Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 71

however let's see if I can share this just going to my facebook I put this tempered glass thing on it and now come on now I've gotta kind of just to press something

and I need some anybody who's a chewed-up with these phones I can't seem to figure out it doesn't give me any predictive text anymore so that's really doing my head in ladies ah come on for God's sake we are Salaam

almost done almost sure that now I'm learning I'm not arise done this done so people are ah in al hamdulillah wa kafa mas wallet or salam o allah rasool allah mustafa well I bet in Ladino football Oh mom be who da master Bobby ah sorry al madina too far wha bad for Salaam allahi al l ohm what

animus Arnim become a bi bonitos a todos RI people warning light sir and as always swagatam saw Gotham right so people you need change phone don't buy Chinese phone anymore no that's a samsung s 9 I've got people yes 9 I have to say look super slick I am impressed how are you all doing people I'm actually in a bit of a rush today so I gotta try to keep the session slightly restricted quite a few things

on my mind that I'd like to share though whoa so ah arrived people those of you tuning in I want you to click like I want you all all four thoughts I want you all to click share the share button right there people look at that with the signs right so and get this out there what I'd like to I'll be touching up I'll take some questions and stuff I'll be touching up on a few interesting topics things like as well some advice

in shall law some mercy ha for students of knowledge and also what is meant by reason I guess that's an interesting one and also I'll be sharing some thoughts on the share has an ally video and malama yes al hanafis as well so those of you evening hand evening right so those of you just tuning in click like click Share let's get this out there how ruin head doing it our Maliki wrap wrapping it from

London I've gotta get the t-shirt I gotta show the t-shirt god damn mama got it here but he says my lackeys do it best hands down by courtesy of Harun head people right so I long what Simon Rashad let's take some questions to get this show on the road people to get this show on the road so I've got out of my hot and cold here right so all right so look at the check out the ice ball people check out that ice ball had to

kind of get that alright you know that people you know that you know that right so water wheel so take some questions some have already been submitted I can take some from the as possible is possibly hermanos let's take a look right [Music] these phones are jamming too much now man see this is it as you all as the as like a years up whatever the phone stops Jam it's must be like some signal that the so they want you to get some get the

next one up which I have got by the way but still I'm just trying to say right so look at that doesn't even let me get out of this now yes alarm let's take some questions from here then whilst this can chef Abdul Hameed is getting attacked after that video sure Abdul Hameed is not getting attacked people share huh

Bill Hamid is a cage fighting beast I seriously doubt any of them all on us I think they haven't got their head screwed on if they're gonna try to come on for God's sake no patience left in us these things have been now built - look at that I don't know I give up let's try this one instead try bring up some questions what is your opinion on the hadith that

there will be more women in Hell than men that's not true there will be more women in Hell than men because if all the women are in hell what the hell would the men want to be in heaven for [Laughter] let's be honest it's gonna be a bit boring if if just men are in heaven and so we're everybody's like you're right bro you're right bro just fist bumping each other it's touch touch respect

shall we pray again now for the five hundred and seventy fifth time obviously come on what kind of a paradise would it be if they weren't if they were gonna be just a few women there that's the so obviously that hadith isn't true and you know the hadith these kind of hadith have to really be analyzed and people have to be careful what they keep preaching you know what it is that some of these hadith first of all

right first of all the other this had eat sometimes it's miss quilted as is the one about not the women lacking intellect and stuff like that and I have highlighted in the past look the one of our intellect that was simply said in a context and it was out of humor that's been misunderstood would you consider yourself as an intellectual I would like to consider myself an theological inheritor of scholars such as Muhammad Abdul Rashid radar that's an interesting

question you know I want to I want to touch up on that question tonight what are your thoughts on gog and magog you see I've become all of a sudden the expert on the end of times one thing for sure people you gotta say I have single-handedly brought back an entire dialogue to life in the entire western world and that is the second coming of Jesus amongst Muslims every single person speaking on it right now in our

recent months is a direct reaction to me so as I said once before that you can love me you can like me you can hate me but you will not be able to ignore me now you they can sit and cry so it's an interesting it's an interesting thought interesting thought that you know for God's sake I've triggered an entire international debate Wow just sitting right here all thanks to

Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook so right so that's it's it's amazing but it goes to show that why people are so afraid like there's all this big who are going on right oh my god oh my god let's not let anybody become let nobody go astray with this Jesus belief you know the the Messiah believe I mean what are people on about they casting each other to hell every single day you know he's going to hell he's going to tell he's going to hell

all of a sudden what if I see this is the question why what are they so afraid of that is the question that is what people ought to be kind of prodding and digging deeper into that what are they so afraid of what you know it's not that they've got this passion for Jesus Christ what are they so afraid of these the clergy that I've unearthed here and the truth is that I've unearthed the fact that beliefs have crept in and the clergy can no longer control the people

the theme is free from the might of the kind of the clasp that was once practiced by the European ecclesiastic Church these kind of things cannot be practiced today and it rocks the foundations of people because they you know they they this cognitive dissonance they've been hearing the story since they were kids and the movies try to teach them all these things that everything we say in these bullet points must be so and and now it gets massively rocked nevertheless let's take a few

questions and then we'll jump on to some of the the the other things anything is my phone working now or is it still laughs for God's sake get off here man you know it's you know I I got a message from one of the Milano's I mean not these mallanna's the other and I was trying to play and it seems to frozen on that so now it's just not I know maybe if I restart my phone but at least hasn't frozen on something you know as a

kid when you watching a movie and the whole movie is fine but there just is one scene in me and it has to be that scene that your parents will walk in on and you're like and for some reason it will just freeze and you like you know and you and Judy a shoe will come flying all of a sudden your parents will be like oh yeah

sorry that's a oftenly often it a term of endearment used by Pakistani parents for their children right so guys let's take some questions it's happened to the best of us I tell you tapping and you're like thinking but trust me see the whole movie was fine it was just this one right okay suicide is Haram what about women who commit suicide in

times of anarchy to protect their own now look I think if people have committed I wouldn't encourage I wouldn't even courage obviously people to commit suicide at all even for honor situations like that I wouldn't personally think I think that's all a matter of perspective I understand for but people who do commit suicide you see I in my understanding Islam used all these strong strong rhetoric as a preventative force so people don't do it

once post action and pre action there's two different attitudes pre-action people are the Sharia will be very kind of have this almost like a harsh attitude towards so as to dissuade people and act very no like so it doesn't give them it has to it needs people to always have hope but post action if somebody has committed suicide the the the attitude must be one of compassion okay and it must be one of

understanding and solace and seeking mercy and helping the family and things like this this is what the attitude is pre post so you see this is the thing that people don't understand the wisdom they think the Sharia is always this kind of robotic thing it's not like that it's not like that so you see when people would have fought each other and you have to remember in the time of the Prophet how these fights would have happened and I'm you know murder and and there were kind of tribes and warrior tribes and so the verse says

anybody who kills another because they were believers by that point most of them anybody who kills a believer he will be forever doomed eternally harly then fear forever in the health you know in doubting in the fire of hell forever but yet that's a clear verse of the Quran yet Muslims we don't believe that so that is pre action post action there's a different attitude so there's a lot of this in the Sharia are sometimes so we really owe to kind of have this this understanding of wisdom

that pre action post actions of women or men who have committed suicide I think it I think I do personally I think in the past I've commented on this as well I think it is actually a great philosophical conundrum really and I do agree in some to some extent with Albert Camus that the philosopher the French existentialist where he speaks about it is perhaps one of the greatest conundrums and puzzles of philosophy of and that is suicide and I kind of agree with that but so I think Muslims ought to have a more compassionate and that is

the Islamic ruling in my understanding used to Train I don't know what that means I've rolled with Jason right strong deterrent okay Kant then some of the questions people should we take some questions awry dr.

Brown is of the view that although the traditional view may be very monolithic and devoid of nuanced system we have and going is to open the door for a free-for-all buffet of ideas and practices why is that not a good enough reason to go outside the traditional understanding of Islam you see people what makes you think I'm not on the traditional understanding of Islam I am on the traditional understanding of Islam it's just because you see me looking a bit modern that's all so you're assuming that I'm not on the understanding that that problem lies

in your head not with me I am on the traditional understanding of Islam we traditionally Islam has always told you to be of the time to be of the time you have to be of the time Islam never told us to be of 7th century Arabia it told us to be of our own time of our own place that is the traditional understanding of Islam I don't know what when you're saying for for example for learned scholar or such-and-such academic or let's say in this case dr.

Jonathan Brown I first of all I don't know exactly the context of what dr. Jonathan Brown or star Jonathan Brown is saying that and I do respect him no I I don't know what the context to that is but you see I think we need to stop having this fear scare mongering attitude you know there's this scare mongering attitude oh my god everything's gonna go everything is gonna be destroyed the moment we say you can have things easy in Islam oh my god oh my and you have to remember that people did this with the Salafis first so when the seller fees when the seller fee that were a few decades ago really

started to with all the I don't want to say but with all the ching ching ching that was poured into it when it started to spread like wildfire so people try to use this scaremongering tactics like oh my god if you start saying hadith anita these quran hadith ELISA need everybody's gonna go man everybody's gonna go out and Bible party and start going oh my god oh I think what to do that really Wow I'm off to do that and the public are gonna go crazy and there's gonna be you have so misunderstood the Muslims Muslim no you

gotta be joking nobody's gonna read what nobody's read anything relax I said to people then like I say now look stop scaremongering if you want to refute the Salafi aspects refute it properly don't do this scaremongering tactics like oh my god the whole Deen now that you say oh I've got he says in Buhari oh they've got the hadith everything's gonna go mad and people are gonna be picking and choosing and the moment you say you don't have to follow method everybody's gonna pick this and pick that and they've got too much more you know if no will be and they've got the money I've even academia and they've got

them I love even has them and they've got these take care of if not the bar and they've got show Connie's nail all part and they're going mad and crazy nobody's doing anything like that relax of the unfortunate news is nobody cares I hate to break it to you guys you know to these movies that are like so do all this scheming ring honestly I mean I don't know how to take that as whether it's a good thing or a bad thing I mean it's unfortunate but Muslims really don't care nobody cares about the Deen like this religion doesn't actually

mean these things to people religion is just like nobody really cares about all of this like it's all in your head and in your mind okay awful quick books on my arm a lot out of date thick books are what I would say is out of sync there needs to be a huge effort to update them to kind of rethink everything we are out of sync massively yeah you know if I open these fit books I mean they're beautiful and I love collecting them especially of the school

of Madinah right but the point is if if I was to open them and go beyond worship and maybe some chapters of marriage divorce stuff like this and the huge and that's really just the first one three chapters out of eight chapters let's say the rest of it if I was to read out selections to you you'd be shocked now what the hell is that even honorable like why have we even got that stuff this is what you would actually be thinking if we're talking about things like transactions which are so you know pre industrialization nothing to do with our world and you'll be talking about

how to use words which nobody speaks in that language anymore let alone those words and then it'll have the whole justice system and the Penal Code is at the end that that's totally out of sync and he'll talk about you know how you could retaliate with wounds and is the wound cut to this point is the flesh or to the bone and you can none of this stuff makes any sense to people it's totally out of sync nothing to do with our world why are so deep in blood our to our knees from hatred by Muslim - Muslim we should focus on I

