Early version. Transcripts and tags are labelled by accuracy tier. A position is shown only after two independent reviews have found it in his own words.
Mufti Abu Layth ArchiveBeta

Recordings › Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth

Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 70

salah salaah namaz prayer salaat namaaz as-salah al-salah salawat hadeeth ahadith ahaadeeth hadis hadees ahaadith saheeh saheeh hadith sound hadith authentic tafsir tafseer exegesis tafasir tafaseer malik ibn anas malik bin anas imam maalik imam malik ibn anas imam bukhari sahih bukhari saheeh al-bukhari saheeh bukhari imam al-bukhari jumu'ah jumma jumah salat al-jumuah friday prayer imaam imams prayer leader janaza salat al-janazah namaz-e-janaza janaza prayer janazah prayer funeral prayer udhiyah qurbani qurbaani udhiya udhiyya kurbani ka'bah ka'ba kaabah masjid masjed masaajid masajid maaliki malikite malikiyyah maliki school ijtihaad ijtehad independent reasoning 'urf fatwah fatawa fatwaa fataawa legal opinion hukm ahkam hukum hukam ahkaam halaal permitted lawful haraam mubah mubaah fard farz faraid fard ayn fard kifayah fardh sunna sunnat sunan prophetic practice dalil daleel adillah adilla proof riba ribaa sood usury mutawaatir tawatur mass-transmitted saheeh muslim imam muslim muslim ibn al-hajjaj kufr kaafir kufar kaafirun imaan eemaan eeman ilm al-kalam kalaam theology shaytan shaitan shaytaan iblis iblees shayateen shayatin satan jannah janna jannat jahannam jahanam jahannum al-mahdi imam mahdi mehdi al-dajjal dajjaal ad-dajjal antichrist quraan al-quran sura soorah surat suwar soora chapter ayah aya ayat ayaat aayah aayat tilawah tilawat tilaawah wahy wahi wahee sahaba sahabi sahabiyyah sahabiyat khalifah caliph khulafa khilafah khilafat caliphate khilafa rashidun khulafa al-rashidun khulafa ar-rashidun rashideen khulafa-e-rashideen makka mekka madinah madina al-madinah madeenah yathrib ahl al-sunnah ahl as-sunnah ahlus sunnah ahl al-sunna sunnis shiah shiite shi'i twelver ithna ashari 'alim aalim ulama ulema ulamaa da'wah dawat da'ee invitation jihad jihaad fitnah fitna fitan strife in sha allah in shaa allah insha allah inshaa allah alhamdulilah al-hamdu lillah alhumdulillah alhamdulillaah as-salamu alaykum assalamu alaikum assalamualaikum salaams salam alaykum wa alaykum as-salam greeting duaa duas duaas supplication fitrat natural disposition amanah amaanah amanat trust deen al-din ad-deen ad-din ibadah ibada ibaadah ibadat rahmah rahma rahmat ajr sawab thawab thawaab sawaab

video · 2:21:22 · 8,200 views · 20 Mar 2018 · Open on YouTube

Press play to load from YouTube. Nothing loads until you do.

Transcript

machineauto-transcribed, may contain errors · source: youtube auto · click a time to seek · dotted terms open the glossary
0:01

whoa damn finally all right let's see if this is live right oh it's just about to cancel that because for some reason my internet was playing up again even though I've changed it its BT now but still but al hamdulillah it worked after half an hour of trying see but people like me we don't get an excuse because

0:40

we always late so it doesn't matter that was this close to me just about to send a message to say look guys I can't do anything I've been trying for 20 minutes no no Joey I'm just writing this here about just sharing it

1:20

then you got a new phone and just share that I know a sudden become I take you that's done god damn I hope just no internet interruptions in Sharla hidden and hamdulillah wa kafa what salat wa salam o allah rasool mustafa voila a bird in ladino table ah remember ho de ho mr.

1:51

da ba bi sorry Almudena toughie well bad for Salaam allahi al ñ anam assalam become bienvenidos a todos arrived warning lights and swagatam people swagatam right so I'm sorry I genuinely I like I said look people like me we don't get an excuse because we're because we're always late but today I gently was I've been sitting here for about 25 minutes now I've had to reset all my internet

2:31

Reuters and the bloody Wi-Fi thing my iPad my phones I and then the BT Reuter was just driving me mad and I came upstairs now to say there's gonna be no show and just as I sat down some halal I started working and then they say I deny miracles this ain't no short of a miracle huh

3:03

what is it dunya need I tell you I'm so hooked to this new T I've bought by the way this it's cool extra strong Tetley so I comes in this red box I'm just totally hooked to it Dona Ana Tajiri bear Dona Nita Geneva or how are this Keisha calm a that in the form of trials and tribulations jo kuch Muji Diavolo tarae-hyung whatever he has handed to me I'm only

3:41

simply passing passing it along people passing it along so the Red Bull and that is easier that has to be done but I thought you know I said something warm as well among that on the end of getting out of this man flu ah so people are no more silent so what a week again what's being going on man what's been going on people what's been going on a lot of a few things to discuss I'll be taking some questions and answers I mean I'll be taking some

4:20

questions as we're going along I'll need you to click like click share share this live feed get it out there people get it out there I will be commenting responding to the question on on the legend physicist Stephen Hawking's on his demise the controversy that it kicked up in the Muslim world can we say you know may Allah have mercy on him for non-muslims I'll be touching upon that

4:57

also I know chef srr has responded to with a video so I'll be touching up on bar as well sharing my thoughts but what else has been going on in this right about blocked who's gonna be you know I hola hola cattle cattle venom venom blocks you for us for telling the truth you know let's actually speaking of blocking let's have a few words people let's have a few words you know this is that time we say sit down see empathy

5:37

sit down Tina Tina the thing is look let's let's have a few words on this block thing yeah the thing is you see here's the thing people I need you to focus you know this is my life yeah so this is my live kind of session so on this uh in fact I'm gonna tell you what really the what really made me think about all this blocking thing yeah so I

6:14

got a message from someone I'm sure you want to mind me sharing his name Safwan and he got a message me saying look can you unblock me and and I said yeah sure no problem no problem ah no I problemo and and he said something to me when I'm blocked him I sent him a message and he said to me he said you know what the you're the reason I'm still Muslim today and I have to say kind of hit me that I didn't expect you know I just thought somebody saying you know just hey unblock me and so I'm

6:54

blocked him and he said that and I kind of felt I'll be honest with you I felt bad for having blocked him in the first place I can't remember when I blocked him maybe a while back almost maybe some of the admin kind of blocked him but you see in light of that I want to say that look you have to understand something I need you guys to understand this message and whilst you're understanding it feel free to share the live feed click share get this out there some interesting

7:30

topics for today you see you have to understand that when I'm engaging let's say the public or I'm doing a live feed or I've made certain posts and sometimes my post can be controversial you see it's difficult I mean it's it's I suppose when I say difficult I mean there is going to be a huge backlash to a lot of my stuff like right now I'm do this I'm gonna get a hell of a lot of I'm gonna get haters jump on board I'm gonna get all sorts of people trolls I'm gonna get all kinds now you have to

8:07

understand that look I when you troll me it ruins it ruins this for everything for everybody it ruins the experience for other people it interrupts the genuine flow that genuine people have people want to ask genuine questions you distract the topics and also it's it's not easy you know responding to everyone you can't people just keep coming like lemmings it's like that old game the lemmings this non-stop they just what you know like it's like one guy will come and he'll say

