taught them the art of persuasion the art of persuasion people it's quite a unique art who do you think is closest

to you in your thick and theology well in fact I am generally maliki method so I do follow the school of Medina and in theology I mean I follow I you know I've been trained in a shoddy thinking but I don't blindly follow it I take what makes sense and I don't take the parts that don't make sense I do also I am also influenced by people like you've nourished the great Maliki legend of Muslim Spain the philosopher I'm influenced by him I said I like when I say I'm influenced as in I like the way he thinks on certain things he questions

the ashati is about certain thing so I don't blindly follow people in faith as in in Crete because to say I believe this this this this that's stupid because then you don't believe it you just stop now you're just saying it because the person is telling me to say right somebody seems to be asking quite a few questions on Moodle Don Harden IRA wait they let me pour a drink for myself

if you pass wind huh with it if you pass wind near the end of those walls washing your feet ah you made it all the way to the feet to washing the feet you made it that far and then the Voodoo betrayed you so it's like the wind was like watch

watch just watch this wait till he gets right to that part then it was like ah [Laughter] that must be quite incredibly annoying so if you reach the end whilst washing your feet do you need to do will do again the tragedies I have to say I think you know this voodoo and I'm passing wind has become such a I think it's become a kind of habitual tragedy

for Muslims because I think so many Muslims hold in then they gasp they like oh call it my little break so they have so much trapped so I think this this one big problem you know this one so I think yeah I mean yes you would have to repeat you over though so leave this hasanat who kiss who kiss I know kid harden you tosser huh what the hell is

coming whoa what's going on in the questions yeah yeah esta pasando deep questions coming out let's take some deep questions people what's going on let's take some tea let's do some rapid round here let's do a rapid round of questions I hear that my good friend maulana sheikh abdul rahim Lambada sahib ah here he shared a fatwa on his facebook page later on I hear he took it down share the fatwa saying you can't contribute to

organ donation bother to her brother Hamza her BP Ganga teal shirt Yokohama ba home is symbolically bata means alcohol but but alcohol I'll even drink poison with the condition that somebody takes me into the arms Allah right so I

hear that Lambada Sahib damnit Mercato mahalia chery chery chery she Lambada Sahib I hear he gave he was kind of encouraging that because from next year I think April 2020 there is going to be it is going to be legislation that all people in England are automatically opting in on donation and they have an opportunity to opt out I personally encourage all Muslims do not opt out it's very important that you know with organ donations and things like this and

I've spoken about that in the past and there are many people including move tomorrow via who's done a lot of research on it is online his Fattah including dr. Mansour has done a lot and a few other people and you can't find that but they scaremongering of like telling people oh my god this is her arm opt out opt out is a conspiracy of the West opre a conspiracy conspiracy conspiracy you know when it comes to taking an organ no not in that way naughty naughty I don't mean in the motherís away taking

an old old habits die hard but I mean when it comes to receiving you know receiving an organ I think that these obvious these people will be first so right so but I heard my good friend chef Lombardi it was sharing that football Lombardi bars this one not nice my friend this one makes me once again want to talk to you you know I think you know someday

most mostly Shelly mother G should come down and share a cup of tea with me those phenomena I think we could this could be the beginning of a beautiful beautiful friendship what is it though my egg ple much I think somebody said what is do you like and read the poetry of boola-boola shop Alisha is an amazing epic poet I do like some of it I haven't read so much but some of it I have read it is amazing I

do I do love it ciao mamma Tosi doing it let's take some rapid round questions people rapid let's bring up the speed these are all who are the enemies of Islam can you give your thoughts I've already spoken a bit about the whole thing what do you interesting interesting

question on yeah Persian poetry some of the old Persian poetry I do love I seem to understand a lot of the old I don't know about the reason but you know the old subcontinent scholars what had written my Amir Khusro and which they singing Khali and stuff like this I do I really I seem to understand some of it or I think I'm understanding it I don't know what the hell they're actually writing but all the prophets alive in their graves was the 360 idols

in Kappa I don't think there were 360 idols like that but I think there were a lot of maybe altars and things sacrifices and stuff like that and there were a lot of gods I think 360 might be exaggerated they've lost poetry kun combo but - technically people alcohol because nothing interesting ever began

with a fruit salad this is not alcohol by the way people some people said stuff for law you know this Mufti he's got alcohol on his yeah Kaka hey Daniella loco - ah curry sauce / v8 rasca if they don't let a person be this this this one my drink you know this or no alcohol while Ibrahim - I was