totally agree I totally agree Holly - get in the past numerous thing I'm happy getting a shout out go on there you go Nomura you do in it you do in it dude what is the concept of McHale Matata nikka Mota is a temporary marriage which self terminates so you have a self see that using that word with Muslims it's like self destructs they like he or she is but she comes with a contract that

self destructs everybody's like what the hell that would be an interesting thing for a Muslim you know if they wanted to sell the dolls the sex dolls that would be an interesting the contract self-destructs so Mota is a temporary marriage marriage of pure convenience it's just basically to be very it's past the watershed so to be very kind of frank about it it was really just for sex nothing else on both

sides now what are generally is deemed Haram generally speaking it's interesting because it's one of those discussions that became sectarian eyes dweud nothing to do with sex it's just a moment that she I took it up that see Sunnis unleashed that the hounds of hell on this must Allah and they turned it into something else in essence I don't really you see many Muslim scholars have traditionally said they made it very clear that like a

worker if Nara behaved not the bar all these great legends had said that marriage is not a lifelong process according to Islam if it does if it works out like that that's up to the couple otherwise it has no there's no promise that it till death do us part and even if a person got married with the intention in his mind let's say or in her mind that she wanted out after a while the marriage is still valid according to Islamic many many scholars of Islam especially a lot of the these great legends that are quoted so but the difference with motorized it you wouldn't nd it would just self-terminate

so if we said twenty-four hours on the clock then 24 hours when the alarm goes off its off it's like that and they used to do that in the time of the Prophet and then the Prophet forbade it and then he allowed it and then forbade it and then they say maybe he allowed it again and then for baby and so it's interesting some of the Companions always believed it was permissible people like if not burst for the aloha although they conflict you know they bring some narrations from him saying no but others say yes people like a Mehran I've never seen another some of the Sahaba and some of the tambourine and stuff like that they did feel it was

permissible and interestingly even at a Mia's grandfather I believe may have kind of had gone that way and the Maliki legend of the last century the share Holies LOM of his time the great mood state of the 20th century if not sure any stuff see writes his understanding is that most are temporary marriages are permissible if there was a need for them like a in Aurora if there was a kind of like that kind of a need so you see that diversity there but generally it's understood most people will say no and

in my understanding I think I I don't inclined personally so much towards that the strength of muta because I see that as like self-destructing to me doesn't make too much sense I think if there was an understanding that people themselves although the concept of if people wanted a relationship based on sexual pleasure Islam does not forbid that so if people wanted to do that and they had an understanding as long as it's a mutual understanding and they weren't kind of just conning each other or deceiving

each other then I think it's up to them they're adults nobody else needs to get involved but they should be allowed to kind of bring it to an end because maybe they you know maybe they loving it and they don't want to bring it to an end so why should it self-terminate that's that's why I'm mmm I'm not so sure but even I sure does argue for it in image stuff see so that's interesting I mean that's what motives why are leather socks mentioned in hockey the books that's a really good question because after books athletes books of

Creed we have to understand something Creed the Prophet never book Creed ever he never bought up either he brought faith there's a big difference between a man and a PITA scholars the men they brought Creed okay alone is messenger boy Iman now you see this is why yes what as I've you know I've trained in the traditional sciences I've trained in traditional Creed I've studied here I've done things like this but Creed is man-made Iman is from Allah

and his messenger so a man we embrace wholeheartedly and a last messenger only told us a few things when they are when in the famous hadith when he's asked to define what is faith he says that you believe in Allah you believe in his messengers you believe that in in why he in Revelation in these books you believe in angels means medium and somebody asked me the other day what are angels and I said look we don't know that these things aren't Allah never explained what they were and he never asked you you need to know he just used the term now today we

might understand them with wings and flying and you know these with the halo and that's just all media stories narratives myths the core I never defines what they like so you don't need to know these things all you understand is something that's very different that is deployed by Allah what the image you have is based on your culture and the prophets had believed in an afterlife and believe that allies ultimately all-powerful look how simple and beautiful that Iman is that was brought to us by our messenger sallallahu alayhi

wasallam and then came men and they beginning you know like people keep quoting amantha Hari who by the way amantha how he is not even from the scholars of theologies not a theologian but he is a scholar unquestionably but he's not from amongst the mythical I mean I don't know why they keep they keep making up his book his book is just like a baby's book but it's just he wrote this thing with a hundred and sixty-five points now this is Creed C Creed has a is linked to power it's linked to the institutionalization of

religion it's linked to when it comes in hundreds of years after the Prophet at least two to three hundred years after the Prophet we're seeing Creed is formed religion is heavily linked ties in with with many other things with Empire with expansionism with stuff like the clergy in themselves become a force to deal with who holds the most power who should be in charge who can we condemn see how can we condemn for example people will say how can you condemn the Shia people will say how can you condemn the Shia you see because they believe in a lot these messengers and

these these things they they'll say that you believe in these things this is what the owner my in the past would have said they've said how can we condemn them so we need a list of rules and then when we make these discs read anybody who doesn't go by these bullet points we can condemn them and outcast them so who gets to make the creed and who gets to these are all positions of power now it's very naive to ignore this and I accept many of them may have been sincere people and you know may Allah reward them for this sincerity but it's

incredibly naive to ignore the power positions at play because you have to remember these people became judges they became rulers they became not rulers like that but they became judges who in that day and age there was no police so the judges had a certain amount of short par with them certain amount of what you might call today police that they would send to arrest people and stuff this was a huge position of prestige a position of power right so okay so that's the institutionalization of religion which I totally cannot stand and that is what the Prophet warned against when he said you will do exactly

as the Jews and Christians before you and that is what the Prophet in my understanding was talking about is that you will go on to institutionalize this religion just as they did people say he was talking about clothes we can get in life that talk about taking a glorious hadith and dragging it down so lower making it so shallow like for God's sake yeah please talk about minimum age of marriage in Islam okay please watch my eye I would like to talk about that briefly please watch my video on the age

of Ayesha at the time of her marriage it's on YouTube it's if you just type my name you can see my channel on YouTube and you can see it there the age of Ayesha watch it please understand it it is about one and a half to two hours long take the timer and watch it it's got timestamps we have to understand and that in Islam right it is haram listen to me Haram to Mary children okay do not do not be listening to these these people who say otherwise

and they are snatching the Deen from in front of you these movies or Imams or these dyes or these people of Dawa or doing nothing but destroying the deen of islam Lalaji they are destroying the deen of islam anybody who tells you it's okay to marry a child avoid that person like the plague okay it is not okay to marry a child and it is never being sanctioned by Allah nor His Messenger these people are lying attributed a lie to Allah she says no way in the Quran I've shown in the in great detail in my

clip that that one verse they try to refer to a lie speaking about women post-divorce women he begins the verse Allah begins it with women saying using the word women and addressing women how could how could why would he all of a sudden switch to tiny little girls and he says women and those women who have been divorced and lies addressing them and says that they should wait three menstrual cycles in case the in case they're pregnant and things like that and these are the social implications but he mentions and those who do not have menstrual cycles and those who are

past the menopause they can wait three months or so on now it's interesting here they try to say where Allah said those who do not have menstrual cycles he's talking about little girls you sick what is wrong with you Allah is not talking about little girls read that off I see the tapasya I've quoted in I quote what is it about yeah and I quote a few other ignite the yams a few of the toughest healing they they mention this is due to illness those women who don't have who have irregular cycles or don't have cycles for whatever reason then they

will wait the months right and this is why this is why these things were clearly there there were several olomana did say in my malik in his day and age when he was asked he said no he said if a what if a girl when they asked him when can you marry her he said she must be nubile she must be of age and obviously now I'm not look let's not confuse this discussion with a discussion to do with the age of consent does it vary between this year or this year that is cultural I accept that and I accept that you know Islam to specify

a particular age although many ala ma did go with 15 and 18 and the Ottoman Empire in its time did also stipulate anything beneath 15 was illegal in their time and was punishable so and they did that based on thick on Hanafy thing and the other thick of its time so yes these rulings are there but the age right whether somebody say 16 15 17 18 14 these things may vary culturally I accept that that nobody is arguing about that we're talking about little girls

these things are disgusting these things to even entertain that and then to drag in a line is messenger to justify a stupid sick kind of understanding that you've got has no place in Islam no place and I asked these Allah ma you know these ala ma that are I watch this video somebody tagged me in a video now of this guy who's always doing that Allah and many of you have probably watched in and don't really want to go into but this video where he's in Hyde Park Corner and this is recent I think it's in the last week or two or something and he's arguing with it seems

it's a non-muslim I don't know and it's a short clip it was on some kind of secular thing or I don't know whether it was a right-wing group or but somebody tagged mean so I ended up watching it it's about three minutes and the person's asking him that but you and this is they were asking this is Ali that WA now I do know Ali that WA as in I've met him on a few occasions obviously with me he's been very respectful now with me he's not really discussed things this isn't I don't have anything personal against him if anything he's been very respectful when

he's met me and he's come to visit me so I don't have any kind of like you know I'm not people who show me respect I do show them respect okay so this is in no way against him are now still I have that respect for anybody who shows me respect now but I'll be honest with you when I watch this this is to do with the things being said not him as a person but the things being said I was disgusted okay and I was really kind of hurt in a way that this is being presented as Islam and he was being asked that look okay so would you marry

your daughter and he says yes he says if my daughter was nine years old and a 40 year old man came and I would ask my daughter he goes I would check if she's sexually capable and in the comments I mean in the subtitles it said we don't know how you would check obviously that is an absurd statement I'll check if she section I don't know what that means either I'll check if my daughter is actually capable at the age of nine I mean but anyway it's because the person then says let's say hypothetically she is capable the person says that to him and he says yeah I'll ask her are you sure you want to marry this 40 year old and if she says yeah then I'll say al

hamdulillah yeah well look as a person I think that you know and and this Ali Dawa as far as what I can recall him telling me he's a convert to Islam and when he told me ages ago you know when he first met me honestly I feel sorry for the understanding of Islam that you've been I think brainwashed into or you've been bombarded with right this wall is an abomination to Islam and then what really hurt me I don't know whether you said this in his right mind or he said it accidentally but the fact that

it's recorded he went on to say look we don't have an age of consent in Islam which which that that's not the problem because you could say if these things vary whether it's 15 18 whatever in culture but he says he follows on by saying we don't have an age of consent in his farm girl camp as long as the girl sexually active he puts that closing like sexually capable I think he says and then he says whether she's nine five or four I honestly was like oh I was just shocked that what on