8:46

something and you'll say look the answer is and then another one who come forward to do deleting the consumer and then your answer and then another one who come who having said the live from the Quran and then you'll say no listen but I've I've said this I said boo another one will come like a lemming boys you ever said diddly from the person do you think look for God's sake Macario oi what's wrong with you estas loco what

9:25

the hell's wrong with you look I can't be answering everybody like this and then people will say like one guy will come along and say oh it's like this Stephen Hawking things thing now one guy will come along and say oh he made dua for a cafe huh hmm hmm and then another one will come along go and I'll probably respond by saying look please re-examine your whole reading of the Quran another one will come along and say hmm hmm another one who come by and say hmm even I knew that I don't even know the Quran and even I know that

10:02

mmm and you think well I think the first part of your sentence was spot-on even I don't know the Quran we shoulda stopped thee because you don't know the Quran me so off you go so you know people go mmm mmm and it's irritating you know seeing all of this so I and I've told people like the admin as well that look I don't keep alarms I'll just drop a gift like one of those like wine people up even more and

10:41

people go I got the guy so you think you're funny and then I'll just post one of those funny faces and and look but that said I want to say look if you want to troll me here's a fair thing yeah if you want to troll me call me privately yeah right come to come to my private messages and kroll the hell out of me I don't care okay how's that for a deal right but don't if you troll me on my public things where other people are trying to also have an

11:19

experience I will block you okay so and if you're gonna get annoying then you will be blocked but if you wanna annoy the hell out of me all you want to attempt to annoy me how about you just come to my private messages spam the hell out of it man I don't care you understand see me in person and talk to me all you want I don't care I will happily seriously if I bump into people I'll happily talk to them so now the thing is when you do it on a live experience it interrupts everybody's

11:57

experience so is that that's my deal if anybody has been blocked unnecessarily then I will say look if you've reached out to I tell you why if you reach out to Muhammad Saban on Facebook because obviously I can't say reach out to me because you're blocked but if you if you if you do reach out to Muhammad Saban let him know the sicko right and that's it willing shalwar unblock you okay how's that for a deal but with the

12:37

understanding that you cannot troll me on live things or on my public stuff personally you can troll the hell out of me okay I don't care about that right so that's something saw because I felt bad I'll be honest with you I think some people you know like after reading that message I felt like blood yell you know it it touched me in you know it kind of it was a it was a short but very moving message okay so let's that laugh is shocking

13:14

hell yeah oh yeah people hell yeah so what are we looking at should we take one two little questions before we get into some of the stuff got quite a few people click like click share get this out there man get this out there Northy was the prophet unlettered illiterate that's an interesting question in you see that's interesting because in my understanding I'm kind of inclined towards what Walid al bhaji the

13:52

legendary Maliki Don from Muslim Spain he wrote a book I mean he's from about a thousand years ago in fact can you guys see it's gonna show you can you guys that's his commentary back there I'm just tense at you know one of those like we gotta go I just tense just use an excuse to go can you see that over there but can you see guys can you see like that over there I can't point it out properly let me just take my top off write that book over the Atlantic

14:32

are is that month over there which you can't read because it's backwards right but that's because the camera is reversed right now the that is his commentary on the motto of Imam Malik now he has a book full tactical method the onion nabi azad kitab that the the tacit the kind of the the detailed analysis result of the met happen he's trying to say of having looked into this issue is that

15:10

the messenger of allah wrote that was his tactic i am inclined towards that understanding it's very interesting out a big book I mean it's I don't know it's not that big I mean it is its imprint he basically he shows several hadith to demonstrate that the prophet salaallah alayhi wasallam could read and write but not but it wasn't the general culture so it would have been kind of like because they

15:47

never generally wrote so it may have mean you know maybe not as so for example maybe not as I don't know fluently or as people in the culture because generally people weren't writing in that culture so he kind of demonstrates that it wasn't the custom of the Prophet sallallaahu I leave Salem and many people around him to write hence he wasn't known generally as a writer because that's not what he did he didn't write generally speaking but if he had to he could read things he could

16:25

make them out he wasn't like to him these were like hieroglyphics for example like he did understand but it wasn't there wasn't that sense of when you get a normal writer the sense of fluency that and the fluidity that that writer would have that wasn't with the Prophet in many people around him because their culture was one of being unlettered or it was an oral kind of culture and surrounding and tradition but he could and maybe if some of you are learning other languages you can maybe relate to that so for example I'm learning

17:03

currently Hindi been learning Hindi for a little while now in addition to español español is obviously awesome and for the Spanish the TV series and movies are just too good the best way to make it up so but for Hindi now sometimes it's interesting you see because because I've been a bit lazy and I've I've been a bit too because of that you know I'll like sometimes if I'm looking at letters you know if I think of a letter I can't think like sometimes I'll think

17:41

well how do you write for example girl like let's just say that kind of like gah not just the G but if I see it some way I will recognize it like if you just said some of the letters from the top of your head like I might kind of be a bit confused like because I might think hmmm but sometimes when I see it I'll recognize the oh that says girl like home like in Hindi so I'll see sometimes on the TV on the dramas on the things like you'll be on and I'll recognize like I'll be able to read it when I saw it when I see now that's I'm just trying to show you how you can relate to this

18:19

but if you ask me to just from the top of my head just write Hindi non-stop I would probably struggle to write it just like alright maybe certain words and but if I see them I would be able to read them and so that's the thing and what some of the evidences that I below Lidl bhaji presents him back there is for example the hadith of the vision when the prophet salallahu alaihe salam was taken on his night journey and when he says that when he saw paradise and when he saw hell mokuba Allah Bobby ha and written on its gates were these words

18:57

and things like this he uses these hadith to show how was the profit telling you what was written unless he could read it now so what no but generally on me is a title of the prophet salaallah alayhi assalam but I think that on me is different to having an inability to read I think Umi is more like in a natural state like

19:36

like from when he was with his mother you know like from um and it does mean an unlettered like people who don't kind of get so influenced by the environment around them but generally speaking it is unquestionable that the culture the whole culture around the Prophet the Prophet included and many people around him in the hundreds and maybe thousands did not use to right that was not the thing okay so there is a difference so for example you could just because like you can right you are not a writer

20:13

oh just because you've said a poem it doesn't make you a poet you understand so these are the kind of things that I don't think this is that controversial to be honest with you this is a my Turkic this is something I will either Maggie said before and I know some of the Olamide disagreed with him and some of them went to the extent to calling him a kafir some of the Maliki are like Abdul Hameed aasaiya from North Africa but call de odd discusses this in his terrible Masaryk which is over there some way but in his thirty Burma Derek he says they just misunderstood Albanian

20:52

body wasn't saying anything our voter he was simply saying that the Prophet had this kind of ability to to to read but it wasn't the culture like many people around they could make out words and they could it wasn't that these words to them were not like hieroglyphics like if I show you how rude lifx it doesn't mean anything it means nothing to you but when you even if you're not accustomed to reading a lot in something that a certain language that you're from have familiarity with those words you can still make them out and recognize

21:30

them so that's what what I will either bajji was kind of going to in saying that the Prophet wasn't kind of like that he couldn't read you know like people there's a hadith of hudaibiya when they write out the thing and it says then he wrote and he crossed out I will believe the body says that he is talking about the Prophet and all the scholars started saying oh like oh my god who is the he talking about because the Prophet couldn't read or write so it must be talking about highly rowdy lon but the truth is I would even try to say look crossing out one two words and reading these kind of things a prophet

