Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 81

just one moment almost done sharing this rod in alhamdulillah wa kafa well salat wa salam o allah rasool mustafa why body ladina table all oman be hotel method will be a third a little medina dr.

firebird for salam allahi allah o allah wa salim become marhaban Hornung lighter by rally who shall meet and of course all Gotham people's forget them all right Alamo sanam beacon or rather people Momo is in the house is that you mo mo is that you though is that you Sid are doing it doing it right everything is well yep everything is well Li light Huntly light hamd

Belgium one okay I don't watch any football so I've got no idea the only way I I hear anything about football is I see some of the memes awry so people what's going down what's going down man as you can see my eyes it's coming along you see the only place ever we're here grows slowly for some reason for ease here other than that the Pakistani genes are like in overflow

everywhere else but here this right so people what's going on mad animal Salim become an asylum those of you just tuning in click like click share people somebody saying that it makes me look bright with more of course Naruto hey Baba Naruto hey Noreen or Sarah pan or that's all neroon Alan or yeah the lovely new Rahim insha Allah for I am the light and none shall reach the Father except through me

oh sorry wrong religion getting carried away that's a today's Monday yeah it's a wrong religion right so all right Elizabeth a Louis Allen is wearing like harem you know from some of the ridiculous stuff you see in the in in the Muslim kind of I don't know how to say the Muslim the Muslims seen so to speak it's the kind of Muslim scene

right so ridiculous stuff seriously is Mike Haram Mike I somebody sent me a link to that I I still haven't watched it actually I clicked on it and then I thought what the hell am i doing I thought seriously let's get back to that TV series I mean right so Salaam of T I graduate tomorrow I mean I mean I mean more are this in the house all right are you doing it you're doing it those

of you just tuning in click like click share people get this out there right yeah so some people trying to say well Nikes Haram and this is Haram that is Haram and people are so trigger-happy with the term Haram it's like he's like Stallone so well alright yep swagatam swagatam did you see Ali Dawa cool

Maajid Nawaz and McAfee I did see that Abu layth I will send you a watch hi he trying to unite in that seat trying to kill me with kindness as the poet says that the Barker Nikki or became Rasta tea for us that to destroy me there were many other ways as well

for us ajaan unique humor but I say Alya now why is it that they the only way they thought was through love yes and I'm sugar and sugar and for your kindness and courtesy no send me your address hahaha naughty naughty what if you trying to turn up at least turn up with it you got to make a date first we can't just turn up so

I write people what's going down the weather god damn what do you think of imam toh he D so heavy as opposed to Imam shitty a mantle he D I've you know I've I've seen a few things of Imam Tahiti it's interesting because I've I've seen some suggestions you know you click on one thing and you watch and then YouTube gives you all these suggestions YouTube artificial intelligence right so it's it's shown me a few things and I've I've

watched a few things to be famed some of the things you know credit where credit is due he's speaking a lot of sense speaking about the theme being one of compassion that the message of Islam has become overly distorted that Islam has kind of got hijacked I agree with all those things that he's in some of those clips I've seen I have seen some other clips of his we he's really provocative I don't know if they're out of context or they older I don't know how out of context they could be but we're he's saying some really disrespectful things about saying that

Omar or the Aloha and stuff like this and I find that very highly irresponsible I mean obviously as a Muslim so many Muslim I find it utterly unacceptable but I also find his actions if that is what he's provided those clips were legitimate I mean they weren't kind of dubbed or something like this I have seen some way he's saying all kinds of things about saying no more all day long on and stuff like this and I think that is if that be truth and that's highly irresponsible okay that's

the amount o he D because I really think that there needs to be bridges built between the Sunni mainstream main Muslims in general and between the Shia community I think we really need to kind of bridge gaps and we need to kind of at least just learn to kind of get on and I think there is no solution if I'm going to be honest there is no solution to these to these kind of differences that the Sunni and Shia have I don't think there's any solution to them but except

for the fact that we just don't discuss them among stuff between ourselves so and we refrain from abuse now if that can happen I believe bridges can definitely be built and I believe it's important too to build these bridges because you know most Muslims like grow up Muslim they don't really understand what is from me what is Shia what is these kind of things and and then there's just like a hatred and this is like a lot of cussing a lot of dissing and I just feel that that's not the way forward that's all I feel that you know real to

me a person I'm gonna be honest me as a person I I feel that I obviously I mean I've been very vocal about it in the past I have a huge the utmost respect for the wives of the Prophet the companions and all these people I do accept like everybody else that nobody's infallible however I I wouldn't be really too critical of the Companions like that nodding on a personality scale like that I know sometimes when we're discussing hadith and we've said that some of the scholars in the past like

the hanafi madhhab and other people they divided the Sahaba the Companions as those who were like true like I don't know if true is the better word but the core companions as in those who actually spent time with the Prophet participated in expeditions and did things and those who maybe just saw him and then some divided them as people who were learning companions and scholars and those who were just I mean they were companions but they weren't known as the most learned amongst them like for and this is where the debate on Abu Huraira or the alam on comes because the hanafi madhhab highly I mean mentioned in the

earlier soul books as did some of the scholars the Abu Huraira was not from the kind of the scholar companions and therefore you have to be weary when he's transmitting certain things because it may be by meaning and the meaning may have got and even after him it may have got kind of shuffled up so things like this are different but to cut to criticize their personality I think you got to be weary because it's a very sensitive topic so I completely I would just say leave that alone I know that to me that if you're gonna criticize them you see this is the the weary thing that

you see because last year there was this whole thing when people were criticizing and I said well if you're gonna criticize them why don't you if you want to be objectively critical then you would apply the same critical lens to even say the Hylian of the why only to Mario Oh model why not to say an idea or the Elan and and I mentioned last year a lot of the scholars who held that stance including Imam Malik who was was critical of air st.

alyre of the alam on in a in a in an objective way he was critical he wasn't never had no hatred or anything obviously loved said gnarly but he was critical of him in saying that said no a leader of the alarm did pursuit did pursue power and therefore he saw that kind of kind of paved the way for some of his judgments now and then a lot of people got annoyed when I quoted that and he's triggered off a storm and and he did all of this last year and to me really obviously then I dealt with it but in hindsight now you know having

moved on almost a year a year older I think like these things like to me as a person do they really matter like I mean I like history whatever's happened has happened like I don't know us talking about it it's different year we can talk about it but we can't change it what has happened has happened and we need to really focus on the present and we need to focus on how to move forward and how to have bridges between us the the Shia the Sunni and I say Sunni by very wide

I'll include include our hobby brethren in that as well all of us suddenly as in the mainstream because Sunni as well as a huge spectrum what does Sunni mean I mean nobody truly knows what suddenly it's such a it's such a black isn't it what is for me I mean when did this term start actually emerge Allison it's amazing because the self never used this term they never said by the way we are I listen man this comes

much off to the seller and then it's amazing because but anyway today cysts Sunni authored oxy orthodoxy right so main stream but the point is we need to move forward so that was an answer stemming from what my views on people like mount or he D I don't know him I mean I don't know him at all really not on have any personal I've seen some videos some videos I've seen very decent kind of things being said by him in some videos I've seen very provocative irresponsible things being said so I don't I don't know but I don't know him that well I've never really paid too

much attention to his thing right so differences aren't right yeah I don't I don't actually feel that the difference is honestly between Sunni and Shia are so huge I think it's just a historical perspective that's all on politics on leadership and stuff like that that see because you know all these other things like I watch this debate a Shia friend he sent me a link to a discussion of his

with a Sunni at speakers corner speakers whatever they call it speaker's corner Hyde Park whatever so they were I watched not all of it but what some of the and they were speaking and in between they were talking about Sunni Shia kind of different season and they kept bringing up muta Matara you know this temporary marriage and and obviously in all honesty if we're gonna be fair the Sunnis are unfair on this matter if we're gonna be if we're gonna be objective that they unfair insulating the Shia on mata temporary marriage because really what I used to do with