I've got no words what do you mean sexually capable five four how on earth how on earth could you even like those sentences don't go together like these things I I'm out for words will LA he I'm out for words and I would plead with the Allah man that I would plead with the Olimar that these all Imam who have come out to attack me you know who these orlimar that have become so passionate about the second coming of Jesus Christ you know peace and

blessings be upon him all of a sudden more passionate than the Christians right so now I would plead with them that will they please turn their focus by all means keep it on Jesus Christ and and I'll engage you that's fine but will they turn their focus to these ideas please will they condemn these ideas will they say that these things are unacceptable in Islam look let me tell you something people each society each society has a characteristic or certain

types archetypes that they hate it was wisdom wisdom why Allah sent the messenger of allah he sent the prophet muhammad sallallahu alayhi wasallam from who he was from from he was from mother then from China from Quraish from you know the best of these tribes from amongst them selected from Bani Hashim why did he have white the Lord have chosen him to be from any little like just a secondary tertiary low try but

that's not how society works Society see status the Prophet was seen from a very noble try amongst people and people had that impacted them even though social status is man-made it's not from god but Allah knows that look this is gonna make the difference in our society look in old society murder robbery these kind of things are hated everywhere people want don't like obviously murderers and

things like this but in this society everybody hates rapists they hate pedophiles now you have to understand what you are doing you are placing you as Muslims are placing and The Messenger of Allah who is the best of creation and portraying him as a pedophile what are you doing why are you doing these things first of all that is wrong it is a lie that one narration this one sole

narration they bring right which mihari brings and accidentally you know Bihari may Allah have mercy and obviously he wasn't a prophet of God and I've shown him in my whole detailed video how that was unacceptable this one narration he clashes with so many of the narrations but he brings this and then these people they they happily they endorse this they say yes so you know so this is our tradition you don't understand look people hate they abhor pedophiles in in this part of the world and I think

rightfully so so why would you get the who we think is the best of creation and put him in this list so I strongly urge and these people who keep saying to me you know this is a modern this guy follows these desires this guy does this this guy is destroying Islam I ask you to kind of challenge it to challenge these issues to portray Islam in the true light so that's right it is in other books you're right it's inside Muslim which makes it even worse and reduces our age to six you're right

who's that now John Dow Jones in Muslim makes it even worse he puts it down to the age of six that the Prophet married her and all these kind of disgusting stuff which clashes with all the other hadith in Bukhari by the way the hadith is still the same hadith it's to do with aisha from her nephew and someone is the same hadith but it's got different wordings and stuff like this now so that's I've really and this other issues look challenged these issues i ask i urge these people look listen did you know these people will say these people then say there's each man you can

do this kind of stuff to hell with that each man there is no each my own this they will say this consensus these people i ask these people to challenge these issues do you know in these books they will find that scholars say a lot facilitated slavery they will say this in in these books all these scholars that because they lived in a time when it was normal so they will just justify using religion say Ya Allah facilitated slavery slavery stopped blessings in it bla bla bla bla bla would you say that today this each mad they'll say this each man that Allah

facilitated and allowed slavery to happen and so on because we live in an age where these things have changed these things are forbidden in Islam they are Haram and I've explained this before you can watch my clip on trajectory hermeneutics and how with the coming of time these things would have been forbidden so you can watch that they now somebody's asked a question was even a Hodja uncomfortable with the hadith in Bukhari well the last time I checked if in the Hodja wasn't the person we worship even a Hajer even a Hodja even a Hodja you know these two

they were great maja a theme salah abdeslam ah right and even a Hodja right even the Hajj it goes on to get influenced by evenness Allah the Haditha methodology created havoc which we are still trying to recover from and you know may Allah have mercy on them and bless them they did things there were great scholars in their own right in their own right I'm not denying their academics I'm not denying their capacity they memorize so many hadith a great people like this they were chef ie so they were already very dogmatists when it came to hadith

but they what they did by the way they brought this motor water thing into hadith before then wait if even a Salam brings this in this wasn't even a discussion to do with the science of hadith even a Salah brings this in and then even a higher kind of cements it you see I don't cave even a Hodja doesn't accept it even a Hodja also accepts the hadith of Satanic Verses did you know that if I just say is the hadith of that the Prophet added to the Quran the Satanic Verses he says yeah that's kind of okay 'his and hadith oh what the hell's that all about you say the hadith that the Prophet made up

verses of the Quran the verses in surah Najam that after a loss condemns well at welcome lads and minaton aza well Manasseh that when a losses were lateral also Aminata surly turtle okra that these three gods he then the narration said that Prophet then added the verse silca Veronica Lola those major entities were inertia fire at seven and a Tortuga these two things have just written above the Quran these are the Satanic Verses that indeed the intercession of these deities will be sought after in the day

of judgment that the Prophet said this they say to to to kind of please and appease the kuffar of garage that they say these two verses were added into the Prophet read them they were added into Quran but he read them in front of the kafar of garage and they all fell into prostration this this is referred to as the Satanic Verses this are the yard and all these great scholars condemned the hell out of these narrations as pure fabrications which they were no such thing and then comes even Hajj as much after them and says actually they're okay and when we look at this senator Hassan

they were acceptable what the hell are you on about they're acceptable you see nobody is above Allah and his messenger Allah and His Messenger nobody in my Malik told me that clearly that everybody you reject what they have to say except the messenger so if anybody comes to you with these kind of narrations if you hide your is saying something if now hide you say oh it's okay to marry a child because we think though no it's not okay right you might think it's okay people might say over would you condemn it look I'm not here to condemn people I'm here to just

criticize these ideas okay they were people who lived in a time where they did whatever the world did but we're not in their time so that's important to kind of clarify these things and I hope people will challenge these ideas there's also the concept by the way that the blood money of a woman and I'll go into this in much more detail in a future show the future episode that they say the blood money of a woman is half the blood money of a man and you know they claim the age man on all of these nonsense nonsense they base it on weak life the I've had Eve

the hadith they base it on and the sahih hadith says that al mu'minin al Muslim unter to care for d'amato whom that that Allah was a prophet was obviously speaking to people in further he speaking to the believers he said their blood is equal equal he never said a woman is less than a man yet in all these books they will say that there is each man on this they will say we accept that a woman only her blood money is only worth half of a man and this has nothing to do with inheritance this is to do with the blood money this is there's no verse in the Quran to do with this speaking about the men women

whatever Blood Money this is in a hadith a week have you live happy that they based this on so when you hear scholars throwing around terms like each ma Ajmer consensus be weary because when they use these terms it's usually because they lack evidence in something and they're trying to exert control so it's important that we that they challenge these things today that this is not true that all Muslim male or female they male or female they they blood money is the same right that and blood money was to do with accidental death it was

compensation so if you did something let's say you I don't know in the past you accidentally killed somebody you would have to pay compensation so they would say for a woman you pay half of what you pay for a man and and you see opinions it's their opinions but don't attribute this to Allah and His Messenger okay so that's what I say right so okay I hope some people are saying that they can't see the transmission I hope you guys can see is it is that okay the inheritance I'm going to mention something to do with inheritance you know that this a famous scholar today they've made this

inheritance thing into a big deal right like once again in the past there was a Maliki legend I'll ensure line the future go through some works dedicated to his book his name was even our boom okay and he's actually you know I've spoken about him Amboseli the great malachy legend who said that the capital punishments would change in his day and age he was from like the eight hundreds going into maybe nine hundreds like that so eight hundred eight hundred his early years so he was in the ninth century not going into nine

hundred eight hundred Hijri now so the ninth century of Hydra now this a pina Arun is actually like one of his future from his generation from his daughters line so from his daughters I think grandchild or something and he is also a great fatty in Islam very great Maliki done and his name is even hardened and I'll go through this his thing in much more detail in the future one at some point but he had an issue he had a fatwa which he passed a ruling in his day and age to do with inheritance it was to do with the wife

now you know the wife can only inherit a certain amount okay so whether she's going to whether she's going to get a fool or whether she'll get an eighth stuff like this depending on how many wives there are and stuff like this such the wife would only get a certain fraction and the children most likely would get more than the wife and the father would inherit and the mother would inherit and all this kind of stuff but the wife would get less okay so whether depending on the whole context of who's involved but she would get whether it's going to be an eighth or you know how many they are or fourth or

whatever these fractions will add up to in her situation depending on how many family members are involved in stuff but if not our lawn in his time passed a ruling and he was a great Maliki legend he said and this ruling became known as elekid wa CI a-- he said that look this woman who spent a great portion of her life with this man she said sorry he said that she would have helped him to achieve whatever you achieve even if she didn't physically help but she would have been doing things like taking care of the kids or

in many of these cases in the past she would have physically helped because even today in the rural part of the Muslim world women actually work in the fields they go they kind of they take the crops they kind of sift through them organize them do all of these things so he said that this woman cut and say ayah means your hard work and he said the hard work this woman has put in during her lifetime he said that this right he said if that this this is not fair so he passed a ruling and this ruling still

exists in the Maliki method today he said that the wife would inherit 50% of everything before the inheritance is even split so she would get half and then from the inheritance she would get her own allocated portion too so the inheritance then everybody can get their portion and she can claim her portion from the inheritance so she would get 50% of everything before there's any

division of any assets or anything now just look at that subhanAllah that now was he deemed a modernist this he was at Lee over 400 years ago he's deemed a great Maliki scholar of his age right now I totally agree with that I agree with his ruling totally now what I'm trying to say is that was he teamed you know people say oh you know you're making these things how will we make these things exist these scholars looked at it and said mmm in our day and age things are different so we need to we

need to put so they said we need to kind of make sure things reflect our own DNA so okay so that's enough um and there has been recently as well in Tunis they've got what they call the d1 if that which is the main kind of central body of giving fatwa which last year gave the fatwa that they felt men and women boys and girls are equal in inheritance and they are Maliki in fact people criticize them because they said oh they did this to please the government or whatever but they've got justifications they've got Quranic

verses and things like this and they show and they've passed that fatwa the fatwa does exist and that is now part of the law within Tunis Tunisia which is a Maliki it's run by Maliki principals in that sense so okay now right so let's let's move on people let's move on what are the things are we looking at any questions so that's right okay I wanted to also touch up on I'll give some reflections I'll try not to take too long on the this point I'll give some

reflections on the video made by sher Hassan Ali if I can get this to open that is because I had his points written down so now first of all this is my just my reflections on share has an Ali's video now share Hassan Ali who spoke about the second coming of Jesus he made a kind of Facebook live and he said he spoke about this now I want to highlight that I actually respect have have I do have great respect for chef as an ally I

see him as a kind of senior in age in that sense in respect I've met him personally on a few occasions we've disagreed in the past as well on other issues we've disagreed respectfully okay so I remember many years back we had this whole discussion on gin possession and stuff like this we disagreed one could say with zeal but still respectfully he still showed me a lot of respect look I don't know what's in people's hearts but I just go with the apparent okay so so in that sense what I saw from him was love and respect and he visited after

that I once drove him around and you know it's it my ma went recently was it last year the year before when chef yeah yes sir Adi came to London so I went down and he was there with me that time he met me we had a discussion a brief discussion we share here so called these well he was there as well sheíll Hassan Ali and even afterwards you know we went to get food very respectful asked me to sit next to him stuff like this discussed with me very so I have a respect for sure Hassan Ali I watched his video where he was

refuting and speaking about but once again you know he wasn't disrespectful and so in that sense I have a policy as long as somebody's respectful to me I will always be respectful back to them so just some points on what he said he brought forward a few points he you see I like he was there was more transparency which he has an ally so he made a point very clear in saying that look this thing of the second coming of Jesus cannot be clearly proven from the Quran so let's focus on the hadith I like that because at least that was an

only step and you know so and that's the truth so okay he he highlights that look he starts he goes through several hadith and he mentions hadith and he says that look the he says look the majority the Muslims believe that Jesus is coming back I accept that the majority of the Muslims do believe it but they believe it because they've been totally a story since they were kids majority the Muslims believe ya jus Jamaat huge have these very long years which they go to sleep in and then these

kind of likely critter like I don't know like gremlin like creatures and and most of the Muslims believe that it doesn't make it true there's no sigh he had these to prove stuff like that but this is what yeah dude Matt dude look like these kind of gremlins with long gears and they put one off of them when they go to sleep and they put the other one underneath them and and there are all these kind of things these stories that we all I heard as a child and we all heard just because probably ninety over ninety percent of Muslims probably believe that about yeah judy module it doesn't make it true so just because Muslims believe it but that's more so to do with them just