22:09

could do that so that's not something oh so I hope that's of some help that's not to strike up a controversy but it's to show that look and that in itself is from the amazing character character and qualities of the prophet of God sallallahu alayhi wasallam I like that question Somali that our language is innate or all the other na or are they kind of learned through society is it nature versus nurture I

22:48

really find that fascinating I mean apart from me having an inclination to [Music] wit psychology psychology with me just I love psychology totally and you know ever since I've been young I've loved to kind of I've had a fascination with the mind and brain you know to get into people's minds I don't know these things has come naturally to me psychology was just awesome I know I'm Chomsky yes he does present the what they term lad a language acquisition

23:26

device where he says the brain is high wired for language I do fall in line with that way of thinking I feel that the language that that the brain human brain has some kind of kind of wiring if you like that is empty it has a base a very universal base kind of grammar to it that that can be manipulated in so many ways and it's very raw it's very raw very base but languages just fit onto it so well and I think like animals don't have that human beings have that

24:05

innately and hence you see Studies on feral children children who were left in the wild on children who are deaf dumb and blind and from the outstanding legends of the the last century Helen Keller who was deaf dumb and blind and an inspiration to the world really Helen Keller was so some things like that like how do they acquire language because think about if you're deaf dumb and blind but then when they write like if you read Helen Keller's books or even some of her words she will write perfectly in fact much better than most

24:42

people now one is understanding you see very pidgin speak like me you you know like Tarzan you know that kind of speak broken speak pidgin speech like go chop you mark but they don't speak like that they speak with prepositions they speak every you know completely perfectly so the question is how does that work and I think that's a fascinating study and I I am inclined towards that human beings have a moral base this kind of and I find that awesomely represented in the

25:21

Quran when Allah says al Rahman khaliqul in son I Lama who knew pea you see he created man and taught him expression like that is to me just a wonderful kind of first not that not a Lama whole Kalam he taught him speech you see a parrot can just speak but like animals also come you some animals communicate sir and monkeys communicate with certain screams that represent kind of words

25:58

they have cries for for example lion or they'll have certain kind of a bird they'll have certain kind of cries which if they've done tests psychologists have done tests when they play that one so for example for the bird if they play that scream the monkey will kind of duck or if they play that scream for lion the monkey will jump up on the tree and they've also seen monkeys trigger the monkeys with that so a monkey will kind of have all these bananas and another monkey will come and he'll say do the scream like lion lion lion we're gonna

26:36

come to lion in a moment lion Rastafari so lion they'll say something like lion and the other monkey will jump up on the tree and this monkey will just go and steal his bananas so this so monkeys do things like that and other animals do communicate but Allah doesn't say I love my whole column it says Allah Mahalo Bay yeah he taught mine expression see we we can express ourselves with such power and capabilities that when I say something

27:13

my words can trigger the same emotion in the receptive hearts and minds of those listening to my words that is amazing amazing so yes so I am inclined to and I'll say something else as well about this about the language base I feel that morality works in the same way I feel that the fitrah is a kind of moral a raw rudimentary moral base that we have it's very raw like language and it can be adapted to your times but we have some

27:52

very raw base of like we uncomforta with harm for example it's like we we see harm and this empathy like we don't like seeing harm we don't like seeing I mean these things can be channeled but we have that sense of empathy tying in with this we recognize harm we recognize as good to avert harm to avoid harm and then based on this things start to build and we have a whole complex morality so that's some of that somebody asks people if you can click share click like I need

28:29

you to get this out there before we yeah for Judah how article aha you know Allah inspired the this kind of consciousness that we have this kind of I feel that in some ways the roar is similar to the kind of consciousness that we have that can be argued I understand that people could argue that well if somebody's comatose would they still not have a role then that consciousness obviously they would but they don't have access to

29:06

it but I kind of feel these things you know the intellect the consciousness these things are all interlocked and this is maybe parts of what they say raw whatever that means is this is in my understanding I could I could be wrong nobody really knows too much what is meant by the raw in the Quran Allah says or multi-terminal me Allah kalila you know you were not given from its knowledge except a little but I do kind of I kind of inclined towards this kind of sense of collective consciousness

29:42

that people in a certain given time they that these if if this is kind of part of the raw that we are connected in certain ways that people feel sometimes like you can remember somebody so much and they can feel it in some ways only usually when you're close with certain people and there's some interesting studies done on stuff like this and it's difficult because it's always replicated but it's it's at the same time beats probability it happens so much that you know it's interesting that and I feel like the hadith of Allah

30:21

Janome agenda that they that these are ah or something that is all kind of bounding together with each other in some way and the Prophet said Metallica I mean huh yeah Estela fat and what you know the it's antagonistic they will just repel each other but what matter or is it matter Arif Amin her at elephant and what kind of has this harmonizing with each other that they will kind of sync and I just find this I find this very interesting I know young Karl Yune kind of had this understanding of a collective

31:00

consciousness it's interesting I find it interesting I'm not saying this is it that this is but I do feel that there is something in and Eva that all people maybe at a very subconscious level tapping to because I think because it's interesting how discoveries always happen around the same time how the mood of an age seems to just change how things so I kind of think that there's some I feel there's some validity to things like that but a loved one right so people somebody we see I'm not the

31:38

souls I don't know what the souls in that said I don't you know what I don't buy into I don't buy into this kind of like the soul is like you a ghost kind of figure look like some my soul is like me a ghost version of me this floats around comes back I don't buy too much into that personally I know many people do Christians do some muslims muslims do as well other people do as well some Hindus in their version of the Atma I'm not I know I don't know it just doesn't resonate too well with mean that I think I I'm more kind of inclined to there is

32:17

something this consciousness that is kind of makes us but I I don't know I don't honestly I wish I didn't know these things these are some of the mysteries of the universe but yeah the the aid and the yes of course the the you know all of that obeyed the super aid and all of that by Freud right and I find this I do find it interesting I definitely find the fact that sometimes you can be so bounding with bound like clothes with someone that you could go away and you could be thinking about them or even later much later you

32:56

think about them and this and they kind of react and I just feel that's interesting you know that's really fascinating that how people and and I've read somewhere once about is it possible that because the brain works electronically we know this so I read some way in some kind of scientific theory that is it possible that the you know with the neural electoral activity in the brain if somebody was to be close with somebody especially through eye contact could it be that for example this is again may sound bizarre to some people but could it be that if they were

33:34

kind of like bio photons photons are massless kind of things which you can't see they created out of nothing they just kind of emitted usually by electric things and other subatomic particles if that they become entangled because what we do know in quantum physics now is if you entangle subatomic particles and move one the other automatically moves no matter what the distance could it be that this at some kind this resonates on this kind of consciousness level that people have some kind of remote weak connection could it be it's open to

34:12

study it's open to study right so people let's move on let's move on there was a question there this age as ahmed about the splitting of the moon i have answered that in previous episodes please do watch that i've highlighted that he didn't mean that the moon act we split you just meant that II perceptibly to the people there and even assured explains how most likely it was a lunar eclipse or something like this and I've gone into much detail in previous episode so you can watch that and and hence he brings a hadith shut

34:51

they're mentioning if not by saying it was an eclipse and he goes into much more discussion I've discussed it previously but it's it's so the moon splitting was not I mean it may have been perceived like that to people but it didn't actually split okay now and we don't need to think you know we've got to understand something the prophets didn't come to do be super humans and new superhuman miracles I think we've kind of messed up our understanding of we've got this mythological version of