Phil is to do with how we practice like the laws of Islam which is nothing to do with beliefs so motorize simply having a temporary marriage now whether you accept it or don't accept e is a matter of fit it's not actually a matter of Eman and for some reason we've made it a mockery mine and what the hell has it got to do with Iman and there's been many Sahaba who allowed Malta coming right down to the likes of scholars like even our shul from you know the great Maliki legend people like

this they allowed what I wasn't and today the Sunnis have this equivalent which in slang terms is called Makia an economist yah which is like a low commitment kind of marriage where it's just a what I call one of Erik Erikson's stages in psychology and development which he says low commitment high exploration so these are like and the Sunnis I think really to be honest with you if they open if if the Sunni scholars weren't that critical of Matata

let's be honest they would be on it like they would be madly on muta if we're just gonna be honest because all the Muslim circles seem to be discussing all the time it just marriage marriage marriage marriage marriage like massively Despres deprived and depraved so it's just face it you know so why are you bashing the Shia and what aha that's sister I just find is it just a point of jealousy anyway let's move on let's move

on all right so what's going on right I've done a bit of shopping peoples and book shopping you can't really see my books here but loads all right you know I spoke last week about salable party and this research that I've been doing for a little while now somebody said mata is fun though I kind of wish Sony's believed in it too you believe believe of course of course we are people of belief on that note there is a people who are interesting research on the topic of

Matara and there is a recent Maliki scholar from Morocco who's published a whole book after his research which I I think it was his thesis but his research is called the wide remote ha Cara attended either phil phik recently which means that Motorama reach like temporary marriage a revisiting based on sunni thought and it's really interesting because he argues in this book the Matar is not actually haram but

only through so many sources and it's really fascinating his kind of whole and he has a debate with share with the Salafi shell hits on YouTube his name is Abram as rock this doctor and he debates in Morocco a he's Moroccan and he debates another Moroccan Salafi so his Maliki debates a Salafi by a popular dari Salafi that I by the name chef is Ozzie and he's debating him and it's so the debate was so dumb some of you know it's like the usual kind of responses which I found really immature like you

know okay if you think mutters okay then marry your daughter to me now I'll do motor with her what the hell is that about how could I mean seriously could you imagine two academic kind of like professors Michael it's saying Oxford or Cambridge having a debate like this is this how what a dump what a stupid thing to say like oh so you think it's halal to have a temper okay then give marry your daughter to me as a temporary marriage and then that guy says something like get lost I would

never marry my daughter to even if he came asking and and then he this was as he says well I wouldn't want to marry your daughter because she's gonna be ugly like you shuffle and this is on YouTube I thought wow this is like a debate between so this is just wow this is amazing man like how dumb people are anyway moving on so people last week as I was mentioning I was doing some I'm doing research for a little while now on this whole Saahil

body and can we how certain can we be that the book Sahil Bihari with all its content is the work of imam bukhari himself the entire content not just like most of it or some of it but the entire content we have today how certain can we be that that is exact that is the Imams work himself so there seems to be it

seems to be quite you know it seems to be not as clear as I once thought or many people believe it to be so and I was mentioning last week there is a book so this is the book this is one book people that it's been it's published by a Maroc I mean it's the author is a Moroccan kind of researcher his name is Rashid ll and he published this book this is one book coming in the whole discourse called sahih al-bukhari in hiatal store rather silent Bihari at the end of a fairy tale and this was

published last year in Morocco and then what happened is the Salafis kind of made a big hoo-ha and they said well you know burn the book and they got the local magistrate involved who then prohibited any further publishing office so there were very few copies left SAR contacted the publisher hamdulillah he had a few copies so why not so we flew over me and sheikh hong kong because that's how we roll and so let's pick it up and do a bit of book shopping waltz with this so so i've brought back some interesting books this is one this is a

fascinating book right so it's about sahih bukhari he's gone through a lot of research into show one the criticisms that were pointed towards Buhari some blasphemous hadith are are inside Buhari but also a lot of work on the kind of manuscripts that are available so for example most of the copies if not all the copies in in in in Saudi in mallinger maja this is Malik Abdulaziz so in that University he I believe he goes he has access to and he does research then he kind of includes all

the manuscripts and shows how these manuscripts are problematic because they're not as abundant so he has an entire kind of list of all the goes on spanning several pages of the this all the kind of manuscripts what century they were written in so you tend to find that the earliest complete copy of Sahil Bihari emerges about 200 years after Imam Bihari as in that's the oldest copy we have today it's about 200 years after him and there's a lot of issues with his students because they stems from the

factor that Imam Bukhari Azhar highlighted last week he during the last few years of his life was blacklisted so nobody would take hadith from him well very few people would dare take hadith from him so he became very toxic and radioactive by no fault of his own he was an amazing person but sectarianism kind of dropped him in E and so people kind of banned taking hadith from him this complicates the problem further so the students that took Buhari from him none of their copies are found I mean none of they they're copies do not go on most of the reliable students except one

student whose name is Ferrari and he has no like he's a bit none of the hadith scholars of his age comment about him like he's not really known amongst them now his students take Buhari from him but they openly say that his copy was incomplete and we used to hadith around we would change chapter headings we would do stuff and they all have their own variations on so it's interesting that whole so I went I got hold of this book to add to my research so in Charlotte there will be a lot more coming on that in the future while I was there there were some

interesting books I'll share some of them with you and this is a really fascinating book it's a once again written it's published in Morocco it's a kind of it's a collection of a lot of different I don't know if articles is the right word but small booklets if you like dedicated to topics that are that are controversial but I love the title and it's dedica that's one of the discussions involved as you can see oh me camula to Oakland or Dean that my mother a complete woman of aqil of intellect

and Dean and that's obviously said provocatively for the alleged hadith which I don't believe to be Asahi ADIZ which is a hadith that says that women are not receptacle or teen that they lack uncle and lack Dean so this is a part of this article was or this booklet in amongst these kind of collection of responses is that my mother a woman complete in both intellect and Dean and it kind of goes on to shed his light on why this hadith is utterly unreliable and I find that amazing so that's

something to insha'Allah you'll be hearing more of in in the days to come this was a little interesting book I picked up on the thirty how the Quran has been organized I thought well in terms of revelation and then the way it's being put together some journals on earth either this once again it's from that same publisher to do with that was speaking about my mother who's a complete woman in faith and intellect this is another interesting book called ethanol and on that the ears of of

livestock and and what it is is it's a study into evolution and how that is I believe how that is compatible with Islam so that was a quite an interesting I've got her in Charlotte take a look at these but I tell you something a quick glance at this made me think about there's a verse that he brings to our attention at some point as I was glancing through this the verse of the Quran that Allah mati a little insane Hyneman Adel that has then not come upon in San a portion of time let me a Concha

