Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 82

see now we is live people bees live off one little all right down down up down let us let me share this out there just

sharing this right yes but I'm man-whore right there is right all right people click that share button get this out there people Wow why is this phone going slow now is this some kind of a rise almost done almost

done people are rah I'm just sharing this one moment come on cap damn it see this is the the frustration of our age when we when the phones don't respond yeah come on he may get some if I was alive I'd be running a different

commentary here now oh come on just taking the meek now oh yes um that's better that's better that's better come on come on come on haven't got all day here

well that's probably like the longest has ever taken me to hopefully that's done right so how are you all doing people how are you all doing in al hamdulillah wa kafa vas salatu salam o allah rasool mustafa wanna ideality notable Oh mommy who Dahomey tada Bobby sorry Almudena Tabitha whoa bad

for Salaam Allah he ll own anima sonim become marhaban running lights bienvenidos a todos para rally and people saw items for Gotham right Sunni defense yes I will be coming to them to our good friend a little later on a little later on let's begin first of all begin with on a positive note not by not beginning with Wahhabi haters and

blasphemers these people we come to afterwards we need to first of all begin with the love what's going now people what wow so much has been going on let me just take a sip that's what I'm talking about people

ice chilled cold heat whoa Barney seppius Naboo G though mija Nikita of channela I was saying actually the other day I'd asked somebody to write that out for me in a calligraphy kind of style in in urdu Barney seppius Nabu G that my thirst wasn't quenched with water from a Chanukah tariff Jelinek Allah so I set

off towards the wine house the pub so ask somebody to write that out for me in a kind of calligraphy style if they could and they wrote back in or do they wrote Barney seppius Nabu ji don't make Connie Connie ki taraf tell me class [Laughter] like I set off to eat instead what's coming down people what are we looking at so much has been going on I want to take some of the Q question z' that have

been submitted as well because people say they say yeah you asked us to submit questions and you never answer them that too is a stylish tale no I want to answer some of them so you know this school permit discúlpame right so my apologies right so what else well this weekend we've had chakra midweek that's something I'd like to kind of mention give a quick summary of how that went down some of the key points to transfer

some of those gems to you people also some of the hype around that we'll discuss that as well and I saw today disappointed I had to shall we begin with this I saw this post wait I made a Facebook post on it actually somebody shared me shed with me a kind of status of somebody I don't know who used but as it transpires obviously turned out to be [Laughter] [Music]

right so it turns out to be some somebody having a go on Facebook I don't from the UK by the name of Faro clipping a pacer or something must be some fake name anyway regardless and regardless and somebody shared this with me and I had a read of it and it said it was this person having a rant about football now I myself do not watch football right I don't watch for I just don't see any

interest for some reason I just can't get interested in sport but that aside so this person's kind of having a Goa England living in England having a Goa England yeah what is this huh art if now are to do so let's let's take a look at far ok sir I love the open you know the fake Arabs you know this one I'm the eben [Laughter] right so forgive

my crudité rather but anyone who says football is just a sport devoid of meaning is either a liar or a a yes a it is clearly an indirect expression of an underlying reverence right instinct suppress by secular ideas right so so that's what it is anybody who's into football really they just brainwashed with the love of this world and that living condition

that unites people on primitive bonds only to politically distract them from their miserable lives tainted by the ideological flaws in capitalism let's let's go on to add any Muslim to add oh one must add quite prudently at this point hey any Muslims who support England any Muslims who support England whether as a

joke or in seriousness ought to seriously reevaluate what it means to do so to align oneself with their enemy is to betray the very cause our people work for our people who which people last time I checked Oh what Karol Bagh dad he wasn't our people right so I don't know which one this fake Arab is referring to

as our people Your Honor I do not know [Laughter] right so insofar as it is a nation whose record is scarred with our blood and demise if anything check this out we pray England reaches the final and loses so it's a weaken cow so it's weak and cowardly people feel a greater sense of inadequacy twisting the blade in their

declining state war on earth is this guy on about what on earth is this idiot on about [Laughter] this guy I the only thing best-case scenario is that this guy is he's kind of sectioned and he's under to is undertaking psychiatric treatment that's the best-case scenario here that this is somebody who's mentally unstable but he managed to find his way to Facebook and

make a post worst case scenario ba-ba-ba-ba we have the extremists on our hand you know the fake Arab the these kind of people stay well away from them stay well away from these people a cancer a cancer in the heart of the unmanned especially people in the West look.we weather look I don't even watch football I don't even watch football but

of course my England win why not it's where you live you ought to love your land you ought to be kind of proud you ought to be even if it means little to you the sport even if you're not into the sport but still unless you I mean I'm not saying you have to you can support another group you can support another team there's nothing wrong with that but to have an inherent hatred against the very land you live in yes these people what are they doing here my simple message to them is first of all

stop those benefits stop can they stop claiming all of these we are becchi all of them claiming benefits aiming benefits is scum I'm gonna sound like some of these right-wing fascists now but it's I bet you that claiming benefits yeah and then going on Oh or enemy our enemy our enemy quit hon

tani general right yeah is this your dad whoever you are obviously must have come to this country for work so behave this is the kind of stuff that triggers hatred racism the triggers are divided a dangerous divine and a poison in the name of Islam it triggers Islamophobia so I saw that and I was disgusted honestly I thought that why don't you just get lost pack your bags and go ja ja Simran jaha

G left knee zindagi jaw go go to the land of milk and honey where and where is that by the way Pakistan they'll be like no I'm Sonia well don't worry they'll have you baptized I bet my brother here hasn't even spent a week in Pakistan if he does

he'll come back crying good he thinks he's seen he thinks he's seen life difficult he thinks he's seen people corrupt don't worry anyway I thought I'll stop christened and bless today's gathering with that rant out the way so what else are we looking at of course look you should ought to have a love for where you live we need to now teach people teach our youngsters to love their country we ought to do this and this is from your loyalty to this Deen that Islam is for

everywhere the whole world and you know this this is so interesting share Akram that we in this yesterday he did a sahih bukhari darts and amazing does just touching up on some of the gems that he gave from in that ders he mentioned amongst the yep chef Akram not we a doctor a criminal to me as well yes so he one of the things he mentioned was this he said he said that look Muslims in this country they always go on about protests

about other parts of the world Palestine Iraq Syria always and yet they won't even know about the let's say non-muslim neighbors and their suffering he said that Muslims never come out hardly you ever see them about protest to do with this country so his point was that look how do you think the non-muslims feel they feel that Muslims are just very incredibly sectarian these were his words that they don't see England or the UK as these they're out

in arms whenever something in Iraq is happening Iraq which which is fine it's not that that's a wrong concern but the point is that it's always foreign it's never about home that they never come out kind of saying well what about the issues going on here they don't even want to know and you get on the contrary idiots like this saying oh these are the enemy the enemy honestly I don't even know how this country allows these HT

org I tell you government conspiracy how the government allows them to exist but not just them people like them as well this this disease but what occurred amid we were saying was that look why is it that Muslims are not they need to be more concerned about what's happening here like brixi Muslims all right fine Muslims Ark some Muslims are concerned but they're not open arms for example let's say the politics going on here they're not open arms Boris Johnson designing what's the house of card play

going on what is going on what's what are the tech Muslims are like like they act like this ain't our home but they want to speak about only what's going on in Iraq or in Syria or in Palestine only and that is wrong so they ought to speak more so about here as well and then there's no harm then you can speak about anyway you can speak about Yemen Palestine Syria wherever you want but be from where you are you were born here for God's sake

you've lived here all your life so stop acting like an immigrant so that's some some point somebody has just come on and say she's gone laughs right right so from buddy said this Salam from the Rochdale crew huh Rochdale salams just ROG tails got a bad name recently so just in case I give

this Salaam and it gets to the wrong wrong gang and they say mashallah Northy ablates giving us Salam all right people so what else with some gems gold I've on said gassing I'm only kidding no no offense no offense of course with much love for everybody right whatever city they're from and Allah Akbar from the UAE allah wa salamu marhaban become marhaban become Shafiq kabali has just

tuned in to say you ant imagine noon yeah he was he look a ticket etiquette he's not only am i mental but he finished it off by saying brother he you must have thought that because we're somehow I don't know maybe he thought I'm like a brother and this is hereditary because the vichara must be mental as well so he's thinking oh my brother therefore you must have also inherited this what water concerned this Omaha's hi oh hi oh yeah ha ha

