Hypocrisy in the Sunni Hadith Methodology | Mufti Abu Layth

if you're to say well how can we accept this narration i don't believe it look nobody's telling you to believe it but let me make a point here let me make a point look there is a rawi there is a narrator by the name of imran ibn right this guy is one of the leading warriors of his time leading of his time he's from the taber in era yeah he is used by bukhari on more than one occasion in his hadith at least two come to my mind straight away where he is being quoted by imam bukhari he's one of the people imam bukhari uses

as a narrator as in he's trustworthy this guy would openly openly if you look at the nubula if you read fatalbari ibn hajj statement on him this guy would openly praise ibn muljim for killing saydna ali radhillah openly in fact he has a very famous poem saying that when he struck ali in the head to kill him that strike was a strike full of taqwa and like it's blessed and so on and so forth he would openly say these things yet bukhari

he's okay because he was from the worshipping people of this ummah what kind of let's be honest people i want to ask you a question i'm not shia i disagree with the shia on their points uh i support uh you know the stance of i and my videos are very clear from uh you know i'm not and the shia know this about me i'm not kind of but let's be honest if we had somebody praising al-majusi for killing um let's say there's a narrator in the taberin who writes poems praising the murderer of umar

would we accept him so why do we accept the the one who's praising the person who murdered the ali like this is just this is just ridiculous like we are just so drowned in prejudice and bias the point is that anybody these were all great companions that you know said ali said omar i i believe these were all great companions of the prophet they were all very close to prophet sadna ali was murdered by namul jim some guy openly praises him and he remains praising him till his deathbed in fact ibn hajjah writes in fatalbari

some people said he did tawba this guy he says no he didn't he says now we yet bukhari accepts him so we accept him you know up here you know the hypocrisy that we have and this is why it infuriates a lot of the shia people but can you blame them because here's a guy who's killed satan ali and he is somebody who's follows that person and praises him all the time writes poetry not only praising him but praising that he killed ali and then suddenly say yeah this guy is fine we can take from him

but we can't take from imam jaffar or any of the shia imams if it's in a shia book when they're describing that hussein used to wear earrings why oh because it's coming from that's just stupid let's just be honest i'm trying to be fit so