Amezcua that he was not a mentioned thing now it's interesting that everybody that people generally translate that or interpret that to refer to that we were dead that we did not exist depth sorry not a good translation but we were non-existent that and then we were brought into existence but it's interesting that the way this author sheds light on that verse and it seems to make more sense that Allah meeya tll in sanik wouldn't it be then said differently like maybe

something like a Lamia murderer that has time not past when in san you know Lamia konchem with Cora when in San was not but he says I love ya ta Lilian tiny he no minute dad that a time of age did that time from age from as in time as a whole not pass over in San whilst he was not a thing to be mentioned but that is interesting upon reflection because it should have been the whole of the as in age the whole time with a capital T has passed and in son did not exist unless

why did it say a portion of time passed when he was not a thing to be mentioned was it because that in San was still evolving as interesting and at that stage in San was not a thing to be mentioned that is a very interesting kind of and something to be looked into so here's another book I picked up people this right in front of us is Abu Saleh man al hafi the hot bobbies a brief commentary on the summary of Bihari the reason I got this is because people

because his he's a very early scholar who passes away in 388 a jury and he took Buhari from one of the students of Imam Bihari sorry his teacher took it from one of the students whose transmission is lost shortly after although this is an incomplete it's only a summary but it's it's just to kind of show well in case people argue that it is still found in its earlier transmissions it isn't because this is incomplete it's a it's a kind of summarized version but it's interesting to see how he highlights

differences as well so I bought that what else I've got so many here but I won't really go through all of these because it's just gonna take forever this is an interesting book being brought into print it's the most to serve of Abu Musab Azorean was a student of imam malik from medina so i thought of in fact why not people why not the top seed I picked this up I never really had this before tafseer of sheriffy driba a tough see Ramana who is a steno muhammad abdul i thought well now be an awesome addition to my

addition to my library so why not I put that there once again a little hadith by Ali even when Medini something in what I've called a little hadith as textual pathology people textual pathology so when you're looking at hidden kind of pathogens Allah copyrighting these terms right there people right narrow to real pathogens that's what I'm talking about but there was an interesting thing that I was looking at this hadith in here

there's a discussion on Al Hassan and has he heard from the companion Bakara and there was an interesting discussion in this book because although people like Ali benalmadena said he had and Buhari said he had but scholars like yeah him mine said he'd never heard from Obara and including dark putney who criticizes and says even though Buhari has a narration from him saying he heard from a book from a baccarat companion where the Prophet the famous hadith where the Prophet says to him when he

hastens to pray that don't hasten next like as in Tzadik Allah had a son may Allah increase you in ambition but don't don't do that again like don't come running come calmly to the prayer but what's interesting is how they quote here people like Abu little body the Maliki scholar says that the Hassan in that hadith may actually be Hassan igniting the son of said Ali Road a lon so they're not even sure which Hassan it is but what makes that more interesting is this is the same chain

that is used for the hadith that Lane you flee have common that such a people will never be successful who make their leader a woman and that is the same hasan from abu bakar so the discussion is has he even ever heard from over cara and there's a lot of debate in there right people tell you what no point going through any more of these it's gonna take forever let's let's take some of these questions what's going down must coming down people what's going down limited what does that mean limited

oh right oh I forgot these questions that have already been submitted why don't I look at them one hadith dislike drinking water the first thing getting up can you shed light I'm not sure what that hadith is where the Prophet dislike drinking water first thing but any of these kind of hadith by the way on all to do with hygiene and etiquettes of like health and stuff like this they're

not they're not about halal Haram Allah mentions in the Quran that he will not belittle any of his messengers so here these would stay otherwise yeah there is a hadith in Sahil Buhari and it's in sorry Muslim as well about Moses Ali Salim and basically it's a very disrespectful hadith which is blasphemous but unfortunately many Muslims have been kind of fooled by and

they feel that it's an authentic narration just because it happens to be in Buhari and hadith basically states that why it's to do with the Israelites and how they would all kind of bathe together and they would Moses aleihsalaam would bathe separately so they used to discuss amongst themselves why does Moses not bathe with us like why doesn't he line here as in in this kind of water wherever they were with us so they had this understanding that they

used the term in the hadith that he was Adam which means that his testicles were swollen and they used this they say though that's the reason he's embarrassed and so the hadith goes on to say that so when Moses came out one day early Salam he put his he had his clothes on this rock and he went to get his clothes and the rock started running and then Moses is running off to the rock and the rock is running and he's running naked and inside Muslim as well I've mentioned so they all looked at his genitals and said oh well mm you know his testicles seem quite normal this is

ridiculous this is such a ridiculous statement this whole hadith is fabricated these are just stories from the Israelites that have crept into Islam and you know and Muslims have kind of endorsed them along the way so that's one of them do you find other sometimes preposterous narrations that hadith is very blasphemous against prophets because Allah says about moosa aleihsalaam that he was were jiàn he was wedgie like he was an honorable person a lot kept him an honorable person not like this and you know rocks running

around with your clothes and then moses beats of the rock as though the rock is an intelligent thing is beating it up crazy crazy stories that people believe disrespecting our prophets disrespectful so yeah so that's and you get other stories by the way like another very popular let me tell you another very popular fabricated or miss transmitted hadith inside Buhari which is this one about a bull rider or the law unquote the devil and the devil taught him something ridiculous totally ridiculous i mean it completely contradicts the

quran and sunnah and disrespects islam because let's just take a look at this hadith there's a hadith in sahih bukhari that the prophet salallahu alaihe salam Tora Bora that you had that he had the wealth of zakat and which was to be distributed so this is the wealth of the Muslims it's like Bayt almal is part of that so it's a like the Muslim Treasury many a step-over era to be extend God over it like I have like night duty on it so Abu Huraira say is that whilst I was doing that a man came and he stole from this

he steal something Sabo Raider catches him and he makes up some story about how his family are suffering and how they really poor or and things like this and they're really suffering so Abu Huraira decides to let him have him first of all that is bang out of order because it's not up to Abu Huraira the alarm to do to kind of dispense of the wealth from National Treasury of the Muslim just because he feels so couldn't this this is right but let alone put that site put that aside so he lets him have it so the next day he comes to the prophet and the Prophet says me abu huraira did something happen

last night and he says yes there was a man now that you mentioned he there was a man that came and he tried to steal and i caught him and and he said his family was suffering so i gave it to him and the prophet says to him ah he's a liar let's check this out he's a liar Kathy what's a yahood and watch he's gonna come back and lo and behold he comes back this that night so he comes again he steals the game and Abu Hurairah catches him again and then he

tells about her Aida the same story that all my family I'm poor I'm a poor person my family and I worry that again lets him take it like look at this so not only is he letting him take money for the second time or not money but things food or whatever it is but it's not above raters to give but the Prophet has declared that that person is a liar yeah a paella still disregarding let's say what the Prophet is saying and the prophet has forewarned that watch he'll come back again and he does come back again and a Beretta falls for it again he gets duped again by look how stupid

this narration is and then he comes the next day the Prophet asks I've over ADA hey did something happened and he says yeah actually you know he came again you're right and he told me again and and I believed him again and I gave him again and same abour the Prophet says he's a liar watch he will come back again this is in soluble Hardie by the way so and lo and behold people he comes back again our the thief how addictive thief he's on it the pathological thief

he's back again and he comes to steal and this time Abu Huraira catches him again and he says aw he says ah listen let me go let me go and he says no not gonna let you go this time and he says okay listen listen listen okay check this it says okay okay listen I'll tell you what if you let me go I will teach you something about your religion that you don't know I mean first of all just look at this offer so let me get this right this guy who is a thief who the profiler said is a liar and the Prophet told you yet you have