[Laughter] anyway let's let's move on to yes I was saying some of the socio-economic net we had an awesome kind of thoughts from sahih al-bukhari and it was really fascinating to sit in you know why because it's good to sometimes just sit and and learn from somebody else let's see what they gotta say and you know it's it's good sometimes relaxing slightly you know relaxing so amazing this a lot of it was heavily concentrating on us I need on the chains

of narrator's going into the Estella the criticism Bihari Muslim who they rely on who are some of the problem problematic narrators once again the two the two that are problematic elaboration Qatada oh the same two who transmit the hadith just to find marital rape those which the Wahhabi defense are trying to justify and I'll come back to that chef Vikram said the same thing that these two narrators are problematic but generally others less so really into a

lot of Kalam a lot of discussion on Rijal on the narrator's some fascinating points I found that amazing seriously another interesting thing was that I I discussed with chef Akram that we as well this whole understanding of can we today prove sahi Bihari to go to be traced back to its author Imam bara alleged author Imam Bihari fascinating discussion and and I have to say and this is from the amazing kind of transparency of chef Akram that we he said that this is

indeed a fascinating challenge he said that this is a challenge and it would require a lot of research he definitely agreed that it is a substantial problem that it's not a superficial matter he agreed with that I don't know if he he obviously you see what is the outcome of saying something like this my outcome of saying something like this I think maybe he may agree with that my outcome is that this means we ought to take whatever we read from Buhari stuff like

this movie the group you know with a pinch of salt and we can take it we can practice it as long as these three factors it doesn't go against reason it doesn't clash with the major sources like the Quran and established soon-im 3/5 and it doesn't approach an Islamic principle so I think he would agree that part I didn't really ask him what I did do was have a long discussion on can we prove this can we confidently say because the question is this folks imagine we're not talking about Islam

for a moment imagine we weren't speaking about Islam imagine we have speaking about Christianity or something else in that case we would be very critical of these things we would not we would say wait a minute us so for example the oldest copy of Bihari that we have his complete at is complete is at least 200 years after the Imam that's an issue the the only real transmitter of Bihari that we have his student Ferrari Mohammed apne Youssef el Ferrari the problem with

him is nobody from the science of hadith in his time seems to recognize him his first recognition on what I mean by recognition is just that he's okay in hadith nobody certifies him or vouches for him till at least 200 years after him so that's so many generate so people in his time never validate him so and he's the only transmitter and that's only part of the problem so I go on and obviously in a forum that we agree that these are substantially these are true problems

and issues that need to be kind of looked into but that was amazing other than that there was we discussed I tried to livestream certain section last Monday session you started the miracle behind slaughter of ibraheem alehissalaam but did not complete it okay I'll come to that in a moment right those of you just tuning in if you click like click share and get this out there

folks another interesting point I'm not likely to focus on this I did I discussed this during the dust off show her come as we with him I asked him as a question the 12 Imams hadith this is an interesting hadith because I've seen this being thrown around by a lot of people by the Sunni and the Shia so the Shia I think kind of leaned in on it to validate their 12 Imams and the Sunnis it since I Hadi that there will be 12 Khalifa from Koresh now I asked Sharon

Edwin I said that look on the topic of doctored hadith hadith there have been fabricated as an example I said how about the topic of Halawa because Halawa people is a notion it is an a concept that did not exist in the time of the Prophet or in Arabia before the Prophet so the Arabs never used to use words like Khalifa like they had the Arabic word Khalifa but it didn't mean what halifa means today so for example the

Arabs would have had like let's say they would have had a the notion of Hajj we'd like they know how to pronounce latest sorry they would have nearly that letters need pronunciation but the notion of the science of tad we'd hadn't existed even though that we'd is an Arabic word so just like each the heart is another example the prophet uses the term it's the heart in a hadith as in register had al-haqq him but generally the Arabs weren't using this word the way we today as Muslims use the word each the heart so we don't say like the Prophet or the Sahaba won't say

hey today I did it's the heart for example this like if you use the wordage they had in front of them if they had meant its linguistic understanding about effort exerting effort so they would probably get the gist of what you're saying or they might ask you what do you mean by that so the interesting point is that Halawa the Arabs never used to refer to their rulers as Khalifa's in fact mostly speaking they didn't have Kings either some of them did I know the famous molecular moons their molecular Arab and they were some buddy hanger in the tribe of hem ER and other places

there were some kings but generally speaking they were Baba L there were tribes they had their own kind of no Kaaba there is the Assad they had amides they had this concept of an Emir of Wally's things like this and Malik kings and stuff like but they never had this notion of Halawa so this doesn't emerge till after the Prophet so how could the Prophet have been speaking to them about notions that weren't yet in existence like how could the Prophet be saying to the people that all rightful all right

guys there's going to be a hill afar then the Halawa is gonna go away then they'll be kingship and the Khilafah will come back and hence at Madurai Sunni share happen very soon you can never consider this hadith bite but other as an example other Hadees like this hadith in Bihari there will be 12 whole afar surely that what does that mean kula far like what are we talking about people who come after in what because the Arabs never at the time had this notion so this shows that this hadith is most likely doctored and made up most likely perhaps during the reign of Bani kumea

and up to I would assume probably the 12th hail if halifa or the Caliph most likely in his time this would have been doctored because this is what is just a fine because how could the prophet be addressing them with notions and terminology that are not even in existence yet one way out of this is you could say that this was done reliable manner as in the Prophet never said in it like that but he maybe said something like with this kind of meaning and they

retrospectively changed the words to fit that that's probably the best case scenario in which case if the words have been changed perhaps the meaning has been altered - that's the best kind of angle that people could hold on to but in generally speaking this appears to have been doctored because it doesn't make sense because even after the Prophet has passed away oh but when they say to a worker what should we call you we I know why don't we call you halifa - Rasul Allah the person who came after the US

after Rasul Allah The Messenger of Allah but there you to know this anyway they ought to know because the prophets been mentioning halifa khalifa' khalifa' khalifa' all these times so they ought to know that there's a concept called a khalifa and a calif and he laughs at you now the hey leaf why would they and when they were arguing to say how should we have the leadership why were they not using this word when they were saying I know why don't you have an immediate imagining and an Amir from being saw why weren't they saying you have a kale if we have a Calif - all of these things are

all right so I'm not sure what these questions and so that was an interesting point I presented that to share her candid we he said that that he I mean he said that I yes it's unquestionable that hadith were definitely transmitted by meaning and he said but this is also an interesting question about when the notion didn't exist how could have they been a hadith and he said that is a good question and it would require research

right okay next question after US has asked a very good question the question miss empty my people right it's a very good question that if we're going to say that these hadith books have some doubt in the way they've been established are we not putting the Quran into doubt right okay so that's a very good question and we

actually discussed this yesterday as well with Chef Akram that we and I said that it's really important that Muslims stop fabricating our past right they Muslims need to stop fabricating our history and trying to reverse engineer it right they are doing a disservice the Quran was not established in the same way that hadith is not was collected anybody who says this has no idea and they are lying they are either lying or

they are ignorant of how the Quran was transmitted the Quran has never been transmitted through it's not this is a lie that these people are saying this is the biggest Muslims became over the centuries so influenced through the lens of the Maha theme they started to see everything the way the Mohideen saw things that is a lie the Quran was not transmitted through it's not where are these you know this is not that we use a chain to transmit something this emerged out between a hundred to a hundred and twenty years

after the Prophet this is not how the Quran was transmitted the Quran was just taught so I so for example I know the Quran I'm gonna teach it to my children I'm gonna learn me the Muslims just taught the Quran on mass transmission they just everybody it was their goal to just fall with the Quran so they would teach it to their children teach it to their family teach it to the their wives sons daughters friends and everybody was just transmitting it like this the lost my brother Allah one he made a if we can

call like a master copy a master print of the Quran which is known as the must half of us man or the Russman earth mani he wrote it out like this and he sent it out several of these copies into the key capitals of the Muslim world and everybody was to just make a copy from them and they were to teach now it didn't have dots and things like that the way it does today hence the ways to read it could vary so people could read it with slight for example there's a verb you could read it

