Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 86

how are we doing people Wow the heat the heat man I'm feeling it it is super super hot all right so let me just share this first of all one momento right you're sharing this folks right I'm just gonna get

all right almost done right I'm just sharing that with my who is my old um let me just grab my book folks it's one moment because I make this pencil in sometimes one two things that I don't forget to say so just one moment one moment

Roy Dunbar come back back I am back here is so how is it going all right people the heat is the heat killing us or what I tell you England the UK is not catered really for any weather if it gets too hot we just boil and burn because the houses are

created to insulate heat if it snows I think they tell us don't go anywhere if it rains for like a day the street start flooding what is happening to the UK you man so cool right folks in alhamdulillah wa kafa or salat wa salam wa an out of Salah al mustafa well I love Eddie live in October woman be who da master Wahby sorry a little medina testify what bad for salaam allahi al l comb Anamosa hanim become marhaban

bienvenidos a todos running light sir Caesarea Kyle as well for already Punjabi speaking and swagatam swagatam people swagatam so did I forget for here bodily right Islamabad people there from Islamabad all right I don't know silent comedy drama deed right people what a week hell of a lot going down a rattle some cages as always it's got to be done it's got to be done don't you think so

you've got to rattle some cages sometimes but that'll not a year you know there's a poet he says he's actually the first line to his poem is epic he says he says jang-soo Lupe on Charlie torta caranas earlier you see if any if if your principles are getting questioned oh people are trying to get you to

compromise them then you must clash the caranas Rudy here Jose in the whole toes in darkness are honest if you're alive then let it be known that you're alive I like it this is what we've got two songs I'm from Australia from Down Under Adam asylum become enormous island right so exposed exposed exposed comma Club

hey Baba exposed raw Rochdale crew always every Monday watch ads were saying the Rochdale Rochdale yeah our couch but normal yeah it's it's it's been blacklisted but it's all good it's good it's good to see that you're holding down the fort in a positive sense I mean you can always say you know so what but now my god holy token Amna what's what happens if we but it's good to see that this all this positivity from Rochdale see watch it to trim your

oh yeah i'll st sham is his name on more efficient st sham means you have to say shehram carnival ah you know like somebody who has shame and modesty about himself and the question is asking is it okay to trim your cojones is it okay to trim them every week I mean why do you want to trim them for God did y'all giver why you're just gonna keep cutting them and their reproduction no work you

know if you keep cutting them away well you see that's what happens I guess maybe he's been trimming them already a lot of due to blood loss vichara he's he's thinking he's doing something Islamic it comes they go he goes I'm just just doing the Islamic record he's encroaches he's like he's like oh no

it's Jamar game yes netboot Eternia we gotta do this sooner hey some are saying that share Akram another we Sahib I'm going to speak about that later on this is this I've got to speak about Calculon rattling some cages people this whole body thing and I'll discuss that this a abdullah andalusi i wanna discuss some of his comments these are Wahabi

brethren the mojave defense all ah so much people for you sub gentle-hearted kentucky something so people what is going on what is going on well study our scene is in the house I don't know silence somebody said are you mad hell yeah I wouldn't have it any other way so because if you're insane in an insane world are you technically insane jello I'll leave these kind of Abdullah and

the Lucy I'll talk about him in a moment let's any recaps right people the week what's been going on those of you tuning in click like click get this spread the love out there people spread it we sit back tea drink a saying he sits back and enjoy mohammed mohammed khalid animus and ambach on marhaban right so what dad was saying I said rest in peace for the brothers yet that's an awesome reminder to begin with that may Allah grant ease

to the family families of those who lost their beloved young youthful children to what appears to be joyriding so these are the dangerous people these are the dangers youth it's gotta be contained because you see it's one is yourself and one is those that you will hurt by your loss I guess I mean the the parents the families it's tragic to hear it happens I guess you know it's the way of the

world but even though we need to be more careful you know there was some kind of a police car chase and and presumably they lost control and completely drove into some I don't know whether it was a tree or what and the car was just completely destroyed and four passengers have died so may Allah grant ease to the families that are suffering after them and really it's unfortunate because it's a tragedy stemming from foolishness so

that's the thing that's what makes it so much worse right so see it is in the house all right see there's one some medals I saw your Facebook post with the judo going down keep it up keep it up right so Muhammad have you come to Pakistan Pakistan there's amazing things going on in Pakistan right now I'm really excited about the whole Imran Khan thing I did watch I had to skip through his speech but the the recent speech at in Lahore that he gave him minar-e-pakistan really interesting to see how this will

play out because you see Pakistan has a hell of a lot of bureaucracy and he's naturally upsetting those bureaucrats by trying to cut the luxuries that on warrantied kind of undeserved luxuries that they had so I wonder how this will play out I mean may Allah grant him success I totally am a fan of his work and you know so cool right let's see what else is going on why do we seemingly always get schooled about what not to do rather than what to do I agree

Samir has a ditch from lots of love from Serbia all right right back at you man all of you deserve it Wow Serbia people yes Allah may Allah grant ease to the people of Serbia they they to underwent a lot of suffering you know this is what we need humanity the message of compassion of love of Mercy to spread throughout the earth really somebody saying it's easier to complain then give solutions right somebody's

once again going back to the hair trimming question about I heard it's wide you've to cut your hair why do you want to cut come and cut my hair I'm quite okay I'm quite capable I can cut my own somebody's writing that it's wide you've every 40 days look relaxed yourselves just trim it it's hygienic just do it as as often as you can as regulars you know without you don't have to have like a timetable and say oh oh it's now August the 6th

I must today embark upon trimming trimming the basement you don't need to be so robotic about he just just naturally just just do it just just just chill a little so what else is going on what else people what else right is a Muslim woman allowed to go out without her husband's permission

is she an adult which is a rhetorical question by the way because obviously children child marriages are categorically Haram in case somebody responded by saying no that would be like her what the hell so of course she's an adult and of course she doesn't need his permission right so but the thing is look this there's something about living when you live with people people are involved in each other's lives unfortunately but they are to some

extent people's to some extent they were involved in each other's lives you know so people might say eh you know what I'm which you go today or what and people do this kind of stuff I suppose or they might say listen I'm just off to this place I'm just getting these speakers I suppose they share a is somewhat of a life together so Delta hey you know this kind of stuff you can you know you you have that communication but it's not really a kind it's not like she's your slave Oh employee that she has to be very precise to be precise or take permission or take

leave she doesn't have to do these things if she tells you I mean this is a kind of like a mutual courtesy that's what it is you know we we embarrassed Islam ourselves by by this kind of outlook really these days would make many men need permission nowadays to go out there from the Y you know so many people I know they're not allowed out it's I'm serious they're not actually allowed out can you believe that they need permission and then if they're out the phone

where are you where are you how do you hide the mediator jakey's Oh what is this what is this under the thumb but there are a lot of men like that as well believe it or not right obviously I wouldn't know from firsthand experience but I've seen the expression on the face of the other when I thought what in God's name could bring such fear to the face of this person what could it

be as the Antichrist himself arrived as World War 3 I mean what what has happened then you realize a cha-cha it's the the missus from home calling him [Laughter] cool ah right so what else people right so this week also I on this week I met up with some of these Baraka boys if that's what they go by I think some of

the good good lads local my likies friends students that kind of stuff but and they had some interesting musical kind of get together and we also did an interview which was really interesting actually it was a discussion with those of you who don't who know face'll hey I don't know if he spelled it Faizal or Faizal face old Salah or Salah face on salah man he has been gifted a voice I have to say he's been gifted a flute

from the flutes of doubt Ali Salaam honestly he the man knows how to sing I'm telling you and he improvises on the spot you can't believe that that he just made that song go on the spot and he did and he does and listen I was totally wild and then we had a kind of discussion that was recorded we he was going through a lot of questions struggles that he had regarding faith in the past and amongst that was this whole discussion on slave slavery within the Islamic context and

and I suppose sex slaves they never used to call them sex slaves by the way but being able to have sex with slaves with female slaves what was the whole story about this so I mean he didn't fully understand so we first had to go through some DVDs we had to go through some videos and some all these illustrations then he was like ah I'm kidding I'm kidding do not cut and paste that people right so this it was a really interesting dialogue though honestly III it was

intense it was difficult there were some difficult questions but hopefully that will be that was also that was hosted by momma Dee so momma do those of you mama do tall friend and student those of you probably know I'm already through social media so hopefully that will be out soon and you guys can can watch that discussion he was it was interesting right so right what's the Maliki stance on charaluta right Maliki stance what

Stan Stewie what position do we our flexibility in the in the stance stands [Laughter] right so I've said before that look with Nakata you know what in in the coming weeks I will do a detailed discussion on Carol Mata but I've said before that look this motor I think there's a diverse diversity of opinions some allama believed it to be permissible like the legend Scheffel islam of the Maliki

sure he writes in his stuff see it and other people and I think all of these permissions are out there some people said it was hard on some people and this thing that making it a Shia thing that's just that's just dirty politics you know dirty sectarianism it's not a she I think I'm just being honest it's not a she I think although it is today pushed off as a Shia thing and and then it's Sony's kind of try to insult she are by this kind of stuff and I think that's not fair really we should be just we should be just look I to disagree with the Shia our ideology and the theology and stuff like this and that's up to

them I mean but my point is that in this day and age first of all we need to build bridges that's very important I have said that in my understanding that look I like to view religion objectively religion a lot of religion is just folklore it's just kind of kind of cus this kind of folk lauric tradition that is being put together for people and Islam too has fallen victim to that it's a great amount of it is folklore today and the Shia faith is no exception to that it is also you know has a huge amount of folklore as does the Sunni

tradition as well the Shia tradition however I feel heavily focuses on certain kind of myths I'm calling the myths obviously to them I'm using the term myths in more a kind of discourse analysis sense I don't mean to them they not myths there realities but it relies on these concepts the concept of for example tragedy the concept of redemption these kind of things as you've seen other religions as well this is kind of like a universal theme found in many religions like