once again you you know you've fallen for his thing again the Prophet said it again you've fallen for it again now this thief has come and he's saying to you you're a companion of the Prophet you've got access to the Prophet but he's saying I will teach you about your religion so Abu Huraira says okay go on and teach me and he says you know when you go to sleep read ayatul kursi and he teaches him something about ayatul kursi and then a beret says okay and lets him go so we've got a repetitive kleptomaniac okay and and a thief who's just non-stop

thieving from the Muslim Treasury a beret is allegedly in this hadith constantly falling for it like is that he's being duped constantly and then on the final occasion he's saying you know oh you're gonna teach me about my religion oh that's awesome what is it that you're gonna teach me and he teaches him something Russell ayatul kursi about before you go to sleep and read this and then Abu Huraira comes to the prophet and the Prophet says hey did something happen again and he says yes he says actually he came and this time I caught him and then he said he's gonna offer to teach me something about the religion the Prophet said oh really What did he say and he said he

said this about itíll courtesy and the Prophet said you know what that was the devil however he told the truth on this occasion how blasphemous is this happy seriously let me get this right what did he mom Alex a mom Alex said that there is nothing about this Dean except the Prophet as tortoise nothing about this theme except the Prophet has taught it to us as in there is no path to Jenna like worship and drawers and things like this that are set except the Prophet tortoise but here we need the devil the devil

people to come and teach us about Islam right and the Prophet ain't teaching them the prophets saying oh oh yeah oh yeah by the way yeah that's correct I haven't taught it to you by the way but the Devils mentioned oh yeah yeah yeah he got that right what how blasphemous disrespectful is this hadith it shows Abu Huraira to be incredibly clumsy it shows up over a dealer to disobey the Prophet it shows the Prophet to have not taught the people this this this door rather in we needed the devil to come and teach us Wow it teaches the fact that somebody's

thieving from the National Treasury and the Prophet is letting it happen it teaches the fact that the companion doesn't seem to be so fast he's falling for every night it's a mockery mockery people Oh as some more reason save mercury Macready the mercury of the bean you know this this is the kind of sometimes nonsense that is crept into our tradition so we have to this is why be weary that these things go against the Quran they go against the Sunnah they go against our teaching of faith they go against like things like Imam Malik has

highlighted that the Prophet taught us that all access all rituals of this Deen were taught to us by the Prophet okay we don't need the devil to come and teach us those of you those of them that want the devil to be their teacher they more than welcome all right so let's move on speaking of that people this there was a meme that was going around so I put her on snapchat with there's an interview between an interviewer and interviewee so it's about the devil sorry

it's about the jar it's about the job so the interviewer in this meme I didn't make the mean by the way people though I made the mean right you're forgetting special ops and how governments do test their own behave the Prophet wasn't doing a special ops right so in this happy sorry in this meme the interviewer is asking so he says also your did the gern and he says yeah and says you claim to be a god and he says yes he says so what are your capabilities he says you

know I can bring the dead back to life I can make it rain I can gather armies I can do all this kind of stuff miraculous stuff so the interviewer say so how come you haven't fixed your eysan he says I never thought about that that's a good question by the way so I'd put this on snapchat some people got offended they said Oh why'd you oh all you mopped the joyful will you look to determine if mop did the job so I was like the judge here tomorrow

cha-cha-hey-hey is that the judge your who is he abused why are you so offended the Jarl is getting locked people get so offended this one person messaged me and he said he said oh brother what are you mocking to the job I was like cha-cha something I'm why am i mocking to the job he goes oh it's a very difference of opinion I said what I can't mock him I'll mock the Dajjal all

I want why can't I mocking me why is he a good person so you know what's interesting is I asked this person I said look I said well what makes you think all differences are always valid and respectable I obviously don't believe in the jungle you believe in him fine that's their choice but I never made that meme anyway but yes I find it funny and if you want to mock the Dajjal even if he exists you can mock him there's nothing special about the jollies not a saint you know this this obviously to me is a mythical character that came in from Christianity but to other people who want to accept him he still he's not he's not a good

guy you can you can mock him it's not and the interesting thing is I said well do you care as equally worked up about those hadith there are blasphemous towards our prophet and the person said I do I said what about these hadith like in Buhari and Muslim that claim that our prophet had sexual relationships with a child do you not get offended by this and it's amazing how like this goes to show you know like these people like to said oh I believe that's a respectable difference of opinion I honestly I lost

my I just don't need lost it immediately block that person anybody that tells me that's a respectable position I honestly I do not want to hear that right so because people like that to me have betrayed Allah and His Messenger so so these kind of things any of anybody that's openly I'm not talking about the Dajjal now I'm talking about things that people that openly Muslims that openly promote that the Prophet had sexually sexual relationship with a child and they'll openly say you know that they

openly teach these Muslims that openly teach this I don't mean people like the common people who don't know but Muslims that are activists that are going about openly teaching stuff like this they have betrayed a lot his messenger and it honestly and they've either got some warped understanding of Islam but like I find it difficult to believe that they are genuine in their love for Allah and His Messenger I find that difficult to believe that anybody that says that that openly teaches things like that and their justification that people in the past study but people in the past are dead they you can't call them to change their

position but you are alive so no point saying you know but someone so who died 500 years ago but he's dead so it doesn't matter now but you are still alive how on earth are you saying this nonsense so this is the kind of yeah so these things really really work me rile me I want to get worked up sometimes this is the kind of thing so anyway right let's move on to some of these questions people what's going on what's going on what questions have we got

trickling in right the Sunni defense I'm gonna come to that I've got that here so let's take a few questions because I've not taken any questions and people are gonna think what the hell we've posted questions on his status and porque porque why is he not responding to any of them so let's see people let's see yes Salaam all right how should we discard papers that have a large name or other venerated words on in Arabic on

them you can burn them if you like you can incinerate them so if you have old must haves poor on stuff like this old copies of the Koran or that's become and you need to kind of safely do away with them you can incinerate them or if you have words that are like a last name and stuff like oh I believe in this day and age you can shred them if they become totally like by shredding them they become completely imperceptible not like there's different types of shredders so obviously some just kind of leave it so you can still kind of make out words or

letters and some completely obliterate everything so if you can completely obliterate it al hamdulillah that's fine is it necessary to pay zakat whilst living in the UK especially considering that the high tax rate and the fact that our taxes in a way go to with social programs if you do advised to continue paying the cut do we have to pay on savings or you see the cut is not really for kind of current accounts it's more to do with savings

you see the issue is this people we have a truly kind of caught up in our film so in the past the cut was really to do with stuff like livestock it was to do with produce from farming etc these were the real things the cat was all to do with it wasn't really to do with gold silver and stuff like this he wasn't really because gold and silver weren't really people's kind of wealth the common people their wealth in abundance wasn't like gold and silver that was their kind of day-to-day

earnings by them trading other stock that they had so the cart really came to deal with these kind of things in fact we don't even have a Saudis speaking about how much the cart we should give from gold we don't actually have anything that's aji alright so now this is great somebody just trying to hell is trying to call me right so we don't really have anything sorry there's some hadith about silver and stuff like this

and then there's a lot of analogy and this weak hadith which the scholars have just accepted because they needed something for gold and they kind of just set the standard and then everybody accepted you know and I'm fine with that I don't have a problem because I understand they just needed rules and law and order and stuff like this but the reality is there's really no SIA these about how much gold you should having and then you start giving zakat and stuff like this so I think the cut really got formulated in it's interesting because that definitely obviously is there in the

