Recordings › Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth
Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 72
wudhu wudoo wuzu ablution al-wudu wudhoo salaah namaz salaat namaaz as-salah al-salah salawat hadeeth ahadith ahaadeeth hadis hadees ahaadith saheeh sahih hadith saheeh hadith sound hadith tafsir tafseer exegesis tafasir tafaseer madhab mazhab school of law madhahib mazahib madhaahib combining prayers jam' al-salah jam bayn al-salatayn jam' al-salatayn malik ibn anas malik bin anas imam maalik imam malik ibn anas imam bukhari sahih bukhari saheeh al-bukhari saheeh bukhari imam al-bukhari imaam prayer leader ramadhan ramzan ramazan ramadaan eid eid al-fitr eid al-adha eid ul-fitr eid ul-adha eidul fitr eidul adha bakra eid bari eid choti eid udhiyah qurbani qurbaani udhiya udhiyya kurbani masjed masaajid masajid shari'ah shariat sharee'ah maaliki malikite malikiyyah maliki school hanafite hanafiyyah hanafi school ijmaa consensus fatwah fatawa fatwaa fataawa legal opinion hukm ahkam hukum hukam ahkaam haraam forbidden mubah mubaah mandub mandoob mustahabb mustahab fard farz faraid fard ayn fard kifayah fardh sunna sunnat sunan prophetic practice bid'ah bida biddat bidaa dalil daleel adillah adilla riba ribaa sood usury da'if dhaeef zaeef da'eef da'if hadith mutawaatir tawatur mass-transmitted imaan eemaan eeman sihr sihar jadu jadoo kala jadu sorcery shaytan shaytaan iblis iblees shayateen shayatin satan jahannam jahanam jahannum al-mahdi imam mahdi mehdi al-dajjal dajjaal ad-dajjal koran quraan al-quran sura soorah surat suwar soora aya ayat ayaat aayah aayat sahabah sahabiyyah sahabiyat khalifah khalifa caliph khulafa khilafah khilafat khilafa rashidun khulafa al-rashidun khulafa ar-rashidun rashideen khulafa-e-rashideen madinah al-madinah madeenah yathrib shiah shiite shi'i twelver ithna ashari salafis salafism wahhabi wahabi wahhabism sufis sufism soofi 'alim aalim ulama ulema ulamaa shaykh shaikh sheik shuyukh shaykhs umma ummat jihaad mujahid deobandis deoband nikah nikkah nikaah nikah nama nikahnama hijaab hejab hijabi zina zinaa zinah fornication in shaa allah inshaa allah alhamdulillah alhamdulilah al-hamdu lillah alhumdulillah alhamdulillaah subhan allah subhaanallah subhanallaah bismillah ir-rahman ir-rahim bismillahir rahmanir rahim bismillahi bismillah al-rahman al-rahim as-salamu alaykum assalamu alaikum assalamualaikum salaams salam alaykum wa alaykum as-salam greeting niyyah niyah niyat niyya niyyat al-din ad-deen ad-dinvideo · 2:23:17 · 11,000 views · 3 Apr 2018 · Open on YouTube
Transcript
machineauto-transcribed, may contain errors · source: youtube auto · click a time to seek · dotted terms open the glossaryall right all we life let me just check share this if it gets mm-hmm [Music]
right there is just sure this right people are I just waiting for this too just sharing this if I can
type right so I believe we alive that's what I'm talking about so
push this up my don't hopefully that should be okay all right people all right so in hamdulillah wa kafa what salat wa salam o allah rasool mustafa well I live at the live in October woman behold our method or be a 30 al madina toughie Bovard for salaam la here an alone anima sodom become more heaven people for bienvenidos a todos me hen tell us what I'm talking about
Ansel Adams la Gotham right so we've got Imam zubayr yousufzai Saab in the house animus Island Imam sub animus on our own hit al-maliki all the way from London doing it doing it people along was silent no more silent oh my my glasses I left him here my props I wound up so many people I think with that people are like I love it I tell you I love it
there's nothing quite like whining some of these people of he makes my day huh not this not my mini baseball torch haha that's an awesome gadget though you gotta say yeah right so put that down this thing I'm not gonna be wearing this today but it's just in the background so I thought whilst people are logging in come on people I have a silent click like click share get this out there this has serious a very serious that's going down here very serious stuff as you can
see now I'm young come on click like you know what was hilarious was somebody said I recommended mom to to a friend who's never watched him and I said two ninnies an academic so the person says he tuned in for the first time and saw this and he said that back now my awesome shades prop shades maliki shades they're in the background right now how are we doing folks how are we doing
click like click Share do you have any advice for women seeking knowledge I have some advice insha'Allah let's let's take let's go through need to punish some Muslims tomorrow whoa whoa punish some Muslim whoa what's all this about people so it's been quite a week ah
where's my right fundamental people I've taken some questions put some down I'm just gonna I think I've left the book over there just one second one second yep I'm back I am back I am back yep so that's awesome right so how has this week been what a week people want a week I'm telling you
a lots been happening little l-hamd so great things got to take some time off to go on a a nice shopping spree nothing quite like nothing quite like consumerism huh so I I went off people had a quick flew off to Morocco bought some awesome books spent a few days there some of the book shops incredible the one in Rabat is awesome that a man if anybody's ever visiting Morocco
there's some one to in Marrakech in Fez quickly whilst people are tuning and I'll show you guys some of the books I've kind of picked up some interesting stuff this is basic Maliki some of you have probably been through even a shell I just picked it up what you know a small little thing I've got many other copies of it but this isn't a solo fit book on the Maliki mother by chef and 40 muhammediye he and ruler T something I've got anyway before but I just thought as a small as a small kind of booklet book thing that's interesting
some research on on the whole Mahdi Jesus kind of the jar thing interesting kind of a critical review I thought will now be interesting hmm let me go through some of these although the author the same Buddha Mayer from my understanding does incline towards a second coming but he is quite critical on certain things so that I I liked I liked that I thought you know he's more transparent than your average kind of guy who's not
let me show you an example people here is a chart that the author has provided of all the hadith regarding the Mahdi as you can see this is to do with their coming a guiding rightly guided Imam all of these but there is AR the hadith of the eyewall medulla or all the fabricated and weak hadith regarding the Mahdi even though this this person isn't necessarily I don't think he shares my
opinion on this matter but still it's interesting that he was at least transparent to say well really the only hadith you're looking at all of that nature but anyway I thought that's worth it's interesting I'll kind of go through that I picked up some commentaries on this a commentary on mucosal Holly known as Jo ah here adora V Holly alpha del martes are by a chef Abdullah shamsid-deen great Maliki scholar at Italian Maliki who passes away in 942 he
jury which equates for about 1535 so that's something I picked up this is actually in seven I believe volumes it's coming to print recently I believe last year it's being brought back into print it's an awesome commentary on Sakhalin I so that's the whole seven kind of volumes of it so alright alright alright so here's another interesting commentary on the rice I love even Abizaid al Qaeda
money this one is done by the shareable Mohammed Al Julie the famous algae's Uli and sometimes very popular I mean there are a few Julie's but he is very popular so this country has just been brought into print I believe just last year at the at the earliest really so it's something which as soon as I this is a new a new kind of print avi although I think there was some copy copies of it around a few years back but
they've kind of reprinted the whole thing and I thought well I saw that I thought that sound that looks a bit interesting that was in four volumes so I thought definitely get my hands on but this is an interesting book it's basically a kind of comparison between the Hanafi student abu hanifa student imam muhammad and his transmission of the Mokpo and how it's had an impact and there's a follow-up so there's like an evaluation of his transmission with other transmissions and also how his his
his Moorpark kind of varies a bit it lacks about 700 hadith almost but how his transmission went on to influence certain suely positions but I thought that's interesting this is once again Malachy for those of you who have heard of the the koutoubia which is a poem by fatiha here ought to be this is a brief kind of commentary on a brief commentary is a stretch really just a an explanation of certain words but I thought interesante interesante and some hadith II stuff I thought well why not
there's the island I right people the island you know the hidden faults in hadith so this is by even ABI Hatim arrazi who is asking this in two volumes gettable island where he's asking his father and a boozer drazi two major scholars of hadith on certain hadith that are problematic and things like that right people those of you who are into Maliki thick alright this is what I'm talking about there's a book this has been recently brought into print it's al Shani abul
abbas al al shiny the Mugabe scholar passes away in the 9th century history his commentary on the rissalah so managed to get hold of this this is in it's on the reseller aim you're looking at it people you're looking at it that's what I'm talking about all those volumes right there so that's I believe eight volumes right so some interesting stuff just put those down over there right so as you can see I've been busy with certain things this is a
book in strange hadith and the kind of problematization of of them so I thought well they'll be interesting especially with a lot of the research I've got going on nowadays and this was an interesting this is an old book by a feeble birth daddy on how to rewire is done so these are all interesting and they tie into a lot of the research I've got going on but some interesting things are worth sharing let me share some gems that I've been taking a look at some of these books this is another book of Omaha tomorrow z is a great Moorhead
discolor and hidden kind of defects of hadith so let me you see here's a hadith I'll share a gem with you there is a hadith the even Hussein has in Asahi and it's also transmitted by Abu Dawood from somebody called Hari j-pin a Mossad who transmits and the chain goes on to obey even a cab that the Prophet said in Le Ludo is Shaitan and Shaitan and that the Buddha has a specific Shaitaan dedicated to it and his name is will Han Fattah
who was was Alma so be careful of this OCD kind of behavior with of what was this whispers now many people may have heard this hadith okay now this hadith about there being a devil for wood and his name is will Han they are all transmitted I have pretty much through this person how digital Musab and and he is heavily criticized so so in this the ll of Omaha tomorrow Z he he speaks about this and he says that la a selfie
Heidelberg and in a v-shape vihari jaleesa Bilka we're in the sabina what are followed Norma bark so there's nothing authentic in this entire chapter from the Prophet so if you hear of a hadith saying that is a devil to do with what's wasa when you're doing hoodoo beware of it there's no no such established hadith like that this is the other book of ll hidden kind of defects in hadith by the great Mahad it's once again if not be hard him the son of ABI Hatim who's asking his father Abu Halim and abuzer aha
what's interesting here is I thought out of sheer a hadith I was just taking a look you've probably all met many of you may have come across this heavy now it's interesting that there's a hadith the abuzer are highlights that mama transmits from zaharie from anis that when the Prophet so this is a hadith Zoey is transmitting from anis that when the Messenger of Allah passed away here took the tail out of the arabs a passed they became apostates they abandoned the deen of islam Cipolla
abu bakr in namikawa rasul allah salallahu alaihe salam o bakr said Omer to a new party learn as hata Allah la ilaha ilallah the whole bakr said I heard the Messenger of Allah say that I have been commanded to fight people until they declare la ilaha illa llah what's interesting is this is Zoe transmitting this from Ana's a boozer us then highlights the hiya hatta he says had a rotten enema hua Zhu and ready to live now have the live not but that Zoe is actually transmitting
this hadith from obey the light not the live notes BA from Abu Huraira and who is then saying it's from the Prophet this is not from Ana's and that is a mistake and this is a that people have transmitted or whether Zoe has done this or people have claimed to have done this from Zoe it is not true this is not from anis so it's interesting how these hidden defects and they you've got a sound chain from Zoe going to anis and it was authorized saying actually that's wrong it's this hadith is not even from Ana's this hadith is actually from above or
Allah and obeyed the lies transmitting it from him and so he's taking it from him so it's interesting I thought I'd highlight some of these points some of these gems that I'd kind of come across here's another interesting thing this is a book I picked up about even a cthey evaluating and criticizing other officer in that went before him those of you that have just tuned in if you click like if the click share share this link get it out there so I was just going through some of the verses that even I could see a kind of criticizes about other people and there was an interesting verse I thought well let's
it's it's it's an interesting kind of methodology really that you see this verse in the Quran in surah maidah that Allah says yeah you're latina a man who let up too loosely de wa antum harem do not go hunting walls you're in a state of a harem allah is addressing people woman cat allahu whoever does however hunt and killed a an animal woman Katella home income motor a midden intentionally for Jessa who mr.