Christianity how Jesus Christ redeemed himself for mankind how the tragedy he suffered the tragic suffering how he was tortured and you see similarities with for example Hussein amongst the Shia kind of tradition of how he redeemed mankind and how he's portrayed sometimes even in pictures almost christ-like and you get these kind of themes in other religions as well so to me that this is really like part of that folklore tradition I mean human beings are gonna do it like it doesn't you know I I see it and but I also see that most people

will always want folklore for most people they won't want kind of pure reason and stuff like this in this day and age in the West it's a bit different but otherwise people throughout history have generally had an inclination to folklore because it kind of settles well with them and they they kind of keep it makes them it works for them okay so so I disagree with a lot of but but let's be fair when we disagree with even other groups or whether it's gonna be the Shia whatever you know let's not just falsely attribute stuff to them like this kind

of what are thing that people have turned exclusively into a shia thing is wrong it's not a Shiar thing in essence although the she I do have it it's actually a Sunni thing as well but so anyway I mean that's but I think most importantly look we have to today in my understanding we have to work towards building some bridges because it's not gonna work otherwise you know this hatred for how long will we have hatred you know in our hearts most Sinise don't know anything about Shia Islam most Shia I probably don't know hardly anything about Sunni Islam

except you're circulated stories and you know for how long will we hate so we need to start trying to extend friendship and love and compassion and you know understandings and just not discuss the controversial stuff cool right so what else is going on people what are we looking at let's take some questions the hadith of the Prophet not praying for nudged noticed is really that part of Saudi or

yeah we somebody hails from yes we all know who we're talking about HD so he hails from not just the prophet in the Hadees I mean if it be true he said that this will be a cause of great tribulation I mean I know we can take that with a pinch of salt but the reality is that the Wahhabi sect has

been a cause of great tribulation although it has it has brought some good with it as well you know we like I said if we're going to be just then I think they did kind of cause a reaction and a wake-up call for the majority of the Muslims because Muslims were kind of completely out of it they would has owned out until the Salafi is kind of arrived one could argue really I suppose that's perhaps the other seller fees that did a lot of that questioning like chef Rasheeda though and other people but

still they did bring back an importance towards hadith and stuff like this which was which is good it's good but then they overdid it you see they overdid it and they caused a lot of harm in the process they kind of created a culture where we now almost worship Bihari which is a huge problem because this deification this semi godlike status of Bihari that we have so this statement of it is the most authentic book after the Quran is utter nonsense utter nonsense this you know this thing

utter nonsense and it's really been kind of pushed by the wahhabis and the Salafis and then then you know the other meth habit especially like people like the do Bundy's and other people who are insecure they also started to bigger no this is the problem isn't it like in order to show the world that you're secure you to start boasting of that thing that your adversary is bringing ah typical but yes I'll then the kind of the open these big dope mihari so much as well and then a lot of the hanafis and they took it to like a divine status

as well and now we have a problem because now we're realizing there's a lot of cobwebs in this story ah and some of these cobwebs I've highlighted I've said this what's this problem you know now people are upset they like Simic is careful yeah so but this is the problem is he had of you not you know decided to worship Sahil Bihari we wouldn't have this

problem you know how have you just accepted it like a useful book that's useful but like in my malik tool that you accept and reject from it you know like that's what the scholars of hadith said they've nabbed Albar all these colors he said nobody would have been a we would not consider somebody to be a true scholar until he learned to accept and reject hadith so this had of they done it like that we wouldn't have had a problem but obviously because the seller fees are dogmatists they create pictures of God from hadith from these isolated hadith if not they take these isolated adi and grow

pictures of god i mean not physically draw but they mentally kind of sell to them they read things from Syal bihari and then say god is this so you know god has two right hands he doesn't have a left hand he has two right hands God has one leg [Laughter] galvanized what if they turn got into he has one foot he is one shin he has a back he has some teeth according to them yes I think two fingers what is this that's like and any jumps and he moves stuff all like I'm not making this up

I'm not making this up what la he you just have to read there T the books so this is what they write this is what and then they say after that or don't picture it behave how can you not picture it how can you not picture it after I've said all of those things like if I say to you look this a clown and he's climbing out of a gutter and he's got that pinky but don't picture it of course I'm gonna picture it what the hell if you didn't want me to picture it don't say these people don't let us be

in peace this is so now obviously to them this is a greater problem because how on earth now do you prove you're up either since body and you know what it is look let me clarify something for the record I need to clarify something statement time statement time I have nothing I I have no issue with salvo Hari or with a man Bihari always I have

no issue with these things let me be very clear okay just in case people want to misquote me then at least listen hear me out I have no issue with a man Bihari I I think is an amazing legend of this oh man I totally have love and respect for a man Bihari the Imam who died by the way who died oppressed by Muslims of his day and age oppressed by these same Salafis back then we call in aptly the humbly and oppressed by the hanafis the Hanif is they actually a man Bihari for several years was deemed a heretic he was called astray he was called as India he was

called somebody who you can't take your faith from pretty much the labels they throw at me they threw our Mambo Hari and for years on end nobody took a single hadith from him and he died that bechara no this is this is who they today like to worship their own ancestral you know that the people whose books they the belief that they are following the system of the Salafis this kind of maja be a leader that you have is traditionally called humble yet either they them and the hanafis tortured Imam Bihari to death so in mine Bihari which are you know

like he was going from town to town they wouldn't he went to Nisha food they wouldn't even allow him in from the gates pleaded with people can can I take some refuge they wouldn't let him in you know this he would go from town to town you know even when he spent his in in his last few years when one of the greats what's his name I'm a dignified is a nice Aboudi who kind of gives him refuge and and he actually copies his history book from him so Amon Bihari had an amazing book it's not a history book but it's a book on the records of narrators

it's called a history the great history atari whole kabir here's other works as well but it's a little kabir is transmitted by this person he stayed with but did he transmit hadith as well think about him embodies with him why not take his sahi on body but no it didn't transmit it why because he was blacklisted nobody wanted to take a deal from imam bukhari imam bukhari today who they say Imam Bihari Imam Bihari in his day and age they tortured him and he was called a heretic a deviant he was out of a Sunnah he was they called him a hidden

kaffir and he just went from town to town nobody would give him refuge and eventually died in just some small town of Nisha poor and he actually prayed to God that killed me because I can't take this anymore and he died and you know even today research shows us that one of the greatest causes of death is loneliness it is seriously causes a person to shut down and to give up and that will to live diminishes and so Imam Bihari just died and he made oh Allah Allah you know he

says in his famous store that laqad dark Italian are Dobby Morocco but you know that that this vast earth of yours has become so narrow and claustrophobic for me that just take me and he died and this is the same you know the same attitude of these model reason these mullahs and these they the ones who tortured him to death because they called him a deviant just because just because he disagreed on an opinion about the Quran like he said that we don't call the Quran you know he said that of course this book in front of us is

created Oh deviant deviant don't take a D from him tortured him the same Wahhabi they great great great great theological ancestors the humbly zinati that they're the ones who tortured him and the hanafis the hanafis are the other ones who tortured him why the hanafis hated him is because he had beef so to speak with imam abu hanifa he used to criticize imam abu hanifa and you've criticized the opinions of the Hanafi method so inside inside this book al bukhari he was known to have criticized the Hanafi method so they had issue with

him and beef with him and so and you know then they circulate nonsense like surah see imam syrup see writes in his book all the reason we boycotted him is because he said if two people drink milk from the same cow they become brother and sister I mean come on behave this is like you know this is like he'll give a liter keep naturally at least come out with a better that's like you know that's like everybody in the room like hearing this thinking they're thinking like for God's sake you could have at

least made up a better lie than that at least makes them at least let us lightly digest it oh if you drink milk from the same cow you become brother and sister I mean come on everyone she wouldn't have said something stupid nobody says things like mediator dak say this is this is the thing they don't let people be man they don't let people be so anyway that's imam bukhari in this day and age so I have love for Imam Bihari I have this book that is transmitted and apparently is allegedly

mumbo Hadees book I have respect for the book as a whole but my issue is not with the book my issue my questions are genuine okay so let me come back to this discussion on Bihari later just in a while when I'll discuss some of these counterclaims but okay when we are allowed and not allowed to mix with the opposite gender Dan Anderson is asking Kemal Ibrahim is asking on KFC