35:28

religion where all of a sudden Islam religion needs to be about superpowers and super humans and demons and all these kind of mystic this kind of mythological characters and all these things for it to have for it to resonate with us like if it's just real human people then it's too boring all of us either boring or we can't really see this is the irony we then feel we can't relate and the amazing thing is Allah says in the Quran look at kana lakum fear of su Li lei or sort of Hassan that you have a perfect

36:07

example in the Prophet how could we have a perfect example if he was superhuman it wouldn't make a lies telling us look you can relate him Allah says when we would not you know what did what did the kuffar of Quraysh say they said send send down somebody from the sky send down you know both go send down an angel or send down this alas really kills him says are they crazy we don't do things like that you know we don't do things like that you are a human who Linamar an abortion or miss mcgoun you highly except that Allah has

36:45

revealed on to me so you know I'm not I'm a human just like you like I don't do these murals I don't do these kind of like these kind of superhuman things that you want because they were saying look why don't you do this why didn't you just make a garden appear here and we'll believe so the point is if Allah was going to do these things later on anyway let's say a lot did decide hey I'm gonna send now Jesus from the sky then you might as well just send him and get her over and done with at that point and everybody would just believe because that's all they asked for you know it's like they say hey what you do this no point telling them off and then saying

37:23

like are you crazy we don't do things like this and then later on doing it anyway that's like a massive contradiction like what do you mean you don't do things like this well you're doing them anyway so exactly so and then there's no pest what is the purpose of faith then it's just like saying well you know it's okay there's empirical data hey you know law says well Oh sha Allah Allah Allah come on my Towanda if Allah wanted everybody would have believed but he didn't want

37:55

to do that so right so HT ha do I believe it's they had to be practiced by modern-day scholars of course it can who dares to lock the doors of each DeHart will kick those doors right in these people huh put all the locks you want on it you know what it is these people are

38:30

just haters nah it's just a small narrow minds that all nobody is incapable of new thought see this is what whole relief colds religion back because the attitude of religionists this kind of dogmatists to people is that whole in the world this is the attitude hmm that anything new that you guys have ever uncovered only falls into two categories one you know God never mentioned it so

39:06

therefore it can't be true mmm this is number one - once it's proven to be true well okay even if it's true but God never mentioned it so it's not really important see this is not how Allah wanted you to become he never wanted you to become dogmatist look what Allah says well at acuña Cal Athena hotel kita do not be like those who receive the scriptures before you for father I'll a human element that so much time passed

39:45

over them they became old with these books that focus at global the heart became stern do not be like them always keep a fresh outlook Allah is telling you this in the Quran do not be like those people they had the book and they had it for a long time for taller animal Emmit they had it for a long time went and they had this book and they King Don to it then the hearts became all narrow minded and they became more do not be like them Allah is telling you so this

40:24

is this this is this is the thing right yep there is a hadith of Mahathir bin jabal regarding each they had and some people have tried to problematize the senate whether or not the Senate has problems with it but the understanding is sound okay so somebody asked a question they who was the the kind of sacrificed or not sacrificed but to be the son of Abraham that was to be put forward not that who was sacrificed but you know the Sun the the kind of chosen son of Abraham and Sarah was it is my L

41:02

was it is Haq was it you know Ismail or I sigh right the thing is look really we have nothing in the clear Quran that indicates I there's some kind of indication like we many Muslims in fur they kind of like infer this to be a smile okay the Jewish tradition says it was is hawk many Muslims believe it or not felt it was is hard people don't know this see this is another kind of thing to show cognitive dissonance did you know robbery bro haha bro tomorrow unbeliev dit was his hawk

41:41

The Legend of Medina Imam Malik actually believed it was his hawk so I think this these kind of things sometimes we don't need to really get so bogged down with I think the the point is that look I my principle of looking at things is like this I want to share this with you means that if there is nothing conclusive in the Quran and there is nothing clearly unquestionably established by the son now there are some hadith but they can be interpreted or they can go this way that way if there's nothing like that

42:19

then I think look just leave it doesn't really make a big deal you can have an opinion either ways that opinion is simply an opinion you can keep it but it doesn't really mean that was the reality because a lot of iya slee didn't clarify there's nothing about and a good example here is like somebody asked about Jesus speaking in the cradle now first of all I'll I mean I tell you I'll come to that when I'll come to that when I respond to a point what's a DNR what I don't know like do

42:56

not resuscitate is that what it is I'd been okay this question people if you can share the feed get it out there come on share this feed people be tested in your faith god damn somebody said why does this guy swear so much on his thing I'm like I'm like you need to see me my everyday life

43:27

you think this is swearing now and somebody responded quite well by saying because he's British Thank You shukran whoever that was and it's true things like words like damn in the British understanding of English are not a swear okay so it's all good people it's all good so I hope that makes some sense all right should we take one two other questions before moving on to this issue what are some of the questions people those of you just clicking and

44:06

just logging in live now if you just click share' get this out there let other people share some of this cave huh what say you can you donate your organs after death that's a good question you see can you donate your organs yes you can you need to understand something here donating organs is not Haram contrary to what you may have been taught we have to remember that look in the UK our Islam our

44:43

version of Islam is influenced massively by two things by to two places regions in the world Pakistan indo-pak India Pakistan Bangladesh but heavily like the Pakistani culture and Saudi Arabia both of these places have they probably influenced 90% of the Islam we have in the UK and maybe in in America a huge amount maybe not 90% but a massive amount there as well so we have to

45:23

understand that these countries whatever they say we think that's Islam but there are so many other countries 14 plus more countries in the world are Muslim Indonesia Malaysia Egypt Tunis Morocco in our Jordan this time all these places Turkey all these places in the world have Muslims even other countries have Muslims China has a huge population of Muslims you know we restrict our understanding of Islam just India has a huge population of India is sometimes very similar to

46:01

Pakistan sometimes a bit different but they my point is that the views here are massively infrasonic organs that's not true we can the hadith they try to use is completely misrepresented okay the hadith they are using is the saying of the Prophet that her metal that that day's sanctity of in son matin can hurmati he Hagin that the former of an in son of individual Al mark once he's dead is that the sanctity is the same as

46:40

what whilst he was alive now this hadith is speaking about Muslim okay you have to understand Muslim now Muslim people is a it's basically have you watched movies like hostel not to sidetrack or the hole saws onra fry jigsaw let's play a game so this mindset right people had I'm just trying to kick your twisted mindset people in the past had this kind of a

47:20

mindset especially to do with battles okay so when battles took place all raids or when they attacked an enemy tribe these kind of like kind of Muslim version of like these kind of Viking figures and the reason I relate people to fighting Vikings is because that image comes clearly in your mind and Muslims in there very early Arabia and you know pre Islam and even into Islam had that culture they used to live off raiding each other and things now this culture when they attacked other tribes or they had rivalry and

47:59

they beat their opponents they would maim them and they would really go hostile and jigsaw on them they really would like they would cut out weird parts of their bodies they would like cut out like the famous hadith of like hind' cutting out Hamza's liver and biting it you know like this kind of culture existed they would do things like cut off ears you know a bit like what you saw in in the Vietnam War people making kind of necklaces out of Vietnamese ears and things like these people live that kind of culture they would do things like cut off limbs hang it in the person's the dead person's

48:39

bought a body like around his neck like maybe cut off his hand hang it here cut off his head stick it on a spike they would cut out like parts of his body he could have his pull out his heart they would do these kind of like horrific things so the Prophet taught them that is Haram it is forbidden and the sanctity of a human once he's dead is the sanctity of a human once he's alive this is what the prophet of God was teaching he was not talking about organ donations right you see that is such you see this is so