McCotter laminin on a Yakima be Heda were Adeline and so on so whosoever does do that for man cut allahu minkum MO tommy them figure sir but as their own then a person has to give a similar kind of animal as a sacrifice mr. McCotter la mañana what's interesting is Allah uses the word Mata ammidon whosoever kills and whoever who so ever hunt intentionally so Thomas who's the great the great yemeni kind of much the head of his time and the student or even at bass he says
that this is does not apply to anybody who hits like ends up hunting by accident as in if you let's say you were shooting an arrow and you happen to just kill a prey as opposed to intentionally because allah says oh man cut allahu minkum what I made an whosoever did that motor on me then intentionally now the interesting thing is the evening Athene and most of the scholars reject Thomas's reading of the Quran here of this verse and they say it doesn't make a difference whether a person was
forgetful or intentional or whatever if he kills an animal he will have to give a sacrifice and implica theory is also criticizing the who's the famous tab for that view here it's interesting you see because that in my understanding taboos is spot on because he that's in that is the reading of the Quran that is a laws actual words a lie saying whosoever does this intentionally and even though this must Allah may not be so much of a big deal today with hunting but it's interesting how people read into the
Quran then superimpose their understanding on everybody else that's an interesting thing really to soul - I'll share one two gems that I've come across I've only purchased these books in this last week read and this this week gone so and just got back yesterday but there were some things I was taking a look at they're worth sharing this is the jaw here that I was speaking about by a titania barbed Allah Tata they're interesting must align here which is in the most assertive Halil look at that people inspiration from
lefties er life is a great big canvas throw all the paint you can at it Allah that was by a left-handed person that's from my desktop you know my calendars left right so it's an interesting must Allah hear about human beings if they pass away do they become impure and were a Dominion that they remain pure according to ignore passing womanish are burned web not will hack him and that is their understanding woman Abdus Salam and this is what the Madonna reads according to the Maliki
method although some Maliki's like salmon and others said that a person if he dies he becomes impure but that's not the general understanding and even a ruched also goes on to say that a person remains pure and Khalil hi and that was what called the yard goes with and many of the Iraqi Maliki's but what's interesting is Halil highlights how there's no distinction between a Muslim he kind of alludes to no distinction between a Muslim and a kaffir I thought I'd just share that go far all Muslim we are pure as human beings and that is obviously a from the most a sort of
kalila go into school of Medina so it's interesting I mean these were some of the I fought out just whilst people were tuning in go over some of these animal sattell and those of you just tuning in click like share get this out there people this is another copy of the morph apart a book on the objectives of the Sharia by the legend and dawn the Maliki dawn from Muslim Spain Imam a shot to be his morphic art okay the first really the first real major book on the objectives of the Sharia she's authored about 700 years ago so I
picked up a nicer kind of plain I have to say I do like these kind of these creamy yellowy kind of pages they this saw that they have a they're softer on the eyes but here's something I thought is worth sharing and he obviously is the Malachy dawn and it's interesting he's discussing here there's a section where he's discussing about if the Quran has an apparent clash with a Sunnah with a hadith and what should our
approach be but it's interesting the hidden highlights he says is that what my alumnist a little hubber Alaka editing Pattaya if this hadith does not fall back on a clearly a clearly established principle I cut ie a conclusively established principle of Islam and then if it doesn't and it clashes with the Quran fala put them in tock demon for an Al Habib a clock there is no question that we give preference
to the poor man it's interesting right so that's that's interesting how we speak but what's more interesting Allah Allah you thought I was gonna stop me you underestimate me people have asked what about motor water honey look at what you man shot to be safe he says what even for in namazu kerim into water
Abba in nama Valley Farm Imran J is the he says that that this is as to what has been mentioned about water about having a hadith which a motivator for in the Mahalo Holly boo the majority of all of this discussion is follow am it is simply hypothesizing and matter that may be possible they're just playing with clues abilities well unlike a lot AG to fill a bar in a Booya
man you could orbit waturi he alas a man LLL walk up he says and you will hardly ever find anything that could be called motor water from the a hadith of the Prophet till his age which is eight hundred years after the Prophet he's saying well battle math kuru fill masala bathroom fury water since the discussion in this is a discussion in something that hasn't actually happened but it's a hypothetical often are Darrell Walker or if they claiming it happen but it was so great when he says wala Habiru Jade Wafi
Allahu Alem he says and there is no real benefit in this discussion Allahu Alem Don's people Don's of the school of Medina right so that's all of that I did pick up for the hanafis out there I picked up a copy of Sula Selassie over canister see I thought can't leave out the hanafis now what's interesting is I wanted this discussion but it seems to be missing in all the copies I was looking online as well where he's
speaking about the rewards of the hadith of the Sahaba who you accept unquestionably so he mentions you except people like he's going to say they the minister bit the whole of irrational Abdullah Abdullah Thomas told all these people but then he says what am I Ruth will ideality what Bob T will hate as to those companions who were known for for memorizing and stuff like this Kabir Herrera were on a signal Malik and rowdy Allah and Madero mami Manish Sahara be sober who's and then all of a
sudden the discussion seems to change I mean that's what it unless people are claiming this discussion because all of a sudden he's then talking about puberty and stuff like this and mmm something I'm missing in these texts but it's interest because the hanafis are some of the early scholars who were very critical of a lot of the hadith that were being transmitted in the name of a rider of the law so I thought I'd get that but it seems to be still missing there seems to be a page that somebody has ripped out in that but anyway I thought I'd share that with you guys
some of the things I've been up to how's it all going man let me just check I'm just trying to alright god damn there you go oh that's done oh ha just trying to block anybody trolling he's gonna get blocked people it's gonna get blocked so I can see I've really annoyed a hell of
a lot of people huh let's talk meet I'm awake Elizabeth Donna Gyu he's saying I'm awake let's talk meet ha it's all about the carnivores the findings people the fangs he didn't have a job I've got no idea what you're talking about what's the ruling on TV TV is fine I mean just don't try to eat it I don't know what else anybody could say right
so it seems I've it seems I've upset a few people as always do you know right so guys this a I think it's worth highlighting naturally every week I'm upsetting some people but that's just standard I mean would I if if a week passed by and I wasn't upsetting people I mean is is that even me am I even myself am I possessed Allah
Allah somebody's asked a question Feroze has asked a question do you believe integer you know this is an interesting question because this question is built upon a presupposed belief okay it's interesting because it's built upon a presupposition okay because you are asking about something already having a belief construct whereas if I gave you a word of something that you've never heard of
let's say or if I just gave your term let's say you have heard of it but it's something like if I say the do you believe in the embezzler somebody who embezzled or do you believe in the like what are we talking about or do you believe in so you see when you say the jar you you're not starting from Ground Zero you're starting with beliefs that you already carry I've told people before that jail as the Antichrist is a myth does not exist in Islam the word
the jail does come in several hadith they all the the hadith that it comes in you've got now how do you look at these hadith I've told you before this ties into the topic of Jesus is Second Coming the Mahdi and this Antichrist if that's what you want the term to mean at the jar because the gel it means deceiver it could be referring generally because in some hadith it comes on its own my approach to this is any of these hadith that are linked to each other are all
unacceptable and that is clear so there is no Antichrist that is coming that he's got this kind of devil child that he's gonna come and try people and that is absurd that God would test people like that because that you see that is to call God an unreasonable God and the kind of sadist a sadistic kind of the God of the Old Testament kind of this sadistic so basically Allah never gives you proof to believe in him but he he told you to just believe in him based on reason and perception and look around
him but then he sends a devil child which has immense powers of defying the laws of nature and bringing the dead back to life and basically giving you proof so God tells you go look in the earth and look for proof of me and then he sends a devil child who will have shown you proof and then if you follow that proof you get done that
has to be the most absurd that has to be the most absurd suggestion that Allah is gonna say to you look follow me based on proof that's like I say to you right okay right somebody's gonna come to you and they're gonna tell you that they're from me and if they tell you to go with them go with them and then somebody comes and they take you and then I say ah but why did you go you are supposed to know that that was a test so this is absurd right you're supposed to believe
based on your evidences then God sends a devil child who has all these evidences and then but if you follow the perception what you're actually seeing seeing is believing they're para crear and espanol you know you seeing is believing so you see this you believe it and now you get punished for doing that that's that kind of a God is just a sadistic God who's just twin with people just trying to torture them it makes it completely clashes with the concept of ar-rahman and ar-rahim so no we don't
believe in I don't believe in these kind of things you want to believe in them you can believe in them it doesn't bother me people out there believing in the subjet e monster and the bogeyman and it doesn't bother me what people believe but no to me Allah is not this kind of sadistic God who kind of toys with people and tricks them and tries to trip them up and stuff like this right so that's not right okay somebody's posted a link I'll comment on that in a moment so and anybody who's trolling spamming they're gonna get blocked right
so so that's as far as so the Dajjal if you have if you start from Ground Zero where you have a preconceived idea of the Antichrist you will then look at these hadith and say well okay anything that's linked with Jesus and this and their problematic and I'll show that in the future when I do my course on the Jesus on the second coming of Jesus being false but the the Dajjal hadith are either referring they're either referring to the Shaitaan in some narrations where Elijah where the Prophet has mentioned the term that John the imposter the deceiver who is the
devil is the deceiver or maybe because I find that hadith interesting that a time will come that every prophet warned his Ummah about this time with deception the deceptive will be so powerful what is this deceptive and that's just my take I think maybe it's to do with that we are embarking on an age where the virtual is becoming imperceptible from the real and it's becoming more real than the real that's just my take I don't think I don't say if you have to take that you can just chuck all of these hadith out or you can just consider those to do with the devil .