being indoctrinated by whilst they were young indoctrinated is strong word but they were kind of put this mythology he says that look this does come in a hadith he quote several hadith right I'm just trying to go through some of his points here now the thing is I'm not denying that these things don't come in hadith my angle if you watch my preload I would advise if share Hasan a leaders watch this then chef shook her and for your response first of all and secondly I would advise if you do have some time I know you're a busy person but if you take out some time and watch my previous

video it is on YouTube and I explain why this is a narrative in crisis it's not to do with the fact is there a hadith I know there's plenty of hadith but the hadith have problems and it's not just and I will in time to come in my detail video in the future which will be like a course like video so I will dedicate several hours to everything in that video I will show the East Nadi problems but this is more than just it's not the issue here is that the details inside these hadith clash with Islam stuff like Jesus will force people to become Muslim Jesus when

he comes he will seal the deal there will be no more evil left on the earth he will be a judge he will you know animals will become vegetarians he will break the you know these kind of things don't make any sense and then I understand sure Hassan Ali said these things maybe like metaphor but then the whole thing could be a metaphor one could argue you know if if you're saying everything you know the breaking of the cross as a metaphor the killing of the pig is a metaphor that evil disappearing is a metaphor if if you say the animals becoming vegetarian our metaphor if you say you know if you're saying everything

is a metaphor that oh he will force people to become Muslim is a myth then why is Jesus the only non metaphor if so it doesn't make any sense okay now you see he highlights I think she has an ally highlights that look all scholars have had minority opinions this is interesting you see because what chef doesn't see here minority majority he says that show me a scholar in the past

who had just rare opinions this many let's begin with imam abu hanifa imam abu hanifa in his own day in age was seen as an absolute deviant by people and this is just a fact you just need to read the comments on him why because he had isolated opinions from everybody if you see even has them other people transmitting from abu hanifa they say oh this they'll say he said this well let me pull me I don't mean cobbler cobbler who feel Islam nobody before him in Islam had ever said that statement on so many statements about hanifa said that

he had his own ruling his own niche they had a good look like up until the time of abu hanifa everybody believed that zakat would be given like let's say solder control fitter or Sicard you couldn't give it in money you'd give it from the actual thing the actual I mean you would obviously the cut in money would be given of money but other things like let's say you've got so the culture of the cotton fitter or other kind of things they must be given from let's say we to offer you know the actual kind of staple diet in my mama honey if I said no you can give money because money at the end of the day it's the objective he went against the

absolute reading and the consensus of all the ulama and all the Sahaba before him but he didn't matter because he said you know at the end of the day Islam is trying to help the poor what better way to help them than to give them money because they can use it for their own needs you see not so many things imam abu hanifa was the first but yes just because today his views have become a majority in several parts of the world but that's to do with time that's to do with power positions following politics sectarianism is to do with a lot of things to do with the fact that his student abu yusuf becomes the supreme

judge of the muslim world and spreads the Hanafi method like wildfire because he would only appoint a judge if the judge was Hanafy so you're telling me that didn't play a role in the Hanafi mother becoming accepted if you read the statements of the imams about abu hanifa when he died you'll be shocked read what imam ahmed mohamed liked to say about him read was Sophie an authority is contemporary we had to say but they really spiteful words they were like they would you know all this they show you in these lectures this nice and loving and lovey-dovey they weren't like I mean they had that side at times but

read they would read the criticism of Abu Hanifah by these great scholars they rip him to shreds they really harsh and almost vulgar almost towards him they they speak of him like they say when he died people will I thank God that deviant has died they were like really really bitter towards him so this is right so this is so when he's saying you know Sheikh Hassan Ali says yeah the scholars had a minority opinion at times this minority majority is deemed by later people it's not deemed by the people at the time

because this is a power position you see you don't you can't say oh look looking back that was a minority position because that could have been a majority position if it took oh if we took up let's say the Shia became the majority of Muslims then Sunnis would be deemed as deviants and a minority if the Shia today were outnumbered the Sunnis we would just be see as like a deviant sect and they would be seen as mainstream Muslims so it's not these are power positions this isn't like something which like I'm

not trying to say I don't disagree with the she I do disagree with the Shia and a point but what I'm trying to say is who deems her to be the the majority minority is to do with how politics plays out and how power positions play out over era over time so so he asks a question she has an ally did the Prophet say these things I don't believe the Prophet said these things about Jesus coming back I honestly don't now yes you've got plenty of heavy but tell me tell me something why are 80 percent

almost of these hadith only through Abu Hurairah of the Aloha did you know that that almost 80 percent of all these had these to do with Jesus coming back or just through Abu Huraira so you know when they say we've got so many hadith they just all going through Abu Hurairah and about 50% of them are just going through one person if does she have Zoey so you know when they keep saying we've got so many tens and tear or car stop counting the hundreds I got it's the same thing they're just going through the same person and I will show

in my detailed video did you know things look guys here's an interesting point did you not because we all know Abu Hurairah used to learn a lot from converts he used to learn from Campbell a bar he used to learn from Abdullah bin Salam to the extent that needs to think so highly of the above a lot of the alarm and spent a whole day at Mount Sinai he traveled thee and he studied with Kabbalah haha he says in the hadith he was teaching me from the Torah I was teaching him what the Prophet used to say did you know there's a hadith check this hadith are people they say hadith that Abu Hurairah transmits from this one I believe it's

in Sahih Muslim as well but Oh am i sorry this one might be Muslim Ahmed but I mean the chamber at this stage is irrelevant but it's from Abu Huraira to the Prophet saying that the most harsh of my Ummah against that the gel will be bunny to me the tribe of Tamim yeah I like because bunny to me was seen as like kind of hard knocks back in the day so they used to kind of have this thing about them that we're kind of hard knocks and stuff and you know in that famous poem the guy says what is the nasty tamati lied to me me Danza he goes in the might of the people it kind of completes with to me because Tama means

to complete and Tamim comes from the width um this is why isin nasi tell my Aletta me me and that's part of the poem and so the thing is that look they had this thing that they used to think we're done zand they're really strong and stuff so this Abu Huraira says I heard the Prophet say this and this is in the books of hadith that they will be the strongest in fighting the Dajjal yet yet Oh naughty naughty the same hadith this thing is transmitted in the other books of hadith image with a chain going back to Kabul a bar cab the who was the comfort converted to Islam not as a

saying of the Prophet as he is saying he says you know I like from the Arabs I like to me Bunny Tamim and he says that you know buddy Tamim they will be the harshest against the Dajjal you see and you have to remember Abu Hurairah I used to sit and he would teach hadith non-stop like this like Sardella hadith they call this in Arabic saddle hadith he would just go one two three four and then he would talk as well maybe the people writing it from him would think everything he's saying is from the Prophet maybe the people from

them would think that I'll tell you another one guys this one is gonna shock you yeah right check this out you know the famous hadith about that they will be women who are dressed yet naked and you know this famous hadith everybody's heard it right and that they will be in the Hellfire and they will genera dyes will be forgiven for forgiven forbidden for them and you can smell paradise from 500 years of a journey of something very famous hadith right so this hadith is in sahih muslim from abu hurayrah that he

heard the prophets saying he heard the prophet say that they will come up people who men who will hold on to like the tails of cows right and women who will be dressed yet naked and they will be from the Hellfire and they will generally be forbidden for them even though you could smell it from whatever now Imam Malik you see my Malik is a Don he brings this hadith in the mosque table but he stops it on Abu Huraira now people don't realize the wisdom in what Imam Malik was doing they think oh he

brought this as a hadith he brings it and stops it as a statement of Abu Huraira now people say yeah but this sounds like a hadith now it does until you find in the other books of hadith like I believe even a B che ba and other people have brought the hadith with the chain going back to Kabul a bar cap discomfort who by the way doesn't convert in the prophet's time he was around in the prophet's time but converts in almost time he the chain goes back to him he

begins by saying and I read in the Torah that and then the exact same wording of the hadith that a time will come when men will hold on to the tails of cows and women will be dressed yet naked and gender will be forbidden for them and you can smell Jenna from five hundred years from the Torah he says not from Allah and His Messenger so look people yes this hadith I know this hadith but these are the eighty percent of them are just coming through Abu Hurairah we here are the great companions ways

Abubakar where is Omar do you know there's not a single hadith about Jesus coming from Abu Bakr Omar Ali Osman any of these people you telling me the great companions never knew the Akita abu huraira or the allah one who comes to islam in just three years before the prophet passes away yes he spends time with the Prophet yes and he must transmits he non-stop transmission Omar odilon told him off said you know what he's actually said I'm gonna beat you if I see you continuously transmitting like this because he says you say things which I've got no idea where'd you get

this stuff from and he himself admits learning from other people now I'm not saying whether the mistake was from him or whether it's from people after him or listening to him saying ten things or twenty hadith sorry not hadith let's say there's twenty things that he's teaching and they think all of them are from the Prophet but maybe two of them weren't two of them he picked up from and Kabbalah bar or from abdullah bin salam from other people but the people writing it just write them all as one so so anyway i hope that makes kind of sense now the other thing that sheikh hassan

ali mentions he he mentioned some principles i'm gonna skip some of these to go into I think it's it's worth discussing his principles he says I would like to fair play to him though he said about each man and stuff this kind of stuff is always debated and motiroti he does make a point in saying he feels that in motiroti any hadith can be made into art either - correct - correct the chef now according to the Hadees and the Martelli these who make up the bulk of the Sunni Muslims that is not true okay

only firmly established hadith like so many what they do call what Allah you know this discussion on water water was actually an updated discussion first had nothing to do with Hadees it was even a Salah who kind of brings it into hadith but these people it was nothing to do with heavy initially it was to do with a soul a soul effect and soon of Ikeda right so he says that they don't have to be motivated that's not true according to the majority of the scholars they do have to be motivated so just to correct the sheriff that he that might be his opinion I respect that but that's not the the method he represents like the