49:18

naive that you take the Prophet and you place him in an anti progressive kind of position like that the Prophet is against humanity progressing why don't you know how irresponsible can you become in the prophet's time organ transplants like this didn't happen more primitive versions did happen okay it's like like the prototypes like so for example having a fake nose so so there was a companion in the lifetime of the Prophet who knows got cut off in in a battle and he took a nose made out of

49:56

gold he stuck it on the Prophet never said anything to him like hey what the hell does that nose serve as a function you know it's why are you wearing gold or why have you even got a nose it's not like you can smell with it you know it's not like these these kind of things No why are you wearing that God knows just so you changing the creation of God or is it just so you can compete with other human beings this isn't how the Prophet treated him the Prophet never said anything to him he kept the golden nose like the Prophet this is a known incident and there were other examples as well when people did these things these were very early

50:36

prototype versions of what will come in our time as actual organ transplants obviously humanity still had a long way to go before he could discover all these things and that's all good Allah says in the Quran you know do you have a let me you know how did do you not see kafir better along huh how elaborate began creation cero fil ardi from the walk and look and search and discover so so this point of organs now later on after the Prophet within a few centuries Muslims

51:15

like within even two centuries Muslims started to do certain prototype surgeries like they would get animal bones and sometimes mend them they would do things like like let's say a person needed something they would use sometimes some animal bones and wrap it up and see if that could heal some of the early scholars speak about these sometimes if a person lost like let's say person like for tooth like let's say your tooth had fallen out or your teeth were broken sometimes they used artificial things gold other times they like just got your teeth and just held

51:51

them there and sometimes it kind of just sealed itself back in and there's a whole discussion we the scholars see no problem with this kind of stuff and in my machete you also did have a problem with stuff like this considering he considered it to be dead and and felt that you have to break it back out which I think makes no sense but uh and then we come to our time when this is actually viable now you see people who are gifting their organs this is falls under the verse of the

52:29

Quran woman yeah and who brought a soul to life anima en acidemia then he has brought the entire mankind to life this is the kind of verse that relates to stuff like this now there is I speak often about the Scheffel Islam of the last century and the Grand Mufti of the Maliki evening I showed his successor and junior to him and a student of his but also a very senior scholar who was in his time deemed the Grand Mufti of the Maliki er is chef

53:09

mohammad al Aziz mohammad al Aziz jayate now I do have his Vitara around here somewhere and I've quoted them in the past the chef giant he in he in the 60s speaks about this issue of organ donation the birth tabara they call it kind of tomorrow Allah but that kind of giving your limbs and things like this especially if a person is dead and he issues the fat why it's absolutely fine many of the early Marvel as her have issued the fat White's absolutely fine they've said it does not violate any

53:47

understanding of Islam it does not go against the Quran it does not go against any established sunlight does not approve the principle and if anything those hadith are talking about something else and he actually corroborates the verse of the Quran about whoever gives life and I think it's one of the greatest acts of charity that a human being can ever do and I'll be honest with you I think it's actually very scary it's a scary thought even if I think about it I'll kind of be a bit scared if I'm gonna be honest even though I know that I'm dead which is weird but I still the thought

54:27

somebody kind of like taking my eyes out you know taking my liver out pulling my heart out the thought of these things are really freaky and if I'm gonna be honest I think it's that fear that really makes people say it's Haram nothing else in my understanding or maybe some ignorant kind of interpretations and so this is why I would just be I'll be honest with you I'd be kind of frightened and freaked out about doing this if anything it's just the fear even though it's

55:05

technically an irrational fear but it's an instinctual fear it doesn't make sense because you're dead anyway in your body parts will just I mean in a post-mortem they'll kind of cut up your pieces anyway and then they're just kind of chuck them back in and sew it up but right so the point is you wouldn't feel it if you're dead no I mean if you're asking do does the dead person feel this from an Islamic perspective no because whatever's in this world stays in this world right it's like it's still it's got the Vegas rule to it whatever's from this world it stays in this world right so the dead person doesn't feel it at

55:44

all but I mean the fear that you have now even though you know your body will be dead but you still kind of freaked out by it so that's all it is and I think people who are so adamant on this rule really I think they ought to if they really believe in this and they prepared to preach it then they ought to sign a clause that they will never accept a donor from anybody else you know you can't be and they will never encourage anybody of these to take it on man you know if the parent was dying and they could get a receive a donor of a kidney or a liver to save their life or their heart or their child then they

56:24

shouldn't encourage that person you know if you're gonna preach to people to not give then you can't preach to to take that's wrong I think that's double standards and he shows the religion as a hypocrisy so that's what I'm gonna say that if you have you interpretation which is a wrong understanding of a hadith but if you want to push that and you want to say this is in the name of God then you should stand true to your principle and never allow anybody to as far as advice is concerned to take either not be the first one you know because these people a lot of these I don't mean to diss them

57:02

but you know these pot bellied kind of people and you know illnesses can befall anybody can can afflict you know they can afflict anybody but a lot of them will sometimes oh they'll have these shoes and they'll be straight on the list oh yeah can I get a kidney transplant can I get this can I get that can I get a blood transfer kind of take a calf is leave a hell yeah no no no this this stuff is it makes embarrasses the Dean and it betrays Allah and His Messenger in portraying

57:40

the true image of Islam so people let's move on let's move on right so I'm gonna discuss as well about I'm gonna discuss about I was gonna say Richard or Steven Hawkings and the whole thing but before I get to that alright somebody had asked about DNR do-not-resuscitate people if you've just tuned in if you click like if you click share can you share this get this out there people come on get it out there get it out there I want you to

58:18

sting burn the haters ah the hate and the hate about DNR people do not resuscitate it is permissible and to select DNR in my understanding if a person wanted to they can you see this falls under the ruling is it an obligation in Islam to medicate to take medication it's not an obligation in Islam you don't have to seek medication but you should like as in its its it's

58:56

the human thing to do now even the Prophet encouraged that people do seek medication but if you didn't it's not like your sinful know you're going to to hell or you're doomed you know it's you it's a foolish choice I think that you have such an Amana from Allah good health and you don't see that said DNR is something totally different DNR is usually when people are in a very debilitated state do not resuscitate now if a person is in that state of mind in

59:35

that state like let's say they cook you know life is the quality of life is not they at all and I don't mean by quality the luxuries like am i chilling in my bed penthouse I don't mean like that kind of quality of life but actually like you're suffering non-stop you've got nothing but pain like let's say your key vital organs are failing you know like things like your heart is playing up you live kidney all these things are playing up your lungs now in that situation let's say you were to go down

1:00:12

and the doctors ask you that if you did go down would you want us to resuscitate you and they wouldn't I don't think they would say this to young people but especially people who are of some age so people who are seen en age they usually ask them would you would you want us to resuscitate you or they'll asked a loved one would you want us to resuscitate let's say your parent or your grandparents now this is a difficult question when it's asked to loved when it's asked to the person themselves they can just say in Islam if they don't want they can say no I do understand that

1:00:50

that to be permissible that is not Hara because it's because if you're only being kept alive on borrowed time so to speak then it's only inevitable and it's not like you are killing yourself but if your organs failed on you you do not need to kind of borrow time and just endure suffering if you do not want to okay so a person can select the DNR do-not-resuscitate when they asked a loved one I think it's it kind of makes it very difficult because you see the loved one will or the near and dear to