it's as simple as that right now right I request you to study maulana modu d for good guidance yeah sure insha'Allah if it's relevant I'll listen to anybody right now there was a I'm getting a lot of these quash I don't know why Facebook has updated something but I don't seem to is it possible to prove through empirical evidence that our law exists no it's not possible we can't prove that Allah
exists not prove meaning impurity proof proof can me like you could say the term proof or proof has has a general understanding and I suppose you can loosely use the term like oh I've proven this to you you know by just debating it with you I've proven I don't mean in that kind of proof I suppose you rationally I do believe that it's rational to believe in a creator that's my understanding I don't think it's an irrational belief or an unreasonable belief to hold belief to hold at all
now as to can you empirically prove that there is a God no you cannot and then it would be useless to have faith and hence there is there are these miracles don't work the way people want them to work because then there would be no test of faith it would just be empirical data so people you know we're hooked up on miracles we have this kind of obsession about miracles and you know Jesus is gonna come this is a miracle or this is gonna happen it's a miracle and everybody just wants supernatural events to happen but they don't happen and this
is why they keep getting ridiculed by non-muslims and atheist so my suggestion is to strip the this folklore and superstition away from Islam go to the pure understanding of Islam and keep that as two things mentioned in the Quran stories in the Quran you have to remember when Allah mentioned in the Quran about stories there was an objective why he mentioned them the objective was that you take a kind of a lesson from them it was not about the kind of miracle per se now Allah was not
trying to teach biology when he was teaching a story he was not trying to teach physics wasn't trying to teach geography so you don't make your lessons out of those stories you take what Allah said and you keep it to what he has said you can speculate that's up to you but what he hasn't said don't add you can say this is my interpretation I'm inferring this from what Allah has said but don't say Allah has said that that's different so Allah when he speaks of certain events that were miraculous that
appear miraculous he was the the purpose was law was not mentioning much detail he was just mentioning something so let's give an example of people have asked me the staff of the stick of moses musa alehsalaam and they've said that why you know this when he threw it became a snake that's one way to read the quran but when you look at you see this throwing the stick occurs in three places in the quran okay
now in one it says find out what bernama be it's whoa it's a snake but in the other mentions the same incident fayette at a zoo Karajan it is shaking as though it is a snake so it's interesting now in one verse Allah says it as a snake in one he says it was shaking as though this was Musa stick as though it was a snake now how you take this is up to you do
you believe that Musa stick Ali Salaam became an actual snake many Muslims may believe that one verse of the Quran clearly doesn't say that it states that it was as though it was like a snake now in my understanding that it was not a snake okay when he threw the thing it was not a snake but it was described as though it was a snake and what was the purpose behind this because let's look at the objective of the Quran let me explain the the whole story you see in
the time of faroan a magic was added somebody just laughing his head off if you don't mind at least allowing me to finish what I have to say you know before you just continuously non-stop laugh your head off right so in the time of Moses magic was the thing okay it was the thing that these people it was seen as the elite that these people had these special powers through the gods now I want you to understand something
how were the magicians pulling off their magic because Allah whose is the same a similar kind of verse to describe the Mystics that was Satoru our Yunnan knows that when they threw the sticks you hate yellow Olay him it would appear to people as though they were snakes how was that happening you know if I throw a stick it doesn't appear like that so how was this happening now many of them of a serene have written that they were using certain kind of compounds and chemicals and many of them are Syrian right that they were using things like Quicksilver
like which in Arabic they called zip buck like mercury now these kind of things were reacting to heat so hence in the Quran when they say to Musa that we will have a magic showdown they specify the time and Allah quotes that in the Quran they say well moreda come doha that you have to meet us that when when when it's early just after sunrise when it's early morning so the sun is shining down now was this just coincidental that they mentioned that time many of them
first Syrian say no it was in fact you can read up the toughest e they say it's because they needed that light to make the mercury react the Zipit which was in their sticks so they would fill their sticks with certain things and when they would throw it how they exactly did this I don't know but this is what a lot of Memphis sitting do right that day that the chemical the compound they had within thee was reacting with the light and that's why Allah mentions the light of day being important for them now we see when they threw their sticks people get because
losses was terrible nests that they people was a Hawaiian and NASA was terrible moon people became frightened the people had fear that Wow they were terrified that the these are actual snakes they thought they were actual snakes everybody accepts that the sticks were not snakes we accept this that they're magicians their sticks when snakes are lime self says but the people were sterile a boom they were petrified Allah mentions was star had warned from Rob from to be terrified because they thought they were snakes
now musa alehsalaam is taught by Allah how they have done this he is divinely - now the thing is the magicians didn't know like a pot outside their circle nobody knew how they used to do that people believed they were actual snakes that they could turn them with the power of the gods of the pharaoh gods but moosa aleihsalaam is inspired and put by allah how these people are doing this
trick now Allah mentions that he is then told to throw his stick does he come across this compound this chemical this does he come across this Allahu Alem I would believe that he does Allah teaches him these things hence he throws it and he is petrified but then Allah says in the same verse get you a handy see his hand which would have made contact with this touch place it what mom who in a generic the place your hand where some were under your either under
your armpit what you side with this warmth and then remove it and it mentions that is hand lights up and if you read what I'm officer in say they say it would to on me no I share that Rays would were coming out of it and then Allah mentions mean really soo without there being any harm now in this understanding you see there's the great Sufi scholar my Kadena Bernardo bina he says a similar thing he says that when moosa aleihsalaam met the
magicians and they threw their sticks and then moosa threw his stick and it appears either as a snake or according to some people it becomes a snake but Allah says that when he threw this that for either here tell a fool my offical telephone it take consumes it consumes now it's interesting how you read a lot this is a tack kun eat Allah says tell careful Maya fickle now it's interesting how you read this because this can be
read in two ways according to the Arabic language either it ate their sticks that's one understanding in eight districts or the other understanding it ate they lie it exposed their lie now what he Edina Berube he highlights as well that if moosa aleihsalaam threw his stick and his stick his snake just outperformed the snakes then there would be no purpose to this because all that would prove to the people is that his magic is more powerful than their magic
so it reinforces a superstition so all it takes now is another person to come and outperform mooses magic you see because if what we're doing is look those people have brought falsehood which is more deserving of a prophet to outperform them or to expose it as falsehood so what Mohideen apna are we highlights is that when he threw his stick his stick exposed how they were doing the trick so people for either
here telephone my offical it consumed their trickery their falsehood and people realized that they don't have no power from the gods that was just trickery they would just be witching us they don't have any true power of the gods now you tell me which one of those two narratives be fits the story does is it one that moosa aleihsalaam comes and outperforms them in magic so he does a greater trick than
them let's say this is in the to the eyes of the of the spectators so they did a trick remember the spectators think these snakes are real because law mentions that was started they're petrified they terrify they see the snakes and they think whoa now moosa aleihsalaam comes and performs a greater snake trick then this is to the eyes of the spectators so they say this is narrative one they say oh we're gonna go with him because his trick is better that doesn't sound like a like a divine
thing to do that doesn't sound like that just reinforces the narrative of wherever you see magic just go with the stronger magic now no I'm not saying moosa aleihsalaam claim to do magic but in the eyes of the spectators because they're doing this for the spectators remember that they say we're going to gather people and do this as a show as a display so to the people Allah mentions the people see the magicians as real and they see now losers thing as real so if moosa according to the spectator who's
not a believer he sees lots of snakes whoa a more powerful snake whoa okay I'm gonna go with that one because it's stronger that doesn't reinforce though he that just simply shows well it seems to encourage a superstitious culture like okay just go with whoever's magic is better so if after moosa aleihsalaam dies another person comes there's even better magic just go with them or is it more befitting that moosa aleihsalaam exposed their magic and showed the people that these are just liars they
have no connections with the gods that they speak of that they gods do not help them it is a lie that to me sits more right with my understanding now you can take the other understanding you can say no I want to believe that Musa al-salaam in the eyes of the spectators did a greater magic which but we believe that was real though and the first one wasn't real but to the spectators it was all magic now they just followed him because his magic was his magical event was more powerful than the other magical event so
this seems to follow a doctrine of mighties right in a very kind of the argument of a very kind of priests but I mean a philosophical argument that is well known about my teas right especially argued by people like through Symmachus and stuff like this from way before now from the time of Socrates that might is always right you always go with mind now I mean you can take that approach and many Muslims do I see that as naive personally but I mean they can take that hamdulillah I mean I don't say
people have to believe what I'm saying to me that's just a superficial reading of the Quran because to me that just reinforces the other message it just shows you're one was just stronger so we should just go with you but if tomorrow if after you die somebody else comes and does something stronger we should just go with them so and this is what Imam Malik said you see this is the interesting thing not that he said this about the magic stick but he said that when he was debating somebody and they said look let's have a debate and he said well why and they said well if you beat me I'll follow you if you if if I be here you follow me and he said well what if tomorrow somebody else
comes and beats us both we then follow him I mean truth ought to have consistency to it so that's my reading of of this but I mean just to explain so when people ask about things like look essa aleihsalaam his birth I have highlighted that look when it comes to nobody listen in the Quran the apparent reading we have to understand that there's many readings in the Quran many things in the Quran that nobody seems to take literally okay sorry most Muslims there's some things which nobody takes literally like let's say
when Allah says he placed his hand over their hands no but he takes that literally then there's many majority of the Muslims do not take the ACTRA where Allah is describing body parts for himself to be literal nobody takes I mean from the majority of the Muslims which is there are Chinese and the Matsui these and so on don't take that literally they say no this is just idiomatic usage and so on and then I ask you when it comes to the birth of Jesus peace and blessings be upon him nobody takes the exact reading of the Quran literally so it's interesting because
the exact reading reads that whoa Maryam Allah the asanas for jihad for NASA nathie that Maryam who who preserved her private parts and we blew into her private parts that God blew into the private parts of Maryam aleihsalaam nobody takes that literally so I mean and then the other verse that speaks about her birth about this birth of Jesus Ali Salam speaks about an angel coming in the form of a man and then he blew into her into her and then many of the verse 18 so he blew him from her
blouse or Hebrew blew in from her private parts they write they write things like this and so no no and he says Tom asta la ilaha Bashar and Surya came as a full-fledged man and and then appears two hands so I can grant you a child this is the reading of the Quran nobody takes this literally so don't throw this at me trying to say oh well you know nobody's taking these things literally if you did a lot doesn't go too much into detail about this all we know is Allah
mentioned certain things he mentions now Allah never refers to by the way a lot never refers to Mary Maryam as the Virgin Mary in Islam we never refer to her as the Virgin Mary this is a Christian thing right we in the Quranic never mentions her as Virgin Mary right so I'm just saying that there's many things we have inherited from Christianity now the birth of Jesus aleihsalaam even when it's interesting even when Allah when some of the the people are asking the Prophet about they're trying
to debate with the Prophet Allah responds in a riddle he doesn't respond clearly he doesn't say he says the similar to Dove him is like that of Adam leaves it now people can infer from that what they like but Allah hasn't said Allah could have just very clearly said yes it's like this this this but he doesn't he say it's the similar to dislike Adam now you could say yes but either never had a dad but then denied them have a month so and you could say yeah but that's not what he's talking about how do you know because a lot just
responded in a riddle he didn't respond with with the exact verbatim thing so the general understanding that Muslims have is that okay there was some miracle ISA Ali Salam is born the general understanding is that okay this is without a father now from a scientific perspective you would look at things like parthenogenesis where we where a species does self reproducing this does happen in several species in in certain lizards and certain things up until just a few decades ago we didn't
even know that ever occurred in birds and it does happen pathogenesis and that's a perspective that somebody could take the main thing is that it's not something that was so such a big deal the interesting thing is that look whether Jesus whether Jesus was born of a father or wasn't born of a father makes no difference to Jesus's method and message according to Muslims it doesn't the general reading of the Quran does imply that he was born without a father that's the general reading implies that although he doesn't say very clearly explicitly it implies that
now it makes no difference in Islam to to this miracle let's say impacting his message in any way contrary to what Muslims are making of it today and what's interesting is Christians themselves the early Christians didn't believe that Jesus was born miraculously that's interesting it was only two three hundred years after Jesus that that this became official doctrine so st.