McDonald's much natal Kootenay that's the thing hell yeah so look opposite gender who says you're not allowed to mix with the opposite what does that mean mix with the opposite gender what does what does that even mean like shared space having shared space while I'm not allowed to be in a room if that we're not allowed to have like what 10 meter squibbed shared shared or what are we what this is why you know with these kind of people this is my advice folks when these people say these kind of absurd statements rephrase the question and

show them how ridiculous this question is so when they say you're not allowed to 3 mix 3 mixes it's just a made-up word it's not even an English word I mean free mixing means to do with music in the tapes and stuff like this that they free mix it doesn't mean this like like so what they asking is shared space so can men and women share space now all of a sudden you see when you say it out loud you think well it sounded ok my head actually but now now that I've said it loud it kind of sounds dumb actually

like then all of a sudden you feel embarrassed like wait a minute sorry no no no that ain't my question because what does that mean like share space what like 10 meter squared 15 meter squared 5 meter squared I mean what kind of space it's stupid you know this oh are you allowed to talk to women [Music] no cause you like to talk to me what the hell in fact the problem sometimes is not communicating although that is another topic in itself that can men and

women ever successfully communicate [Music] that's another topic in itself because I do think sometimes men and women can never successfully communicate that's a different discussion philosophical discussion like nowadays you can endure I don't know I think men I don't know but a lot of men I think like for example we can't understand so many emojis I think we can only understand the obvious emojis like happy laughing angry you know stuff like shocked

we can't understand emotions beyond that like where is that what does that mean this is our handicapped nature as men we can't understand haha so this miscommunication mmm so so that's the of course they should be communication you know so many people get they get married and they haven't successfully communicated and

you know in some cases that's fine like people get to kind of you know they're okay and in some cases it's it's a tragic shock because they realize that what the hell they completely can't get on with the other person they completely find the other person very different personalities totally don't March they and and then people would would ask them you know did you not communicate before you got married did you not speak I mean wouldn't you speak to each other you know so this is just a huge problem

people so communication is key that's what I would say second gaze is Haram I heard chaos what is this second gaze third case what what is this what is this kind of nonsense that people go on about look keep it natural that's what I say just keep it natural you know this is the problem we want to micromanage everything we want to micromanage everything oh you're allowed to look once but not twice

oh I blinked oh is the blink part of the first look or is it part of the second look what is this will turn the Dean into a joke what is this kind of stuff you know you're not allowed to look there's a see there's a hadith of the Prophet since they wanna hadith where the Prophet is with his cousin who's staring at the woman that he finds attractive and he's even mentions he's going like this so add another he's like he's like

mesmerized by her beauty as often people are but the thing is so this is easy and he singing with the Prophet and he's doing that and the Prophet simply just kind of turns his face because he's and loads of people are noticing this by the way so the prophets is kind of telling him that look just I mean he's looking again and the prophets kind of like telling him and he's looking again and the product and then he says to the Prophet did I do something wrong and the Prophet says it's not that it's just that I just thought that things were getting a bit

out of hand that's all so look the Prophet why didn't the Prophet stuff for a lock the moment you looked after nor point two seconds he became Haram you know there wasn't nothing like that so yeah so exactly so we kind of turned the deen into something robotic and then we kind of complain now why is it the way it is and then people then all these you know we've got issues and issues and yeah so there anyway right what else what's going down why have why has Allah made the Quran so

unclear this is an interesting question I've lost it now here it is while he had people reading horrible things into it why is it more clear so that Isis and other Psychopaths had no chance Marius Marius what a mystic named Marius what kind of wonder what language that why is the Quran considered divine revelation aren't we commanded to lower the gaze

okay let me just finish up on lowering the gaze I don't mean by that G ays as in lowering the homosexuals just in case somebody's like okay I've lowered the gay the two gays are lowered them right so we have some miscommunication so I don't want people to be having any miscommunication so lowering the case yes because look the Quran is speaking about harm you know when you're kind of like idling away in you making people

uncomfortable this is what the Quran would have been addressing that don't do that you know because that is it makes people very uncomfortable and you are causing even if it's on the low end of the spectrum but you're causing harm to people so that would have been the understanding and if a person felt that they're going to by looking do something I think people need to chill out as well a bit you know people like oh my god if somebody looks then you know then they'll have to do something what this is what I call the yard said that know

the responsibilities on each individual themselves so this is what there is a difference between you know like ogling and kind of like staring down somebody and between obviously looking or meditating as some cause that's a joke as a joke [Laughter] anyway right so what's the other question what were we talking about yeah harassment is obviously forbidden so

that's the that's that's true so that's what the verse of the Quran would have mean speaking about yes I'm with ducky Hans got it it's the desi gays you know the I know what I'll do I wanna crack that girl this this is people's this is the kind of desi way of seducing a girl I'll just sit here and stare at her like this until she's

absolutely petrified anyway right so all right so let's move on right the other question somebody asked why is the Quran sometimes why is the Quran sometimes not so clear why don't you like his bow tie dear ah the same way I don't like bacteria and viruses he's looked at here I'm gonna come on to them in a moment this oh come on to them they are an

extreme they are a cancer in this but anyway I'll come to that this thing about the Quran it is true that the Quran is not sometimes so clear and that is something that that's the kind of fear objection that people can have against against I suppose revelation and against Muslims if we're gonna be fair but I think that maybe that the reason behind that is that sometimes in order for something to grow and develop it

needs malleability it needs that that kind of an element an X Factor of plasticity and that comes with some ambiguities sometimes some things not being clear and I know this is then a double sided blade because um it can count against it's a bit like evolution you see the kind of cells need to be able to to be able to mal reproduce they needs to be

kind of the ability for Maori production and mutation in order for it to allow them to evolve like if cells could not reproduce in including a a kind of mutated way as well then they couldn't evolve so it was the need of evolution that as a consequence you would have things like cancer do you understand although there are carcinogenic kind of elements too but what I'm trying to say is the Maori production of cells is also necessary

for evolution so sometimes some kind of ambiguities misses that's my understanding but I do concede I I accept I'm not you know I'm not one of these people that tries to shy away from things or tries to lie your cover up it is true that the Quran the language it uses at times no I mean that sometimes it is a minority of occasions but sometimes it uses language to allow certain things to go on even though at a deeper level you know that's not so let

me give you an example let's take Christianity as an example now the Quran when every addressed Jesus Christ alayhis-salam it seems to address him with words not whenever but at times at times throughout the Quran on at least four occasions throughout the Quran it seems to refer to him in ambiguous words that the Christians really only related to and we as Muslims today don't accept Jesus Christ like that so it

seems to refer to him as the Word of God logos which in the Christian thing is and the word was with god and the word is God you see so and in the Quranic refers to Jesus walk le matin ilaha illah maryam walk le matin minho and the word from God now it doesn't refer this this wording is not used for any other prophet or anybody only for Jesus Christ now it's interesting that the Quran did

that because in essence that is a very kind of Christian narrative like we as Muslims don't actually believe that another thing interesting about Jesus Christ Ali Salaam is whenever the Quran mentions him in certain not whenever but in certain verses it mentions the Holy Spirit won't roar help others but it doesn't mention the RO he'll put this really for anybody else like in one verse there is only one other verse where Allah says you know that the Quran has been brought down unless Allah who

help others that you know that the rural Buddhist has brought down but beyond that verse it's not used for anybody except Jesus on at least three or I think four other occasions it mentions that were a year now and we strengthened him with the Holy Spirit what is that talking about because why is it using words which we as Muslims don't actually use it's it's actually leaning in on a Christian narrative so it's interesting the Quran does do this because the Quran was revealed over a lengthy period of time and it was allowed to create bridges between

certain people that could then in the way maybe connect because maybe in essence the Quran wasn't about Creed it wasn't about this kind of dogma that we as Muslims later on turned Islam into Creed like there's a hundred and sixty five points which you must believe if you don't believe these points you are a kaffir you know this kind of thing just didn't exist in early Islam and it was more just about the faith okay now so it's it is true that yes there's certain things

in the Quran that sometimes it uses language that can be interpreted in different ways people can another thing to remember as well the Quran primarily came for the people it was revealed to it did not primarily comfort us it came for us but by extension so the Quran came somebody's asked a question they rod radar Khan I don't understand the question though what's the point of the Holy Spirit I don't understand the question I don't think there is a point

to it in that sense yes the Quran does mention with Jesus the Holy Spirit on more than one occasion it mentions the Holy Spirit helped Jesus seem forth reinforced Jesus and things like this but what does that mean for us as Muslims it doesn't mean much maybe for Christians it meant a lot more so this is my point so what I'm trying to say is the Koran sometimes maybe it was bigger than just us and we are so egocentric that we think it's all about us if you understand I mean one of my understood

one I I have a view as well although and that is I don't know whether that would come much into this question but that is that this term Allah in Islam the Quran mentions we are upon the middle of Ibrahim I have an understanding that maybe the middle of earlier grand prophets varied so it's not and I don't mean by that they're the way of practice very because that Allah clearly says all of the prophets they practice is very they lose

varied I don't mean that but maybe there milah meant the entire discourse of religion the way you look at religion as a whole may have varied and maybe we are upon the one of ibrahim ali salaam and that's an interesting thought then so maybe certain because you see in certain religions maybe there wasn't a stress on things like on the afterlife for example and maybe that was their miller it was a different middle i mean these are just some thoughts that I have sometimes well

anyway let's get back to the problem is Trinity in Christian religion no he doesn't Lima what's this what's going on trolling going on so I can block some trolls can't see any trolls what are your thoughts on quantum entanglement I find quantum mechanics solemn on third Judean is asking you that is my right hand anyway for God's sake grow up

people the camera is reversed anyway right so the quantum entanglement I think is amazing I think quantum physics is amazing honestly mind-blowing it's and I really feel that you see my understanding is maybe consciousness is something I definitely think consciousness or we access consciousness through the brain I definitely feel that that is definitely correct but I think what if we access it at a quantum level and what if consciousness is something that is more

out there and we have the ability to tap to it and what if there's like a sea of consciousness and a collective consciousness so these are things that I feel and what if consciousness is the raw so these are you know and and hence a la blue he says and from his consciousness he blue from his Roy he blew that one man rowena Allah says we blue from our Roy into Adam what if this and I think about entanglement