time of the Prophet no doubt about that does it get more discipline does the structure of zakat become kind of more what's the word very kind of mechanical after the Prophet and I suppose I would argue that it probably does that it's probably after the Prophet that circuit becomes a bit more mechanical and very kind of it takes a lot of detail that

perhaps that didn't exist before in that sense so this is hence a lot of this confusion where can we give the card we can't we give the card stuff like this emerges over the ages or you know as generations kind of parse and different rulings but so cut right really is somebody just who is this sorry people

some person it's just anyway right so the right so the so that's so today how do we deal with the cat today you can just give you can have a savings account the way I I would rule is how people like it now I showed the great Maliki legend and these people said it is a bit like the Hanafi method as in once you have a lump sum that exceeds the nisab the kind of threshold then provided that minimum threshold lasts right throughout

the year then you can just pinpoint a month in the year [Music] right I'm going up this again people I don't know what happened then right guys I'm just I don't know what

happened there I'm just gonna mm-hmm just one moment folks no idea let me see trying to share it

never you see that's actually a good there is right a lot of my mates have actually said that's a good point they've said that I think I'm living proof that the evil eye doesn't exist because if it did if it did exist I think I would

definitely have been afflicted [Music] right so it's no right cool evil eye yep let's get things moving right what are the questions folks what's going on what's going on devil did that hell no you see in my life these things like sorcery wizardry

superstition they play very these things don't really exist in my kind of worldview so what's going on folks let's take some questions salaam could you explain the allegations against quran compilation during cross man answered me i don't know what that means how do you know which hadith we can accept or not right okay that's a very good question the hadith people you see when we have a hadith there's a few things we need to see does it clash with

reason the three principles here does it clash with reason does it go against the established sources like the the Quran does it go against the established Sunna three those right does does it uproot an Islamic principle provided it doesn't there's no problem here the chain is fine then we can go with it hamdulillah what's that about Dawa man and right okay yeah I did see this clip [Laughter] yes L am so so this somebody sent me

this clip about there's three kind of preaches it was actually shared by the Atheist Republic on Facebook and they were saying they were obviously they were having a field day so it said like this these guys they were talking in this clip in his brief clip about YouTube hey jebby youtubers so hey jebby youtubers yeah and they were saying that this is sick like how can how can man and man's let their women how can these

women be youtubing these hijab' women that they are you know men are going all astray and and then so in between right it's past the watershed people so I'm just quoting what they're saying right so in between he says I know somebody personally he says I know somebody who said that he'd masturbated over a YouTube hijab a youtuber I don't know what's more problematic is like okay

that or the fact that you know them I mean who are these kind of people that you know what the hell is wrong with like this you're in a day and age where the Internet is widely available and and these kind of friends of you and you these all like grown men kind of some kind of uncontrollable kids that are like kind of like I don't know these are like grown-up men and he and he's saying yeah you know I've known somebody personally who's done this what the hell that was that would have been one

awkward conversation it's like oh or bro weaving up to you well funny you should say that well I got kind of carried away this afternoon yep what do you mean well you see well I was on YouTube and I kind of saw this hijab but I mean what is

wrong with these henna peoples and don't these kids these guys really realize that this them discussing this is making a further mark of this beam I honestly don't get it and the funny thing is that during their discussion it's only a few minutes by the way the comments were awesome the comments that the atheists had going on the oh my god I think I almost had a heart attack laughing I found is so hilarious

but uh and they quote this hadith in this so during this discussion these three guys they say you know you don't understand this is from the Huayra this from the reader you know the protective jealousy in Islam he says you know you don't and there's a hadith of I believe he quote someone from its active no marzo he quotes it from a companion that that he says that oh about if he's about finding the man with his wife and he would kill him and the Prophet says in the Quran for you that you are a person with Lehrer I have more here than

you and Allah has more here than than me and you combine this hadith by the way they completely quoting this out of context this has got nothing to do with this they said this was not about promoting Lehrer this hadith was because that guy actually the discussion was that the Prophet was saying that you need to bring witnesses you can't throw allegations at women and this person gets because some person had claimed that he actually saw somebody with his wife but he got away so this is the

backdrop to what's going on and this companion says you know if I found somebody I would just attack them and the prophets condemning him by saying you can't do that and even though you might have jealousy but I'm prohibiting you but I've got more of this kind of concern this lira for then you have and Allah has more than us meaning that to safeguard people's lie and the well-being comes first it's paramount you can't say well even if the prophecies even if you found them you

still can't attack them now this is they've completely turned it on its head to say well this hadith is about promoting leader and this kind of what the translating is protective right there yeah I said co-signers comment I'm not going to read aloud because right so because the hadith is not talking about leader like that so they translate his protective jealousy uh-huh but that's not what you see their actions protective jealousy this era is when you protect their honor when you protect them when they're defenseless when you

stand up even if you're fighting for them it's not about it isn't what they're translating it not the wording but they're translating the meaning as insecure paranoia that's all it is it's just err a man who's insecure about his wife the oh my god the oh my god why did a guy look at oh my god why did you look at her why did you ask like they give the question or somebody he says if somebody said you know they ask you and I accept that look cultures very many cultures people wouldn't ask I accept it would be weird in certain cultures to just say so bro

how's your wife people would find that because if that's not your general cultural practice you would find that a bit strange I accept that or to say well so how's your sister and in many cultures people we don't do that and I accept that that's there's nothing wrong with that that's a cultural practice but he said that you know genuinely somebody asked because somebody asked me once ah how you doing how's your wife has everything and he said I said to him bro don't ask about a man's wife well if they said it like that like how are you doing how's your wife has your family what the hell why you get why are you acting like an

insecure paranoid like that's this weird mind like this you see this kind of stuff is not Islamic at all that's just to coat over your insecurities by using this hadith which has got nothing to do with that right so right what is right what are we what are we looking at what what are some questions what's going on all right so we've had this people have asked me to respond this being another video ah [Laughter]

these videos um there's been another this she's a lovely Reema sorry I mean I don't know what the current I'm not gonna read that aloud right so right so there's been another video as they were always off against me you know it's always funny games so the the video let me just deal with this for a moment and I'll come back to some of the questions video was by our lovely our lovely Mojave defense you know the lobby certainly defense they've done another

video qui robbed on AHIMA stock robbed a year after yeah right this so there's been a video by Sony I say Sony loosely hobby so me defense we're top he's saying that oh I haven't answered this question he's highlighted in this video saying look in my video about the video declaring marital rape Haram in that

video he says I quoted something amongst the many quote so I'm gonna come to this he says that these quotes were from some forum and they were misrepresented so they're not actually accurate okay so right well my brother let's let's take a look at what is going on this way this sport karate karate so just to summarize there's a video you can check my video it's on YouTube it's it's to do it's called that rape

marital rape is Haram in Islam overly I mean if you type that in marital rape Haram you should come up but under they I explained I mean in the video I explained how rape is categorically Haram including using religion to justify the rape so if a person is emotionally blackmailing or religiously blackmailing a woman to rape her that is still rape so I've explained that that is categorically Haram so her husband just as like let's say a husband is going to beat up his wife and like beat

her up if she says no to sex that is clearly rape now if he's going to say oh I'm not gonna beat you up but allies gonna punish you after you die you see that is no less rape that's just like saying in other words a deferred beating so that's just threatening her still because it's still a threat but it's a threat with a deferred punishment so it's still Haram categorically now right

so first of all this there is a hadith and I've done a hold so what I would advise these people when they get a moment please go check out my video because it's over half an hour I do a complete breakdown of how that is coercion and that is Haram and know the hadith is not true and to say that the Lord is angry because you and in gaining sex is ridiculous you seriously overestimate talk about self-aggrandizement like that yeah no I

know it is is that a metaphor for like the Lord down there because it's not what you you mean that the Lord is ain't Lord is angry is this like some kind of like a nickname that you've got going on because there's no way on earth that God is gonna be angry about you not having sex okay I'm just making real with you right so you seriously got an ego issue going on because that is not true by any measure no matter how much you think about yourself so right now there's this hadith which is weak