Paul the Pauline church and all these people did not claim matthew in his gospel does not claim that jesus was had some miraculous birth and what's interesting is the jews never accused mary of adultery not in her time not in jesus's time they didn't that I'm aware of and I've neither did the Christian sources mention this the Gospels don't mention that she was ever accused if she was accused they would have killed her there's no two ways about that the Mary was such a weak character in front of the Jewish Council they would have killed her they I mean
they killed Jesus or allegedly they tried to kill Jesus and he was a man a woman if they if they wanted to kill a woman it was nothing in that day and age in that kind of a patriarchal society so it's interesting so I would say that look way Allah hasn't addressed things we leave them we just focus on the message right so yes now that is true somebody has mentioned she says well um iam sustantivo sure but then that's we see these three women in the Quran who are mentioned like this that they given glad tidings now the wording is a bit
different but Ibrahim ELISA Lam's wife is given the similar tract hiding that when she's at such an old age and she says how can I have a child when I'm at this old age but she still goes on to have a child as a career right so his wife goes on to same thing he says that well how can we have a child when my wife is barren and and the same thing the angel says while alive he wants to do something he says be and it is and he and she goes on travel child I'm not saying and the apparent reading of the Quran doesn't negate the apparent reading of the Quran does imply that
Jesus was born miraculously not explicitly but it does imply that so I and I'll go with that I have no objection in going with that but I'm just saying we're allies stopped we should stop don't overly assert things Allah hasn't said things like that in the Quran now you are just asserting them because of your own background because of your own thinking Allah does say if you want to assert everything Allah says that we blew into her private parts assert that you're not going to assert that are you so you're gonna say
well that's a metaphor well that's interesting so I mean my point is that you see this whole story this whole that is this description of events to do with miry it's mentioned certain details here there here there we can take it we can handle it I take the lesson from it that all-wise teaching you he wasn't trying to teach you Allah wasn't trying to teach you biology he wasn't trying to teach you historical facts as in all right people document this this this it was just trying to give a message of encouragement of how people have suffered previously and how this message has gone through different
tribes and different people right so I did say look parthenogenesis is one explanation I'm not saying look I'm just giving an explanation to start off with I have highlighted that we when it comes to Jesus and Mary are more influenced by Christianity than we think that's what I would say our understanding of Mary Mary is never referred to in Islam as the Virgin Mary yet many Muslims think of her as the Virgin Mary so it's interesting we have a lot of things in Islam that are taken from Christianity
they have crept in but the general understanding look I'm going where I'm going with the general understanding just in case people try to say oh you know mostly a belief isn't going with this I am going with the general understanding I am saying that the overall overall reading implies it does imply that there was a miraculous kind of birth it doesn't I don't feel it explicitly states it like that I think it in my understanding it implies it strongly so that's that's the difference but I don't think this is that important I to me this isn't that important this
is like whether if you're gonna if you're gonna tell me you know what was know ELISA Lam's father's name I don't know it makes no mess even has no difference no bearing on his message what was such-and-such father's name we don't know it doesn't really make a difference in my understanding it doesn't make a difference so moving on I don't want to focus too much on the whole Jesus you know ELISA Lam thing I do think we are heavily influenced here by Christian kind of thinking right so
what have we got people what have we got let's take a few of the questions let's take some of the right okay guys I think I need to clear up there's been a clip an audio clip going around right right somebody's asked about mid shop on the 15th of Shaban is that an innovation the 15th of Shaban is based on weak hadith it is not an established event in Islam according to the Quran and Sunnah if people want to practice it that's up to them Imam Malik didn't like these kind of
things he don't like innovations and that's my own understanding as well right so I don't I don't lean towards innovations I believe innovations in my understanding I believe them to be inaccurate incorrect and wrong but if people believed in them and wanted to do them I wouldn't condemn those people that's my approach so if people want to celebrate all these kind of ceremonies and make things up and do this kind of stuff you know it's this is like to me this is like folklore religion I I get that so I'm I'm just going to leave them
to it I it's not actually authentic Islam but it doesn't really make a difference as long as it helps those people at hamdulillah isn't it to me it's not a big deal I wouldn't condemn somebody if they were saying I want to believe in could be that I want to believe in celebrating moley's I want to believe in Hutton's and I want to do these things I want to go to shrines and I want to do all this stuff to me all this stuff is superstition its folklore it's it's not really authentic Islam in any way it's but if it helps people and they want to do it I'm not gonna condemn them although I am critical of this concept I
don't agree with it and I consider the the concept to be highly flawed and Imam Malik was actually very harsh against it because Imam Malik's words well whosoever innovates in Islam and claims it's a bitter heart has actually betrayed the Prophet Muhammad sallallaahu loser so he man Malik was actually very harsh although I wouldn't be that harsh to people because today it's too widespread so if you're gonna be that harsh people are gonna only react so I just leave people to it right okay so there's this they this audio clip voice not going around
let's lighten up the mood people it's lighten up the mood are you encouraging men to dress like I can't even see the rest of what you're saying Muhammad SAW get a life people need a life seriously I wonder what it's like I mean actually I be terrified to wonder what it's like to be in you know in the lives of these people the world must just be so miserable speaking of miserable people this of an
audio there's a voice note an audio kind of recording of me being shared where I'm criticizing the deal Bundy's so I thought okay I've got to speak about this since it's since it's it's viral on some groups so basically what this is is there's some guy from Canada I think I can't even really remember his name to be honest with you some miserable loser web Ria's right Oh old guy I think old age probably like maybe Adam our car
member may be approaching his 50s or something but some guy who a few years back was very friendly he kind of like got in touch with me on Facebook and supported some of my stuff must-haves for me to have been in touch with him and then he discussed certain things with me through facebook Messenger and me I have a habit I send voice notes a lot of the time so he obviously now becoming a passionate hatred of mine some of these people when they become haters some somebody commented on one of these things that they hurting like an
ex and that is so true they become obsessed with me and I I don't understand what I've done today I'm thinking for God's sake whoa it's a good thing it's a man if it's a woman then they will definitely be a scandal so this guy what he does is he gets my video of my audio recorder these kind of voice notes pieces pieces them together and he shares them now recently I think last week they've been going around on clips so this is probably a
few years this must be a few years old so I think this is like from because I listen to the voice note and it spoke of an event in 2016 so it must be from 2016 now first of all apart from the fact that I think whoever you are like whoever these losers are I think that's a very low blow anyway that you know you you share things which a private conversation but put that aside okay fine you want to share it share it but I think that in itself describes your character that you know that's a great character right so this so the thing is
now put that aside in this audio clip he's put my messages together so I had a listen and you can you can hear the interruptions and you can hear him typing and I'm responding and and and you could see that the clips kind of several clips put together because the audio recordings only allowed two 60 seconds so he's a he's kind of like he's had them all kind of patched together and it's probably about five probably four minutes long or something but in it I'm highly critical of the Deobandi kind
of movement within the UK and there's nothing and he who ever and these people are sharing this on all these whatsapp group so I've had people send it to me say oh my god I openly say this stuff you're under estimating me that inna scandal if you want a scandal come ask me if you're stuck on scandals this ain't no scam no for God's sake of course I think that the Obon the cult in in the UK is a court of course it is not every do Bundy is like that I accept that many do Bundy's I respect
but the movement as a whole in the UK is a code there's no two ways about it I mean it doesn't mean I don't like several people and I'm friends with them I openly say that that they mafioso so in this clip I'm saying that the mafioso they kind of emotionally blackmail their followers which they do with all this has autism and oh if you do this this is you're going to be Haram or you're a kaffir or if you if you don't do the clean if you don't follow us like this this is harm you're gonna go to hell you're gonna burn in hell over this if a woman travels 48 what she's gonna burn in hell some woman cuts her hair she's
gonna burn in hell if all this nonsense that they go on about nothing but utter nonsense and when it comes to justifying their own statements of the a Cabul of the open they bend over backwards and do like 10 backflips just to make sure their own Imams are ok you know it's like I quoted last week casa minha no Theresa saying that they can be another prophet after the Prophet but they'll defend that they'll they'll quote a Rashid at Montgomery be using disrespectful words towards the Prophet but they'll justify that but when it
comes to 48 miles a woman conk off god forbid god forbid that they should show any lenient any leniency or any ease to make life easy for people nothing but utter control-freak mentalities these people have got insecure and I'm being honest I say this stuff openly you know these people are sharing this this clip of mine as though I'm gonna be like oh I say this openly and I say only that these people will not be the future of Islam in the West and you can mark my
words people I tell you what llahi I can swear by a ma that what the teachings I'm giving you today about this theme being built on reason in two generations to come this will be the main understanding of Islam in the West but you mark what lie mark my words and history will be testament will will be a testimony that I said it when it was unfashionable to do so the difference that's the only difference I'm saying these things when it's
unfashionable to do so and history will bear testimony to that because this theme is built on reason the cobwebs off of indo-pak culture that these the open these umbrellas have wrapped around this religion needs to be stripped off it otherwise Islam will fall it will collapse it will be decimated by atheism decimated they can't stir these do Bundy's and Braley's and people can't stand up to atheism what Allah he III say that you could get one forget that I somebody
like just knowing the basic arguments like me I could easily destroy the Iman like that's how easy it is just some of these arguments I'm and this isn't a fraction of what atheists are showing on their websites and on YouTube then they say why have 20% of young Muslims left the Deen I say this openly there's no way in Britain that the future of Islam here lies with the schools like of the cults of the urban never he never ever yes i i i believe that the the urban school or cult will exist will continue to exist i don't think it will die down
but it will remain an isolated very kind of pocket community in in the years to come they're wrong children and the children of their children will forget renouncing the occult will renounce Islam so I'm being very open about these things and this doesn't just apply to do Bundy's applies to anybody with this Kurdish mentality this is going to go it has no role in the future of Islam especially in the West and especially in Britain so that's me just being honest okay and look the tub leakage 'martha