as I'm just saying as an example like let's say it said something like I don't know let's say said yalom or talam like i'm just saying as an example or it said something like from these that's like let's say said ya lamu a limb your limb these are variations of how something could be read but generally speaking the context always made it clear now on some things they disagreed because how do you read it as long as it made sense to them they just read it and that is the truth

the Quran you know when people say we've got these gira arts and these Kira automotive ah tiara and these kilowatt we've got these variations these seven and ten this people have just come up with this this was just the way these people ready these Quadra these rest are people of recitation just read the Quran in a particular way it made sense to them and they've really it wasn't this is why we have to stop this way that people are do you know with the problem came the problem came when Muslims in our recent century in the 20th century started to

come up with ridiculous claims like they started to say things like you know the Quran if one vowel has changed then it's not the Quran like every vowel has always been the same now they should never have made claims like this because these claims then make us look stupid because first of all its faults vowels of the Quran have been within different readings however people read them if it made sense if it fit if it applied to the wrestle osmani then it was okay and you could read the Quran like that otherwise you're gonna say people like

look you've got this is my I'm getting interrupted now by Zarate Zara up ya Salam okay and then pick John up when he go okay okay assalamualaikum i'm john vamp it

ticketed the rosamund the resident guru Joe Joe Joe right so right so coming back to this thing that look if it like let's say you take one of the reciters like Natha now now if it wash right is taking from him our lawn is taking from him two people are taking from the same even with whether it's gonna be awesome or all these key people you have other transmitters taking the recitation from him and it's different so what is different from Carlo how are they taking from the same person the Heder and it's

different so we are making a PC so the thing was this that's because it just made sense to the reading now this asserted the Quran in its early stage the way it was revealed had certain flexibility in how it could be read now hence you find some of the a hadith in how the Arab said some things how that flexibility was just locked in and transmitted through the response money of man Rowdy along on made a master script of

the Quran which in with the Companions present I mean the Quran was first compiled in the time of over Kuroda lon then you know last man's time he made a master print he made several of them and sent them to the key I think maybe seven sent them to the key capitals of the Muslim world and asked them to be copied from and taught on mass like just he teach them now the way you read them right could vary because people certain words could be so it's like saying how people have I mean this is a really poor

way of poor analogy but as an example let's just say the way we have certain accents that vary in English now now some people may read certain things differently they may like whether a word is read like I don't know like like let's say secretary or secretary or library library now these words would sound different but as an example that's a poor analogy or let's say and the way we have words written like American English British English we write color

we owe you our color ello you are and they write it just all are now if somebody was writing this both would still be right now like this the meaning that was that could be read from this transcript was okay because this is what the Quran was transmitted as and it had that kind of some fluidity and this is what it was the problem Muslims never had a problem with this what happened is along came some reciters later on so these recitals these qira'at became popular people

started taking from them that's fine they started to say look here's a better way of reading and people took it hamdulillah is nothing wrong with that but to think that Quran was transmitted through these people only is a lie it was never transmitted through just a seam and through these people now fear and so on that's not the case at all and then to say that these people this is the motivator and this is this and this is this people have just come up with this over the time and over the ages and then in the last century we've had

people making claims like if one vowel of the Quran has never been changed now don't say stuff like that because that's wrong it has been moved up and down because it was allowed to but when you make that claim then it just takes a few ex-muslims a few atheists a few Islamophobes to come along and to say well hmm well you know you say no vowel has change and here the entire word has changed here the meaning has changed look in this recitation you're reading it very differently in this one you reading it differently so it has changed

so D and then Muslims are like but but but but but but but the meaning the meaning does change in several words certainly certainly it does and can have subtle variations but that was the nature of the Quranic kated for that it was never this constricted rigid kind of thing that we think it is today we think the Quran today is this locked in thing it was a even its meaning was to open up for new generations in different ways that was the kind of if I can use the word miraculous nature of the Quran but

people today like we've got locked into this thing of oh this is the must-have find me where one vowel is different anyway in the world your Bible is different you know like with at MIDI that who is a great person but this culture emerged and even before in different parts when trying to refute the Bible Muslims started to say things like our even one vowel isn't different I know a silent imam mark is in the house Hamas Island Imam all right those of you that don't follow the Imam please

do an amazing legend from from America from the States into his fitness and if you have any questions reach out to him in Charlotte right so the question here in what I'm trying to the point in what I'm trying to say is the way the Quran was transmitted it came with a certain amount of fluidity that is how the Quran was this and that's just how it was but I know some Muslims may struggle with that but that's there's nothing wrong in that the problem is when people present it in a very rigid manner and then people like Orientalists or atheists or

Islamophobes will catch them out ok so then you'll have a problem ok so I just wanted to clarify that and chef Akram said exactly the same thing yesterday show her I'm not weak he said Muslims need to stop all this saying this these recitations mustache over the lip is Haram my moustache ain't over the lip but so the he said the same

thing saying all these Mota what these different kira automotive art and he said this is just people just made this up along the way and people just went with it so ok I thought answer that he answers some questions [Music] yes I mean that does mean that there's subtle differences in the meaning of the Quran as well that is true when you read it if you read it in different ways but that what I'm trying to say and this is what what could even know how to be the great Malik he says as well by the way that this is what the Quran the flexibility

came with the fluidity and he says you know this hadith of that the Quran was revealed on seven letters this is just a nonsensical hadith it has no basis that people just keep transmitting this okay right so cool nails nails are fine right so anyway let's go go through some of these questions those of you just tuning in click like click share people somebody had asked me about the ibrahim ali salaam ibrahim ali salaam which one of these sons were slaughtered this is

interesting because i think we have nothing truly conclusive that tells us which son it was okay so many muslims believe right this tsar olaf we keep saying we fix your camera how about we fix you instead and block you so behave yourself before you get full you get blasted into oblivion right so now the coming back to what i was saying

ibrahim ali salaam the sacrificing of his son there's two points i want to take a look at one which son and two i want to take a look at the actual sacrifice offering a sacrifice what is this about okay so these two things first of all which son was it now there is a difference of opinion within islam as well is not an agreed-upon fact majority some people majority of the people seem to believe it was a smile ELISA Lam and they used certain evidences certain

hadith to go with the Prophet saying things like I am the son of the two two men who were almost sacrificed and so did these kind of things and the user the narrations to imply and infer that it was a smile ELISA and other people felt it was is Huck aleihsalaam amongst them they say it was horrible hot pop Radi Allahu unbeliev that Sahib Lama say if I believe believe that as well Imam Malik actually believe it or not believed that it was his heart and not

his mind the great Maliki scholar from Muslim Spain or the evocative not to be the dawn and legend right of Muslim Spain he actually right he actually explains the whole difference he's got a whole book on it called I think it's called an also hey if it's a being the BA something I do have it here some way and I went through it's a good book and he goes through all these differences of opinion and show although a worker in Harvey himself goes with the understanding that it's a smile

in the end but there is no conclusive it on this matter I once sat in a lesson many years ago with a share trying to say how the Jews have got it wrong and it was an issue is is hard it was clearly smiled the truth is that's false we don't have any conclusive et most Muslims we tend to believe it was a smile other Muslims believed it was his heart they were great Muslims people like in my my league like one where even on hot barbara the Aloha I eating almost say you great people of this palma so both opinions hold strength okay so that's

the first aspect the second aspect is what about sacrificing your son now you see when we read the Quran it's interesting that Allah doesn't say he commanded ibrahim ali salam to sacrifice his son okay he doesn't say that

ibrahim ali salam Allah relates as in rates the ibrahim ali salam mentions to his son that he saw a dream the in our film Minami and me as ba Hawk that I saw a dream it was a really strange dream in the dream I was sacrificing you now we know in old nations and old civilizations people had offerings and they did these kind of things as sacrificial rituals and things like Ibrahim and if some does not say

any way that Allah told me to do this well Allah does not say anyway he is telling ibrahim al islam to do this rather abraham ELISA Lam is telling his son in his old age he tells his son that look I saw in a dream that I'm sacrificing you his son who's is young at the time very young is obviously a young boy says to him that this is revelation and you should do it you have been it's a command so he says that he tells him if Alma taught math