Hanafy method that's not the Hanafi method right so right he highlights sep 7 or so argument which he can summer he asks look if a person if you reject a hadith in Bukhari will you be consistent of course I will I'll be consistent in rejecting and he asks what is your principles look my principles are simple I'll highlight them to see if I have eath is valid you can check the chain once that's fine then three these are the principles right here as they in the books of hadith by the way these are in

most alone hadith by even a handsome by even or Jozy even to three bara we've so UT they all mentioned these things that it cannot go against reason number one that's and they actually put it as number one it cannot go against the established Quran and Sunnah and he cannot approve the principle of Islam that's my principle I'm how I'll happily share my principles with you he asked that what are the principles of methodology there you go that's my methodology and if any hadith clashes with these things it's unacceptable unacceptable he said would you allow other people to do this of course as to the common laypeople

look I'm as I've said before in my dialogue on the AMA in my lecture on the age of Aisha common people don't understand like they don't haven't studied this science so I would say to them if they confused about hadith they should speak to scholars but if it bothers them but they feel that this hadith must goes against Islam for them in the understanding then I would say it's safe for you to not practice that hadith even if you haven't consulted but if you felt it went against you on standing of Islam you can suspend it right that's absolutely fine and then you can seek guidance on it and you can

seek clarification nothing wrong with that so if you found a hadith for example saying you know let's say that you find a hadith about I don't know something saying you can kill yourself or you can do these so you think I don't think my understanding of Islam doesn't allow that well you find this hadith that says oh every time you kill a lizard a gecko you get all these rewards which is in Buhari and by the way and in I believe it's in Muslim as well but it's so every time you kill a lizard you get all these rewards and and that hadith makes no sense okay because the

hadith says the reason you kill them is because the gecko the small lizard blew into the fire of Ibrahim Ali sanam to kind of make it heat it up do you think come on so what would one lizard do to the fire of ibraheem alehissalaam and even if you didn't want to kill that lizard why are you killing all these lizards like I doubt it these lizards did that and it's about it lizards or conscious beings like they don't plan I think I'm gonna get you back like so why are you killing lizards and it says if you kill the lizard in the one go you

get a hundred rewards and if you kill it in two girls you get like I think fifty or something and if you kill it in three dollars you get ten or something it mentions this hadith is made-up there's no way on earth that is a hadith right so and then this thing you see another thing she has an ally part of his argument was scare mongering now I get this a lot of mallanna's do this this is nothing personal to share has an ally who I mentioned I have great respectful but this is just part of the trend of that mulana trend you see to get the masses they've try to intimidate

them you know how will you be on the day of judgement when you rise up amongst these people and you know would you like you know this kind of scare mongering the whole theme like if you doubt hadith if you doubt this hadith today tomorrow you'll doubt or an watch watch like these kind of things you're scaring people but that's not true because look I could show you these hadith like now let's say I showed you that this Geco hadith which is sahi and let's say people saying oh you can marry a little girl because it's in Buhari oh if you deny that then tomorrow you're gonna deny the Quran no I could show you

a hadith in Sahih Muslim that is insulting I think to the prophet and to Ali that the Prophet sent early to go murder somebody because the Prophet so he was having an affair with one of his his own apparently according to this narration the Prophet slave girl who wasn't his slave girl was his wife but they say his slave girl so he wanted to kill her cousin and then when I Lee goes there he finds that the person doesn't even have the male genitalia like if the person's having a bath he gets up he doesn't even have a private but it's been unfortunately cut so how could have he had an affair so I'll he kind of leaves him and says Oh comes back and tells the Prophet in the Prophet that says all okay what on earth is that what on earth is that that's

utter garbage utter rubbish it's blasphemy so you telling me if people reject that today tomorrow they're gonna reject the Quran no of course not they need to reject stuff like that so Buhari Muslim these are not the Word of God so I think look this scheme mongering thing that on the day of judgement what will you do where will you be and stuff like these do you want to rise up tomorrow with these people or rise up with those people relax none of these Day of Judgment business right look everybody is trying to attain the truth everybody is trying to attain the truth so I think that kind of stuff is a skimming during which a lot of

unfortunately a lot of Imams do that okay and fair enough look share Hassan Ali said it's his belief that Jesus will come that's fine that's his belief I mean Jesus isn't gonna come but if you want to believe in it that's fine I you know it's your your situation I don't have a problem with that I'm just showing and he did say that look this is a debate about principles that and once again that once you Oh one of these kind of worms of questioning beliefs everything is gonna fall to pieces I think that's because of

your lack of faith in our team that this team is much stronger than that by removing cobwebs the Dean is not gonna fall apart and I can guarantee you this Dean is not gonna fall apart right so I think that this kind of scare mongering that look if we question this today then tomorrow all of Islam is gonna show up as weak then that's I think you've got a low opinion of Islam if not the share but anybody who thinks that I think they've got a low opinion of Islam right so I think you need to question things of course you need to question things otherwise anybody's gonna get anything

past you somebody asked today why are wiping the socks part of it either Creed that's because the she I don't do it so they just want to get back at the Shia by saying let's do this so really it's got nothing to do with Creed nothing to do with Creed but yet they've put it in the books of Creed just to distinguish themselves from other groups right so that was my response to chef Hassan Ali so you know just like a long hey for making that video may Allah bless you and there was a little you see I I

did want to say that look one point that look at the end of the day we are all Muslims we are all part of the majority the Sunni thing and I would advise that you know if anything just treat this as a difference of opinion so when you're speaking to your followers just please address them as this is a difference that's all you can say it's a minority difference but just treat it like that don't don't treat it like don't sectarian I see because this is nothing to do with sex okay so that's that right the second thing isn't really second

okay this is now a response to share Mulvey share yes it'll Hanafy now share the acid al Hanafy on the contrary who did a speech acyl now I just want to begin by saying a sofa which is Maulana Sahib should say he's Institute I have great respect for okay now once again I don't know what's in people's hearts I only go by what apparent okay so chef there's people like chef sir he must eat yogurt move the Imran these people I have great in

my heart I have love and respect for because from what I've seen from them so far is love and respect and at the end of the day even if we disagree on things and a lot they you know from as far as I'm concerned they are in a very respectable and dignified position in my eyes you know I may Allah bless them you know they're doing great ground like grassroots efforts they teach people you know there's a lot of the homeless projects they've got going feeding people true Islam which I think and we disagree on things and that's not a problem to me but I'm just wanted to

clarify that now at the Institute yes al Hanafy you know Maulana Saab came down and gave a lecture mawlana saab on the other hand this mallanna yeah said at the open deal Hanafy i don't know if he's really a true version of the Hanafi but i mean that's his on the on the contrary i i don't feel i don't really hold in a very respectable position I used to and I'm gonna be honest I have a policy that as long as you show me respect I will not you know I I only respond to people once they've openly disrespected me

I will then feel that it's fair game as Mawlana Yunus no money saw one of my teachers I would like to consider him a great mana zero debater from Pakistan when you come here we you stay at my friend's house at nasse house and he used to say that you know I'm long gone a chair there and we don't we don't pick on people but your home a chair tie was good for thinning but whoever picks on us we don't let that person go so this yes Annelle Hanafy decided to pick on me now he I contacted him as well he shared

a he shed a lecture by by chef daddle the great Maliki Mauritanian scholar who does when it comes to beliefs is Salafi inclined and we he is doing tuk feed it was a video aimed at dr. Adnan Ibrahim from a few years back saying anybody who denies the second coming of Jesus is a cat feel so shaky Asif shaped this and I contacted him and I said to him sure I'm really kind of disappointed and hurt that you know that you shed and we had this kind of dialogue and I said look

okay will you at least clarify because you implicitly encouraging Muslims to call her the Muslims careful why would you do that why would you do that I mean you you know better than that and you don't believe this yourself you don't believe I'm a caliphate for not believing in that so why are you implicitly encouraging this I said would you at the least put on the a message when you share it would you put in your words say that look although I'm sharing this for information but I do not believe this and I do not encourage Muslims to call her the Muslims Cadfael

would you at least put that in and he disagreed he said no like he wouldn't he left it as it was and he said to me I'm sharing it for information I said a cha-cha posh huh information I said I don't see you sharing his videos where he says that you don't have to follow mother I said I don't see you sharing his videos where he says women can go wearing makeup and stuff like this and they could take photos no see you sharing those for information I don't see you share his videos on the selfie

Utley therefore information and now it's information just because I've taken this stance I was like a charger charger you know this this so people like that they they've taken these open digs at me tacitly saying it's okay to call me a cow Phil so okay so with people like that I I have no respect for I'm gonna be honest so people like that I don't respect so this is nothing to do with the Institute we delivered this he delivered this a sofa Institute which I do have great respect for and so for those people you know may Allah preserve

them and bless them in their lives but as to share Maulana Yassir at the open the Alana V then in the words of the author poet Ahmed for us who says that you know now let us try some different miracles through our poetry huh they says all good Karishma gazelka dict now let us try some this poetry for us observe a ledger but delicate egg thing that for us let us change our tone a little and then see what happens so

people like this he I have to say I am so disappointed in his his presentation he said I watched his presentation and he says okay I'm not going to tackle any heavy I'm not going to tackle any hadith I'm going to prove unequivocally through the Quran alone that Jesus is coming back right so Mawlana yes here at the open this up first of all I have to say people honestly and this is not me

taking a dig this is me being objective that what has happened to the state we can we resurrect Jesus later on but can we resurrect the English language and bring that back please seriously is this british-born scholarship it's it's I

think if nobody was arguing for the coming of Jesus except maulana yeah said at the oven this heart i think that enough to even turn the Christians away from me oh I mean did you guys seriously watch it I can't I can't get over the fact that the level of English sounds like that I mean this is not me trying to take it I'm being honest that why like at one point chef yes it begins this lecture and he says okay so God took up a large hook up Jesus Christ he took him up with

his body with his body is disembody jism Andrew body and jism and he says so the muscle is about killing body it's about killing body so what is the opposite of not killing body what is the opposite of killing body tell me so he says what is the opposite of killing body so the the audience are like I don't know what's the opposite of killing body he says not killing body what is the opposite of

sleeping it is not sleeping what is the opposite of driving it is not rising honestly you couldn't make this stuff up you know you couldn't make it up I'm being honest this is British born British born people yeah after watching so I wanted to clarify that Annie brings all the verses of the Quran I realized what the problem was with malaviya Sidhu Bundy's huh the problem is it's it's the word

unequivocal so people have printed that off from the dictionary calm this is unequivocal right so we're going to read through unequivocal he said I will be proving unequivocally right so unequivocal this is from dictionary calm okay not not so also so far I like I like this one I like not equivocal unambiguous okay okay unambiguous clear Oh having only one

possible meaning or interpretation having only one possible people having only one possible meaning or interpretation oh so the whole misunderstanding was on the word unequivocal how can you prove this from the Koran unequivocally how can you prove it when each one of those verses has several interpretations oh yeah

seriously yeah yeah I'm Anthony father Anthony Gonzales okay Anthony Gonzales what is it what's going on here what unequivocal means the only has one clear understanding then you close it quotes all these verses and the verses have multiple understandings so he says see I proved it unequivocally thinking I say putana

honestly ya Salam yes hello oh my god I think even Christians watching that stopped believing in the second coming of Jesus Christ after that that was hilarious and then he said oh you know he miss quotes and this is another thing look why can't we just be honest as colors why can't we just be honest this is another problem like we want to just insult and like trick the crowd into thinking like look I can tell you that let's say let's say he used

a verse of the Quran I'll be honest I've said in the past that's one understanding but the other understanding is this why can't we just be honest this is poor scholarship so it comes to this this verse of addressing Jesus where the people said kafir no currently woman can a film a disappear how can we speak to somebody and he says oh when he speaks to us raw shellfish rod he said you know he picks up on man kana kana was past tense and then he says this is yes have a double knee he

says oh who said kana is past tense and amidst quotes check this out he says I misquote a Lucy I don't misquote him now yes what you could have said you see that this is fair let's be fair you could have said right what he could have said was oh his reading of a Lucy is different like I don't you know that's an interpretation of what you of what a Lucy saying that's a take on it we've

got a different take on it he could say that that's fine but to say I'm miss quoting now why would you do that like you you see you're just trying to gain credibility and discredit my authenticity now let's look here is in rural my earning sheriff a Lucy the Hanafi when speaking about this verb about this verse man can - Oh Kelly moment carnival Maddy Subbiah first of all begins by saying Allah kitada al-muhajiroun me so okay what is the math he starts explaining it then he

says was - skeletal ayah then the ayah brings about a problem be an Akula menu kalamoon us carnival midi so BIA habla semantically me filet hakuna Mahan Lalita a jubilant car he says okay here the presents a problem because everybody who was in the math in the cradle as a young boy you know he says that but everybody was like this so why what is the like you know why are they saying that because everybody used to be like this then he brings zamok sherry a whole