somebody said what about that I'm not saying that none of these people haven't done great things they've done great things even in that audio clip I mentioned that look many of my all-stars are the Bundys I mentioned that I have love and respect for many of these people I mentioned that they've done some great works and I acknowledge and I will a credit where credit is due they've done great things but the harm they're now causing in the UK with this kind of this version of Islam that belongs to the colonial age right and India colonial India does not belong
here so it's making Muslims suffer so that's what I'm kind of highlighting and I mentioned on there about them being homophobic now the background to that was during that when in in 2016 I was on this particular whatsapp group of the open the young graduate allama up and down the country somebody added me I hate these groups but they added me and I made the mistake of staying on for a while because I only get annoyed with these groups and they kind of put me on this group and so and they started discussing these things on this group
all these kind of things and and somebody ended up discussing homosexuality and these are all Alama mallanna's young mallanna's obviously much younger than me they're probably in their mid 20s they're freshly graduated and they must have been about fifty of them or under 50 maybe about 40 to 50 on this group now these people they the hatred that they were carrying so somebody discussed about non-muslims being homosexual and these Imams were saying things like oh the way you have to deal with them in Islam is we stand 10 feet or two three metres away from
sexuals and we do this and we do that and and I just said look listen guys look I get the fact I get the fact that this is Haram in Islam but why are you guys being overly insecurely homophobic what's this like we have to stand three meters away from them and you guys are Imams and you're teaching this to Muslims if that's the way of life while Imam Malik said Imam Malik said when he was asked about incest if that's their way of life that's their way of life we leave them alone if non-muslims are homosexual then homosexual is none of
our business you don't need to get so insecure about them being homosexual you need to stand three metres away from them because this is what islam teaches us no it doesn't slum doesn't teach you that why are you lying why you lie this is the thing this is the thing that why are you lying you guys this is poor scholarship poor college so that was my comment when I mentioned in this voice note about them being very homophobic so they got upset when I criticized them then I left the group hamdulillah
handling but I tell you people seriously this is the kind of bigotry that we find sometimes and you don't hate hate is some hate is found amongst all people but once some of the worst kind of hate is found amongst people of religion and it's an unfortunate because The Messenger of Allah came rahmatan lil island and the messenger of allah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said that i have been sent to perfect human
character sallalaho aleyh and yet we find and this is in different communities as well you'll see I just saw this clip a few days ago about a Hindu festival going on in India and you've got all these these people outside a mosque because it's I forgot which festival it was it was a particular festival dedicated to ROM and they were had bricks and they were stoning breaking the Masjid hailing you know yelling you know like she lyrium she dumb and they're yelling freedom and they kind of like stoning and breaking a
Masjid it's like what the hell is wrong with you people why do you have so much hatred like I don't get like see this is what I even in the name of Ron now I'm sure Ron why whoever but by their own writing by anybody's understanding would have been a person of upstanding who would have been a person of good character he would never have been happy with this kind of behavior you know yelling Sri Ram Shriram and stoning a Masjid breaking a must-read throwing bricks at Muslims and what is it and and Muslims they know
less that when they come on to this you know this this is no different you know this last week check this out people I had in my understanding it was done by Muslims they've reached out to the Daily Mail check this out the Daily Mail a right-wing bigoted fascist Islamophobic newspaper they've reached out to them to gun for me can you believe this so I I've seen that the day basically they and this my understanding was this was done by
Muslims that Muslims who took a disliking to me they found out that there's one or two Sharia councils in the UK that take a liking to some of my rulings that my rulings on saying things like that condemning emotional abuse because I've said very clearly that if a woman is upset in a relationship she has every right in Islam to leave that relationship whether the husband is happy or not she has that right and this is her right that Allah has given her nobody can take that from them I have given that fatwa I've given that ruling emotional blackmail is Haram
I have given the ruling that if a person is upset in a relationship right the man or woman they have the right to leave it just because she's a woman you can't hold her in religious marital captivity you can't hold it I've given this ruling if if a person took another wife now there is this this thing that somebody asked me as well that look in Islam does the husband have to inform now generally there isn't an obligation but if a person did have another wife and I'm not two down with all these kind of like secret kind of marriages and stuff but if a person let's say it wasn't a secret
marry let's say was an open marriage a person took another wife the first wife has the right to say I'm not happy I'm leaving she can apply for a thalaaq annette the lock must be granted I and I've given these rulings I've given the rulings that it's Haram to marry anybody under age any child in Islam it's Haram I've given this rule and one or two Sharia councils in the UK hamdulillah have taken a liking to that some of these rulings and I've acted have kind of incorporated these rulings and I wish all of them I wish not just these Sharia councils these must-reads all Muslims
incorporate this but just because of this my understanding is some Muslims sent they got the fact that okay because normally Sharia councils have such a bad reputation and they they sent they basically try to get the Daily Mail to come for me that I'm influencing some Sharia councils and Sharia councils obviously notorious and me I've got you know I've got a criminal past or whatever and in the past I you know I've been to prison or stuff like this what the hell like this is Muslims doing stuff like this and I stand by my
rulings I say that forget Sharia councils I want every Masjid every eylem every Muslim to adopt these rulings in condemning abuse in every they condemn Muslims condemn domestic abuse but they don't condemn the other kind of abuse they don't condemn emotional blackmail or forcing women to you know there are unhappy relationships holding on to them and stuff like this they don't condemn that and I wish they would say I stand but this was Muslims doing this can you see this they would go to a paper that hates Muslims to kind of get a story on me like it's like this
is the kind of bigoted religious bigotry I'm talking about it's amazing subhanAllah so this kind of stuff you you you get this stuff and but I mean this it's it's interesting and these people and some some of these people who hate me so much I don't even understand what I don't even understand why because at some point they were like they must have been in contact with it's like that person sharing this voice know what's the there's a poem for our Jam
say milli i'm jang ki tarah i'm you hear a decapitated even on kita that they meet me today like a stranger and I have been sitting watching their part her inugami order collegiate they have all ham same as rachel urato Baima no Katara
this is the this is this is the kind of stories that we get let's take some other questions people let's take some other questions what's what's going on Oh doc Imran is in the house people start I refer to him as a stud but doc Imran Khan who runs Metroflex gym in Birmingham I'd like to since I've just seen doc I'd
like to anybody by the way that needs gym tips that's your man right there get in touch with him with Metroflex but I'd like to actually say that this had a very you know an awesome kind of sit-down with with dark discuss certain things one interesting thing I'd like to also share is this thing on hey Jana it's very interested because I've been asked in the past about hey Jana bloodletting and stuff like this and I felt that look this is as if Nicole Doon and these great scholars in the past I've said this is not a son man it was just a practice at the time of the prophet of the Arabs what is interesting
is doc has with his medical background has conducted research into the kind of blood that has been extracted several samples are huge a substantial study sample and and had that kind of analyzed and evaluated for toxicity and seeing that there is really no kind of high level of toxins as opposed to normal blood and so it's interesting it's interesting and these things they've become a bit of a culture now this whole thing of hey JAMA and stuff like this and I'm not you know if people want to
do that I'm not condemning it maybe there's some I don't know maybe there may be some benefits or something but generally it doesn't remove toxins and stuff like this and it's not Sunnah in my understanding it's 48 the sample study was 48 samples people that were analyzed and I believe that doc has got a paper on that as well so you can reach out to doc and he'll probably share that insha'Allah with you guys but that's that was awesome and I think another interesting thing is that's worth mentioning his dark core you see during our discussion who mentioned something very it was an
interesting point and I want to kind of share that you see he said that look when you mention let's say minority positions like I mentioned minority positions on certain things is that he said that that's because he's got a background in the social sciences and medicine and things like this he said well that's like in academia when people will mention a let's say study and will say but there's a minority report that states this so you doing what is pretty much the same thing but in academia people know not to follow a minority
report so so this is so he so he asked you know so why wouldn't you see that equally kind of mirrored in religion so I thought that was a very good question because that's and it's worth discussing and that's in the social sciences I would totally agree because studies are based on objectivity so studies are based on things like you know blind studies you've got the kind of the study sample confounding
variables how did how can how was this study impacted was it you know one tail two tailed things like this a lot of things are taken into consideration when you're looking at studies now it could be that you've got a Minority Report but when you look at the study sample behind it it was weak and stuff like this right so you would say oh well that study sample was only four people and this was based on four hundred people so naturally that's weak but that's in science in religion it doesn't work like that because in religion most things are not based on objectivity unfortunately
some there is a bit of objectivity in there but it's based on things like power positions sectarianism it's based on getting control on claiming this to be that you are carrying out the work of you are you see it's not it's not to do with that kind of people of religion claim things they don't claim they do they say God I am carrying out the work of God here so it's not the same as the social sciences or as when you're looking at minority reports here in
religion how something became minority majority is not based on the study sample or whether it was qualitative or quantitative data or whether it was a double-blind experiment or whether it was one-tailed or two-tailed or the confounding elements it's based on how it got a democratic following how did more people end up following this and that is usually to do with power positions people they got in positions of power they influence things usually through politics or through other kind of power positions of social structure
it's not to do with the evidence so for example the Hanafy method spread not because people said I know the Hanafi method is so strong and this isn't an attack on the Hanafy method but I'm just being honest it spreads simply because every use of became the supreme judge of the Muslim world and appointed Hanafy judges everywhere so people just became Hanafy prior to him taking up that position abu hanifa was actually in fact I'll read out to you check this out people I read out to your quote which will shock you right that