that you need to do and you will find that I will be patient like sacrifice me that this is revelation it's it must be God telling you it must be God telling you to sacrifice me and then I could see yes I mean some people may take an angle that was it the Shaitaan giving this this kind of an insinuation that's an angle another angle is maybe even if it wasn't the Shaitaan but it was just a dream it could be I mean that's an angle some people have

use that verse except when the shaitaan kind of threw into them thoughts about the profits and stuff like this there is that verse and it is and you see here's omar soliman pública me rustling will Anna be in Allah is that Amana alqa Shaitan fee omnia T so this kind of verse which some people have foolishly used to justify the Satanic Verses with our prophet but this some people may argue that this was to do with that same dream and ibraheem alehissalaam this coming from the devil other people it doesn't have to be that though it doesn't have to be that it could just be

that sometimes you see even in psychology when you love something so much it preoccupies your mind and you have a fear of loss and people often end up dreaming about that thing and ibrahim ali salaam we know that in his old age he he was really fond of this child all of sudden he had a son and he was really fond of him now he has this dream so it could have been just a natural dream it doesn't have to be something although that may be an interpretation but the point is that it's his son who starts emphasising to him that no this is

revelation you need to do it to the extent that he convinces ibrahim ali salam that this must be a test and i'm going to do it and allah saves a smile and tells ibrahim ali salaam that look because of your conviction that you felt that a light commanded you to do this even though allah hadn't commanded you but because of your sheer devotion commitment to a lot of the most beloved thing to you you thought allah has commanded you to sacrifice it and you

were even prepared to do that to go to that extent for your love of for allah that allah for that love not the act of sacrificing but for that love allah highly commend ibrahim ali salaam and tells him that don't let this stops him from doing that tells him sacrifice an animal the the RAM that appears and will make this a Sunnah for people that will come as well from your Sunnah and this is the level that your level of devotion to

Allah even when Allah hadn't told you to do this but you felt that Allah had told you to do it maybe because of this dream and your son telling you that you were prepared to sacrifice everything for you just so you remain faithful to Allah that love and devotion from Ibrahim he himself has the status of like the the commitment of a civilization almost in one man that in neighborhood can OMA he was like an Ummah in himself now this is the the understanding ok so I just

wanted to highlight that so people have asked things like this and this is something that atheists ask a lot as well that Ibrahim God why would God want Abraham to sacrifice his son God didn't tell Abraham to sacrifice his son so I just wanted to clarify that no way in the Quran does Allah mention that and no way does he say I wanted him to sacrifice and and do this so just to clarify these things ok so I hope that of some help

rights are the Ibrahim entering the fire have answered that before no way in the Quran does it actually mentioned and that Abraham was thrown into the fire doesn't mention that anyway it mentions Allah saved him from the fire ok saved him from some people understood from that that it must have meant he was thrown in it and then saved that doesn't have to be the case a loss uses the same verse saved Noah from the flood it doesn't mean he was thrown in the flood and then

doesn't mean that so okay so that's the Satanic Verses I vaunted on several occasions wouldn't a prophet know if it's a commandment or not you see he doesn't say it's a commandment it's his son who says to him that do what you have been commanded and here at this stage because dreams can also be revelation they don't have to not every dreamer prophesies has to be a revelation but revelation can come through dreams so at this point

ibrahim ali salam became slightly he he thought maybe it is b and his son insisted that do it and he thought and that's why he kind of started to believe all this must have been a commandment and Allah then obviously saves him from doing that and tells him no but so that's the the kind of summary anyway what's your view on sheer wash what a sheer SH ei I don't know what that is okay let's take a few questions people

somebody asked about the Satanic Verses I've answered that enough time so many times I think it's shocking how oh my my mates and their sense of humor I mean where would we be without the without our sense of humor in this world it's it's coming home people it's coming home hell yeah hell yeah right so I'm going to I'm going to bring up some of those

questions that people have asked on Facebook I want to first of all give her a shout out to Indra shukran shukran muchas gracias I don't have it with me but Indra for your gift you sent a gift much love much appreciated right and so I just want to that shout out before I forget all the way from Indonesia look at that look where this voice reaches now that is the connection that see that in itself is a blessing from Allah people this connection a global connection Indra Gandhi no no not in drag on the

Indra our good friend is I'm going to I don't want to meet it I don't want to misquote his surname so I'll I'll have to read it out I'm probably gonna read it wrong but it's Indra Arya Ted Arya Teja Arya tej I believe so shukran a Hana brother much love for that once again right I'm just going to go to these questions that have been asked on Facebook because people have said you're not answering some of the questions that

we post on the port a port gear and they've got a valid point to be fair we need to answer some of these questions Salam from Germany arrived Robert alaikum as Salam I have a dream let's just hope it's it's it's we're not talking about the ones that require Wilson right so where are we where are we people oh no this is the other

article come on let me get into this I'm trying to get to the questions for some reason all right I'm there people I'm there right so here's some of the questions just going to go through some of these can you please this is from John Rambo from a Rambo right can you please touch on the issue of post-mortem huh look at

subconscious touch post-mortem what is happening this does it cause pain to the soul which many scholars have mentioned of course it doesn't when a person is dead they are dead people they're dead Imam Zia is in the house ellos salen Imam Zia people those of you not following Imam Zia of the states originally from a Brit over in the states do follow him amazing

Imam with great character right so right next question when is your video in response to share this are going to be released regarding isa al salam the video is going to be a full day's course maybe at the end of this month you know it was just one thing after another then there was Ramadan and then Ramadan just kind of and then so after that now we're thinking maybe when it's holidays and yeah it's gonna be a full day's course and it's not just to chef as rod it's for anybody and everybody it's for the whole we had this whole kind of trolling

toddler this whole gang of trolls right from some of them this hard-code the Obon the cultists cultists right it's for them and anybody else as well it's gonna be for everybody right so inshallah but it was good I thought let the topic let everybody say everything I thought let them empty their hearts out and then I will come to kind of bring those souls back to life huh where did sectarianism arise from surely Islam

is about unity rather than separation absolutely I'll be you've hit the nail on the head it is about unit unity right Chico chocolate chicken taco says can you please clarify your controversial views how they make sense when almost 99.99 percent not even 99 percent how much 99.99 percent Chico Chico has been doing some analyses and doing some statistics measured way not quantifying

all of the ulama worldwide as though the owner - we'll hang out in one I don't know like shisha lounge or something uh are you guys the ulama yep that's us how does this statistic dew point zero zero point zero one percent how did how does that happen anyway scholars disagree with you and such views disagree with you

Chico Chico what a name no intent for misrepresentation please correct me if I misrepresented to you good morning we tickle tickle the question one stories in the Quran are nothing more but just some irrelevant stories look at this whenever I said that that's a great ways in it I'm saying what is this view of

yours well first of all I've never said that so okay to the Shaitaan is not real it's just an imagination so not said that either so okay Chico chuckle right ciao ciao ciao bella ciao in a towel towel towel that's it this is I've not said any of those things what I have said is that somebody has asked does the shaitaan have to be a figure per se like a person like figure or

could it be things like these insinuations within within us it could be that's an interpretation I've said I don't know how the Shaitaan actually is it seems like Chico Chaco seems to know the Shaitaan Chico chocos like what are you talking about I know the Shaitaan personally Shaitaan is like my cousin [Laughter] number two the stories in the Quran on nothing more look at that what a belligerent and disrespectful way of saying I've never said that I've said that the stories in the Quran the most

cap the way to captivate people human beings is always through stories and the Quran also brings stories it brings narratives they have great lessons in them I've always said they have great lessons in them but what they were never about was trying to get caught up in the science of them so Allah wasn't trying to when he teaches you the story of Musa at least I'm he's not trying to teach you for example how geography works or how geology works or how how does how our illusions conducted or he's not trying to teach you that it's trying to teach you the narrative of moosa

aleihsalaam and you can extract this lesson of that right overcoming wrong of having patience forbearance of fighting for what is right of justice of struggle you can take these a victory you can take these lessons of allah being with you but you too have to of being able to make mistakes in this world like Musa Ali said I'm when he accidentally killed somebody because he got into a fight with him that sometimes in life may go wrong perceptibly but still hang in there these are amazing lessons that the Quran gives you rather than just saying them it gives you them through a

beautiful story now because stories captivate human beings so yes I but I've never said the irrelevant stories ooh anyway all right so and somebody shukran did say these ain't his views so much love too Imran Khan said that much appreciated right what's the point right just a few questions is it permissible to keep a dog as a pet in the home according to Maliki v and the answer is yes it is permissible I've answered that previously on a few occasions you can't

keep a dog as a pet if you like I know generally generally I think the Pakistani culture we are just freaked out by dogs I don't think I'll just feel very very uncomfortable I'm trying to overcome but we just have this phobia I don't know I don't think I had it when I was an absolute kid but along the way anyway so that's but the question is yes

according to Maliki v dogs are pure they can be kept in the home if that's necessary and people like if nobody's a al Qaeda one in his time and did used to keep them around the kind of if you alright alright that's great almost gotta set this up again

all right side so I think there's not the whole thing off they gotta straighten these folks on momento momento this is gonna any time I touch this screen now it's just what it is this desk but I've got isn't the I gotta change this that's better