not to make his house line hmm is it okay to dig up the prophet's body to check if it's rotted us Aden hash what on earth are you smoking lay off the drugs lay off the drugs look the people who people who pass from this world they are in a different realm they are no longer in this realm okay nobody is in this realm once they pass away that's it that's the way the world works

so musty sob can you do a drunk life cha whilst doing Miren Miren Valley the the Don's the legends you know these people are my heroes you know I was reading this poem of me I'll share it probably one of these days on insta really it was one of those heartwarming poets heartwarming poems you read it and he

says he says any mere he addresses himself obviously Mira milker but who shouid on say pra mira milker both who shouid tumse pyaar a it's Robby memory John it's it's such a kind of like a heart melting kind of poem it's it's very simple I mean this one's not corrupt or anything he just says he addresses himself and he says

that mere milker both who shoot him say p re that that he calls him kind of like endearment pra like my love he says that after meeting you I've been I'm very happy that I've met you my love to himself he says this is hashtag self love and he says is Robby meaning this ruins in this world of ruins some are bad all that marriage anthem so he says it's Robby memory John to my bother that may you forever prosper my dear in this

world of ruins and it's something that really Wow like you know you read it and it just you think la la mere diva it is amazing the parallels the contrast between like the sense of hope the sense of despair the sense of the endearment of his himself to himself but yet at the same time he's only just met himself you know the mere milker Tom suburbia that I've only just met you in some ways that we never truly even get

to know ourselves but yet that there is this connection this yearning now may you forever prosper now it's just amazing honestly I when I read this kind of poetry maybe man could show that I III really I get it takes me in a different world you know it's like I'm it's my kind of high basically we are limited sobbing yeah Robbie here is

referring to the world is Robbie mm Eddie Jonathan a body that may you forever prosper in these ruins what Mary John wha you know that reminds me speaking of poem I'll give you another poem and and I think we can maybe wrap up on a similar note contrasting despair and hope and things like that you have moment on moment again you know our legend who said Omar Katia Ishqiya

both armed a moment that we've spent our lives loving these goddesses these beautiful goddesses not these women and he says that after he worked making a heart muscle Mahoney what's the point of trying to become Muslim now but what he means by that is becoming a like can you actually become sincere at this stage but he has this other poem which I've said that one already but he has this one way once again it's an amazing one which really touches me he says that to Muhammad

Casey tadhana that you would like you did not end up being mine in any capacity Oh muhammadi Casey Tejano Verna Dounia Makani says otherwise what is impossible in this world of possibilities look look at the silver lining at the same time like there's the despair the dark cloud of like you

doesn't like you could you know you would not mind him any capacity like despair but then at the same time this thing of like Varna duniya Makani you know water is truly impossible in this world of possibilities not everything can be achieved in this world now it's like wow what enthusiasm what optimism but then at the same time interwove in' with realize i mean yet in any capacity i didn't manage to obtain this ahaha

crushing oh I am moment on moment right honestly these people this is why I advise people to really look into things like poetry right okay let's take one two questions and then who are the blower's of them all there's more to the question I thought kanji company a company is there is there a hotline after that yeah

are you advertising on my life huh down the number right so I think there's more to that question who are the blower's yeah are you gonna name in shame have you no decency are they not the creatures of God as well right who are let me open this question of who are the blower's of the knots i cha cha cha cha cha cha cha cha he's talking about who are the blower's of the knots in the in

the surah who is being referred to as those women who are practicing some kind of alleged witchcraft or superstition so that doesn't mean it had a reality to it so if you read the entire surah allah is constantly saying look i seek refuge in the dark what does the dark to dark doesn't harm you but it's by association and i seek refuge in the women who blow on knots what do the knots do nothing but by association and the superstition Cassie the evil culture of damnation all

of these false taboos this shaky kind of backdrop all of that and then a losses or sherry has it in it acid I seek refuge in the envious when he envies what does Envy do to you it doesn't do anything but by association the acting out cool a church it was a religious question after all I thought it was you are probably thinking masha'Allah people seem very tired on this why don't I inspire them with with some

leisurely activity right so Hina Tariq oh my god I'm late how this EMI you're well late Anna heel well Lee who are the all I'm sorry were mentioned in the Maliki books which for call I'm sorry are you talking about he talking about the general I mean there's so many scholars mentioned in the books pavé Sarah Hershiser say Oh meet Piazza he shudders say Omid