I really think you know with basically two subatomic particles like electrons or you could get other you know some atomic particles as well what they can do is become entangled now the thing about this is once beam together like however for whatever reason they get entangled no matter how far they are if one is altered or moved the other one automatically means and part of this will is also a part of I mean I know China recently conducted several experiments underwater as well and incredibly successful and things

like this with quantum entanglement I've always thought what if there is like I was reading once about something like it was a theory about what if there are bio photons that are emitted because the photons are like massless particles by the brain because the brain has electrical kind of surges and it operates electrically as well as kind of with you know fluids as well but what if that if two people have a connection a powerful connection and then maybe

through the eyes what if bio photons were to become entangled what about that people hence no matter how far people are sometimes they have that bond and connection that's an intra it's just a theory that I was you know I because I was thinking about this once and I came across certain kind of theories about it I thought that sounds so because it is I think sometimes very interesting how people have that bond how they can be thinking and other people can be thinking of them internal it's almost like a very low-key

kind of telepathy but not like full-on communication but it is subtle and so that's some food for thought right - what wouldn't that be rather Eastern the thought I'm not sure what that means right okay so what are some questions right so on that note I'd seen some articles about Jim possession people somebody's asking why is the or on divine scripture you see that's a faith element we as Muslims believe the Quran

is divine as far as empirical all we can simply say is that it comes from the Prophet Muhammad sallallahu wasallam now for us as Muslims we believe that that was revealed on to him from God that part we can't prove and non-muslims wouldn't really accept that part they may accept that yes it came from the prophet muhammad sallallahoalyhiwasallam but they won't accept the rest that it came from God for us as Muslims we would say that we believe it came from God

there's no harm look they they don't have to believe it came from God and we don't need to be insecure we don't need to be insecure i people faith is a journey ok I tell a lot of people this that faith is a journey and just embrace it it's not you know we're not here to say we have I have empirical proof that this is this oh this is no the faith faith is a journey and that's why it's called faith you know and they and it's okay but it's not counter of reason either so there's a difference in some people who feel it's count of reason so

all these great prophets had these visions and understandings to in fact at that book that I went through is a very good book the history of religion by Holloway professor Holloway now it's amazing how in the beginning he speaks about those people of enlightenment these prophets and like Moses and the Prophet Muhammad sallallaahu little and other prophets as well you see two other people that they acknowledge that definitely these people had some amazing inspiration because they they they had something that changed the world and you know you don't

have to believe in the prophet Moses you don't have to believe in Jesus Christ you don't have to believe in the Prophet Muhammad and peace and blessings be upon all of them you don't have to believe in them but the truth is they change the world and now Saudi so people do you recognize that they had some kind of inspiration some visions of intuition but to us we would accept that was revelation they said it was revelation those people themselves said that this was the voice of God that spoke to them

now to other people who don't believe in that they would acknowledge that it was some inspiration and intuition but they just won't acknowledge that it was the voice of God right so Yassine Alif LAAM says can't people really be enticed to one certain faith your Dawa skills are not on point well that's what you call criticism people

constructive criticism I like it I like it this one's to you man this one's to you your tower skills are not on point [Laughter] anyway is that what I'm doing here now ah okay so what do you say about what until what and why dude what aunt who this watered oh what a tall dude I so what that told

you I thought you're speaking patois I thought we got our Jamaican Caribbean brethren bredrin on the line they're speaking about what I do would you but this is what if that's all dude okay what the truth is about the essence of everything is in essence God and I mean it's not the general understanding within Muslim theology although it exists some people have it like chef what's his name Maya Dean even our abhi and other Sufis have generally had see what's interesting is what if

that was part of another meal and that's what I meant because it's intra because an essence what they're saying at a philosophical level you understand it that they're trying to say well really everything only exists because of God so that's interesting so I think like what if that is from another meal the body for another Milla what had that as the main understand these are questions people questions I just put them out there and what I get in return is people refuting me with these PDFs

and saying Zinn big kaffir mortared right so Yusuf said he left the millah other people but Yusuf would have been the Miller of Ibrahim because the Yusuf is from the Israelites so

what's the best argument in your opinion that proves Islam is objectively true you see Islam is a faith it's not about being able to I don't know if you can objectively I believe Islam stands the test of reason so but it is a faith it's difficult I would say look when you say prove it to be objectively true I don't believe you can empirically prove it like the way I can prove this book to be here you can't prove Islam like that it's a faith in my understanding it provides meaning to people you know it

provides but then as I said last week or the week before it's like all of our social constructs how can you prove them to be true how can you prove money to be true what makes you think money money actually doesn't exist I mean it's what makes you think the concept of possession what makes you think the concept of human rights is true what makes you think the concept of nationality exists or of States or of rulership or of relationships or of the institutions like marriage I mean none of these things actually exist race does not exist laws in essence ok people could argue they could say you know but

these are just stories that we made up these are all discourse this is all just discourse analysis told stories human beings have spun none of them actually exists objectively none of these things exist I mean you might think they exist but they don't ownership does not exist like for me to say this phone is mine is it's just a story how can you prove that I mean you could say you prove it because I've got it in my hand or because a receipt says that's mine but how do you prove possession with a capital P how do you prove that just by having something what do you mean that's yours yours is something that is only attached to you like how does you know

so these are stories that we have spun as human beings none of them can be objectively proven they all exist in our in this amazing thing called the mind but they provide meaning for us and we believe them to be true and religion is one of those things that we believe to be true so I mean it provides people solace it gets people through this life and it gives them an understanding of how they came here and where they going you can't objectively prove any of these things right somebody's saying ah bah

bah right so even your children are not yours and that was my argument to the courts to the judge he will my children to the CSA Child Support Agency now children can be proven to be yours school it's called DNA I tried that one it doesn't work don't try that one the

judge is just gonna go hmm anyway right so children can be proven to be yours that's something scientific but I meant the construct social constructs do you believe in the evil I know I don't the evil eyes just nonsense it's just superstition that Muslims unfortunate not just Muslims many people have a Christian medieval basically it existed in the medieval times that everybody is to believe in an evil they're matter what religion you're from you don't have to be Muslim you could

have been Christian Hindu anything they believed in the evil eye you know I look at you and and the evil it's nonsense there's no such thing right so the hadith are regarding the evil eye are either non-existent weak fabricated or those that do exist and are barely acceptable those are simply speaking of envy and acting out on envy so Envy in itself doesn't cause harm but what causes harm is when you act out on env so that's what the evil eye meant it meant when

people act out on this kind of jealousy and jealousy but people could say well you know but jealousy already exists in the Arabic language it does but there's different types of jealousies because there's one type of jealousy that you know you don't want the other person I don't want nobody to have these and then there's kind of subtle subconscious like you could be envious of something maybe it's not that you don't want the other person to have it but maybe you want it as well and maybe it's at a subconscious level and it influences your behavior towards that person and therefore you harm that person and this is known

throughout life people have harmed people you know that are that you see that they so a typical example will be like let's say you've seen in several story several cultures like a beautiful girl or a beautiful woman is harmed then and and that doesn't make much sense because why would people harm her but it's almost like they have that kind of this kind of like there is this envy and insecurity and these sometimes are things operating at a subconscious level

as well that people feel inept in front of other people and therefore they try to harm them or cause harm or sabotage sometimes so I think that's what in those hadith that are acceptable that spoke of the evil I was referring to you wasn't referring to an actual like an an evil you know like you shoot out laser rays and cause harm that that kind of stuff is nonsense so yes right I was going to going to speak about gin possession are you the