1:01:30

them will have now an immense sense of guilt because they would feel that you know if I said no and then people will be like you selfish be you know just because you didn't want to take care of so and so you said DNR that is such a cruel thing to say because that's not true I mean they may be some people like that but I think it's not right to ever have a judgmental attitude towards people look sometimes people themselves do not

1:02:08

want to be burdening other people they do not want to be like that they don't want to you know I watched this TV series it wasn't amazing how shocked actually how moving it was it was cool this is us and in there this a scene with the this this kind of father who's now terminally ill and yes it is a point where he's dying and he's he's on this kind of hospital bed and and the person the son says to him they've kind of reconnected often never having this bond and they develop in this short time a very powerful bond and the son kind of

1:02:47

says to him that oh my god you know like you don't know that this was gonna happen and like not that day and he says let me get my kind of your grandkids and my children let me call them and let me do this and let me do that and he say something which was incredibly powerful he says that he says I said my goodbyes to them he says that I I don't want the last memory of me to be one way they lookin down on me like I want the last memory to be where they looking up at me and I just thought that was such a powerful kind of emotion and statement

1:03:27

and and I think people in this world when their quality of life is massively compromised they don't like being a burden on other people and hence if you're just keeping them alive as a selfish decision to kind of just you know just because you don't want them dead yet then I think that is also a very that's also a very selfish thing to do I just feel that that's not right either I'm just saying I'm not saying you need to go either ways I'm saying

1:04:07

it's permissible but I don't think you should be laden with guilt okay about do-not-resuscitate I don't think if you selected that I don't want let's say my grandparent or parent to be resuscitated that that that you need to kind of like succumb to all this guilt I don't believe you need to you know provided it's not a selfish decision okay so I hope that's awesome right people well share a cerrar video

1:04:44

okay a quick question before we come to share the throgs video guys if you can click like click let's get this out there hello can you guys see me people is this let me see I think can you see me okay because I think it kind of broke down a bit there yep I think it broke down okay so I think we're back I think we're back I think that was the internet connection guys is that okay can you can you guys see me okay Mohammed Mufti was seeeeemji all of our subtle anonymous Adlon people

1:05:24

Mufti Waseem is in the house a great awesome scholar from I believe Chicago us young Mufti do you reach out to me if you have any questions can you guys see anything now is it okay I'm having messages from people saying they can't see anything they can't see the stream if some people can just send a confirmation message that it's okay that will just help they cut out but is it is it okay now Halil just said it cut out I'm not it's okay now sugar and chicken guys if you click share this get it out there I think it just went low and everybody just cut off for a moment but al hamdulillah it's back

1:06:03

it's malfunctioning [Laughter] malware so yeah yes so this juma mubarak thing i think just go easy on it folks be weary don't kind of like this bore the hell out of people people do get frustrated with it but it isn't haram to do I did I do find it a bit annoying so you know sometimes you get all these Islamic reminders and they I'll be honest with you I find them annoying I'm just being honest look like honesty Haram you know there's to me this guy used to

1:06:42

send me and these every day like just every day something and then I said to him I said bro please stop sending me this stuff man I said like a I don't want to be rude because look I don't want to be disrespectful to the Holly so please don't send this stuff to me man like if I want to see it I'll find it you know it's like just sending somebody forcing the Quran or forcing hadith on somebody you gonna and then what's gonna happen is somebody's gonna say something like they're gonna receive a hadith from the Prophet and they're gonna say oh for God's sake God and they're gonna say

1:07:22

something horrible and and look what you're making them do you're making them you know and that you making them do that so just people be weary you know you know you don't need to be reaffirm your Islamic nurse to you right so people what right so those of you just tuned in I need you to share this because I'm gonna be discussing now share a cerrar video refutation or response it lacked it had a bit of a refutation in there but that

1:08:00

was his refutation video I need you to get this out there let's see what this is about people so those of you that know the backdrop of what's been going on I saw I had put up a challenge to me since last year December last year saying I wouldn't dare to kind of sit in front of him and discuss this issue on the second coming of Jesus being what I believe to be inaccurate and not established so I think contrary to his expectation I immediately took him up

1:08:37

for me he massively underestimated me so I was straight on it saying look why don't we meet straight away I'm about to go on a Christmas holiday I need you to why don't with me anyway it took us three months of negotiating and chasing him up for him to actually eventually come and meet okay now I'll be honest with you I sincerely doubted that he wanted to meet and wanted to have a dialogue I doubted this but when he did when he did come it

1:09:16

became a disaster and I've got my reflections video on that you can watch it and do watch it please it's my reflection on how the pre-debate discussion went and I was kind of in hindsight not at I mean at the whole thing I was disappointed and I was disappointed with him as well I'll be honest but I was disappointed the whole thing and I acknowledged my mistakes in there too you know I ain't no perfect person far from it and I kind of said in hindsight in the second our way it's about two hours long I kind of raised my voice and I kind of did these things as well and it happened you know you're a human being you know you you get

1:09:53

frustrated sometimes so I said look I tell you what I advised look why don't you because at the end of the discussion share faster are said and this is and he knows he said this he did say this we've got I mean it was recorded by him and by us where he says that look Muslims we can't wait incapable of having dialogue with each other only atheist can do things like that like professors and stuff like that us Muslims you know we can't do dialogues like that we got to do the indo-pak the kind of really do Bundy style although that last this thing is

1:10:31

words but he did say the first part is his words that we Muslims can't do stuff like this only atheists can do stuff like that and and yield so you know and I was kind of like very shocked by his on-screen off-screen behavior way off screen he was like really friendly and mellow and sitting back and are really polite and on screen as soon as we went he went live he became this like kind of whole and like I need you to apologize and I need you to do this and and when we asked him I once again he's got this on recording as well when we asked him afterwards chef how come you like this what happened I mean what the hell I mean and his his words once again I know

1:11:11

he has this obsession with quoting him verbatim Lee but he can just check his own recording but he just said look at the end of the day we're movies and movies do drama right so this is the kind of what he said that you know we this is what movies do on screen now so in my reflections I said look listen let's cut the drama out right I tell you what you or answer no reason you've agreed to give me your best shot make a video show me the best evidences you've got I'm fine I will respond in a video how does that sound now that cuts out the drama it cuts out

1:11:50

you having to do the movie theater and stuff like these it cuts out you having to put on an act and it also cuts out a lot of the hate and playing to the crowd kind of stuff now in what followed after that we had some text messages exchanged in which I sent him some messages saying sure can you cover these questions is the coming of Jesus rational or textual did the Quran engage this or did it kind of sideline this issue as it did with the Dajjal and Maddie why is Jesus coming why is he coming why is the purpose of Jesus

1:12:28

coming and why Jesus so I put these four questions to him and I said to him will you also please quote the US I need of these hadith the chains of these hadith otherwise it's pointless he responded to me in text by saying you know you should have discussed all of this with me before however I will be responding to all of your questions he said this in his text message to me I said fine thanks chef much appreciated at the same time he was asking me I did say this I don't know why he was doing this because on one hand he was asking me I need to go you know hey why do you come now and hang out with me and stuff like this on the other hand he was making a pose

1:13:08

there's a satanic scholar going around and giving all these rulings which was really just confusing me that I don't care drama yeah you know what's going on here I did like you know you're acting all pally pally with me then you're making all these statements of you know you're you're kind of like this satanic person anyway so he put a date now to help him last week I gave a pre lewd a kind of backdrop to my thinking I've raised a lot of questions about why do i problematize the coming of jesus is it