chunk of zamok Sherry's huge paragraph to answer this and he says as a mother sherry answers this front this is what I Lucy results to first he brings two points from zamok sorry to say kind of past tense here can mean the near past so okay it's a past tense verb but it's maybe he means like oh he was as in it's not so long ago like maybe within months with him you know like like within the near past tense as opposed to the distant past he brings this then he

brings another angle then Lucy also brings about way they're saying what if the word canna was entirely extra then Lucy brings the judge saying okay canna can also be a condition what if we use this okay but note note the first and foremost thing that a Lucy does is highlights the problem in saying this verse has presented a problem because canna is past tense they're addressing him in the past tense and what is the

whole purpose of that so because why is that then such a thing because we all were children at one point and then he brings a machete saying just to find that it was the past tense but maybe it was the near past tense okay so have I miss quoted now I could understand that he could say okay that's a you know I I see what most he abou lathe is doing here he is taking this but we understand here that although a Lucy does bring that first as his first response to this problem but we think maybe he too a more inclination to the second

interpretation of saying this was extra but to say I've lied he goes he lied look at that he openly says I lied I haven't lied I just read to you what he actually says so this is poor scholarship you see what I mean now that is the problem now okay so this this thing of wisdom and then he justifies it by saying kana comes in the Quran on many occasions to refer to things like this on an example and an example he quotes Allah bless him he quotes verses

to do with Allah now everybody knows Allah is not bound by time everybody knows that so if you're gonna say about Allah was like imagine we use a verse to say Allah was all-seeing then we know that Allah is all seen Allah will be because any time and place used with God has no restriction on God everybody knows that but just look at what Mulvey yah said at the Bundy is doing to justify Jesus he's comparing him to God I mean that's exactly my point that you

are inheriting this from Christianity that this this kind of thing that to justify that you can use karna what he ought to have done is just said look about a way that says this let's go with that take that Kanna is that you they come sometimes I either that's fine but to justify he doesn't go into that he justifies it by using the verses of the Quran that described God which just proves my point further that look you are being misled so that's and then honestly the rest of it was just appalling he brings all these he says

how can Allah what is the purpose of Allah saying we've raised Jesus what is the purpose if there isn't this purpose many more for Syrians say that that this was to do with that that is an interpretation they except that if nayad goes through great lengths other Dino Rossi it goes to great lengths to say this is talking about his mom his is that his station is elevated and then moldy our Citadel Bundy says what's the point of that of mentioning my arm and why would Allah mention about a prophet because all prophets have a great mom but Allah

mentions they go to surah Maryam Allah says worth could fill kitabi Idris and remember at least he tells them speak about a dress that that in Nam can a CD anivia that he was somebody so truthful and a Nabi were and Allah mentions walaqad Ravana who sorry what a phonemic an and alia and we raised him to an elevated map our allies speaking about a prophet this is what a funnel mckernon alia and that's actually in surah maryam so look so what is the I don't understand it goes all this doesn't make any this is and there was a point where

to be honest he said he say something like mockery and I didn't I I thought he was speaking about there's a verse that is to do with Jesus which says macaroon macaron and you know and Allah made them occur they plot go to waste like obviously a lost plot I'll kind of perform them now but then I realized oh sorry he was referring to the word mockery yes a mercury mercury this is a mockery of the Dean and I thought he's talking about the mercury this is to do with a plot so I was trying to figure out his angle on it like well what does

he mean about the plot thing then I realize a cha-cha-cha he's saying the English word mockery yeah one thing I didn't get in all of this is I would never have thought that the concept of the second coming of Jesus would have been taken up so passionately by the manga tour group

that's no disrespect to the moon Gators but I'm just saying that I don't understand why why all of a sudden so this thing and and then he uses the same verses which I've already answered all these things about shabiha la whom that Jesus may have been killed like this just read for Odin Rossi and then he says this is the interesting thing he says look you kill him on merciful Matthew what Carolyn he will speak to them as a as a young boy he was in the cradle and as a man and he says and Oh Dino Rossi says the miracle of

that is that he will come back for Oh Dino Rossi does make mentions three different interpretations for that and he says himself we believed he reached corral in this dunya and he says cattle can be from three I mean was he even listening to me I actually said all of this already how is this on earth quick how is this unequivocal unequivocal how is that unequivocal Danny I don't honestly I'm lost for words man and then he goes on about hardly anything let me clarify something here people this is very important the rDNA movement has only

taken off because of this Messiah concept because of these people endorsing that a messiah can come the Qadiani managed to take off his movement did you know something let me add let me kind of excessive you there is a hadith of the Prophet where he said that I am that he's the final messenger there who comes at the end lalana be a body and there will be no no be after me the Prophet doesn't go on to speak about Jesus coming he doesn't mention that Jesus will come but he just

says I am the last prophet there will be no prophet after me because some many of these all Imam bent over backwards to justify the second coming of Jesus they had to justify this issue now how can a profit come after the prophet muhammad salallahu alayhi wasalam so they said that jesus will come as an ugly yes because if you strip him of his nabuwa if you say it's not a nubby some of them tried that angle in saying he's not a Navi and the problem with that is when he comes he's gonna change the Sharia like he's gonna say force

people he's gonna change the jizya no more jizya he's gonna say to people either accept Islam or kill you to the death and he'll force people to become Muslim now that goes against the prophets teachings so to do this he has to be a prophet so they came up with a concept they said he's a Nabi Amati or an Athena B now the interesting thing is this Athena B concept that Jesus will come us is exactly what Qadiani then claimed Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadiani he

said he was matina B because he said that Jesus had died a natural death but the Jesus they're waiting is him awaiting is him so he is the awaited Jesus these people paved the way for Karndean is to come that the the Qadiani movement is built on the arguments of Jesus coming except they said that Jesus jesus the son of mary has died but the jesus that you think is the son of mary is actually called eonni who is a

prophet he's a Nabi Almighty he's also part of the umma Barnaby and do you know something the founder of the opened right now mallanna awesome no not we now casa minha not Rahab who founded the opened he has a book called illness and actually what's interesting is shed a cerrar has a video on youtube speaking about this it's it's in one of his to do with the open the [Music] beliefs or something like the open D belief so somebody's got a few videos

but one of them is addressing this now he has a book called a theorem mass which is to do with a hadith of it not bus which is that there are many worlds like your worlds and each world has an atom and each world has these and each world has these and they will have a prophet like your prophet so people then said well what if a prophet comes after like let's say on one of the other worlds he comes after our prophet is our prophet still the final prophet so now marana pass him in a node V goes on to say that a prophet can come after the prophet muhammed sallalahu leaves a limb but it doesn't negate him being the

final prophet because that prophet that comes after and he was so kind of ties in with the Jesus thing that that prophet will be like an unworthy Nabi okay and and and also in the other worlds it will be because he's kind of he say he's coming before after it doesn't make a difference but our prophet he's the heart among nabiyeen but if a prophet comes after him it doesn't affect him being the seal of the prophets this is what Mawlana awesome manatee writes now based on this and based on this work maulana rose Ahmed mallanna Ahmed Raza Hungary we declared him a kaffir

and he took his book to the haramein and had all these orlimar sign that he was a calf in and this was his book called for Samuel haramein and this was the key beef that they had part of the key beef with the do Bundy's they declared him Kathryn based on this belief that you allowed prophets after the prophet and this each man and do you know this work and this writing in this quotation and ruling of mallanna passionately a do body has been quoted by cardi unease and justified they used it to kind of

justify they own that hula music mat Qadiani can come because he's an almighty maybe and maulana opossum mono tree has even said that that's okay so I don't see people like yeah Sarah Deobandi attacking him I don't see them problematizing his thing I don't see them saying this is nonsense but it's okay to say oh he said he said about me I said that Jesus died on earth and this is what Audion II said I don't care cardi Annie said if that's

coincidental I told you that even a bar of the along on m'lady I told which is in Buhari I told you Imam Malik City I don't don't bring to me oh because God the only said it light as though I've been influenced by him I haven't so in fact my whole thing there is no Messiah how can that whole Ghulam Mirza Ahmed Qadiani be a messiah when there is no Messiah in Islam that the Maddy Maddy means the rightly guided Maddy the greatest of all rightly guided has already come and been and he was muhammad the messenger of allah sallallahu alayhi wasallam we are not

awaiting a Maddy a guided after the greatest of all madyun of the person who was guided and that was the Messenger of God who came from mankind and you know this thing he said oh that uh you know he said why not the prophet muhammad salallahu alaihe salam or a different prophet why jesus why Jesus and he says but look Jesus had miracles that the Prophet didn't have you know so this doesn't matter you see that right that is a red herring I'm not speaking I'm not saying I never said that Jesus had to be identical with the Prophet

Muhammad or Moses or nor or Abraham I never said that so there's no point telling me all Jesus had a different life you know he what about this he cured people who were sick you know he did this or he brought back people from the dead and stuff like where is the Prophet Muhammad I never said that there is a big difference between individual things and between who seals the deal who does F like the whole of mankind who is sent for the whole of mankind

that everybody submits at his hands they were saying they arguing that's Jesus that even the Prophet Muhammad in his life only Arabia kind of came to him and embraced Islam but the whole of mankind will submit at the to their knees at the hands of Jesus Christ that's a big that's different to saying that that claim is what I was speaking of not the fact that all but Jesus lived here the Prophet lives there oh but why did Jesus get this how come the Prophet never got that I wasn't talking about these little

things like this I was saying this is such this is a make or break this is everything Jesus wasn't even centum than Michael it wasn't even sent to you know the human race as a whole even in Christianity the debate between st. James and all these other people after Jesus was about this and between st. Paul and someone that do we take this to the Gentiles or do we keep this to the Jews but the Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam sealed everything he was sent that rahmatan lil Alamein now to say that yes but at the end of time

everybody will submit by force all by their own choice but at the hands of Jesus Christ who will judge over them that is that is that is a problem yes that's not me being petty over a little you know but all but Jesus got to do this and how come the Prophet never got to do this so Moses you know did this and how come Abraham did this and the Prophet that's not being petty yeah that's me being very realistic so yeah so that's I think these things were very important that was to kind of yeah Civ and Hanna feared the oven the end you

know it disappointed me that you the deal Bundy's based on these kind of statements have been called kouf are kaffir by the Brahimi's for decades and decades yeah and I don't just I don't agree with calling people kaffir okay I disagree with that approach but they have been called kaffir for decades on end yeah for some statements which I do find ridiculous but I don't call them careful that's I do find the statements ridiculous but I say look some of these things depends which statement like this

statement I find it absurd now the point is now you should know better than to share things about calling of the Muslims careful how can you encourage the creative of the Muslims you know you should know better than that so you know this one not nice you know nothing nothing on one hand you are firming Qadiani on other hand I want you to condemn awesome nano3 sobs thing

condemn it he's paving the way for the Oh Bundy I me sorry sorry of course the Bundy but paving the way for Qadiani condemned it as nonsense and absurd and it's like the kind of ridiculous statement that it is condemning now um then then you can come and attack me and say oh maybe I'm saying certain things oh this stuff otherwise this selective or when it's your own you turn a blind eye oh don't worry I chose I chose it at the up naming it up with the sack home

are fainting of Hawkins we're saying in about 7 you can murder up to 7 people it's forgiven don't worry Bob yeah this one and then you know you come in doing all these reputations of father Gonzales Anthony Gonzales this is why so in the words of Antony gonzo isn't it that same Anthony Gonzales A's