I believe it's unacceptable utterly clashes with the Quranic clashes with the authentic son clashes with the principles of Islam and the hadith is in a bottle modulator farish's o jihad that if a woman stays away abundance like she stays away from the bed I'm not tell melodica the Angels will curse her in another hadith that the Lord is angry with her Hatta to spare either until morning until she comes back Lord Lord

which Lord no no Lord Lord is angry right so this is a you know some road can be used for many things like he can be useful like a woman at home can we call a rap battle bait the Lord Lord s of the house and so he could be using this as a metaphor right so now I went through this hadith and I showed and I won't go through the whole breakdown again but I demonstrated how this hadith is not reliable I've read out the

wordings of the hadith I quoted it from it is in body it is in Muslim it is another all that isn't dar means in Muslim Ahmed it is in all of these narrations I showed the several problem the problems with these chains I showed that how these chains mainly rely on they seem to come down mainly relying upon two kind of tether in you've got a lack mush and it also relies on patada as well and the hadith is transmitted predominantly through a beretta or the Elan but these two people armed only seen

that's people who kind of omit other week some they admit people in the chain so if they say an which means from without saying I heard from they just say so-and-so said they don't say he said it to me or I heard him say if they speak like that like vague I'm is a vague term if they use vague terms then they hadith becomes problematic so I mentioned that I also mentioned how this clashes with the verse of the Quran that I should own a bill my roof that you have to treat women with kindness our law says you either with them or you separate gracefully how the prophet salaallah solemn always talk I'm nurse I

showed that how so all of these these narratives how there is no coercion in Islam all of these kind of things I went through now okay Allah Allah be brothers right so he's pointed out first of all I'd like to highlight our sunny defense brothers they pointed out that during all of this this during my analysis and evaluation of this hadith I highlighted three names which he says which were from I obtained

from a forum that misrepresented the quotes and therefore they inaccurate okay so first of all I want to say first of all I want to say thank you shukran shukran for highlighting that muchas gracias me hermano and Mohave I first of all know we should be grateful when people point things out hamdu lillah man lam yasha Kareem as la mouche couldn love whoever does not is not grateful to people is not grateful to Allah to the Lord right so then I want to highlight that look these these quotes or these

names I mentioned with them what they'd said okay I then a media if you watch my clip which they quite conveniently stopped at that point if you watch my clip I go on I don't stop the I carry on these clips iPad sorry these quotations I do not take as my judgment I do not take as my judgment so one of the these quotations come down to two things one that this person a lash a lavish is a curb is a liar - he's motohama Dini he write that he's

somebody who's Dean is problematic now I go on to say immediately after that why a lot much is problematic I do not say because he's a liar I do not say because his Dean is a problem I say alack much is problematic because he's a motherless and there is uh Nana in this chain so you can watch what I say I immediately after that go on to say this so as far as these quotes being in a forum let's say misrepresented shukran shukran okay they misrepresented I appreciate that you've highlighted

that so his conclusion by the way his conclusion was because these let's say these three quotes these three names and these quote coming down to him being a liar or him being accused he that is Dean was problem at his religion was problematic that these things are from my forum which is misrepresented z4a boo less by the way I love the way they're all say lathe I would live I would last is one of two he's either he's either

Dajjal he's either an antichrist or is just an utter jaw he'll who's absolutely wrong in what he's saying so okay let's go to what I've said why don't you so am I why don't you highlight very clearly that I'm wrong in saying a lot my schism odourless I'm wrong highlight it say that I'm wrong in saying that my the model is say that I'm wrong in the chain that hadith that I've quoted and the Tories that it's found in these books am I wrong no they'll say no you're absolutely right it is in those

books am I wrong in reading the change that it was that much from other Hazim from a beret say no no that is right that is right that will live I'd say am I wrong in mentioning and that it comes down primarily to these two Rorie's say no that is not wrong this on my brother say am I wrong in highlighting that even on Mubarak and his criticism of a lack much am i wrong name or a diploma Dini or intangible command that the amount of Todd lease a lot much has done that is omitted names that Allah Allah and Allah ie has mentioned that you till this one is the author even Abdul Boris mentioned

you don't listen it off that from weak narrators you would have meet them am I wrong am I to say no am I wrong in my conclusion in saying that this hadeeth has a motherless and it's an honor am I wrong rather why don't you just openly say it's wrong let this on this what you cannot do but they would say no you're not wrong so I'll say ok I'm all so so what's the problem my

brother what a problem they say the problem is you're at the jail the problem is you're at the jail I don't know I don't know what's it come back to that I'm asking like right so am I wrong in every so is all of this wrong then have I lied in all of this is this for you know what I've based the conclusion on my own conclusion that is a model is what these people have said the these names have not the bar let her be all these names of quality things a model is

the ll of Tirmidhi all of these things are these wrong say now brother so it's a lot the problem problem is used to done oh yes Alam you know seriously you see look this is the this is the problem you know this is the problem that once I believe how will s is here highlighting that you ask these people do you have a problem with rape going on the marital rape they don't

seem to have a problem with that okay I'll bury me girls Arab brothers you know the Harlem Brothers you know this not all this particular brother right so they don't seem to have a problem with the rape they don't seem to have a problem with such nonsense being attributed to the Prophet they don't seem to have a problem with this going against the verse of the Quran about coercion and all of these things have no problem whatsoever they don't seem to attack what I've highlighted as the actual criticism the actual conclusion of what I've said attack that o you by the way in between

you said these names but these names were misrepresented on a forum okay did I rely on those names did I rely on those things they like go with what did I call that much I kept there did I say his religion was a problem did I say these did I go with that as the reason to debunk this hadith no rather I said he was a motherless but it still hurts but you must either be at the gel or either read a hill so this this is the problem this is what we're dealing with so I've been asked to comment again I've

commented now look if you would like to show that this chain is absolutely authentic then do so show it to me show me an unquestionably uncritical chain allowing this kind of nonsense of marital rape show me and I will then take it to task but this is in a way they just we've asked this is the BS the BS of Apple s the B this is where the research is one thing and the result is another

it's like in fact there's a story I remember somebody told me you know like a sub-continental scholar from the subcontinent he said once there wasn't a somebody doing some research so he was researching flies and he's trying to show the contrast between sometimes research the investigation and the result so you had this fly and he was and what he would do is he would pull like it obviously trapped this fly fly around he'd check it out investigating then you pluck one of the wings and then

you'd say Oh like you told to fly fly fly so that so it only have one wing so kind of flap around like kind of like all bent and everywhere then what he did is he plucked both wings I'm the flight would just stay V and he'd say whoa fly fly and the fly wouldn't fly so he said ah so his result was the conclusion so that was the investigation the result was he said it part is Chi if you'd pull out one wing this fly McKee Theriault