Oh momento let me straighten that up all right so as I was saying next question coming - I take it sir yes so if not be say al Qaeda 1e I think that's kind of knocked off its if not be Zaid a la plata whiny he does highlight these points yes

RI people look at that close-up all right that's all we're talking about that's what we are talking about folks so straightening that right now if not be say they'll tie Dewani who's a great Malachy legend he does say in his time he used to keep a dog in the front kind of I don't know what like a front garden I suppose like a courtyard of his house

and when he was asked he said that the Companions if they lived or the Salaf lived in our day and age they would have kept lions let alone dogs so yes that's absolutely fine you can do that you can do that people right so uh sir my question is regarding the menstrual cycle and women not being able to pray my understanding is the Quran does not the Quran

does not prohibit does not mention anything about praying being for women who are not on the menstrual cycle or rather is mentioned in some hadith fair to say this has been influenced the Quran does mention that having intercourse during menstruation is forbidden but not mention anything about Salah right okay so what is this ruling right okay so this thing about menstruation I've mentioned this before that this is more so a kind of it's like

this it's a dispensation okay it's a dispensation that Islam has given to women on the menstrual cycle it's allowed for them to not have to necessarily pray to not they don't have to pray that is really if anything just seen as a kind of it is in certain hadith these roses are described as a sadhaka a charity from Allah to humans like to in this case women or in other cases whatever the dispensation whether

it's a traveler a new person and the Prophet said toss in a lot of the alaykum Allah has given you a charity Valu so the hata okay so accept his charity so that's what it is in terms of the women being impure that's not true okay so that is not truly that women are impure or that they have to be treated as though they impure and things like this that is definitely not the case okay so you you know people have this

standing ladies inherited through culture so people have kind of inherited this this thing of women are they become impure when when they run the menstrual cycle or things like this that is not true at all okay so just to kind of clarify that's a very cultural kind of practice but other than that the praying part is something which really is just a dispensation for them they don't so they can recite the Quran as Imam Malik said

they can do things like that okay right so now where are we Jesus never went to sleep right the Jesus thing will answer much later on in Shiloh and we'll get to that cool so what are we looking at some other questions where we getting to is that try to rearrange my camera why was my camera doing man it should be hopefully okay uh-uh

somebody said books to the ceiling look at that to the ceiling they are folks to the ceiling that's what I'm talking about right so books are all the way to the ceiling so since this it is I don't know oh right trying to trap this it is I think it's because when it dropped for some reason it kind of just knocked it

off balance the way so I don't know what's gone wrong with my iPad unless I do something like one moment you're right he's back people wheeze back so hopefully that should be I'm hoping that's okay yeah some reason it's just that it doesn't seem to be picking up any of the even though these loads of tons of light yeah but still how bright people sorry about that let's back up and running

just gonna so I hope that people can still see it apologies for that it's back up running I'm just going to right okay here no this is the sharing this as well again gotta share it sorry can't are I so I

don't know what it is this is an iPad pro we shouldn't really be playing not like this but it does maybe I need to update into the latest right I'm just writing part two okay that's done right folks those of you just tuning in click like click share people apologies for the

turbulence that we've had to undergo there right so some people have asked me to respond to they've asked me to respond to Sony defense right so I'm going to give a slight summary and then just respond to them and then move back to some of the questions we've got here just to summarize some need offense or Wahhabi defense as they are a back again

our good old friend baba Frieda Dean Gangu Teli is back those of you who tuned in previously and so my reputations of him well Gangu Teli is now back that's freedom Baba Farid Dean Gangu Teli of a hobby defense and some people said look in your previous reputations trying to defend him they said that look you know how do you say these things about them they never really have said anything disrespectful or blasphemous against the

Prophet and that's not true and they said that you need to justify this kind of claim that you said and I'll play look the first thing that they actually said this was their first refutation against me right so they I mean what's wrong with getting sick and getting sexually impotent really is that like a criteria for him being a prophet this was the Sunni defense first refutation against me not what's wrong with the Prophet being sexually impotent

that is a criteria of his prophethood that he has to be sexually active this is the ridiculous blasphemous Wahhabi nudge the kind of attitude that we're dealing with so you can already see so that's not you know when somebody said to me that oh you know you're you're you know you said this about these people and they've never said anything like that naked so people could see his testicles and you know what he said is that the profit you said you know you guys believed that the Prophet was so

incapable that you put black magic and and then he has this other one as well where he's saying they that they that use Yui that he's attacking like he's criticizing that I'm criticizing these hadith that in bihari that happened that the prophet Moses run around naked so people can see his testicles and they're defending like they're saying like what's his problem criticizing that light and then they go on to say and this is on YouTube this is the thing on

YouTube it isn't even my thing this is the kind of ridiculous blasphemous kind of a hobby defense that they are that and they then coming and attacking obviously they were attacking and attack people like me so this guy one of the key people amongst them Fareed who I referred to in one of our previous sessions as Baba Farid Athene Gangu Teli

so Gangu Teli saab the iranian person is back now and look i want to make something clear Gangu Teli sahib no cemaat if you can inter bail of samat right if you can just pay attention right instead of going on about me being agile me not knowing this me not knowing this even though I first of all all those

criticisms are refuted because they do a cut-and-paste job they're just stupid I'm trying to say oh look a slip of the words here oh he said oh he doesn't know he's a dare he leads a day he must be an antichrist must be at the jail ha ha stop running away this same topic that he's trying to defend marital rape he's trying to say that the Prophet said that a woman has no right to refuse sex to a husband this hadith only comes down predominantly the chains I've quoted come down throughout

much through Qatada metallocene stop running away with this nonsense bring me one sahih hadith one sahih hadith that cannot be criticized 1 ja ja stop this I'm if I'm such a jackal then you should be able to bring one hadith bring one then we'll talk bring one hadith forget all this trying to distract na na ma I know these tactics is nudge the tactics of yours

blaspheming people hateful carry hatred against the prophets stop all this nonsense bring me one saya d since I'm a jackal since I'm at the jail I'm a Jackie Lama know what I'm talking about bring me one at ease about this that justifies this rape from the Prophet that cannot be criticized I will rip and show you where that hadith carries weakness and Ilyn bring me one do not run away from this question do not change the topic bring one hadith one hadith and if you

need if you need help go go to you or am I of nudged get them together compile them get them gather them together and tell them to help you bring one hadith that justifies this marital rape going back to the Prophet that cannot be criticized then we can speak bring one since I'm going on about me being agile maybe there are major Hill or not is irrelevant this kind of blasphemy is not attributed to our prophet salallahu alaihe salam you bring

me one hadith one hadith that i can that cannot be criticized the chain the chain I'm talking about show me one hadith stop trying to change the discussion change the topic oh he doesn't know some an allotment I use his name Solomon alarmers and the point I was making there was actually about Shah Baba and yes if trying to distract this topic by saying oh by posing a video my point in that clip he brings this clip and saying oh he doesn't know Salman my point in that was simply to say because Shaba is somebody who claims that lease is Haram

he claims that leases are armed people might say oh shah baba is in this chain so this ought to be ok but the person transmitting from him is problematic that was the point which he conveniently pauses by the way forget all of this well yeah I am added earlier he'll I don't know these anybody who studied hadith you know I was studies for one week knows more than most Diabolus well well fine bring one hadith 101 Hadees

one don't change the Torah don't run away in Morocco that'll kill up like this don't dodge like round and round like these dogs do right that's an Arabic Ibarra don't do that bring one hadith ok don't distract either you directly knob article yeah bataki carful oculata mu J Reza no say Gilan he take very cassava don't tell me about this so that or whatever you explain how this Caravan got robbed

huh it's not about the thieves or the robbers or the bandits how are you a leader of this Caravan that is what the poet says so either order clean about the car here but our cacophonic you know you bring me one hadith and then we'll talk and if you've got if if you've got the nerve to its rise to my challenge after that this is a challenge by the way Chilean brother my nerdy brother is

a challenge so if you can first of all rise to this bring me one honey that should be easy as I cannot be criticized bring it bring it hard to burhanakum in kuntum Saudi team sitting right here as Mawlana units no money said amazing person may Allah have mercy on his soul Aman are there from Pakistan said either they are we sitting right here yet anybody we're not going in you bring one honey and then rise to my second

challenge prove to me that soil Bihari can be traced back to its author prove it this this one above your pay grade my friend this on you and all you can you can gather the whole of Wahhabi dum and put it together and ra wouldn t be how are you can take this one big challenge this is a big problem you know