this is an interesting quote and it will it will show you actually what I'm talking about check this out I was coming across this the other day somebody sent it to me is really interesting speaking about a Jamaa Oba Nevada who the sillustani abu dawood son of a great scholar yaa coleus ha de matakohe luna FEMA's a lot Anita alaihe malik washable washable well as there is abu al-hassan Ignace allah was her well Sophie an authority was Abu Muhammad ibn Hanbal was hobble he he said what he said to his students what
would you say about an issue in which Malik and his companions agreed upon sheriff a and his companions all agreed upon no sorry and all his companions agreed upon sophie-anne authority and all his companions agreed upon hassan in a Salah and all his companions agreed upon Ahmed even humble and all his companions agreed upon so they said yeah Rebecca let's economist Allah assume in haughty they said oh work ed he was a great Mahad did there is no mass Alamo sound than that and check what he said this is he said for Carla ha Allah a Coulomb he said all of these have said it tougher KU they
agreed that Todd Lily Abu Hanifah upon the misguidance of Abu Hanifa and look at that look check this out ignore Jared if natural bird brings this in his book about Abu Hanifah Linthicum ignore Jared was a great scholar leaning into a chef I thought and a great mom had this wrote in his book at the foul matru keen those who are rejected narrators he said I'm not man if no Sabbath abu hanifa and he's from the rejected and weak transmitters not man in Earth orbit above hanifa check this out Juno Haditha he won the
majority of his hadith is just an illusion and then he said waka deliver fee Islamic oh my god he said this and there's a disagreement about his Islam whether his Islam is valid or not now check that out that some quotes about Imam Abu Hanifa in his time he was deemed an absolute deviant by people Imam Malik although had respect for him but considered his ways unacceptable all the scholars considered his ways unacceptable now because he happened to live in Iraq where the
capital city was where the Muslim Caliphate was the Caliph's asked him to become the Imam the judge he refuses but because his student becomes the supreme judge of the Muslim world the body of food art he refuses to appoint any judges anywhere unless they Hanafy all of a sudden the Hanafi method becomes acceptable and it becomes the most powerful method now you tell me is that based on studies is that based on evidences is that based on objectivity or is it based on power positions is
based on power positions so this is how you see in the in fact is an interesting study into how Iran about 300 years ago became Shia because Iran pre if you go look at the history of Iran or Persia pre let's say four hundred five hundred years ago and going backwards it was not Shia it was actually suddenly heavily Scheffer how does it become suddenly Shia so it's interesting and they go sir it becomes suddenly she had just through politics because of the Shah and so on converting and having his beef with the
the the other rulers and so on so in religion things on seldom based on pure objectivity they usually based on power positions so that's that's the the kind of thing but yeah I thought that's definitely worth mentioning but it was an interesting and amazing conversation and I think I'd like to say that look the reason I also made an article sharing doc in Ron's article sorry his facebook status that and his and by the way he got a lot of slack for making a Facebook post about me and people said to him that oh how
can you and somebody said on there that do you know Mufti lathe has got a degree in psychology so he's manipulating you [Laughter] psychologically to kind of is using you to is that what people give me so much credit I wish I was a fraction of what people make me out to be but yeah but one thing I did want to say is that the reason I think it was really interesting especially speaking to people like dark and dark especially it's because he had of such a different position from me and yet you can sit and
talk with respect and you can enjoy each other's company walk away thinking you know what that was a solid kind of sitting even though we disagree on so many things and this is the kind of other that we need to return to so and that is really the messenger of allah des allies speaking of when he says were in nicholalala who loop in our theme indeed you are upon a great on greatness when it comes to characteristics to people let's move on some questions right I had been asked
I've been asked about a hadith of josematube no savage radi allahu on now there is a hadith of Jose ma I do not believe this incident to be true this is a hadith of a sahabi who it's basically where the Prophet is saying that who's Amos testimony is worth - now it's interesting now I need you to take a deep breath because it's not not I'm going to tell you where where this hadith comes and water is the issue and
which ones are acceptable now this hadith does come in Bukhari and it comes in the Muslim of Ahmed as well in two places it is transmitted by Ibrahim Sajadi most of the in fact almost most of these narrations all come through even Shabbos over anyway right now this there's two narrations that come in Buhari that speak of zeta bethabeth saying
right saying that I was looking for a verse in the Quran this is after the prophet has passed away some Allah leaves on him to compile the Quran during the time of over ker-rah the allah on and there was a verse that the that i knew but nobody seemed to have had it documented and I found it with Jose massiveness Abbott and I remember the Prophet saying that his testimony is worth to now this hadith is fine I don't have a problem with this hadith this hadith is fine in this understanding
it's not that you see the transmission of the Quran is motor water it's not that nobody knew that verse anyway the condition was that it needed to be known and documented by more than one person now they didn't serve it himself right oh this is a hobby in case it was even a Haditha but just think III every call it to be saved in the FIR bit but in case it was even harder but this is a hobby himself had it documented and here he finds it documented with even Jose ma sorry Jose madness abital I'm sorry
rhodiola Juan that's fine as to the Prophet saying look he's a man whose testimony is worth two testimony this is just this is just praise this is fine it's just praise it's like somebody saying that he is a man whose strength is that of two men or his intellect is that of the whole crowd or his it's the Prophet praising him for his character it does not mean that Jose might've Nath orbit or the Elan wherever he goes he will be equate to two people in
testifying as to why did the Prophet say that my understanding is we do not know why the Prophet said that he must have said it at some point just out of praising him as to the narrations that we've got they are weak and unacceptable because in my understanding they disrespect and this the profit because let me show you the narrations that we have first of all this one narration in the most of the varmint which is utterly unacceptable everybody accepts that's just a week even if she has over he is saying it
once again Omar a tip now who's a man this is the son of who's Amos transmitting it from his uncle from who's Amos brother who we don't really were not too sure who his uncle is people say his name is also O'Meara but we don't know too much but people say oh he's also from the Sahaba okay so it's interesting now there's this hadith that he had a dream jose massiveness abbott had a dream that he is prostrating on the forehead of the prophet he wakes up he goes to the Prophet he tells the Prophet this is in the Muslim Ahmed that I had a dream where I was prostrating on
your forehead so the Prophet then lies down and he prostrates on the forehead of the Prophet that is absurd and is utterly unacceptable as week-out out the window that goes immediately then there's a famous popular incident which is transmitted in books like it is in Abu Dawood I believe it is in Nasser II and maybe but generally in these books about the hold is in Mussoorie I think maybe yes so that's that's the
main ones in this hadith the Prophet has bought a can either a camel in some variations or a horse from a Bedouin and the Prophet buys this and then walks off and when he walks off the Bedouin is slow behind him and people come to the Bedouin and say hey listen why did you sell it to him sell it to us and we will pay you more and so the Bedouin says ok so he says to the Prophet I didn't sell that to you yet and the Prophet says yes you did and he says ok who's a bring me
a witness so the Prophet says who oh babe testimony who will be a witness for me so who's Amos says I bear witness he are assume Allah I bear witness that you bought this from him so the Prophet says to him how can you bear witness because you didn't even you weren't even there so he responds by saying well the fact that I accept you're a prophet is enough for me to know that you're telling the truth so then the Prophet says in this story that Oh in that case you can be
equivalent to two people this in my understanding is utterly unacceptable that the Prophet would stand a man as a witness who did not witness something just because because what is the purpose of him being a witness is that he witnessed him not that he believed otherwise all the Muslims testified that the Prophet was the prophet of God how could the Prophet go against the Quran
in having a Shaheed a the way Allah says that you must have a Shahada built is that it must be just what ideal oh well oh Allah I'm fussy come that you must be just in testimony you can't have to say that well all your witness just because you accept me as the Prophet this is an inn to me this is kind of blasphemous I don't mean that this is blasphemous in that sense but it's to me blasphemous
and it's disregarding the entire teachings of the Quran and the life of the Prophet why would the Prophet that's a false witness why would the Prophet have a false witness because Hosea in the hadith says the Prophet says how can you be a witness you never even saw this and he says yeah but because I know you're a truthful person so I'm just gonna say so I believe you and the Prophet then not only accepts I says I'll tell you what you can be in the place of two that that is not the character of the messenger of allah so allah and evils in them so that hadith is utterly
unacceptable this does come by the way it is transmitted they all come through generally through Zoe this is transmitting Abu Dawood from abulia man and Hackerman anartha right who transmits this from shape now abuzer ah our highlights a boozer our rossi who i've mentioned earlier on in his little book he highlights that lamb yes ma'am insha allah hadith and were hidden apart from one hadith a boolean man never
heard anything from shine in this chain and so this is and even if Mahajan a mystic or Eve mentions that the majority of all the hadith of bubbly a man from sure I Baumann áwillá meaning he just found them in a book and he took them so this is utterly unacceptable there is another chain in a nursery which is transmitted from its from Haytham Eve number one from Mohammed Abu Bakar and both of these people have issues with them ok and then there's another chain in I would once again with the same narrators going from Abu your man through Schreiber and I will your man
didn't even hear from sharp so and these generally are transmitted from evening hubs over as well so this incident is unacceptable that the messenger of allah would ever do something like that ok so just to kind of clarify so yes there's a point to this that this happy this story is popular so I thought I'll just clarify that right let's take some some questions people some questions then we'll try to wrap this up right I'd
been asked my question on relationships okay an interesting one and that is okay somebody's quickly asking about quickly asking about hell does he'll have to be eternal and does Allah have to send people to hell look what and somebody else is asking what do I think of share salmon and mass is this to do with the fact that he's gonna do a talk on the second coming of Jesus which I will in trouble are
watching including my refutation right so where am i from am i from Liverpool come on man does this accent sound like the Liverpool accent I'm from Brom town Birmingham central this is Center the heart of England people the heart of England now right I'd been asked a question about relationships God so throw on
relationships and somebody has asked that look they found a suitor which is let's say appropriate or who they like so this girl has found somebody who she likes so she likes this guy but he doesn't really pray is that an issue should she turn that down for somebody who does pray right and we've just got in there are true tuning in there all the way from Indonesia by the way I've had some