data you know if it flies bent but if you pull out two wings you plucked wings your Maqui berry or jet it becomes death so that's that's what you have a huge difference between an investigation so he's assuming that the fly is now death so this is the thing so because that is saying that this was misrepresented on a

particular forum so now a belief must be an antichrist he must be at the job that's the natural conclusion that just follows on the natural conclusion isn't that yes all these hadith and let's deal with the third lease and let's bring a chain that's unquestionably uncritical the natural conclusion is okay because that forum had this or whatever this is misrepresented these names which you didn't rely on by the way but still the natural conclusion is you must be an

antichrist got a lover well do you do do you know the Pakistanis time to go haters are haters I'll tell you haters now this you got it see they have this this drive to them you got to be grateful for your haters as well to be fair you couldn't be grateful because to be honest with you it's like somebody said the other day

about a hater and I said look I said let's be honest I said to the guy if you were anything like that person a stuffing luck I'm not saying it people were saying I'm not saying he was ugly people are saying zolomon yeah but if you were anything like these people like I'm just saying in particular this person we were discussing the other day who was kind of hating I said let's just face it let's be honest if you are like that let's just use the term Muharram deprived you

two would hate the world so you have to you have to have this you have to give you a sympathy to these haters you have to say haters I'll on you mercy right let's move on people let's take some questions let's take some questions all right let's take some questions so I hope that answers so I await look I hope that answers that question to do with this as to him saying those names were you know that's not accurate first of all shukran bought more than you about the new odd okay right I

appreciate you highlighting that much appreciated those names won't be you know at least it's good to know but I never ride on them anyway and why don't you actually criticize what I did rely on and show me a clear chain that justifies you ridiculous assertion that rape is permit permitted which is an obnoxious atrocious statement anyway let's move on why can you do this is maryam thank you again for my Shahada all right Maria you do any do any

bienvenidos bienvenidos I'm gonna saddle and welcome welcome and it it's an absolute honor absolute honor can you do will do with hair gel of course you can of course you can wipe all the people why bother can we apply cream that contains alcohol and pray yes of course by the way that sorry my mind by the way is always on on humor mode I have to be careful right but yes you can apply cream that has alcohol it's absolutely fine okay that

alcohol isn't that same kind of drinking alcohol hair coloring is it okay hell yeah hair coloring is okay there's nothing wrong with that right no love but this is fake not fake person okay NOLA fake what you doing on this fake person's fake live transmission adios adios Amiga adios right view on share Delia who did Abraham Allison I'm take for sacrifice that's an interesting question that's an interesting question what do you think about a boy Brahimi's

racist remarks I've answered this in last week's or was it the week before we so you can check that name so sobriety is overrated people that reminds me of a poem all right poem time poem it reminds me of a poem

Jerry must he kibarim reckon that he says that you're that because your eyes are so known for their intoxication that I will keep their reputation okay Jerry must he kibarim Rock lunga horse I'll be talking a moody Hosni yeah that even if I do become sober I'll say I'm not sober just to keep that reputation of those

intoxicating eyes no Coke mmm there's a bit mixed in there right so right what are we looking at people what are we looking at let's take some rapid round kind of questions what was you somebody said you missed my question what was your question right Qualis to pregunta well it's to pregunta me amigo what is your question what is your question you keep saying you miss mine tell me the question I don't know what the question impressed taking or giving in countries

like India watch my clip it's on YouTube about about things like interest and revive answered how I don't believe these things to necessarily be Haram in the current system because I don't believe that it was that the my Posse they were not aimed at this system so you have to watch that hole it's over it's about 40 minutes long it's a whole explanation what are your views on the chandelier share that Leah are a Sufi group of Sufi order I'm not really part of any Sufi orders as you can see I'm just a a Wondra in my own right

that's all I'm not really part of people who want to be part of Sufi orders I don't you know I don't condemn them I don't to me though I kind of see all of this more as folklore religion I see this as kind of a need that common people kind of have to to make sense of religion and stuff like this and it's not really authentic from the Quran Osuna but you know I ya know I do care don't worry bar it's all good it's all good what are your views on today's yeah I did share that video of some person

criticizing today's you see the thing is that these people have for too long kind of preached their ways it's not look I don't have an some kind of hatred against yesterday's I don't write I love his recitation I totally love his style but you know these sermons these things referring constantly to Jews and Christians as you know like a Hana Z and Harada and you know monkeys and pigs and all this kind of stuff II it's four years they've instilled the hatred for people in the hearts of Muslims and even now look what they're doing all these

kind of things bombing Yemen their support for this kind of stuff it's it's atrocious so yes I was glad to hear that how somebody had confronted him right so you guys should follow the I'll abate tarifa I'm not really interested in any Sufi orders to be honest with you to me it's more about reason okay and through that I find my spiritual consciousness if you

like okay so was prophet Adam the first person on earth what does person mean like hominin of course not he wasn't the first hominid but he is the father of humanity as we know it today okay he all of humanity Adam aleihsalaam is the father of humanity but worthy hominins before Adam of course they would I mean that's my understanding that they would have been you know all the other whether it's gonna be Homo erectus how more you know homo all of these not homo in that sense heidelbergensis home africanus or all

these kind of different ones you're gonna get I believe how my gassed Homo habilis all of these Neanderthal even old homo sapiens but precognitive revolution I believe that they now they were there but Adam Ali salon was the first with the cognitive kind of revolution our dinosaurs mentioned in

the Quran come on what is Allah gonna say to people about like you know but he's gonna mention like t-rex and things like this in the Quran is all of that about obviously these things are not mentioned in the Quran but they don't need to be mentioned in the Quran why did birth man burn the Quran he did you see that sounds very hostile when you say it like that he asked he synchronised the script

of the Quran and then he said in order not to have anything that strays from this let's safely dispose of any other copies so we have these and then he made several some say seven or the copies he sent them to the main capital kind of cities and had them kind of print them up like is he not pretty right from the so that's but when you say like why did Othman burn the Quran sounds very hostile he never burned the Koran like hey where's the Quran let me set it on fire that's how did he dispose of copies that they felt contained maybe inaccuracies

that was the question no lays back saying orange juice muchas gracias know that muchas gracias so what's going down people what's going down right so how do we let's take some rapid round questions and we'll wrap these up people will wrap this up Oh somebody asked about pneumonia Lee honish aired a clip of nominally han estado man Lee Han it was an excellent clip really I totally loved it I'm gonna be honest it's probably I think it's about five

minutes long it's an interview in order to now he's asked the question that what does Allah want from us and he says he begins by saying you know how Dov you asked me this a decade earlier my response would have been entirely different now my response then would have been very guilt Laden or doom and gloom all kind of that Allah wants us to worship at this and you know he wants to burden us with this responsibility and we we're never gonna really everybody's gonna burn in the Archaea and it's a very kind of doom we're guilty and with full of sin and we're gonna suffer and everybody's gonna stop you know this

kind of very he said I had this kind of image and he said well now 10 years later how he'd kind of moved on and how the Quran he saw any messages of just hope and how Allah is saying how he's built paradise not just for Muslims before in Sun for Humanity how this whole this is a caravan of hope basically and the message is one of compassion and hope and so I found it really amazing I mean if you do understand order to do have a watch of it's not right how are punishments from Sharia decided is

my understanding is the Sharia religion sorry the laws was simply a social remedy based on the social understandings available so Islam never introduced any kind of punishment or any kind of things like that that were completely alien to the culture that they came to rather he just placed parameters on the kind of punishments and sanctions that those people already had so the Arabs already had things like stoning and stuff like oh the Jewish that came from the Jewish thing but the Arabs were it was not completely