Gangu Teli see big problem problem you know so I'm waiting so first bring me a sahih hadith secondly prove to me how can you prove to me beyond reasonable doubt sahari going back to its its author but go back to Imam Bihari can you prove it can you prove it hell no you can't what manuscripts are you gonna prove it from

hmm so Tonya based on the Uni Nia oho the Sun Tanya which is people for your information which based a lot of what it did on the soul on the Uni Nia of you've gotta have between you Nene and Bali and humbly from the 788 century he passes away but we don't have a manuscript even of the Union here we have a phone from his somebody who copied it from him did he make a mistake

is that what we're going by and then the Union ear which disagrees with the others marry Wyatt and what is he going through a homily is he disagreeing with most family is disagreeing with the other re Wyatt of surrogacy is disagreeing with and therapy what about February I mean why didn't nobody consider him reliable in hadith up until hundreds of years after him placed on big problem why does Muslim Allah say that Ferrari had a copy of Buhari which was incomplete and he hadn't part of it was somewhere I were incomplete and we

used to move them around which was induced by a bubble either bhurji and pasta nanny s muy interesante and what is Apple will either body say above a legal body says that it's interesting Muslim Lee says canna in the host learn and toss a human he had one copy we all used to copy from and yet they all got it different and then the interesting case of Suhani are you not you may see South unease another person comes hundreds of years after who claims to have the actual copy of robbery ha ha

ha ha honey honey was born in Lahore he was actually sat on he was a Hanafy scholar born in Lahore and he claimed to have found an actual copy hundreds of years after for robbery by the way nobody else has seen this copy he claims he obviously loved love and he goes he goes ma I found an actual copy and then his copy has rah rah it which none of the other copies of Bihari have Lhasa I'm Eva and this one big problem you know where is this where is this

what how do we prove this one you know how do we prove this most so I still eagerly await a eagerly await so these are challenges first of all to the Wahhabi defense team and then by extension to anybody who wants to play Sahil Bihari as a God and to make Allah and His Messenger revolve around Saahil Buhari they need to prove this actually belongs to him and Bihari to start off with can see what they didn't tell you is they told you from Imam Buhari to the Prophet what they didn't tell you is how this book then comes to us because all

of the transmitters of Maharis the copies seem to disappear mystery one person remains for a brief who seems to be unknown by his contemporaries but 200 years later somebody says what a guy somebody 200 years later besides some Hani says this for every great but before him no news we don't know you know who this robbery we know who but we nobody validate nobody vouching for him

so we got so this one big problem and then the copies that go throughout the world or disagree with them hadeeth missing hadith less patched together we've got cut and paste job going on how many hands are copying we've got no idea his own probably student saying by the way he his copy was incomplete we used to move things around any we used to place chapter headings all this nonsense about boo hotties fifties in his chapter headings

more suddenly says we used to make so people somebody might ask here what is that why am i opening these kind of worms to do with Mahadi and this isn't just Bihari the other books as well by the way Sahib Muslim and these have problems as well because aside Muslim is based on the Istanbul transcript which has its own problems but right now we want to focus on body because the reason I'm doing this is to show we need to

return to the methodology that was taught to us by Imam Malik and Imam Malik tortoise in his motto he taught us through faith this was the practice of Medina he taught us that we will never be sound in this Deen until we learn to accept and reject hadith so you must accept some and you must reject some this is the way this is the balanced path of this Ummah in my Malik places anything is more tough and says

we don't accept this hadith Imam Malik himself says if you start accepting everyone after one of these isolated narrations he says the entire Deen will be snatched from me this is the teaching of Imam Malik the other interesting thing is that the Dean who was already preserved through that how you practice Islam was already preserved and is this an attempt somebody may say well why don't we just get rid of all of her

the question is hadith contain a lot of useful detail that add color to this theme and they are important and we know through corroboration that not all hadith are false we know that because they corroborate through independent sources and they fit in with the Quranic teachings with the principles of Islam so if hadith come to us and the hadith are about simply about rules and things like these or how to practice Islam if they do not go against reason as if nor

Josie and all these scholars before us in hadith had said even a handsome that they do not clash with reason and they do not go against the Quran they do not go against the clear sources that have been transmitted the corroborated sooner sooner that has come through like the AMA novel Medina in Imam Ali oh that has been preserved through faith or through corroborated hadith and they do not approve a principle of Islam then they have no problem okay they have no problem otherwise it is a problem and we

need to take them with a pinch of salt okay because some of these theme in some of these hadith insult Islam and they cannot be authentic so okay so so somebody saying reason is subjective of course being a human being is subjective it doesn't stop you being a human being does it you know like is that not subjective being a human being there is something known as intersubjectivity watch my whole lecture on reason okay

about gold and silver first of all I'm not wearing a chain of gold this is silver but I do not believe go to be Haram for men neither do I believe silk to be Haram I have a video I have a clip on YouTube please watch that I go into much more detail showing the great scholars like imam show cannae even if they can eat these people show demonstrating how several companions of the Prophet right till their very death they wore gold and I don't actually personally wear gold just because I just prefer silver but I don't actually believe it Haram believed

it to be a Haram forbidden I believe it to be discouraged that's all right so right so now right I wanted to go through a quick hadith people to show somebody had asked a question and I wanted to say hadith from Sahil Bihari we're gonna take a look at and this is in line it's a quick hadith analysis we're gonna do and this is in line with the understanding of hadith which are

problematic they are in Bukhari there are in other books as well so this one can be found in the Muslims of Ahmed and these narrations in Sahih Muslim parts of it but I'm going to just focus on body just that because we don't have too much time and to show that they are hadith that are problematic that have crept in and these are hadith which insult Islam okay so we need to be really careful about some of these and that is this a hadith let's take a look at this one there's a hadith in Bukhari under a hadith al anbiya under the a hadith of the prophets

inside Buhari and it mentions look it's from bishop no Muhammad from Abdullah no Mubarak called bharanam armor and her mom Anna Barrera that the messenger of allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said lola banu israel lam yakun is allah la ilaha were lambda hoon unser soldier huh this is once again a blasphemous hadith because it's misrepresenting nonsense to the prophet salallahu alayhi wasalam so it's saying that the that if it wasn't for the children of israel that if it

wasn't for the children of israel food would never go foul would never go off like food would always just remain like basically if you left some meteor and it mentions here meat specifically in another rewire it does say to on in this particular revised size meat so if you left me they would never go off it would just always stay sound healthy and right the way it is but food only gets bacteria and these things only happened because the banu israel the israelites

disobeyed god that is ridiculous okay that is insulting our prophet to say things like this that he did not say okay and then it goes on to say that while Ola have work if it wasn't for hawa all right how what here is obviously Hawaii doesn't come in the Quran but Hawaii is Eve the wife if we want to use the term wife or of Adam ELISA Lam although it may be most likely that Adam most likely would have

probably had multiple kind of partners and things like this that's the only common sensical way that human jet that he could populate such a such an offspring through one woman it's it's incredibly incredibly unlikely that the globe would be populated like that right so well that's a different discussion but Lola how what if it wasn't for Eve lambda hone unser soldier her no woman would ever betray her husband now listen