messages from Indonesia all the people tuning in the much love to all of you in sugar and barnacle efika Maha Akuma right so just thought I'd give a random shout out there but look this question of relationships if you found a spouse but he doesn't pray or she doesn't pray should this be a deal-breaker now that's interesting because look I I don't know I think this depends because it's in true hmm what does it mean to be religious that's the
the question you see because in the hadith when the Prophet said people are married for beauty in wealth status and so on but be victorious with the one of Deen you see Dean in that day and age meant Dean with character as well it meant having like this human character to you today it doesn't mean that so I'm not sure what people mean when they say religious you know if somebody's religious because if religious means
religion is important in your life as in it plays an important role in your life because I could look I could take myself as an example to many people I'm definitely not religious too many people depends on your understanding of religion you see to me if I take the understanding that religion plays a huge role in my life then that's then I'm very undeploy religious Islam plays a massive role in my life but how it plays a role is very
different in my life that plays a role in in in its in its teachings in the curiosity it arouses in me in the guidance in the wisdom it bestows in its kind of infinite search perpetual searches sends me on in the in the kind of way that it adapts to all times and places this is how Islam kind of totally overwhelms me so yes in that sense I
would consider myself to be very deeply religious if that's what being really just means if being religious means you're always praying or you worshiping a lot and stuff like this then I doubt all I will be from that category of being seen as very religious or you are contained you know you love ceremonies and ritual in and so it depends what religious means to people so I would say that look it depends on what this if that is important to you what that person is to me as a person personally being a good
human being yes look I'm a Muslim so if I was to marry somebody then being a Muslim would be very important to me and that's the same with most Muslims everywhere and that's understandable do they have to be praying do they have to be praying now praying is important to me that they pray the daily prayers but to me that they are a decent human being would probably weigh heavier than just the fact that they have rituals but then are very kind of arrogant or
something or that they don't have good character so to me character would over weigh certain things all those the fact that they pray is very important but for example you get people who pray but they kind of weird their coltish I couldn't I can't stand people like that I mean I couldn't personally stand somebody that would want to tell me about praying and tell me about doing stuff like this so I don't know this is a personal question that each person has to answer so I would say that look I don't feel personally that you it that it has to be
a deal-breaker I would say that I don't think you are sinful in any way for choosing somebody that doesn't pray I don't think so as long as they're a decent human being but I'm not saying you need to choose that person it's entirely up to you who you choose okay they should click they should be some obviously shared values they should be some understanding and everybody's different so that's my advice on people who are seeking kind of suitable suitors that how should they be should they be into what I'm into and sometimes they don't need to be totally into what you're into because that's us
does your head and religion once again it's different to all people to me religion is a very private affair I would never I wouldn't I don't instruct people around me to pray for example I don't like people I would never instruct my wife or instruction we say oh you haven't prayed the hard get up and pray that I would never do that I wouldn't even I mean it's just that's the kind of person I am because I believe that if I tell somebody to pray imagine in their heart
they get this kind of feeling that well I was going to but now why should I do it because you told me to and because of that you they choose not to pray and I get the fact that look in the Quran there is the verse addressing the Prophet what more allocable Salah was the Medallia command your family but that's to the Prophet because he would have done it in the best of ways me if I tell somebody to pray or probably just annoy them so I ain't gonna do that
so that's me so I think this is a it's it's up to each person how they choose to but I don't think you need to feel guilty at the same time I do think Islamic values are important if they were important to you they should be some shared kind of values they should be that prayer should be important but if a person prays five times a day if they let's say they're missing their prayers or they they're struggling with that or they I don't know I mean it's your call so that's what I would say
cool people any other let's take some somebody is asking about somebody is just insulting the companion area or the Elan and look I've said before I do have immense respect and love for cinema area of the Elan who was one of the great companions as far as my understanding and that's why Imam Malik said as well I understand he disagreed with other companions it doesn't detract from the other
companions please don't come on my page and insult them because obviously to me that will be offensive okay so I will block you there is no two ways about that okay so I've been asked another question by the way on somebody's asking about the the timings for Ramadan I've got a whole series on YouTube called fast and furious short clips maybe about five minutes each approximately where I'm dealing with a lot of questions and I speak about this over the
[Music] so the thing is that right somebody's asking so many questions just trying to I lose my son sorry somebody just criticized the game's about Mohammed or the Imam look now here are the Allah on who wasn't a god I've never said he was a guard and I've never said he hasn't made mistakes he probably did make mistakes just like every other companion made mistakes I mean but what I don't
like is I've said before this one-sided you see if you want to be critical then you've got to be critical of everybody oh you just let it go that's my point what I don't like is just criticize more our ear and the others we we're never allowed to criticize them then so that's my I don't want to really talk about that to be honest with you look I've got a whole video on YouTube and I just want to leave that where it is I don't want to really get into all of that I am my understanding I do respect these I respect all these companions so at least have the decency and respect on my
wor to respect me for that you what you believe is in your heart okay somebody the famous hadith about every innovation in the Hellfire yes I believe every innovation in the Hellfire means that every innovation is of no real avail that means it it's just really it's useless that's what it really means so in my understanding that's I mean that part of the hadith has been critiqued anyway but I mean this thing of every is
a misguidance meaning it's it turns you away from what was the pristine understanding of the team right why would you think I'm right so I want to touch up on this or dar al-kabir and I've been asked for that old Kabir that can you nurse okay can Mirada is when a woman breast feeds a child that child then becomes her kind of foster child in Islam there are certain rulings so if a woman nurses of breastfeeds a child under the
age of two within Islam that child takes on the rulings as though this this was there's a kind of surrogate mother ruling that is applied so this this mother this woman takes like motherly rulings towards that child so she could never marry this child she couldn't that child could never marry her daughter stuff like that if it's a boy or if it's a girl she could never marry her son and things like this because they would become siblings and so there's a lot of these rulings this is called radar there's nothing I mean that's a
well-known ruling in in Islam now there is a hadith of sala allah al meriya who right now who is the wife of a baja de fer now she in this in this particular in this particular honey she approaches some somebody approaches the prophet and they say well look we used to live in a place and we've got a
servant a slave by the name of salim who is the molar of Haditha sorry this is for they for just saying i bought for the fat how they furtively a man now this is Salim is the molar the slave of a vey far now they say look we've got a tight space and he's not really he was like an adopted son but now we've realized in Islam adoption doesn't carry the same ruling so he's not a real son we used to treat this person as though
he was an actual son and now we've realized he isn't so do I have to wear hijab and do all these things in front of him and our place is so tight and I don't really you know so in this particular hadith currently the profit then tells her that she can nurse him five out of there ie he hung Sarada at five sucklings and he will become like a son to you but he's a grown man in this in this narration now the interesting thing is that this is transmitted imam malik brings this
transmission from even a shia observer who then claims that he heard or wa say from the transmitted this hadith and then they go on to say it's a lengthy description of this entire hadith saying that this was the what aisha radi allahu and I used to believe so it was her mother and none of the other companions ever accepted this an earlier of the Aloha on and Omar al Bakr and all these other people rejected this understanding and all the wives of the Prophet they said that that's not you can't do things
like that okay so this Imam Malik brings this in my understanding Imam Malik because when he is asked about this ruling Imam Malik condemns this ruling and says in his book that Roberto Kabir is nonsense there you cannot feed a grown up like this okay and he does not become your matram he doesn't become your so based on this for example ruling let's say a person drank sorry guys if this is gonna cross people out but let's say he his own wife was lactating and he
ended up digesting drinking some of that milk she would become his mom which is nonsense because in the Maliki mother a person can drink that milk it I mean the milk isn't Haram I'm just saying gotta be adventurous so the thing is that Imam Malik has clearly said that this is not Haram and he brings that in the in the Mata as well to show that that's not Haram so when Imam Malik brings this this was to show in my understanding that it NURBS he has transmitted this but we don't
believe this to be sound this is why Malick presented that in the model and because why do I say this people then said that this is the understanding of Ayesha this is the mother of Ayesha yet yet people in sahih al-bukhari inside Muslim from the same chain from Ottawa from Asia is the hadith that the Prophet is teaching them an ayah is transmitting the arroba aminal madera the robber only works in Morada aminal maha that you can only feed and the rulings apply in an
age of nourishment was the child is so young now meaning to or under in that kind of suckling age so this is transmitted by Aisha so why would I shall be transmitting this hadith herself and then going against it but rather in my understanding that was circulated about Aisha but it was not true and Imam Malik only brought the transmission of even an absurdly because he says oh honey from what I have been told and he goes on to say this that Zoe
had said this and this is why another companion by the name of if nabi Malaika who transmits this says I spent a year in Medina I knew this but I was so fearful to transmit it because people would be like you know are so fearful that what the hell he sounded absurd so that goes to show and this is why if nabbed alberto says in his estate car that this showed that people even if you do accept this that people from long ago had rejected this so that's in my understanding that that incident is not a true incident
it's a misconstrued event ok rattle Kabir does not make any sense and you know the apparent reading of the hadith does seem to imply that she's actually feeding the man from her breast that's the apparent reading which is absurd and then even after bar says that but nobody would accept that they would think that she would pour that into something and then feed him but the reading says 5 sucklings humps are other hearts or what would 5 it doesn't make any sense and then today some scholars some Salafi scholars have taken this ruling to be true and they've said that if a woman wants a man to become a Muharram she has