1:13:47

simply that i have an issue with the hadith it's not it's the fact that it has a huge problem with the overall understanding of the Quran with the established Sunnah and the principles in Islam I showed that when we look at and please do watch my kind of pre dude to - to this debate it is I think it is I'll get a thumbnail made for it but it is session it's last week's number 69 I think so now the thing is in there I highlight this whole narrative is problematic because it clashes with many Islamic principles it clashes with the

1:14:26

teaching of the Quran Jesus when he's gonna I told last week I mentioned the devil is in the detail let's look at the detail of these hadith they reflect exactly what the Gospels say that Jesus will come to judge over mankind he will judge you and Gentile that all animals will become vegetarians that Jesus will all evil will rise from Earth that Jesus will force people to become Muslim he will skip them only two choices when you face the sword or you like you face death or you face Islam all of these things went against the whole teaching of Islam you know all this kind of like all animals becoming vegetarian by the

1:15:06

way which is one of the verses from the Gospels for are from from from from the Bible about how animal the wolves will graze with the Sheep and so on when Jesus comes now the I said look and I mentioned that people say how could this creep into Islam and I said that much greater has happened within Islam like look in the very within decades of the lifetime of the Prophet the the head of state like earth man is not only assassinated in his home if the city of the Prophet is held in the siege for days on end the body of the Calif is left on the street somebody could ask how could this happen but it happened

1:15:44

I mentioned the huge splits that happened afterward I mentioned how many people entered Islam surely there were many people who hated Islam and there were many people who were sincere but carried baggage into Islam a minimum of them Christian the whole of sham was under the Roman Empire they embraced Islam the the church was transferred into it was kind of transformed sorry into the Omega but of money humor it is on that mosque minaret then that many believe Jesus will descend which once again all of a sudden there's no mention

1:16:23

of Damascus there's no connection with Damascus in the prophets lifetime no sooner do the Muslim within decades move their capital to Damascus under the rule of money who mayor there's all of these hadith start emerging about the benefits of Damascus and the amazing features of Damascus I showed how there was a problem with this greater narrative so do watch my prelim watch what why I'm saying this I speak I spoke briefly about witness testimony about some of the experts that has been done on forged false memories how people actually believe several memories to be

1:16:59

true but they're wrong now okay so I shortly after doing that pre lute shortly after doing that Prelude I sent that to share huzzah okay so I sent this to him by so he had this and he actually to my understanding watched my preview why I feel this because he refers to certain things within his lecture that I spoke about in my preview so he speaks about the dorking debate which I mentioned how that made Muslims cringe

1:17:36

he speaks about a few other things which which I mentioned in my in my lecture and at the end of his lecture he actually speaks about the pre debate now write my thoughts and this about this whole I watched it last night it's just over an hour long I have to say people first of all I'd think I will think I'm thankful to you chef SR for taking your time out for making that video and the hadith teaches us in the Prophet tortoise man let me ask are in math let me ask allah llahu everything grateful is in grateful to God so I'm thankful that said now let's be honest put that

1:18:15

now that we've done that let's be honest this was your challenge yeah I am thoroughly thoroughly disappointed disappointed isn't even the word that was such an anticlimax you know for somebody who we chased for months on end to to come and who made this such a challenge this is honest unquestionably established in Islam the second coming of Jesus it's why the Quran sooner reason is my aluminum in Edina Vdara which means it says bro it's as bright as day it's as

1:18:54

bright as day yeah I couldn't see the light I don't know what day this is as bright as he never went through anything he just went like okay so summary he most of what he brought in his one-hour clip I had already answered in my pre lute this is hilarious and and he's been through my Prelude he didn't go through any of the questions generally not expanding on the months and at least two of them he didn't even touch the purpose

1:19:34

of Jesus why not another prophet these things he didn't even touch which he promised he said to me in his text message I will be going through the alto you know all these things I'll mention the assignees he didn't do any of this I don't like yeah yeah he drama ki tjak tjaka what is one of this yeah like you know you find on Facebook so loud that you know for God's sake does he dare sit in front of me and do this like this was your opportunity and

1:20:11

this is what you bring and now he said I won't be engaging if he said and he said this to me in a text message again today he said if your thing is worthy I will respond in writing is that so somebody else can write it for you and then he said oh but we can still debate but we can't talk with each other he said this like we gotta have like you minutes my minutes yeah I've given you your whole

1:20:47

time to respond make a video yeah [Laughter] barceló this whirlwind of a storm that you see fight with it Laros Joe you know these waves that you see entangle yourself in them got actual okay Kinari komali how long are you gonna stay safe and sound on the shore you know this what's happened yeah what ha ha koala still problema what's going on

1:21:26

who is the the lion of Atlas una right I don't see any of this what I seriously know you know there's a poem in in Arabic that one of the skull is said about Londoners Muslim Spain he said in in Muslim Spain because at one time there were so many kingdoms that you could walk on foot in one day and cover three different kingdoms so these people used to have all these big titles like Martin made a lot Amit and Allah you

1:22:05

know what toddlers Bellaire you know the one who relies who is the reliance through Allah the one who is strong by the might of Allah the one they they copied the Abbasids from the east they have these kind of grandiose titles so he says what my use a hidden afeerd and Ellison and that which keeps me away from the the lands of Angeles Muslim Spain and Albemarle table they didn't fear how Walmart amédée these titles of Martinez and Marta Boyd and all these

1:22:41

grand titles says al Abu malakut in fear Hiram O'Day I have that royal titles where they do not belong Cal harity tacky interferon so little a city like a cat that kind of flies up and acts like a lion meow lion Rastafari lion can't quit

1:23:16

lion lion name is it oh yeah what is going on what let's take a look at some of the things our esteemed share said within this hour some of the things and I am gonna give the shave a chance because as I did mention I've got some preoccupations at the end of this month so I'm hopeful within the next I'll give him like these next let's say two weeks or so hopefully maybe he will do a detailed video to answer my issues insha'Allah insha'Allah but let's take a look at some of the things he said okay

1:23:55

he took a look at the verses you know it was interesting he mentions like these three verses in the Quran all of which he himself concedes there's a different opinion to them so I don't even see what the point of mentioning them was he says okay there's a verse here which says you know oh you know but Rafa ahoo la la but some people say that you know it could mean this okay could mean that but we don't go with that meaning but you yourself accept it could mean that you know he could mean that and other people have said that so he says you know law

1:24:33

says but Rafa how la la you know a lot took him up raised him to him you know so why to him well why go to the beginning of these verses go to the beginning of these verses what does is a beginning his column with filete ma si I Simon who will COO for when he saw when Jesus felt that there was so much disbelief Holloman and sorry he said who are my helpers my friends my supporters illa llah man I'm sorry illa llah what's this Allah doing they then the people said all that a largest means

1:25:12

yeah it's just like an extra means like in the law well it's the same illa here it's the same word it's in the same context you know so and then the ash artis generally don't accept most Muslims don't believe Allah has a direction so you couldn't say raised up to a lot being a direction and then he concedes himself look these have you could take a different meaning from here you know he mentions things like oh he goes on about Jesus dying not dying on the cross look Muslims have never said Jesus died

1:25:49

on the cross Imam Malik if not a bus in Buhari if not a bus inside Buhari says that Allah says Malika means I'm giving you death that Allah gave death to Jesus the understanding of if not bus is that law gave birth to Jesus naturally on earth so he says well look so if the Romans wanted to kill Jesus and the Jews but they weren't able to but they find him dead so I suppose you know they got