to them that is utterly unacceptable that is miss attributed just misogyny to the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam when he didn't say this is clearly this kind of language is clearly from biblical talk at best okay best this is kind of judeo-christian kind of and many of the things that have been transmitted sometimes through Abu Hurairah rode along on he used to take from his convert teachers like Campbell Akbar and from from other teachers as well that had converted to Islam after

the time of the Prophet and they had they were scholars of Judaism or Christianity when they came and this hadith even in the more Father Abba Raider says he spent the whole day at what he believed was Mount Sinai studying from Kabul Akbar about his religion and in turn he was telling him about hadith as well so sometimes it may come from Abu Huraira or the Ilan sometimes it may come from people from them that they mix things up as well so sometimes they may think of a herida is saying that the Prophet said this but he didn't say that sometimes it may come from the people that's transmitting it from them these

mistakes so first of all this hadith contains to not only factual errors but what are causes to ridicule religion that oh if it wasn't for the Israelites food would would never go off like food would always remain sound that's and that's never that's not how bacteria works that's not how nature works okay nature is not a result of the Israelites okay secondly it says Lola Hawaii if it wasn't for Eve right that no wife or

woman would betray her husband this is nonsense because first of all this is trying to act like well women have inherited this from Eve somehow that Eve was this temptress this kind of seductive evil woman who betrayed Adam this is a very Christian narrative a judeo-christian narrative secondly is trying to act this hadith is portraying that women are the culprits in society Ubik who betray men and that's if we're gonna be honest because it's talking here commonly speaking it's actually men who

more often than not or betraying women that is generally the case I mean if we're going to look at it's usually men just the nature that that they're going to not settle with one woman in many cases even if they do settle that mostly it's men that will always be sleeping around mostly I mean that's just by the nature of males across species it's not actually the nature of females across species to be so if I can use the word like rampantly just trying to have sex with every other for example male

whereas it is the nature of males in most species to do that so so this whole thing is miss portraying that it's trying to act as if really the culprits the real culprits are just women who just are betraying unfaithful to their husbands sleeping around doing things like this and that's actually factually incorrect right so that's not generally society I mean I'm not saying it doesn't happen I'm sure it does happen but generally if anybody if you're gonna criticize anybody you'd criticize the men secondly it's acting as though

they've inherited this behavior from Eve thirdly it's acting it's representing Eve as an evil woman who betrayed Adam right which is nonsense right now right so and by the way when I said male species throughout that I said generally and mostly not nothing there are some monogamous species but generally by and large most males do happen to be very kind of if we can use the word polygamous as in the very seeking extra

if maritally the right word but they're seeking just basically seeking sex from opportunists when it comes to sex right so so this hadith is blasphemous it is inaccurate unacceptable even if we look at this Senate we look at this chain Bishop no Mohammed now first of all it's interesting that Bishop no Mohammed here assault eonni who remember Hardy except from here although Imam Bihari himself begins by saying in like he highlights I don't accept from anybody in my book who is a P that doesn't fit in line with

this yet Bishop no Mohammed sixteen II was from the more jihad that's what people have claimed and that is people who believe that committing sins were not a problem as far as Iman was concerned yet he still accepts from him here who goes from the lognormal Barak in this particular chain it goes through Martin Maher and then through her mom then iboga Reza now her mom it has been criticized although he's generally a reliable person he's been criticized he brings the hadith in Abu Dawood to do with the ring and the Prophet having to take it off when he goes to the toilet and things like this and people Chris O'Dowd said that this is from the one a mistake of her mom her mom making

mistakes they happy does occur out of that accepts acknowledges that and other people try to refute them but he makes mistakes right and then you've got Matt Moore Matt Maher several people have quit critique Matt Maher is reliable in many things as well but he's been criticized for other narrations you've got he's let's see let's see here we've got people have said that sometimes at certain locations they worse than others so you have some of his hadith have been

described as being massively turbulent fee if they're all kathira especially when he was in Basra sometimes in other places he's been criticized he's been asked so they mentioned imam ahmed saying in the rewire of his son solomon after a bill Basra feeis on Eid in his certain as I need he makes mistakes he transmits from certain people problematic things although generally one might say yeah but he used to make

mistakes in a certain city only doesn't make sense first of all you know when people when people have been known to to be problematic you have to be just you have to stop being kind of very naive and you have to think well hmm you know that that you have to take some of these things with a pinch of salt I'm just going to on momento just open this up as well

right right so some of the people my mother has also been criticized for his a hadith from sabot have been heavily criticized although some people supported that but yet looks a bit a known transmitter I assume you've now been a dude once again he's been heavily criticized for hadith from from these people now that just goes to show this person has some issues with him the next

person in right so next person so I'm just opening it in this chain so that's done - we've got taken a look at two of them the first one being her mom who we've highlighted some people have got problems with then Matt mark as I've highlighted although he's reliable yet people have said certain locations certain people that

are saying all these things he has an issue with people have massively problematized these hadith then somebody in addition to the first teacher of Buhari versus tianni in this case is also accused of being from the Moche hub which is problematic okay so let's go back to the hadith well somebody may say well this has another chain and it does if it allows me to open right okay excellent this chain in this case the body the teacher of Bihari is also known as Bihari is Abdullah Al Jarreau feeel Buhari sometime known as a loose nerdy

because he was one of the first people to gather a Muslim who comes through a similar chain except this time it's Abdul Razak a Suhani from madam are from her mom okay from Abu Haider so we've taken a look at her mom some criticism taking a look at mama this is the secondary YN Bihari and now Abdul Razak in this chain okay so if we go back on momento momento

Abdul Razak right we've got people like a mum nursery he says that fee another that we've gotta be weary about the result especially in his later age as the Hobby stays in Mehsana at Adel rubia anhu a hadith man a kid they have been really massively problematically transmitted from from Abdul Razak Assam honey the putney says the jalapeno bouquet and Mustafa you stay a la mama fear hadith

that the hood me transmits that he makes mistakes from mama and once again where is this hadith coming it is coming from mama so and then some people say he had Shiar tendencies and things like this but that aside he's quoted by their be again in the cash if he mentions that wallahu Hara it woman AK here okay somebody who has Hara if he has manicured abou haughty Marazzi says about him that you've double hadith oh well are you a Jew be that we write his hadith we do

not consider them as evidence okay so that's we've got that day about Abdullah pass and honey we've also got same thing here in the middle of Tirmidhi the commentary you've got people mentioning him he's a popular scholar of hadith and he has many hadith which we can accept if they do meet up to the criteria he towards his later part of his life did kind of lose his eyesight and that also impacted his hadith they mentioned here as well can you look and a hadith bartylla he would be taught fabricated

hadith because his eyesight was impacted [Music] right so that's that's there as well but once again same thing about the kirov a availa were hidden and of the reserve had that abit a hadith monarchia that he's mentioned certain monarchia hadith especially as well after his eyesight was impacted so that's something worth right so that's highlighted here as well and as you've seen the quotes from all of these scholars of how to Marazzi other people dark would need quoting as

well transmitting especially when we're looking at his a hadith from marmar we have a we have a problem ok so cool I hope that let me just check was there anything else yeah no that's okay I've included the others so the point is that you've got two chains here inside Buhari both problematic the content of the hadith is heavily problematic as well it goes against the teachings of the Quran which teaches first of all the Quran teaches

equality that Allah to you that we do not inherit the Quran says lettuce it was written with okra that we do not inherit sins from people we do not inherit this betrayal and this doesn't work like that a lot of teaches you in the Quran that food is a gift from Allah he teaches you things like it comes from the earth do you not see how food is brought forth and this happens and that happens this is the part of nature law mentions voluntary delis from metal a heat abdillah it goes against the Quran it goes against the general understanding of the the sources in in this Deen like

the established some men women like that women or just the counterparts the equal counterparts of men they exactly the same our fitrah is the same okay it goes against the principle established principles of Islam that people should not be kind of shamed for just ancestry they and we don't have collective group guilt like all women are culprit because Eve betrayed Adam we do not believe Eve betrayed Adam it's a very judeo-christian thing so it goes against all of these things and the SI need have problems whether you want to look at Muhammad