to she can get she can get lactating milk or from myself or from her sisters or somebody that is immediately related to her and feed it to this man and the man can then now come and go as he pleases this is mercury this one this one mercury of the Deen I tell you that's nonsense people that's absurd that's a mockery of this religion I'm telling you and some people in Egypt tried to give a fatwa saying if you work with people then why not just breastfeed them or they're saying okay you can do
it through hey Lotte gives a whole new meaning to chai latte I tell you so this this is nonsense but yeah I mean the hanafi madhhab my understanding is that that is Haram to drink that milk anyway in the Maliki mother it isn't Haram to drink that milk but I mean in the hanafi madhhab it is Haram but this hadith is not true this
is a misconstrued or Mis attributed event okay of this robot and Kabir okay you can't kind of go around feeding grown men and lactating milk and just in the hope that they now all of a sudden are like your brothers you gotta be joking in this people are twisted you can't be doing stuff like that that will totally people totally going the wrong way can you imagine you're doing that with some kind of intention that now this is now
you can never think of me sexually and that's like they'll be like the first thing they know people are totally twisted ah can you imagine that they'll be like wow that's a deafness signal you know like men can definitely we can't read women signals anyway men think every signal from a woman is always a signal anyway so that's just how men are wired so when a woman just looks people are like ah that's a signal
so can you imagine this as talk about mixed messages because women will be like all saying nice things to guys and and then they'll be like that's mixed messages what I never I was never flirting with yours never I never meant it like I just only thought of you as a friend some guys are always confused as hell anyway and now the woman says hey have some of my breast milk kind of s like
mixed messages on steroids yeah so yeah I mean the last thing come on the last thing they're thinking is oh now I definitely can't think of you sexually that's like that thought said no man ever so you can get that out so the seller fees you have given that fatwa seriously you guys need to check and revisit please revisit because that stuff just ain't happening Garden and
people I tell you what let's take some rapid round questions and then we call this to an end what's with the pack weddings I'm putting a Quran on top of the bride's head they go ah customs are this customs God knows I suppose it they think it brings them some kind of good luck I guess big me up now uh is that uh people blind
ease in the house blind II who's got the his name in Chinese they obviously such my my Cody my mate since were five years old since I'm five years old people right so let's take some rapid round questions why not over the groom's head because the groom is already blessed by God obviously it's the woman that needs a now let's take some quick rapid round question then we call this can you please wear the glasses before the of course I can you what kind of a
question is that the milk protein protein people protein you know the old saying waste not one not so what is what are some questions what is your view on what what is your view do you consider returning after do you consider the hadith about rightly guided caliphs a watch my clip on Caliphate I've already answered that
along with Chef Akram Nedley so I don't believe that Islam was sent about politics I believe that those things were just coincidental and but you can watch that their share from whether he goes into a better explanation and I mention it as well can the Prophet be depicted in film hmm you see I would advise against things like that because I think it's going to cause so much negativity that I wouldn't advise to depict the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasalam thoughts on malala's return visit to Pakistan why not that
a future Prime Minister I'm telling you Malala is definitely gonna be the future of Prime Minister does heaven physically exist I've got no when you say physically you see the thing is we don't know what is reality we it exists how does it exist what is it like how does it feel what does it look like I don't know what it looks like I don't know we've got descriptions in the Quran which really are just there as a frame of reference they're not really what heaven is like because the Prophet said nobody can conceive what heaven is like so we don't know what it's actually like
in that sense in do you agree with the statement whatever harms use Haram that depends because you know fatty foods can harm you but they're not Haram smoking harms you I don't think smoking is haram marijuana harms you damn I need to stop this reasoning huh scandals are tattoos
Haram I don't think tattoos are harm I think they discouraged but I don't think they had on hmm just because it's harmful people of the opposite gender can be harmful you know there's a poem of me I was going across we speaks to himself we say in einer we okay come here be a sheikh Hey he says you know these beautiful women these mirror-like faced women is me too
like addressing himself have you to become besotted by them says in ina who you care c'mere be a jab Garson Nicholson a hair on me now whenever he leaves home job girl cynical thing her on nickel T that whenever he leaves home he's always confused this is the it's an interesting poem of me because in in the same kind of poem he has the line that much cell
imagine all that don't think we are simple parity a phallic pursue that that for time it has taken time so long double caper they say in sonic Alton they're after such ages and generation not generations millennia does in Sun appear from dust many people have said perhaps he was speaking about evolution and things like that here which is interesting and it's in line with that that he says in Heine
ruyan cake me to be a she can and job Gerson Nichols there on nickel T that whenever he leaves home is always in a state of shock but yeah so right so what's going on people what's going on I think we got to wrap this up any interesting things in dodgy shukran shukran vertical or fecal so that some of the I think we've covered up everything right there was an article going around by the way constantly going on about saying oh
Mufti Abu layth or al Boulet they don't want to call me Mufti Abu layth al Boulet basically they're really upset about me having a dig at him Olivia Sarah at the Bundy last week and mockery or to do so baby so these these articles have come out saying going on about this verse that where I said about Jesus carnival Matty Sevilla he was in he was a child so they're saying look he quotes a Lucy and he leaves out these points were a Lucy says and Lucy is not
trying to prove this point and Lucy and I mentioned on last week's show look Oh Lucy begins by saying there's a problem in this verse because it's past tense then he tries to answer and they say no but I Lucy is not saying this i Lucy's not saying this I lose obey huh I don't care I couldn't kill less keep a Lucy I only mentioned him once I've got a whole prelude video forget a Lucy a lie saying in the Quran kana kana is past tense whatever you understand you're saying
this kanays extra allows just added something extra fine that's your understanding I'm going with what Allah actually said with the actual reading of the Quran you can go with an interpretation I'm going with the actual reading of the Quran you're saying I Lucia Lucia Lucy and yeah Wroclaw Oh Lucy Coe yeah I never wanted a Lucy in the first place he's a Hanafy scholar of a later I just mentioned once that look even he problematized this and this is what they've just caught onto and they just want constantly writing articles about this forget that I've got a whole Prelude
video watch my pre lewd and disprove me refute my prelude forget this I Lucia Lucia I don't couldn't care less I said it clearly a lot and his messenger Allah and his messenger that's what I've asked for and reason allies messenger and reason I couldn't care less what I Lucy said yes I quoted him on one thing if you feel he didn't say that fine keep him doesn't bother me I think you've totally misread me so right I've got a prelude video Prelude meaning and intro to why the second
coming of Jesus is problematic it's on YouTube you can search it as Prelude my name mostly will he'll come up you can watch it and review that video refute my arguments forget about this one I Lucia Lucia Lucy what a red herring to just attach yourselves to and the other thing do be warned people constantly obsessing over me it only furthers my cause I tell you right so what are we any final any final
wrap ups people any final wrap ups no what's going on we're going to do the course in Charlotte pops in about two weeks time I'm planning on the Jesus thing and then it will be out just a shout out look at that now wish shout out stay blessed what are your views on publicly Jamaat good views I mean I think good of them I know they've had a lot of politics recently but that's them do Saints exist depends on your meaning
of saints can you give a fatwa on woudl incontinence if a person has incontinence they don't need to do Hulu I mean they can just keep the buddha they've got it doesn't break with the bitcoin i've answered previously all these things are permissible in islam everything is permissible by default and less proven otherwise I think it's time to wrap this up what do you think about the punish the Muslim day I think that's disgusting
when I do I did admire the campaign that Muslims began that love a Muslim day and and I think there's been some very positive campaigns were people in certain parts of the UK are giving out roses to non-muslims and you know the best thing is going to be our character people I I think people should be vigilant but I don't think it's a that threatening as people are making it out as well I don't think so a lot of them but but I think you should be vigilant but I don't think you need to panic go into panic mode or anything that's my understanding
right Keith is shouting for a shout out Carl get real man stop hiding behind these fake profiles use a real name right so people with that I think we've covered pretty much most things I didn't get to go into oh my god I want you to cover the hadith on women traveling abroad what I'll do is I'll cover that next week apologies for not covering that just all these things being so distracted saying bismillah in the toilet yes you can say bismillah in the toilet Imam Malik mentioned that you can do thicker in the toilet I think it's time to go to sleep
Shaheed sad sad but gee I don't know silent animal silent people there you go we'll start right but in the house from from town right and she'll love doing some grass root work right people shall take very good care of yourselves I'm gonna wrap this up in sha Allah till next week if you got any questions reach out to me Facebook snapchat Twitter its mafia belief mount 2014 on snapchat I do try to respond to questions and inshallah take very good care of yourselves till then what Salam o aleikum what
happened to lie to Allah or butter chapter
Something wrong here?
Tell us what is wrong and it will be checked against the recording. Nothing changes until a person has reviewed it.
Sending a note needs JavaScript, which is off or unavailable in this browser. Nothing has been sent.
No name, email address or account is asked for or stored, and the inbox does not store your IP address. For rate limiting it keeps an unreadable fingerprint of your connection for 48 hours, and our database provider's own logs record connections as every website's do. Only your note, its kind, the page and the moment in the recording are kept, for review.
Cite this recording
Stable id, transcript version and tier are part of the citation. Every change to a transcript is logged.Mufti Abu Layth Archive, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/izesmdfwu9g/ (accessed 1 November 2026)
- APA 7
Mufti Abu Layth. (2018, April 3). Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 72 [Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors]. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Retrieved November 1, 2026, from https://muftiabulayth.org/r/izesmdfwu9g/
- Chicago author-date
Mufti Abu Layth. 2018. "Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 72." Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Recorded April 3, 2018. Accessed November 1, 2026. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/izesmdfwu9g/
- BibTeX
@misc{abulayth-izeSMdFwu9g, author = {Mufti Abu Layth}, title = {{Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 72}}, year = {2018}, month = {4}, date = {2018-04-03}, howpublished = {\url{https://muftiabulayth.org/r/izesmdfwu9g/}}, url = {https://muftiabulayth.org/r/izesmdfwu9g/}, organization = {Mufti Abu Layth Archive}, urldate = {2026-11-01}, note = {Auto-transcribed, may contain errors} }