21st century mufti Ralph I Hussein Mufti is I think what you want to say ah step let me correct you and that's Mufti GT you [Laughter] right so I saw this a few Facebook posts and some videos speaking about gene possession and people look let me tell you I have a whole video on gene possession it's on YouTube Jim demonic possessions do not exist people okay there are no such thing as

demonic possessions this is nothing but just folklore folk just kind of stories superstition that unfortunately huge parts of the Muslim world and just plagued with it's just a medieval understanding it's nothing there is nothing the Quran is actually against these kind of beliefs if anything the Quran clearly condemns any such kind of nonsensical belief it even tells you that the devil himself you know the devil himself Shaitaan has no power over you he tells you that that even the Shaitaan is to state on the day

of judgment in surah Ibrahim it mentions that he will say McInally alikoum in Saul's barn I had no power over you it was your choice yet we feel that these little demons kind of possessed people ruin their lives make them kill people ruin relationships make them cause harm and all the death of people nonsense utter nonsense and there isn't a single sighs sorry hadith in in our literature every single hadith is weak and yet people believe in this stuff so this is the the kind of nonsense that we are

dealing with and let me tell you something guys you know sometimes some people have asked me what about some interesting cases that have been inexplicable and first of all I would ask them that is see when you say jinn possession demonic possession is the belief for this rational or textual have you arrived at this through reason or have you arrived at this because you believe that Islamic sources have taught you this because there are no sources that teach and in fact the teaching is counter

demonic possession if you then say that well no I believe in this because through my rationally well rationally it's a flawed argument that you know there's these kind of beings that come into people and it makes no sense because if you read the arguments that these people have written in the past and and people like you know scholars like even at emia have really destroyed lovey you know may Allah forgive him and have mercy on him with this with his book on because the problem once again he's not even a team yet per se it's

just people have taken him to be a demigod almost you know they think even the taymiyah was like the Prophet himself so anything he said you had to have been you know divine and and so even it a me a wrote a book about all that Jim can possess me and and people bounce up and down in glory that oh yes because even it's a me I said of course he was gonna say he lives six seven hundred years ago of course what you expect him to say you know like and and he wrote a book and you should read his book by the way he says that they can become anything they could become a piece of like this book could be a Djinn now he says they can take the and they can become inanimate objects they can

become objects they can become humans they can be what on earth is this nonsense you know and if you're a jinn what do you want to do you want to cause harm if I want to cause harm to somebody then wouldn't I cause harm like oh they want to cause harm to his farm then why not just become a caught a page in the Quran why not because you why not become this TV screen why not why not become the Quran why not become a hadith how do you know that every time you actually wrote that book and how do you know that

that book isn't just a Djinn you see because if I was a Djinn what I would want people to do is believe that I've got these powers and if I can become a book as if in a taymiyah wrote how do you know that wasn't the that just pretended to become a book and said I'm authored by even a taymiyah how do you know it blue taymir was in a gin how do you know anything how do you know then they're gonna say well that's absurd why is it absurd oh wait a minute I'm sorry ain't we talking about demonic

possessions so the whole dialogue is absurd achar so when you speak when I give examples they're absurd it's true though what makes you think well anything is true then I could be a gene we could all be genes as I've said before if you if I was a gene and I wanted to create mass mischief on earth become a terrorist so really Oh possess these people and turn them into terrorists so really Isis are not to blame they're

just demons that are possessed people see you like this kind of nonsense where it gets to it's all stupid and nothing and I'll tell you this there's something very interesting in fact there's a movie I was watching it's called brain on fire it's a very interesting movie on Netflix hashtag Netflix and chill is there's an interesting movie on Netflix cool and it's a book is based on a true true life events of this girl who had a lot going for her in life and then all of a sudden

she becomes quite debilitated and she starts getting these seizures and then it goes from bad to worse and it becomes quite crippling over time but the inter and this is recent I mean this is this is like a fresh story is it's only you know several years old it's not that long ago they only so they ran in America the latest test tests on her they did MRI scans they did they checked you know let with electroencephalogram or EEG came negative for all all kinds of infections she was negative there was no kind of infections her body

results were absolutely of a of a healthy human she showed no kind of diseases she showed no autoimmune kind of attack she showed no lack of vitamins or anything nothing they ran the works on her nothing and she became more and more debilitated and then she would hear voices she would have psychotic attacks no history of any disease they checked for the rarest of disorders nothing you know Lyme disease this that nothing first they just kept saying oh she's just acting out she may have been taking drugs nothing no they couldn't figure

out and it's interesting this is based on a true life event that they just eventually wanted to say that she had schizophrenia they just want they don't know what to say they just said that honestly we do not know what's wrong with her now you see and she started to act weird and act all kind of like a limb started to kind of and start to lose function and now exactly and to kind of have these fits and exactly like demonic possessions and you know the interesting thing is a Muslim doctor by the name of dr.

Najjar actually eventually was called in to kind of as a favor to kind of diagnose her and he did his research and he felt that and he and he had to kind of do like a brain biopsy and then he figured out that what was actually going on was an anti there was a anti NMDA receptors in the brain she had an anti-nmda receptor

encephalitis that was going on and this like basically these NMDA kind of receptors in the brain they receive they kind of react to things like glutamate and these are the kind of neurotransmitters and they were becoming inflamed the auto immune system was attacking them but it wouldn't show up in any and these kind of receptors are key for things like memory and function and and synaptic plasticity so her brain was literally on fire but it wouldn't pick up the MRI and these

things would not pick it up so tell them she was absolutely normal and they could not figure it out so with the help of this doctor in a job he actually kind of diagnosed this and then went on this is only I think 2015 and since then hundreds of people if not thousands have been helped with this diagnosis so and what's interesting is at the end of this book and this movie they say that many people historically thousands maybe maybe hundreds of thousands have been either diagnosed for demonic possessions or schizophrenia

perhaps wrongly because of not knowing that these receptors you know what kind of inflamed and stuff like this in the brain so what I'm trying to say is just because we don't understand something it's not demons like even and this was this was the greatest some of the greatest doctors and hospitals in America saying that look we don't know what's wrong with her but yet they did figure it out eventually I mean they could have just given up and I actually felt proud that alhamdulillah I was a Muslim who could have just said oh it's

a gym thank God he didn't believe in gym possession and he figured and she was cured they cured her alhamdulillah and she was getting incredibly debilitating but yeah so I thought I'd mention that right people let's go on to some of these right body body Buhari yeah I put out a challenge to some of these

right anybody interested in my detailed Jean video you can watch it it's on YouTube I go through all these cases and it was actually a joint a course that I delivered with Chef Akram net we and it was amazing because like why share that room that we had said look this is all nonsense Jean possession and magic and all this kind of stuff is nonsense so we actually have a joint course on that right now some people have highlighted Chef Akram Louise article now first of all on sale Bihari I like to address this now it's

not chef I couldn't let me I'd like to address but just some of these points I want to mention that I had a while back put out a kind of challenge to the Wahhabi or they call themselves so many defense they are in essence the Wahhabi defense very disrespectful people to the Prophet openly I had shown how they openly portray and teach that our Prophet was sexually impotent and they say this with almost a sense of pride disgusting shocking people but anyway and by the way they are then glorified by the likes of the Hanafy channel which

is run by mashallah our talk amongst them Anthony Gonzalez you know our Mulvey mockery what's his name yes here al Hanafy Gonzalez he is part of that channel and and they obviously if anybody's going to speak against me doesn't matter the people that call our prophet sexually impotent and and stuff like that doesn't matter but as long as they're speaking against mafia beliefs then they have become share whole Islam you know even if a dog box against me that dog would receive share whole Islam

status or momentarily you know as long as it's against me but yes so these people kind of tried to as well these you know these were hobbies and their dirty tactics of basically trying to pit I share Akram net we against me just like Oh share Akram they don't call him chef because by the way they don't respect him a criminally they they call him like because they obviously have nothing but contempt as well for people like that and they're trying to pit him against me as in trying to say well oh

look he's destroying a boule look first of all I don't get drawn into your kind of stupid pathetic medieval politics I have nothing but much love and respect for chef Akram not we to me chef from Ned wasabi is amongst the scene seniority within the UK there I've always said that there are a few people who I would appoint you know as that kind of seniority amongst them shehram that we people like chef bobby Kurisu danny people like even like in

Birmingham chefs as far as Medini saw these kind of people are senior people who have a kind of wisdom to them you know they and I always admire that about them and I see them as my seniority I see them as a very respectful and these artists as well but I'm just just gave some names as examples but and to me it doesn't mean that I have to agree with them you know people like chef see the Iqbal from Birmingham as well and people like this I I see these people as a kind of seniority who I have a great admiration a great love you know and and I would never then you see these people

they could say anything first of all share a common as we did not say anything about me personally but even if he did he wish he didn't because that's not like I mean he's somebody who even when they try to pit him against me in the whole Jesus second coming debate you know amazing person he himself just found me and we had a conversation I mean but still even people like that have the right to say things to me you know they could come and ignore top part like a they could give me a slap or to you and not still not say anything you know these people are out of that kind of expect and seniority that I have for them but it doesn't mean I have to agree

with them and they wouldn't want me to agree with them you know they they wouldn't want me to be a clone or just a kind of like a groupie they wouldn't want that they would want me to you know it's like Cher Huck I'm not doing himself said look put out the research so and and I have the right to test the evidence so this article that people are saying oh it hasn't answered my questions it wasn't the only article by the way there were other responses as well that people had made so my facebook posts

that I made problematizing the authenticity of Buhari was actually a response to multiple articles amongst them what had been highlighted in chef Ackerman arduous post as well so I actually had responded to all of these already but people don't know that they thought that this was actually a response to me my post was actually a response to a collective set of articles amongst them that as well and this is something out of respect you can test the evidence you know they and I've never this is not something I wouldn't be interested in having a personal kind of that thing with again chef a

criminally or whatever because of my love for him but as to my stance on this issue I'll address the stance and I'll address what people have tried to bring up here and that's fine and and look the challenge still remains there and this article and other people have said that look we are going they themselves have admitted we have not dealt with the problems yet but in the future we will release articles that deal with these problems and I look forward to that because I look forward to learning if like I said before I have no personal problem with Sahil Bihari or mihari

mihari have zero problem with I love Imam Bihari but the book today Sahil Bihari I have no problem with it but let's be genuine if we were going to look at any religion would we not question these things then why the double standards why is it there's one set of rules for us and a different set of rules for other people when we look at the Gospels we problematize everything oh but yeah but the Gospel of Mark was seventy years at least after you know it was all not even the seventy really but it was written you know 70 C II approximately give or take now you know