father Cobra Donnie Bob get them Bob so take that from me yeah rich Timmy huh me Temari Bob like this does a nice you know lathe Abu layth you can take that and so next time before you decide to criticize me why don't you look in your own backyard start off with Asim Nano Theresa condemn rip his works to shreds please condemn these things and then come to me don't worry buddy and also please chello the other thing the English language we have to work on

that no wonder seriously no one that is brexit man I kind of I think like these things we really need to up our game as as you know the scholars and stuff like this because is this one not nice you know we born raised here you know this one we need to we need to be like here you know otherwise this one mercury you know luckily this is his mercury of the British values you know the English language all right god damn and this is

been so so that one was unequivocally mockery I tell you this one unequivocal mockery so my brother's inshallah I think I'll leave that today other than that of course to malaviya said by the way other than that if you you know if you show respect then there's much love your way if you show respect but that was your respect to me saying it's okay to call me a Kaffir so how's this fair game then right people to wrap that up some serious a few serious words I think it's

time to be serious people yeah I think it's time to have a serious conversation now right so right I want to answer a question somebody has asked me this it is actually way past my time but I'll try to get through this quickly somebody has asked me are you influenced

by Muhammad Abdul and Rashid Rida so this is a bit of a serious serious one people so need to be serious on this am i influenced by I want to turn up to a debate with this seriously just think about it people I'll be in a debate like this keep a straight face now now la la la mawlana honest that

would be awesome that would be like a dream I'm gonna do that I'm gonna do that in the future some point right so okay so now right somebody's asked me have I been influenced by Rashid Rida shares Rashid the reborn Sheikh Muhammad Abduh look I haven't I don't actually know too much about these scholars share cus rod mentioned the same thing first of all I want to highlight something

part of what a lot of the clergy mallanna's do is they want to you see when they want to disagree with you they want to discredit you so they start off by thinking okay divide and conquer so he's part of the Maliki thing now the Maliki thing is a little kind of legacy within Islam if we attack the Maliki thing is too much so let's dissociate him with the Maliki fit to start off with let's link him to some modern-day kind of scholars and then we can kind of attack them because

a lot of people don't like them anyway the truth is look I do have respect I have great respect for people like chef Mohammad Abdu Shara she's radar but the truth is I haven't actually studied much of their stuff I haven't actually read the thing I've read some things over time like sometimes I've come across opinions and I've read stuff but not generally I've read very little from Muhammad Abduh or Mossad Rashid Rida I don't even have his top seed tough cinnamon are and in fact when I spoke of him recently I actually made a mistake I when I was speaking of his visit to the

Obon did my recent video I quoted him as Cheryl as her I thought he used to be the Cheryl as her somebody actually messaged me and told me that by the way you know Mufti you quoted chef Rashid Rida as the Cheryl as her and that's actually wrong he wasn't the Cheryl as her and so I googled it and he wasn't the Cheryl as her I'm sure Mohammad Abdu was the Grand Mufti of Egypt and he was his student so I was wrong on that fact I mean on the trip happened as it did and the rest was correct but where where I assumed that he was the chef al azhar he wasn't

now that in itself goes to show that I didn't actually know too much about him like I didn't that and this is only recently this is like only two weeks ago so I haven't been influenced by them in that sense I am part my thinking has been obviously one it's me my thinking but my understanding of Islam rests within the school of Medina now people say yeah but you're too liberal you're too kind of modern modern is my own day in age but they say you're thinking so I thought look let me run you through some

things to show you and understanding let's take a look at Imam Malik yeah now this is the Maliki school the school of Medina now I'm gonna run you through some kind of thinking then you tell me how different am I really apart from the fact I'm in a different day and age see Imam Malik beginning with like let's say the hadith of all of the dogs and when it comes to lick the bowl rejects this hadith said it didn't make sense there's a hadith in the mapa of when two people transact that they still have a choice Imam Malik rejected the hadith because

it could compromise certain values because if you've bought a purchase now you if you're still there the person could change his mind take it back sell it to somebody else for a better price so the hadith is in the multi magmatic rejected it my mom my lick himself said taking a hadith one-on-one cabrona had will snatch the Deen from in front of him Imam Malik said ok Imam Malik when he was speaking about currency in his time he said if they start dealing in leather but that that will become

currency imam malik saying this imam malik when he was asked about people practicing incest he said if that's the way of life that's we do and we've got control over them he said we don't get him now check me i'll actually read that to you guys because some in the past people said to me i was lying this is the madonna for tower of imam malik now imam malik is asked in this they say ah writer allah the mighty that canister hey Luna feed eeny Meeny Carol Omaha to Allahabad subhana Allah are you Holly what Alec so the person

and Abram pass him says I asked him the people of them MA he doesn't say miju's he says the Vilma the non-muslims living in our midst under Islamic rule he says if they think it's fine in Deen and remember Deen means also their way of life that they can marry their mothers and sisters and niece's do we leave them and doing things like that he said Allah anahulu you are a doula whom feeding him he said we do not engage them in their way of life wha-hoo allama oh he do Ali feller

I am NOT an amine talaq they have the kind of covenant we do not prevent them from committing incest even we do not prevent them Imam Malik said he said if I can as I like minimize the Helu non feeding him if there is something they seek as permitted in their in their way of life and then he says and I learned this from Rabia Torah is teacher who used to say that we Allah has taught us to be more tolerant of greater theological issues the fact that that they worship other gods and things like this so to tolerate incest

homosexuality I think is much less than things like that but incest which in most communities is a taboo right Imam Ali said we do not prevent the way we have force to prevent them we do not defend right Imam Malik when he was asked about going in dip in a bathroom in his time by bathroom I mean toilet can you do thicker in a toilet can you mention a last name said yeah you can mention a last name right now Wow like people were kind of shocked email Imam Malik was asked what if you've got a ring on and the ring has and I actually disagree with this personally this ruling but it

has a lower inany do you have to remove it when going to the toilet because you're gonna be washing yourself and stuff Malik said no Imam Malik Imam Malik was asked when you're doing wudu and you've got a ring on do you have to remove the ring said no they said what if it's tight like water doesn't even get underneath he said no Imam Malik people in my Malik himself right when he was asked about things like in in his day and age right a Muslim could offer

safety to all to any non-muslim a man could do this mall all small scholars accept this they call it giving them my giving a man a man Malik said a woman can do it as well a boy could do it and a girl can do it scholars said that nobody before Imam Malik was being that open extending this Imam Malik today the hadith said that oh you sacrifice if a boy is born you sacrifice two sheep if a girl is born he sacrificed one she Imam Malik rejected he said no there's no difference between a boy and a girl you sacrifice one sheep for either mi Malik did this right if my

Malik himself he became fed up in his room why I became fed up of people people say oh look the way you do things and stuff like this is not released 25 years of his office of his final part of his life he didn't attend the Masjid he didn't used to go to the Masjid to pray but he's Imam Malik at the end of the day right now and I know Imam Malik said based on muscle how welfare if you and I don't agree with this this ruling but he said oh if you quote somebody that was a suspect and you knew that this person was responsible he said that he felt it was permissible to beat that person to

investigate beat him up you think because he said the day and age was like this so you got to change with the day may I disagree with that ruling obviously but I'm just saying look Imam Malik okay Imam Malik the famous you know people say oh you say all these things permissible about sexual stuff and everything and they said they you know they made this big deal about me quoting that the anal sex issue and I never said that I'm promoting it I was just quoting the diversity who said that I was permissible in my Malik him and Malik actually said that there's nothing haram about it in his transmission people said oh the obeah is

unreliable really that's why even a rush the great legend does a commentary on it in in 22 volumes today he said it took him 20 to 30 years to do a country why would you do a country on a book that is unacceptable and many other people said it was the most authentic one of the most relied relied upon texts this is Imam Malik stinking this thing about people say oh you know these kind of issues in our that's a misquote from Imam Ali one of the great Maliki's even a shot burn early Maliki is one of his books that is there he and other but I'm these must assert on my laser feel most

Assad are considered from the Ummah heart of the matter the great books of the method now early on is like from the students of the students of Malik he wrote a whole book in defense in his time for things like anal sex a key person of the method April ought to be quote say in his when he's discussing it in his commentary on hadith the evening Shia and wrote that book he's a Maliki you've got people like abu mohammed el are silly with a great maja death of al-andalus over a thousand years ago said it was permissible sorry it wasn't her ami ozma crew maybe disliked ash have the student of mali now what i'm trying to say is

people say to me for discussing things how can you be mad these people am i not quoting Maliki's to you and I apologize if this is a if this part is coming across a bit kind of whoa but the people say oh one of the first people to speak about oral sex in the Islamic tradition was who especially with asthma the student who was around in Amman Malik's time and the student of the student of Imam Ali but to the extent when hanafis and other people started saying oh when a couple of together you can't even look at the private parts of of your partner because it might make you blind and stuff like this to take away metaphor

his actual wording was what he said that your juice allahu al hasan will be listen he can i mean i'm sorry to be you know vulgar but this is I suppose laughs hiya fifteen there's no higher in the matters of Deen that he said he can lick it with his tongue but just to show the this is going over 1200 great Maliki obvious time they said that the whole he was like the whole meth have relied on him in his age and he's from the students of the student of Maliki and you can then mean for being different for saying certain things when I said they brought farhat the student of Imam Malik who was

responsible for the creation of this book Madonna when he was asked by his ruler the the Amir that who wanted in the in that day and age you know the faith the golden age when they had all the concubines he wanted to take several of his concubines into the steam room with him they kind of ham man he gave the fatwa that it was permissible I said they blow for at the great Maliki I said enough for us and you guys criticize like and I'm just saying these kind of things that Oh people say oh you know this Musti is coming up with all these things nobody had said this before even imagine this you know me my money

they asked him oh can you if a person I'm sorry these things are coming off like this but when they asked him oh if a person has many wives or many comfortable can you sleep with the more together even if it's it's not sexual base I mean what I mean is even but they were all together in one even imagine said yes there's no problem with things like this and they criticize they're saying I'm coming up with a modern kind of thought you see now what about even our happy and I love me when discussing the matter of somebody who gets married they say if it's newly married for seven days he doesn't even leave his property

from evening Habeeb they transmit he doesn't even go to pray like he can pray at home prays what if I they say does it lay a hood doesn't go out for Jamaat doesn't go to he just stays with his intense passion that's all it should be but the thing is this is from love me they transmitted from even a habib that he doesn't do this what about the fatwa when they said a woman a bride who because she's done a pearl Hey right I love me transmits this another Allah man that she doesn't need to wash her hair for up to seven days when she's doing hustle because it's gonna waste money on the hey these are my little agenda and they saying I'm being they

say I might being lenient his modern this is what they they try to come up with when he came to marches of music April audible audio but Quran audibly says there's nothing I find in the Quran Osuna that says is Haram from 900 years ago from Muslim Spain if not the repeat once again a 15-mile a thief a thief from Spain you've got people like Muhammad Nabeel Issa who was the key judge of an entire region from Muslim Spain Maliki said music was absolutely permitted the kadhi from Muslim Spain Mohammed Agnes Harkness Salim these people and they saying that I'm different from not from

this Trudy how different am I in my thinking if not B's eighth note book in his time saying that Olli I don't do Karamat the the whole world went mad at him and then they say oh he kind of took it back because people obviously because people create all this emotional blackmail well this stress bar Kalani they say he did something like that in fact a bluebottle who is around the same kind of time just after from Muslim Spain the great Maliki has his commentary on Bihari he does in care of Karamat like that he says Karamat these miracles can only happen