unfamiliar to them okay so these kind of things it just placed parameters like they would already cut limbs and stuff like this so it came with just just with their whatever practices were but you just placed some parameters and with time as I believe with time and us about possible boards early and many of the Maliki scholars said with time as the punishments of civilizations change so should the Sharia and the laws so that's I've got a video on that on trajectory hermeneutics you can check it out on YouTube okay oh by the way that reminds

me mentioning the word stoning reminds me of two things one there's a so would I believe for fornication there would be stoning or lashing hell no I don't believe that at all in 2018 of course not six hundred years ago I will ask Melbourne's early said there wouldn't be that in his time that's six hundred years ago what about in our time in post modernity you wouldn't obviously do things like that because that would make the religion become tarnished so and we've got a really question a lot of things as well there's this too much work to be done to be honest it's really

difficult so there's a lot that even concepts need to be questioned for example even relationships and you've got to understand something as well even Xena and all of these things need to be kind of looked at and what is it what were married so I shadowed a lot on her says in a hadith that they were marriages were off for example there were four different types and and these became obsolete and the only thing that remained halal was the relationship that the kind of marriage structure that people have today that was in her day and age meaning the kind of Naqada the that that

was there so what's interesting is how our relationships then perceived over the ages and how does does does each DeHart have to take them into consideration because one would believe that they ought to so where does that kind of leave a lot of things and it's interesting it's interesting I'm just saying that people so there's a lot of work basically a lot of kind of each they has to go into things a lot of evaluation I think today people there's a lot of emotions when it comes to certain things but there isn't they're not really thinking about what Islam actually says they're just being

emotional and so a lot of culture that's what there is but yeah so right coming back to stoning I was gonna say there's two things that come to my mind one there's a hadith in sahih al-bukhari once again another fabricated misrepresented hadith about a companion saying oh I saw monkeys fornicate and one of them fornicated and the monkeys got together and stoned that monkey that is you gotta be joking right these kind of things or like animals don't do sit in like it like whether animals was

pelting each other or not is not an act of stoning okay because they were fornicating like that it doesn't the animal kingdom doesn't work like that okay he doesn't work like I mean yes they will attack each other they will Pelt each other but it doesn't work with these kind of imaginative realities like fornication fornication is an imaginative reality in the sense of as is marriage its marriage is part of the imaginative realm it's not actually it doesn't actually exist I mean it's something that's in our minds it's an institution we have built up as part of the imaginative realm religion has recognized it for its kind of propulsive

function in society but to assume animals think like that and they have constructs like fornication marriage stuff like this is absurd right so these kind of things you see it once again it ridicules religion right animals monkeys they realize one monkey at fornicated so they got together and they stoned the monkey to death like what what on earth are you talking about like yes I'm not saying monkeys may pelt each other with stones they may even kill each other I'm not saying that doesn't happen but it's not based on these concepts okay it's

not like a conceptual like thing going on like hey you know that monkey has violated the social norm of relationships therefore we need to sanction that monkey under cold so-and-so which divine justice or let's stone that monkey today that's another example so anyway that came to my mind so that scene that's a hadith in Sahil

Bihari which obviously is false and I'm not saying you see the whole I'm not saying that whether somebody saw monkeys throwing stones at each other has to be false that obviously would happen all the time monkeys would Pelt each other but all this narrative is nothing but creative writing like monkeys the animals don't have these constructs like this okay they don't think like that but this is exactly why we need to find comb religion from these cobwebs because the line is messenger free from this kind of

stuff the other thing I wanted to say about stoning was you know people have asked me about this version and I've seen some ex Muslims and atheists also few Muslims on this verse of the Quran the walaqad Zionism ah at dunya oj al Nahum asabi and how the sky has been kind of lit up with lamps as lamps with kind of with the stars and stuff like this what y'all najara do mainly shayateen and we have and this is interesting we have made them now they some people have translated this they've translated this

as a resume and that they fire at the shayateen as they go up Devils as they try to permeate through these Evans they get hit with comments and things like this that's not what this verse of the Koran is saying okay that is not what this verse of the Koran is saying okay the regim yes can mean stoning but regim he has you see certain for serene I believe amongst them I believe even harsher mentions the other people are mentioned as well it's not just him if you read through divers to Farsi and regem also means a guess like you know

when you get something it's like like people would say a shot in the dark like you take a wild guess a wild guess was also referred to as a regem because it was just a throw like they say in in order to as well painter i pink maybe pink or everything so this thing of like this throwing of just it's just a like what a random shot is a regem it's a guess so as the poet said in the jahiliya poetry when he says that it's that this is truth what we tell you what man who are under bill hadith in moral Jimmy and it is not

we're not just this isn't just guesswork we're not just chatting it you know the words this is what we are telling you is factual so here Allah say is that this sky that you see is lamps and people say well you know the stars are in the sky but lies addressing the people as they see it from their perspective now people see these things as like these kind of majestic lamps that have kind of decorated the sky with his glory and yet and Allah allow if people want he allows them that list

Shia theme that people who are astray the devil's and this share teaming ins from in son the share team we have share teen amongst us they use this as guesswork to predict the future haruman Lachelle t that these share team they look at these stars and through their kind of astronomy through astrology and things like this they try to predict future and luck and stuff like this resuming leash LT but that's what they

are that is what this verse of the Koran means it doesn't mean o the jinn go up and comets kind of strike at them and stuff like that it doesn't mean that at all so yes we have to be careful in our toughest here because if we don't people will they will obviously use that as an opportunity to ridicule Allah His Messenger this religion and we have a responsibility in transmitting things as they are as they make sense right so it shall hope that of some insight people

can women vote about having Sharia law hell yeah NOLA go for it of course when we can vote what does that mean of course I believe women can vote right did God speak to Moses and how did he speak how did he speak to Moses we don't know these things what about gog magog you see chef abdominus rd the Salafi share has very interesting rissalah for ya - drama - you should read it it's available it's online even are sure and other people as well they all speak about ya jus Jamaat

Jude are not these kind of monsters and these kind of little goblins and people that think that people think they are in the reseller P of chefs at addy and other people they've hi I did that these are most likely because from the word yeoju touch like something that suddenly Rises and suddenly kind of with with it brings a kind of unsettling turmoil that they felt that these were I mean people have interpreted differently but chef sadly felt that that was the kind of colonial period yeah children module and why that was so in why that

was so significant because after it the world was never the same again everything changed from the concept of the world to the economy to currency to nation-states to how everything changed and and that's here's a result it's available online I find it very interesting cool can you lead prayers with mmm of course you can lead prayers with the Imam as Imam Malik says in the Mokpo that the person with Tim I will do is not more pure than a person was the Imam right guys I hope that's off some help I'll leave you guys to it if you haven't subscribed to my youtube channel

subscribe to people subscribe subscribe to people subscribe to it my Facebook page both of them like it share it right spread the love people spread the love if you want to reach out to me you can send me a message I do try to respond as much as I can that's on facebook Messenger or or on Facebook I am on Twitter although I need to use it snapchat mount 2014 mal m20 one for Instagram masti Abu layth other than that people take very good care of

yourselves as always you're absolutely awesome keep laughing stay blessed people shall I enjoy the mercy and the blessings of Allah when you see this is how this is this is how you should be positive this is what I'm talking about not like these kind of angry faces going on right so other than that take very good care of yourselves insha'Allah Salam aleikum metal lighter ila or butter cattle