that's still decades after Jesus Christ how do we know who wrote how do we know about the filtering how do we know about where it's being doctored or moved about that we become highly critical when it comes to other faiths yet when it's our own faith we we kind of we have this romanticized view that everything is so brilliant and amazed look let's be legit let's be genuine and I've asked these people to prove the authenticity of style bihari to me that going back to the Imam because look from Imam Buhari

to the Prophet there's been all these works but what people haven't addressed is from Buhari to us and I've highlighted this time and time again that look first of all let's begin with how is a mambo Hadees book transmitted to us so some people have said things like look first of all they've said everybody has known that Imam Bihari had a book I'm not disputing that I'm not disputing that Imam Bihari had a book Imam Bihari had a book called sahih al-bukhari I mean it's a lengthy name for it but let's say let's go with lets

us for now call e ala jami'a sorry the the sahi collection of Imam Bihari now the question is is this that book or has it been has it been kind of changed to some extent are we saying that it is 100% the same book and I think every single person knows in their heart it is not one I think you'd have to if you said that you are either ignorant or you are just you're just lying oh you don't know like either you're

ignorant and don't know the research or if you do know the research you're just kind of giving yourself the last laugh the last idea it's like don't worry you know it's like Alex said that may chant ouch energy haqiqa trollop that I know the reality of generally but then what is it but del cobre la Nika hi al a child but you know it's but it's it's good to kind of keep the to kind of keep some peace in the heart the point is

that look now look let's be like I'm saying let's be genuine here we all will accept that there is some doubt now the question is how far does this margin of error stretch that is the question so I'm going to look at some of these things that people have been sharing so one thing people have said is of course Biharis legitimately comes to us one point to start off with is who does it come through the first source that it comes through and that is mohamed abrini

use of alpha robbery robbery yeah so it can be read Fairbury as well but I I tend to say for a believer whatever therapy yah dff Eureka Muslera hi-hi for a very firm very easy for every is a problem Y is for every a problem you ask me because look one the problem the first problem is that Imam Buhari in his final years became blacklisted as I mentioned he was called a deviant he was called a heretic and he was out casted

by the Muslims he was chucked out of every he was refused access in all the major cities and and he just suffered and then died like that for the last few years of his life now nobody was taking hadith from him in the last few years now the question is that does add an element of complexity because even all the great student Mahad death in students of his like Tirmidhi and Muslim Imam Muslim and all these great Imams of his aid they don't transmit his book they don't transmit it one could say yeah well they had their own book okay but they could have

transmitted his as well you know but no no okay so that's the first so he had several students by the way Mamba Hardy a man Ferrari himself says this is the month robbery by the way some people believe that Imam for I'm calling him Imam he wasn't an imam like that but robbery some people believe for robbery made up the character Bihari I don't believe that and but some people have said things like that they said he made him up and everything just to serve his own kind of thing but I think that's overdoing it but robbery himself says that Imam Bihari had thousands and

thousands and thousands of people taking side Bihari from him he says he had 90,000 loud yell 90,000 people transmitting Bihari and then Ferrari says by the way nobody is alive today still transmitting you except me which is such a black I mean this is that he see that the problem is people who make statements like that how seriously can we take people like that because wait a minute whoa how reliable are you now because if you're saying things like that then we've got a

problem to start off with because that is clearly a statement just to self-aggrandizing your self like it's basically to say you are the master today you're the dawn and that's a problem because now there's a lot of it's become like this ulterior motives involved so okay first problem second problem is Ferrari himself his own students like a voice heart on mousse tamale and other students say that his book part of it was incomplete his own

book was incomplete that his book he says for robbery used to have a book which he claimed was from Buhari like not from a zine he'd heard it from Mahadi now the question is they say for a breeze book was part of it was a Muslim word I was incomplete his own students are saying not only was it incomplete we used to move it around we used to add chapter headings wish to make variations to we the students second problem because look let's be honest some of his key students of

robbery were not scholars of hadith like who you say like abou hate them push me honey one of the key transmitters of Ferrari today was not even he was not even a scholar he didn't even know ready he was criticized by so many people even people who took from him later on regretted taking from him like even one of the great copies that we have today a little how do we you took from three people and patched it together says I used to go back and try to remove what cush may honey had said because he

wasn't an alum of hadith so okay now you've got people making additions and making kind of like editing who are not even clued up on hadith so okay and let's face it human beings make mistakes that is just true especially if you're not an expert so now all of this is going on Ferraris copy is the only copy that really goes out throughout the world and is the only copy that has reached everyone with a connected chain through Samar even even I had your later on says it is the only one that reaches us miss sama that we have heard the

other we might get parts and manuscripts of others which are not through samatha they're not truly connected okay this is a problem now the mother of all problems therapy himself is unvoiced for in hadith nobody's vouched for him like you see you can't be a transmitter of hadith are you even a reliable transmitter and nobody says and look who was alive in his time tell me the man Muslim abu

dawood you've got Nessa you've got okay you might say these people are contemporaries and they're not gonna vouch for him people like Abu Salah Borja tomorrow see what about people junior to him what about Abner ABI Hatim arrazi what about you know if no who's a male what about da rotten e that comes afterwards be happy that comes after what about all these people who speak on reliable transmitters of Hadi why are none of them vouching for robbery none and people say look his own one of

the people who took it hadith from him was a reliable scholar of great like a legend of hadith like even a second Alba's ass who was a great scholar of honey but even he does he vouch for him they say Nessa he took it from for a breed is necessary vouch for him the first person to vote vouch for Ferrari as reliable was 200 years after him I mean come on behave would we accept that for for Christian sources so would we say right would we say that

oh yeah but look it's okay you're asking with them the Gospel of Mark is reliable believe me you know 200 years later or in the in the sea of nice ayah they all declared it to be authentic they said it's authentic would we accept that we will so let's just be honest we've got a problem then we've got a problem that all of these narrations that come from Ferrari they all vary they all vary and there's not just smoke you know this is another thing when we're not being honest see

this is the problem we don't be honest that people say oh they only change the chapter headings that's no big deal yeah it changed the chapter headings first of all you know for years they've been banging on about the whole Buhari feature our Jimmy he called Buhari filter our Jimmy v coffee Mambo hotties in his chapter headings yeah that's gone the rajim took a hey you know they'll limit that's the that's gone out the window so okay so the taraji um that the chapter headings are

now now we all admit that the chapter headings a lot of them were made up ok so put that aside but that's not true let let's be honest many of them disagreeing they're wordings do you have hadeeth missing not even just hadith me thing missing way they have the same ID they have changed that all changed so they've got different names you've got a scholar eighth-century humbly scholar IBN abdul hadi he has a book the variations of the students of robbery in arabic yes there are chapter headings yes there are title headings yes there are small variations

but then there are entire chains that are changed the name here is different the name there is different and they say yeah yeah but we but he made a mistake hmm so there were mistakes say yeah yeah he made a mistake but we're going with that guy's narration but what's to say they never made him what's to say for ever he never made a mistake what's to say could probably not make a mistake robbery was human too he wasn't even vouched for as a reliable scholar of hadith what if he made some mistakes and then when you come down each like

Eleuthera horribly who today we have hundreds of manuscripts based on him Eleuthera how do we does not have a single transmission he does a patchwork you see when you patch things together it's not the same thing like if I say now it's like look like imagine I said like imagine some person said like let's say some person saying you know I saw Mufti I don't know I saw I don't know let's say somebody said I saw Mufti wearing a black coat walking down the

road and now somebody else added in New York and then somebody else added that he looked depressed let's say know somebody like so they're variations of one person said I saw him wearing this coat another person said walking down the road another person said I saw him in New York and other place I'd he looked depressed now when you start patching things together let's say two of them said one thing the two of them happened to mention I was in New York now one person said no actually he was in London now

you might say well you know I'm gonna go with the New York variation and then three of them said he was wearing a black coat and one of them said he was wearing a yellow coat he said well you know I'm gonna go with the black coat see the problem here is and then you're gonna say well you know only one of them said he was depressed another person said he was happy I'm gonna go with he was happy so ice end up with a story of like eyepatch him together that oh he was wearing a black coat happy laughing in New York but the truth is they could have got that wrong because not one of them said it in that way like you just

patched together different things and resulted in a kind of narration it's like the hanafis when they hold their hands in prayer so look there's some hadith that say the Prophet put his hand on his hand there's some hadith that say the Prophet put his hand on his forearm this some hadith that say the Prophet gripped his wrist so what the hanafis do is they say we're gonna patch it together so the hanafis say we're gonna put it on the hand and on the forearm and grip the wrist and play some of the hand on the

forearm like this so this narration that they end up with the hanafi madhhab isn't said by any heavy but it becomes a new opinion so this is this going on as well so a boozer LRO is mixing and then people who come after him every person is changing the text is some extent now you might say well no it isn't but it's in the text like look one of the most relied of one of the most rated right one of the most rated manuscripts is of father Yod share who is damn this at the

time is a body a sufi but a burly a Sufis main student himself changes it against him and then people said well look you Nene or you can call him your name II I say you Nene but that he was commissioned to kind of alter things and then he sits with a grammarian removing grammatical mistakes what's that about so grammatical mistakes were getting me and then we don't have you Nene's copy and somebody made a post saying all mafia boules or sorry call me as in dick this cafe recall me a kafir said this kafir said we don't know who copied it from him and we do the several people