within with him worldly means how different am i I asked you in the hadith in Bukhari when they say water came out of the prophet's hands and has transmits this from hudaibiya even about Tulsa is that this is hurry besides this hadith doesn't really add up it's not really that reliable because only why would only one person from hudaibiya transmit this when there's over a hundred people they why is only one person unnecessarily long saying this he's from over a thousand years ago I've never thought the great Maliki how different am i I asked you I mean these things you know when people say oh he

follows different opinions he does these things I share abrini great madaky who's known by the way for as a myopic says I asked my teachers that every opinion a scholar has in the method does that become an opinion within the method or is that separate and he says I went to one scholar says no you can't take different opinions within them that they're different opinions but the method doesn't have that he says then I went to my teacher I will pass him even as a tune who is a great Maliki of his time and he said yes every pole in the of every Maliki scholar in the method is a coal within the method of imam malik how

different am i I asked you this is what if you go to youtube and watch chef Muhammad roogie one of the leading Maliki domes in the world today on his is giving a lesson in Morocco and I was there at that time um at his lesson and then went to his home with him afterwards he speak covering me there too much the head he was the ground check of the car we need he says in that lecture he says every old the whole of it nourishes all in the method how different am i I ask you right now when people say Oh things like oh he's lenient on priests are we look

at people like love me Apple hasn't allowed me who by the way people the Maliki is quote Holly the first person Khalil relies upon for his interpretation of the Madonna in his mother service is love me and he's the teacher of Mars people say ma ma zouri never disagreed with the method that may be but his teacher was Apple Hassan and love me who disagreed so much that the poet said he said to the girl he said la caja tacit I'll be sahaja funa funa key that you you know that you're kind of the arrows of your eyes have shredded my

heart but he says to this girl c'mon hatake love me madaba Maliki and the way left me has ripped the Maliki method to shreds and here's his famous book called the top seller and right you can't see here but there is it so it's on that shelf it's that hold all those books you can see there those volumes that's his top set up now by the way he gave a photo I'm not saying I agree with it lemme gave the fatwa that if I based on muscle how wealthy if a ship was sinking you could check off one third to save two thirds modern for its AG the Andes

is from about a thousand years ago it's crazy that for twice he said based on the fear what the hell I mean I would go with it as long as I'm within the 2/3 and not the 1/3 so how different am I you know when you say always modern he's thinking it was is that not modern for its time thinking like that left me said that old when it comes when it comes to TM mum if you do tell mum you had this goes away you don't need to repeat Buddha and Huson later on people say this is man stuff like this let me said no how different

am I like I asked you like you know you say all these things when it came to abou possible Buzzelli he said that the her dude the cutting of the hand the stoning all this should change in his day and age he was like 600 years ago he said he should change to financial penalties he was thinking in time modern for his Danny how different am i how liberal am i then if you want to use the word liberal if Nardone al kabir who comes after him and few generations after he says women should now inherit like the the wife should inherit 50% of everything before you split so you are

so I asked you how different is my thinking you know you're saying I'm not part of even a ruse the great philosopher he said that the greatest thing that Allah has given humans is Apple his reason the greatest thing they've given and he said Allah in his book fossil in the heart would never give their in son uncle and then give him a Sharia that goes against the apple that's the words of it nourished so how different am i he criticized the a Shari's on several points in the in this Creed that they had on certain things he said this doesn't make sense this doesn't make sense how different Ahmad he said that that in

son in essence is consciousness he said that he feels that the consciousness was the main thing and everything how different I mean how am I so modern and sold different this was a pure rush the great you wrote the bidets on which they hit you know you you have you've got people like even auto-recall do but cut it not to be who in his time said that the Christians in Europe used to just wring the neck of chickens he said they use halal to eat and today all these people that base they fought want even allowed me the Maliki he said that because the Christian see as okay in the adine so it should be okay in my

Dean so my way of thinking how is it so different that is he not thinking modern for his age saying well the Christians do that today so what the hell you know so it should be okay now I'm I'm not trying to say whether I agree with all these things will disagree but the fact that they're being relevant with their age when Muslims were being persecuted in Muslims in Spain after Ferdinand and Isabella took over and Maharani gave the fatwa that they don't need to migrate that they can just pray with Azshara they can just look and if they can't do TM they can just look at a wall and if they they can eat ham and they can do

all these things and they can marry non-muslims he said they didn't they weren't obliged to migrate how is that thinking not modern and mine only modern how is that not liberal and only I'm liberal you see the skull is sealed off the Sharia with with this part of this Akita talk because there's this whole discussion on is X good because God commanded it or did God command X because it's good it's the classical debate called the divine commandment theory now the scholars got caught up in me and they gave the ruling the a Shari's and all that there is no such

thing as good the only whatever God said therefore it's good then they realize down the road that they kind of like this is a bit of a Oh because now killing is a really bad it's only bad because Allah said it so the Maliki is kind of right the Maliki is here kind of did Ystad rock they kind of caught on to it like try to fix the situation and salvage it by opening up the whole discussion on massive objectives of the Sharia the Maliki introduced this Imam shot to be the real ease expansive world

al al fasi if not our shoe these are the people who wrote on my passage that you can turn away from certain rulings based on muscle ha so how am I so liberal and how am I so disconnected from this legacy when you think about it when the my lackeys when they were asked things like people say making things easy if a woman had irregular cycles or irregular bleeding the malli care the eraklyon said that doesn't even break her google doesn't even break her like how was that not making ease the Iraqi English to say by the way it's one of the principles that Hubble Rahad is rejected if it goes

against any if it goes against reason or the established principles if it goes against chaos or the kawaii this was the Iraqi in the whole school within the Malik here when it came to a woman traveling on her own abuelita bhaji said that thousand years ago she could travel on her own if she goes in a caravan it's fine how is my way of thinking so modern all of a sudden and this wasn't for they day an age when the male Kia said that a woman can pluck her eyebrows even if it comes in the hadith they said that's talking about a woman in her height she

can do that when Qaddafi and it was a yet argue for how can tattoos be Haram they say tattoos we don't think they Haram these are all male keys I'm talking to you how is my thinking really so different when at their dear and the and these people write in their books this is the main mature of the method they write wearing a niqab is Hulu extremism they say fists allow fear idea whether it's in Salah it's all how is that so different from my way of thinking and this and even a share at Makaha Yan has the same thing on YouTube saying that

now my point is that this I'm trying to show if not a shoe writes this about miracles people say all his way of thinking about miracles she writes about the moon splitting I've gone over there saying this doesn't mean the moon actually split he writes about and he problematizes the second coming of Jesus by the way these people that wrote an article they misquoted him absolutely he says every time he mentions anything to do Jesus if you were to take this literally and believe but he problematizes the second coming of Jesus and these are the things and he says like all miracles like he always explains them and people say well

oh you know and he did all these things he says that gene can't possess people there's no such thing as magic this is my leaky old man I'm quoting to you but people will try to dissociate me from them to make me a soft target so oh he's isolated he's with Muhammad Abduh why I'm telling you these people I'm quoting them to you right so I mean look to the extent even went to the extent to even save our mother ionized I spoke about that she'll Jie Jie who went to the extent to say about our organ donation and stuff like this is permissible so why did I white you know am i highlighting all of

these things I'm highlighting them to show that look this tradition this especially the Maliki school it had this huge thing of basing things on wealthy on being of the time yes and there's been many people India that sometimes haven't been like that I accept that there's been kind of dogmatists and people like that I accept that but all these people are examples who in their day and age were seen as being modern for the day in age because that's what Islam that's what islam teaches us and

people say you know reason reason reason who's reason whose reason I want to elaborate on this later on in another session but the the question is tell me when you look at things like the story of Hinduism you look at stories of Ganesh his head being cut off and an elephant head being put on or the story of Hanuman who they call Lord Hanuman the monkey God who flies across into what with modern-day Sri Lanka saves Sita and stuff like this the whole pole I mean the whole story to do with Rama and Sita and Hanuman do you find that at or do you just find it oh I don't believe in it but it still makes sense

and if I ask you you find it absurd why and if you say yeah but it doesn't add up say why doesn't add up you say yeah because it you know it's not it doesn't add up true reason Oh whose reason exactly reason is the ability of a healthy mind to make judgment based on practical evidences and it doesn't add up I could say yeah but you'll see here but monkeys don't fly across and do things like this say yeah but God suspended the laws of nature you say uh-uh I mean you could suspend it for a tree if you believe in trees doing things

why can't he suspended for a monkey monkeys are more capable than trees why is why is Ganesh having an Elfa head so strange when trees doing things are not strange you know what why can't God suspend the laws of nature for a minute here you can suspend it for you why can he suspended for them exactly it sounds stupid now doesn't it sounds like oh yeah but for them they can't do it before us you know it's like so this is my point when you say reason the same reason that you apply to debunking Hinduism for being absurd certain parts

of it and I think this whole thing you see it's not that the point is when Allah addresses miracles in the Quran it's important to understand because a lot of people have been asking me this it's not that whether the miracles are false I'm not saying that I'm saying that what are the us bar what is the reality what were the causes that do you believe this happened is out of thin air like this or were they natural causes to this and you have to remember the truth how you tell the truth so something a lies and trying to teach you science in the Quran so he sometimes is telling a narrative and it's not important to get

all the details and I think there was a beautiful part of a beautiful discussion me and I had with Hanif who came to visit me the other day and he highlighted so in the quran when allah first addresses Muhsin brings us up in to surah in the Quran at least in surah qasas surah taha that when moosa comes to the fire allah says in any an allahu indeed i am allah the fa'budun ewok team is salat Allah Vickery the pray and established the pray and so on and worship Me and in another verse he says when moosa came to

the fire of law says in me an allowable Alamein not in any animal law so tell me a lot cont have said both of them at the same time because they both the introductory kind of so you could kind of say this or this or this o was Allah explaining the event as opposed to everything being literal see truth is taken in layers tell me when you speak into a child and a child asks you where do where do babies come from and people say all the stork brings them are they lying to the children they lying like

I'm lying to this child or lying to you what if they say babies come from hospitals are they lying to the child or even when they get older and they say baby has come from the mother's tummy are they lying because technically they don't come from the tummy but it's that they are addressing them with frames of references that they will understand now this is important and actually since we've spoken about Hinduism there's an amazing I actually like this quote from the Vedas that which is actually said

that the truth is one the sages speak of it by many names that that is to me the days of me that Allah is not trying to teach you science in the Quran when you mention certain things it was just part of the story now how did it happen what was the thing what was that of course they were causes of course it happened within us map it has to be able to fit in with reason otherwise you have to then accept all these are the claims because if you accept you rules yes we don't need reason then why is having a monkey God that flies over and save Sita absurd because God

suspended the laws of nature he allowed Hanuman all of a sudden to become conscious and know and safe see that he allowed him to have an elephant head Ganesh so I think this inshallah I hope it shed some light people I went on over an hour longer than I wanted to I hope it's been of somehow doing Charlotte reach out to me like share the usual inshallah it's been as always awesome I've had a hell of a day and a lot to still do yet so people I'm gonna leave you to it in Charlotte and as people often say to me look the only

problem is you're not serious announcement to all of you guys here I am very serious guys take very good care of yourselves in shalwar stay awesome stay laughing stay blessed in Charlotte salamualikum' we're not mental eye to eye law but I cut