cha-cha Rock famous early oh this reminds me of a must allow a girl reader masala let's let's read this masala and then we'll call it a or call it a night people so you know some Muslim Muslims they go through this issue of halala which is nonsense by the way and I have mentioned that if you ever end up stuck in the three thalaaq masala you do not need to do halala okay if you want to get back together I believe there's always a way that you know that the lark was given an ignorance it was given in one go there's a lot of capacity in the show yeah you

don't need to go semi pimp your wife out for you don't need to do that just to under some guilt of religious some kind of that this is what God wants [Music] [Laughter] God wants us key band would either God wants you to get over it's like what no trust me he does so in the past the problem was when they would get the wife

married off to to some new guy hmm mind you that would be that's my career dream to become a Halawa expert we have this problem okay we just walk around all day in a robe and you're like gosh you're like an expert you're a senior consultant only the senior consultants

walk around in the Rope that's that's that's my dream my dream job how many nothing do I have to pray this Nia Nia Nia spun toward Nia's right so that the thing is now coming to this right so people had an issue they used to think that oh if I let's say I get this guy married temporarily to my wife he's gonna divorce obviously after he does he

has the intimacy right so but what if he gets hooked to her what if he's like whoa that was something I've been living in darkness all my life this is where paradise was right so what if he says no way of my divorcing her so which does happen so now in that situation he would be stuck so I've heard of some all on us that they've done the halala and then they've said when the guy is come and he

said Melissa will you now give my wife at the lock he said I would but she's not doing anything wrong then keeping at the lock just like this is stuff for Allah Allah doesn't like these things oh is it all about chance and now it's about God so you have some of these mall owners that then get stuck like they I mean they don't get stuck they stay stuck they say well I'm really liking this one why should I leave her so now some of the previous in the medieval

time some of the chef's a yeah came out with a solution they said this is in the most a circa widest Zurich she or zurka she you can say in both ways hey Latin Faneca Alma Holland this is a loophole in the getting the halal the garden he says what re whoo-hoo and he says the way you got to do it he says I'm gonna tell you how to do this he says Tirico who and yesterday abdun

severan that let him buy a slave a smooth slave not like a macho not like some kind of like body building slave he says but lame buy a small weak puny slave right so well you thought we'd you have minimum and let him marry his wife off to his slave period aha obviously she has to agree to me some ma he says some maya study lohesh fatale

but then he grabs hold of it that's the small slaves penis and he enters it into the he penetrates the into the vagina and then once that's done he then splits them he's like eh that's enough it's like whoa whoa whoa well that was one second too much there right he pulls it back out and then what he does is he sells the slave immediately

and by selling the slave he says Fei Yan for Nicodemus automatically breaks and with it yes or no ty Lily's managed to have the halala and he's managed to save the situation from this guy becoming obsessed with his wife and keeping her [Laughter] imagine that oh that that slave would just be incredibly confused like what what just happened here like first time they bought me and they brought me into this place and the guys kind of pulled my pants down and holding my I'm

thinking right okay I don't really but that way and then he's putting it into his own life and then I'm thinking okay this is getting interesting and then he's getting more jealous and pushing me away like what the hell am i doing I'm thinking yeah drama gallery why how do i how do I deal with this world Oh

mediator GA Casey this world is too much so these were some of the as you can see there that was proper that was like Newton level that was proper like the Muslim genius of the of the puppy of the scholar at his genius level trying to figure out means a scholar although it sounds here it probably makes sense like he was using all that was his brain on full capacity that I've got a solution for

you guys finally I've cracked it guys with that let's wrap this up in Charlotte's been awesome now this is actually in the book this is in most Asarco Ida's Roxy so butter diamond circa she is a famous chef a scholar and this is in the mostess or of the Kauai this actually chef a thick book and they came up with it and he says this is an amazing solutionn loophole I've we've discovered lads lads right guys it's been awesome having you all on you know taking your questions sharing the

thoughts take very good care of yourselves people if you do want to reach out to me do reach out to me do check out my videos on YouTube like them subscribe yeah chello koi baat you know you don't need to be this this tight-fisted you know this relax you know this there's no harm in pressing like this just hit it man it it huh it like it like it like so other than that people take very good care of yourself somebody just asked about the earring I answer it at the beginning of tonight's episode so reverse rewind have a listen

Charla take very good care of yourselves assalamu alaikum warahmatullah to Allah or barakat or