Nabeel as suspect or whether you want to see her mom as some people having critiqued him Abu Dawood or I'm very happy or whether you want to see Matt Maher who's been more critique than her mom and then up the rose up in the other chain who's been criticized even more than all of them oh whether you want to see that as Abu Hurairah or the law on here was this a teaching from the judeo-christian sources that he got and people mistakenly passed it on as Islamic teachings either way this is a hadith which insults Islam and it is utterly unacceptable it is blasphemous

right so I hope that's been of some help people I think we should kind of wrap this up if there's any quick rapid round questions maybe I'll take a few why was Adam sent to earth as a prophet if there was no other people there were other people as in hominins and things like that I believe they must have been for Adam to emerge and he wasn't sent he was from Earth however can you explain the parting of the sea for Moses I will explain that in much detail in sha Allah in another episode Neander tells of

course not only me and ourselves the entire genus of hominins that have existed including homo sapiens that were pre cognitive revolution right so what else where do we get the records of the Quran records of the Quran are sorry there are parts of salah are not in the quran and that's fine this is an inherited practice from the Prophet we inherited through the sooner the collective son which was documented in fact by the way that was documented much before hadith was documented because people as soon as Islam was there people

want to know how to pray and get about doing things they don't need a Jazza to learn how to pray so you have to remember these things okay so faith is always an amazing source to document the Sunnah and yes so the the raka art of Salafi makrooh to eat fish with dairy that's a fabricated hadith of good I mean the Prophet never generally used to eat fish because Arabia is a desert so you don't get much fish there but it's definitely not macaron or is it true if one eats or drinks anything Haram ditto house Allah is not accepted for forty

days no that's not true can I translate the word Islam as safe teenis my understanding is Islam although it can be seen as somebody who enters into a state of safety I think it's more and the same for mom in entering into a state of Eman but I think it's more ties in as well with submission somebody who enters into submits to the understanding of the creator why the punishment of the grave I believe that you see the punishment of the grave isn't something that is clearly in the Quran in that

sense at all some people say certain verses can allude to it which are true they can allude to that understanding but it's not clear they do seem to be certain a hadith but the some of the hadith to do with the punishment of the grave are problematic because the things they mention are problematic like it doesn't make sense why anybody like so for example the hadith about a person who when he urinates his urine falls over him so he's now getting tortured over that even though you rain falling on over you is not a same it's not seen as anything I mean okay if you're about to

pray you should wash that's a different ruling but it's not a kind of like a crime or seen as oh you know oh my god person deserves to be punished so this hadith is problematic in itself so there are some but most of the scholars have gone with this understanding that there is a punishment in the grave some scholars have problematized this I would feel that this isn't conclusive if you want to believe I would personally say that this is open if a person wanted to believe it they could if they don't want to believe it I feel this scope this isn't

something that is that clear the Quran seems to teach that as soon as people die the afterlife for them is as though it's just within moments so they say when you know minbars enemy mark Idina who brought us back from our sleep that word we and some of them say when we yeoman or barber yom or miss for you weren't we only out for a part of a day so obviously that seems to go against the understanding that they were being tortured and they knew what was going on so I would say look this is just open to people who it make sense to they can

take it to people who doesn't make sense to they don't need to take it I think all of those views of me is pull Sarat real that's an interesting discussion is that influenced from other sources is this pull Sarat brought in from Zoroastrian nism as the Muslims conquered Persia and rastering people did they bring in the concept of the pool syrup that they had because the Rashtriya nism has that as a as a key feature within their belief that they

call it the pool they actually call it bullets were all born I just slipped my mind now they have a word for it but it's that God they God has two sons one is evil one is good and they have a description that is finer than the finest here and sharper than the sharpest blade and that when this world ends they're both sons the demigods if he like will be asked to go past this bridge and the evil one won't be able to and he will fall into the fire this seems to be exactly the same things that same thing that Muslims seem to have

misdescription they seem to have inherited it snow in the Koran anything like this the Quran doesn't seem to speak of anything to do with a bull a bridge of called the Sirat or and it seems to if you look at the description of the Quran of the judgment and things like this it seems to and go against that it doesn't you know there's nothing like this another test after a test for example most Muslims do seem to have accepted this however I don't think it's a key belief I don't think it's from the main aspects of Islam once again I would

feel it's on that spectrum if you wanted to believe it you could if you didn't want to believe it you could I don't think this is established through what I eat arguments you couldn't establish this through conclusive because it's not in the Quran . you may take vague verses in the quran like what i'm minkum Illawarra do her like the verse in the quran and say oh this is talking about always this talking about death or is this talking about day of judgment always this talking about like what is it and some people say is talking about this bridge but that's just that's not conclusive evidence and you may take certain hadith with this same description that the

persian people had hundreds and hundreds like even a thousand thousands of years literally before islam i mean they're like you're talking almost in the time of Abraham just after that really this this understanding of Sirach of Zarathustra and this teaching that there will be a finer than the finest here and sharper than the sharpest played a bridge that you have to cross so I think it's interesting that did we inherit this through the people through local culture and then it got codified into Creed so that's an interesting

discussion in itself ok cool people I hope that's of some help I'm gonna leave it to it inshallah if you do like to reach out to me message me Facebook Instagram mostly I believe snapchat mount 2014 YouTube people subscribe to my youtube channel because I'm always cutting out clips and getting them put onto YouTube for greater benefit so do inshallah subscribe to that share it amongst the love and get it out there is the punishment of the grave like purgatory

in Catholics Catholicism so you pay for your sins actually you see this is the contradiction those who believe in the punishment of the grave do not say it's a wiping of your sins and they just say it's a suffering which doesn't make much sense because you're not allowed to be punished before you you have judgement and then some people say well maybe it's not an actual punishment but it's just a fear and which is a more kind of at least an understandable argument if you're part 6

of the Jakub short yeah cool what kind of a surname is that CH o UD yeah if I read that out there's gonna be another scandal people are gonna go yeah da Mosta gallium Buddha yeah well if I do I

do you know as it says on some of the rickshaws in Pakistan he says imitate the Bhaskar like if you if you either overtake me yeah bird Oscar or just handle it deal with it that's all so Leland William cook a theorem somebody try and tell us his Haram - laughs no that verse was talking

about a specific C this is it when people misuse the Quran to control other people because they can't take other people being happy so whenever people do this what we ought to do is in response to that is to laugh right because first of all you're trying to distort the Word of God because that's not what the quran is speaking about the quran they speaking about those people and the al-qaeda and the afterlife and it's not even and speaking about the loss and it's not speaking about in life general you should be miserable you should cry

go around crying what kind of a God just wants you to go around crying but I would be crazy I'd be very emotional I think you're worshiping I don't think it's god you're worshiping I think you've got hold of some of those Bollywood directors by mistake

some of the emotional ones check girly or is it a law is it somebody else you worshipping so people Muhammad was seeing Han Oh must eat that musty Sahib are you online ah da ba da people must evil seems in the house I'm Thomas Island those of you who don't know him should reach out to him inshallah connect awesome share from America sure kebab Ahmed is in the house an

asylum become animal silent spider-man g-force shed Muslims focus more on the Divine Love why not I would say more than that even focus on human love huh on humanity on compassion what does it mean to be a human being focus on that that is what Islam came for it's amazing you know we've like the real thing the in Sarnia we've forgotten and people today what are you laughing you should be crying mmm

oh and we had you know people are such negative people we had this even with Sheikh Hakam by the way we had these people our good old friend Mulvey sam'l sam'l writing pages of a refutation against chef Akram saying he should be boycotted from attending a Hatem on Darla Luca I mean for God's sake get a life people are inviting him and he wrote this whole four pages which I can't really go

through now but it would be worth seeing some points he wrote these several pages saying right check this out people you [Laughter] know I open this and I think yeah this this what's happened me have a long history anyway those who know know the only way this is most easily salmon you know salmon in Arabic slang today means somebody who is gay in camp the only way

to ensure success in this dunya and the acid sounds like a Tablighi Jamaat behind is by adhering to the Deen the Salaf have gone through great pains pains to ensure this beam is accurately preserved so this is basically from the 19th century onwards the AMA has been ravaged by modernist thought but landed the urban vegan huh 19th century to what

is this one salmon what do you say Sam is deep-ando Lamar also 19th century this one