did and one of them was called Shahabuddin an Whaley oh he's a famous scholar I mean what are you even on about so what how do you know no ad was accurate let me tell you about new ad no ad made several copies okay in his lifetime which used to sell for a living he used to sell one copy of side Buhari for a thousand dinars which in his time was the equivalent to almost a year's salary an annual salary of a soldier in his time if you if you check up ladge the the kind of governor at the time who

had set the annual salary wasn't even a thousand dinars and that's what a new ad would sell his Salma Holly for and he made up to eight very popular copies and the fifth famous one the fifth one he did happens to be what we've got today and then because it's the one we've got oh it happens to be also the most authentic one you know I love these coincidences of convenience whatever we happen to have he's always the best one as well so even if he did make these copies so what like how do you know he never made a mistake because you Nene is correcting

the mistakes of the other legends before him he's even correcting grammatical errors and you Nene bases on who he bases it on ignorance arcade on a box he bases on he races also on Coach Mahan even on a shovel we and he can another hammer we and he's correcting mistakes you know so why can't they be mistakes with this one person but anyway and the Sultan ear that is based on they gets further amended at least with a hundred mistakes and more so where are those mistakes coming from so look and some people had said in this they said that

look because sire Bihari became so widespread it must be sound that's not true because look the science of hadith does not allow you to just pick up a book and transmit it that's called WA Giada which other according to many ala ma like called the yard said that it's impermissible many ala ma said even if you accept it you're not allowed to teach by it it's the weakest form of transmission if you are accepting Sahil Bihari just because of you Giada which other is barely acceptable it has to come through

authorization now the problem is how do you know it was authorized because it comes through these manuscripts and the manuscripts have problems so the fact that it was very well known that's like saying the Gospels were well known why don't you accept the Gospels they were very well known and people will say yeah but you know the Muslim scholars but that's being biased now like you you have a different yardstick for us just because they're Muslim but the truth is that the scholars would have also used certain things for their own power so they did

have a vested interest so you can't say they were absolutely objective because hadith did also bring power to scholars because they could you manipulate certain Hadees they could use this being fabricated hadith by many scholars fabricated hadith let's just be honest listen you know let's not lie great scholars scholars while of said a ways one of the shifts of you know of you know the great scholar of the nephew of Imam Malik but he is one of the teachers of Imam Bihari he himself says I used to fabricate hadith to support the school of Medina he used to say I used to

fabricate make him up from scratch this is the gray skull is made of hadith look let's let's be honest like you telling me these hadith even the hadith to subdue women you think that these didn't serve a great interest for men of course they did they served a powerful interest you telling me that hadith about the caliphs didn't serve an interest for the caliphs of course they did so it's interesting they're happy speaks of certain caliphs of the time who come in hadith books and he said and Rahab he says not a single scholar dare to declare these Calif and rulers weak

because if they did they would have got in trouble so this is my point that let's just be honest I've answered that yes we do accept hadith we will accept but really the Sunnah we make a distinction between hadith and Sunanda Sunnah is already preserved and the books of hadith we take them but they have to meet up to the three conditions that they can't go against reason they can't go against what is it the established sources like the Quran and they can't approve a or the Sunna that has come to through other sources as well like the living traditional fit and they can't uproot an Islamic principle cool so I

hope that's of some help and so really there was nothing I do look forward to maybe people will say and people that say that even you know even taymiyah said even if Bo Hadi didn't exist the Dean wouldn't have I agree even if you ha didn't exist the Dean would be complete but first of all agree with me then that Buhari needs to kind of come down from this elevated status of becoming a god and that's the book Buhari and then yes we can talk bring these are the chains then then let each hadith be measured upon its independent chain and then we will see it's a mmm

it's based on its own merit and then we can weigh them up and when they say we have all these other Mustafa Raja these books written where are these books which books are you talking about and they have problems as well and you know that so ok I hope that's of some help guys whoa let's write so our people who are supporting Sahil Bihari wrong in their age sorry in their in their articles it's not that they're wrong but I feel that they haven't answered the questions not nobody has answered these questions yet people are saying they

will answer the questions later on I look forward to that I look forward to learning as well if you can enlighten me and hamdulillah this good but right now all I'm seeing is you want double standards you want us to to say that you know no no no you know because they Muslim we should give them a green card but because these people are non-muslim we should be very critical so I'm just being objective that's all and as I said as Imam Malik tortoise let's have that standard that Imam Malik taught us the hadith yes we accept and reject hadith then we wouldn't have the problems that we have today right so right let's go on

to write so I've had once again Absalon andalusi right abdullah andalusi has tried to refute me again right of you that don't know this person he's a convert I don't know what his actual name is but Abdullah fair enough we go with Abdul others fine I have no problem Abdullah andalusi andalusi is using because of his mother his heritage his European heritage and the loosest to do with the kind of al-andalus the Spain Iberian Peninsula and it's because he's

from Portugal his mother's from Portugal and he likes to kind of present that and boast that kind of heritage so Abdullah under the sea has tried to say well Mufti Abu layth right you know oh and Imam has earlier and basically what this our brother Abdullah who wants to do is basically establish the Caliphate you know tell me something what is it with these Europeans man what is it with this

white Savior complex you know they want to save the brown people are you Abdullah Andalusia hiya Portuguese you were too easy you must go to gamma Vasco de Gama those of you that don't know Vasco da Gama you see many years many centuries before our brother Abdullah one of his ancestors ancestral ancestors called Vasco da Gama

he also came to our land of the brown people they came to India and shortly after him came the Portuguese Empire and they did the usual you know the the killing the the torturing the raping the pillaging they did the usual in Kerala and go on the Muslims nearly but anyway centuries later now mashallah now first it was in the name of the Portuguese Empire now the offspring has come mashallah he's embraced Islam and he's come to bring the the Khilafah to

us all that's gonna come on buster that sounds about white to me I of white privilege I've gotta give it to these like converts man no sooner do they embrace Islam but they want to go and save the entire Muslim world huh they want to bring to us who've had Islam for generations that they want to bring to us

lava Oh God honestly you couldn't make this stuff up this is what they want to do these people have they you know do they first of all do they understand Arabic no no no have they ever read the Quran in their entire life with its actual meaning no no no no no have they ever understood any hadith or so now or anything in its actual meaning no no no no have they ever studied fifth I could ask these people certain questions on they pray and I guarantee you they

wouldn't know the answers on they pray what they're supposed to pray every day no no no they don't know the answer do they know about fast no it's a cat Hajj no no no but what do they where do they want to begin Oh white saviors yes sir [Laughter] you know Mahadeva Sharon in Harlem a lagoon curry this is not like this is what an angel yeah leave us people in peace man they want it they start off they want to start by saying first of

all we want to bring the Khilafah to you a cha cha cha very committee io Vasco da Gama [Laughter] [Music] bienvenido and wastrel conquistador this is our conquistador our knight in shining our white knight in shining armor you see this is the issue and I don't mean this against by the way against of the Congress I look there's many people who do amazing work they convert to Islam the surprises wow that

they embrace this theme and legends like Sheikh Hamza Yusuf shares no Haim Keller share Abdul Hakim Murad amazing people turn you know thinks sure I mean this was specifically I was because I was giving white examples I mean there's are obviously many any convert from any race but I'm just here saying and they they go they study the Deen they commit themselves to learning they inspire people Wow and this other you know I've got many Facebook friends and people converting who holding great war and you know many of them online here probably I've seen

Deborah's on their Robin is using amazing human beings you know people who you know I think like this is what people should be like you know if they convert to Islam but then you get these others you know you know you know it's like the person asked what is the Abu Sufyan when he wanted to know about the Prophet he said did he have in his aunt's ancestors anybody who was a king who was power-hungry and Abu sofyan said no and he said okay fair enough because I would have said that they just wanted to return to the legacy of the ancestors

and here we have our Portuguese Vasco de Gama I of the la vie de la vie he's come here to establish you come who's come here to establish the Khilafah and to bring us a white Haley a la ja ja ja ha ha Mia more go established the Khilafah forest please and this is the kind of nonsense we have to deal with honestly these people haven't lived

a day in in the Muslim world I'm serious and they want to establish for us the brown people a Caliphate system they haven't lived amongst Muslims or Dalit gathering in CODIS these guys will they'll eat them alive in a single day Abdullah go by go visit Pakistan spend the day there or in the Middle East you realize that you know this all better still go establish the Caliphate just go

establish it just go khulus to this white and bright Caliphate once it's established hum be there Kenya had all these people they want to help us so bad huh Allah how about giving back what your ancestors spoke ah sorry well your ancestors told you no Imran Khan has has asked the British government to return what they looted whilst they were in India well you get all these people have wanting to help Vasco de Gama Queen

Victoria Donald Trump of the la vie you know this a poet he says her more familiar to him that has our own not on every corner I bump into somebody who wants to help me shall I add Mary busty my other car bought now this is maybe there's a lot of people who know drama who know how to act where I live this is the the problem we have today and why

you see because he is white so he becomes the face and many deluded Muslims obviously we have that white Savior inferiority complex so we think oh yes all subhanAllah mashallah this white brother this this brother Vasco de Gama he's going to recapture the Caliphate for us I mean yes Salaam and this is what really this HT in this this is just a weight this is why I'm against our seriously this is

why I'm against Dawa because this is what it causes it brings these kind of attention craving nut cases to Islam who is then come and they become deluded with these groups like Hezbollah hurried and these people who by do you know what these people believe by the way let me tell you what they believe they believe that all co-firing this on this earth are not only nudges are impure and have been created to be subdued and ruled over by muslims they believe that the whole world today is living in Kufa in

this belief including muslims they believe that the whole world is split in two Darryl help and Darryl Islam that the land of war and today the entire world is dar al-harb land of war this is what they teach and believe now tell me if that's if we are living in that'll harm then we are only a step away from declaring the people here as enemy combatants were only a step away because if we're living in the land of war then hey these cough are these impure who ought to be subdued

cough are really are just enemy combatants that's a step away and they and then what's the next step then this is what they teach in the name of Islam Islam is all about powering and having a sort of bond and forcing Islam and then they can pay us jizya and this G Zia thing is messed up and mixed up and out inshallah in the future maybe next week do a whole session on jizya to clarify that this is what they're teaching ask them this is a virus man it is breeding hatred why do you hate the kuffar why they go we don't hate the ku far but

they have to say that now you see so if you ask these kind of our Vasco de Gama these things they all do we don't hate the kuffar oh but we just design but largest wants us to rule them a br who's us you Portuguese you wanna rule the 1.8 billion Muslims of the world and they can say no no no I just want to set up the Caliphate power-hungry nothing but you know Oh what is it what we wanna really what do you want to do

when you rule what is this rule money is that what you want power women what it what is it sex slaves is that what you want what do you want rule rule rule and then they shove it back all on Allah and His Messenger and they say this is what Allah wanted this is what is messenger one we every single hadith about the Shelia I'm telling you is fabricated the Prophet in the times of the Arabs they never even used to use this word this notion of khilafat didn't exist how could the Prophet be talking about a notion that doesn't exist how could that's like the Prophet speaking about democracy or speaking

about a particular rule that doesn't exist yet and everybody understands him surely they would be asking way to me what do you what do you mean by that the notion he laughs I was brought into existence after the prophet's lifetime the Sahaba said to a book about karate allahu and i know what why don't we name you hey leave her to rasool allah the halifa of the messenger because you've come after him they ought to know this if this notion existed this is all these hadees were made up i'm telling you this the twelve qualify for money Omega this is a made of Hadees for the rulers of

money on a year this F come on is common sense everybody can tell they made that up these are fabricated heavy this is just to kind of validate the rule and stuff like that I mean look does it make any sense that the Prophet spoke about something that did not exist isn't these are conveniences these are coincidences of convenience oh if there's two rulers kill the latter they're very convenient hadith isn't it for a ruler so this is very convenient isn't it oh I'm the ruler you're the ruler too well I'm gonna kill you why because oh

there's a hadith oh but my there is a convenient Haditha that I must kill you Wow you're telling me the Sahaba do know that when they started saying who should be the ruler they said well you should have a ruler between from the Ansar and a ruler between them from the muhajireen they were they were dumb and stupid they didn't know all year but the hadith said you should if this - you should kill one the Sahaba never knew that the Companions never knew that but oh but you know so this is what I mean and then Imam he says o Imam al-ghazali Imam Ali wrote in his book Imam Ghazali epic I

mama has a liras a Leela hey we can easily Rosati kinnda ha ha what's going on here you know what are you on about your mama said you don't follow Imam al-ghazali in anything you don't follow Imam you don't follow him in v you don't follow him and after you that you don't follow him in O soul you don't follow him in anything have you ever redismo sus pies where Jesus was seed what do you follow him in you don't follow him as I need anything and then Oh buddy wrote a book to the ruler of his time the ruler of his time - food a petty little area in the Middle

East in Baghdad around but that Eden and this was like every scholar just wrote something to suck up to the king of the time all the scholars did it it's nothing new you know it didn't become the Word of God Oh mom was early mammal has early mammal as early they don't follow her sadly on anything yes this is the irony they don't follow Imam Ghazali on anything do you follow him on a Sood is that where you take your soul from the following minifig how he told you to practice the Dean do you follow him in tasawwuf is that what you do do you follow what do you follow her sad Ian nothing oh I follow him in he said they must be

a Caliphate look he said to the king of his time there were multiple caliphates in his time he's you see when those people in the past wrote about rule when what they meant was as opposed to what as opposed to anarchy Khilafah simply meant Kings the Kings used to call themselves qualify especially one of the bus they schooled himself full of fur now they make Kings dynasts as opposed to anarchy dynasts as opposed to barbarism they didn't mean Kings as

opposed to democracy they didn't have an alternative this wasn't something they were you see when you say oh how come a man was early never own democracy well because they didn't have a system of democracy so he wasn't then he was only comparing it to his discourse his discourse was lands with his havoc and there's no ruler and the civil war between lands where there's a king so obviously it must be a king because with a king there is a rule sorry there is the rule of law in fact in his etiquette book he actually goes on to say if you

could read our record a me he goes on to say why there should be a king he says because with the king he says that we can have count we can have laws we can have who cook if people are pressed we can take back rights because there is law and order law and order that's what they wanted they just want to live a normal life a man has early in the last decade of his life Jerusalem was conquered by the Crusaders he lived in sham that is the region of Jerusalem did Imam Ghazali ever participate in that battle no did he even call people to reconquer from the Crusaders no he totally just left

even wouldn't want anything to do with this he went back to birth dad in the start to teach again he wrote his book on a surah v he could have been writing at a rally to let's do jihad others some of the scholars did did he mama Sally no Canizales Ali this is what happens when we get you know illiterate islamically illiterate J he'll kind of like converts it will come to Islam and they want to teach us Islam never read a single surah in their life with understanding of the

Quran this is it they come and they want to start from the pulpit you want to start by establishing the caliphate huh sounds about white are your hashtag white privilege listen this is the thing and this is a 90 coats on Mufti herbal late said about was Ali and oboes Ali said in his book right somebody said please don't call him a jack he's a jar hildo what does he know about I've said to him does he know anything about Islam I are you even a scholar of Islam look at least be a

scholar of Islam dedicate some of your goddamn life to learning the Book of Allah can you can you do that much before you save all of us brown people on this globe which are so dying to do as a savior can you at least take a bit of time to learn what a lie saying in the Quran oh I can't do that god forbid why would I want to learn Arabic why would I want to study the Quran why would I want to do this Oh was

it hmm I know let's just establish he laughs are Khilafah go okay go establish it if you want to establish it that bad go why don't you go to Portugal a la maza sugar star from Portugal you know like oh I'll tell you what we do you want to go rock

are we you're the simple sympathizes like Abu Bakr al-baghdadi and other people are which way do you want to start go establishing go establish it once it's established let us know yeah this is why they mislead several you know vulnerable Muslims and this is why it's this is why I say to people look if you know people you're youngsters and they if they start listening to or getting influenced by hate think groups like his patottie who were a cancer honestly just try to steer them away from that kind of nonsense day you know

sure if you want people who've converted then true scholars who've converted like che comes they use of amazing scholar you know people che comes a Yusuf has a lecture on this by the way go to share comes the use of YouTube here's a lecture on the Caliphate these days this is just a Muslim myth is a fantasy there is no obligation these are the words of fear hums Yousuf that's a true you know somebody who at least dedicated his life to studying Islam right not just a convert face that you know because I've got the right what is it the lack of

melanin or what if I have the right to our melanin deprived brothers brother they have the right to kind of tell us how to establish the salaah so anyway so those are my words to to me carry me Oh hahaha to my beloved ah un besito de la vie so is that okay in this oh no is that no you don't you don't understand that all nothing will

stop puppy uh I see little star you like it like that but that's what I'll say look this people be weary of these kind of claims I joke and laugh about this but there are many people you've spent lifetimes getting misguided by these kind of people right so I would advise that look anybody at least if they want to speak about ideas within Islam then the least is let them be a scholar then they can be wrong still they can still be wrong they can still be wrong but at least then they have

some substance to what they saying okay right so I've mentioned that these hadith that I've been commanded to fight etc are all problematic I've mentioned this before [Music] why doesn't HT join Isis I totally agree HT ought to go and join Isis because HT are like the the diplomatic version of Isis they like the you know like the in like you have like a group and then you have like a political wing they say oh

no we're not we're not for violence we're not for violent and yet their own if they're given a chance though anyway people as always it's awesome right HT is his daddy but I don't want to really go on about just them but my point is anybody who has that cancerous ideology of wanting to rule the world has a problem okay Salam from Kansas City Missouri awright awright awright people

I'm gonna leave you with it I hope I've answered some of these questions I do reach out to me on Facebook like my page both pages don't worry about it mine don't be you know the art of giving people like you know like what this tight-fisted people nowadays are like yeah I can't I can't like a page he's gonna anyway so like share if you if you have any questions feel free to reach out to me on Facebook or on snapchat Malm 2014 ma LM 2 0 1 4 that's musty stands for musty

Abu layth al Maliki okay all those people look at that from Oldham opinions on Shia I've spoken about the Shia before I think they are our brethren in faith nothing but love for each and all we need to build bridges between us have you had a conversation over social media with dr. Jonathan Brown he's right so okay I hope I've answered that guy's take very good care of yourselves in Charlotte till next week as always stay awesome stay blessed over and out folks and I'm a deacon what I've mental lighter I know but a cattle