1:26:24

the goal who said he died there and then he didn't have to die there and then what this is about just because he died a natural death doesn't mean a lot to him off the you know the thing and then he just died that would be pointless why would a lot save him from the crucifixion and then he just dies obviously he doesn't die there later on he died a natural death and there's one question which he didn't raise I was surprised but other people did raise and I think that's a good question that we

1:27:02

did Jesus girls in I think that's an interesting question truth is nobody knows but then the truth is nobody knows where Jesus was before he was thirty years of age so you see Jesus comes to Jerusalem at the age of thirty close to thirty prior to that way was he even Christians don't know nobody knows where Jesus was all these years where did Jesus where did he grow up and there's a very interest I found it interesting obviously it's not compelling there's an interesting BBC documentary on its it's not a

1:27:39

provocative title called was Jesus a Buddhist monk and it's interesting that they speak of Buddhist records showing that there was a person who came from the East the Middle East and lived with them as a young boy and his name was Issa and how the monks kind of taught him trained him and things like this it's interesting because the Buddhists also had a tradition with reincarnation that they felt that they reincarnation is not like the hindu reincarnation so the Atma doesn't go into the other person but it's like it's almost like

1:28:18

like like like a pool table like one ball hits another and triggers that so they feel that the death of one person triggers the birth of another so they used the the Buddhists had this thing with they would look into the Stars and they would have this kind of sign where they feel a great person has been born because somebody has died now they have in their records that they felt that there was a great birth in the Middle East so certain people set off and travelled to find this birth which kind of ties in with some of the Gospels and the three wise men or the three kings

1:28:58

and things like this it kind of ties them because the question always that Christians ask that who were these wise men because they never appear a game in the story but it's interesting I'd advise people to watch that documentary it is interesting I'm not saying that is what happened but it's interesting it's an it's a it's some research but nevertheless let's come back to what sharehouse ron was saying so he mentions these verses and he says well these verses I admit can mean other things so what's the point of mentioning them then because I said bring clear proofs from the Quran don't bring something and say it couldn't mean this but it could mean this he says Oh what in the Hula a Mona

1:29:36

Lisa but it could mean Jesus it could mean the Quran it could mean this it could mean that so what's the point of mentioning this right so and then he he kind of goes on about what a metallic Iturbi illallah you mean Anna be I've answered this extensively in my pre lewd that look what are you talking about that verse that you're interpreting that there are no people of the book except they will believe believe in Jesus before Jesus's death before this at the second coming makes no sense because look that means most of Christians would have already died

1:30:16

because they they've been living from 2,000 years up until whenever Jesus comes it's only the small batch that will seem but the verse says there will be no well in min a little kitabi Allah there will not be a single Christian and you accept so he clashes overwhelmingly clashes with what you're teaching and plus the reading that I said is supported by bus by Mujahid by Sheriff nahusha by Muhammad ignor ideal Hanna fear the son of Sedna I leave of the Aloha and by by the heart it's even supported by the recitation of obey even

1:30:55

a cab I told you look i keeping the answers to all of these and then I was really disappointed with you know the interesting thing is by the way during this video clip share a cerrar may Allah bless him he refuses to use my name now

1:31:26

yeah you came care yeah here for months on end he's chasing when he came to meet me he was obsessed about what village my great-grandmother was from you know not even my grandparents my great-grandparents oh they from this village you're from through me you're from like whichever nah but ok you know one of my great-grandparents was from the point is like you're so obsessed when you come to see me Oh what is your name what is these lies you make all these posts about me

1:32:05

and now has it nom laena bima na Cigna he's so much there now he can't even mention my name hi yeah yeah yeah bailiff I you know what is moment on moments a GNA up John Tate a bow witha you know the person you understood to be loyal Jeannie up TT asana the person you saw in you may be he who mama name of talent to me yada

1:32:45

hawk inaudible I am that person yeah yeah solemn what are you doing okay you know sometimes you're obsessed with me now you refuse to even take my name and some reformists some reformists have claimed oh maybe in that there's some extra you know what is it some love and

1:33:20

devotion huh otherwise yeah yeah yeah could be a kill and I can be a counselor yeah can i what's going on here man what's he what's he doing what's he doing so I'm and then uh sir are if you're watching this by the way she has heart if you're watching this surround company so I'll get them up cos I get that they are so I get that right if you're watching this when he sat with me he said don't misquote me don't misquote

1:34:00

he corrected me on a word on the word can't I said something like he said does he have the key said no I said will he have you have to correct every word every word but then in his video when he wants to speak about the miracles of Jesus he says Allah explicitly speaks about Jesus speaking as in the cradle yes so in this at about 28 minutes 28 minutes I think about 50 seconds into it he says Allah explicitly

1:34:38

says that Mary came carrying him and then put him in the cradle and then pointed at him and he spoke show me in your Quran where it says she put him in the cradle ja Licio Mary John where does he say in the Koran she put him in the cradle where does he say that informaiton yard remember your rule of even one word can't be misquoted this is a chart so your words can't be misquoted in the

1:35:18

words of God can be misquoted put him in the cradle what put him in hate corn cerca Ronnie uh-huh sounds so nice though yea-ah put him in the cradle uh-huh I mean if it were permissible to update the Quran I would have tried just for you for my love to you yeah but noise possibly add noise possibly but it does but I give you that it does sound nice

1:35:51

put him in the crate right so and then within 60 seconds he miss quotes miss translates again he says they said hey Philo kalamoon how can we speak to somebody man Cana film at a Sevilla how can we speak to somebody who man Cana who is man no no no

1:36:26

was these were not nice my friend this is why this is why great mother serene yeah Hanna FEMA facili tumhari hand of him ever seen it like a Lucy the great scholar he writes that this is past tense they were referring to the past mankind film at D Sevilla how can we speak to somebody who used to be who was a boy in a cradle what is what does he

1:37:02

say how could who is these are not nice right friend don't do this one so look this is some of the kind of things that were just shocking to kind of see and then all this going on once again about Kyle Kyle Kyle Kyle is the greying of the his the greying of the his great I don't know about the shades of grey and how many shades it has share sorry

1:37:39

happy look Allah I love Gosselaar Metallica I don't know about the shades of gray I don't really read up much rooms and watch stuff like that nah no I don't watch things like that but I don't know about the grain but what I do know is the great a shoddy legend mufasa fukn Rodina Rossi in his turf seer highlights Kahuna Cal can begin from 30 years of age he and he says we

1:38:19

believe Jesus attained Kahuna Kahuna simply means camel fully developed like you no longer developing as a young man you are now fully developed there's no fixed age it doesn't mean when you hit 40 you suddenly become a fully developed man this is natural process some people become fully developed at 30 some people mid-thirties some people 40 so you Dino Rossi says we believe he was done in when he was here on earth this is the great a shoddy Mufasa and also I mentioned nobody used that as an

1:38:59

evidence during the selfs time even for Dino Rossi and all these Mufasa Dean say that was a scholar by the name of fog live now insane Albert jelly and nice Apple you came at the end of the two hundred two hundred and eighty something he dies 282 I think he was the first person to come up with that hundreds of years after the prophet hundreds but you know what nice try Jim a cheeky leo but admit you played it well you just chose the wrong adversary

1:39:37

that's all so the point is that look and then I don't know why he was making links to body unease and stuff like that but I don't want to say he because maybe he did that innocently so I don't want to kind of just you know accuse him of making these allegations because I'm sure Jeff Cassar R is more knowledgeable than than that to say things like that so but he speaks about the cardi unease kind of use these verses look my understanding completely destroys the

1:40:16

body any concept because there is no Messiah okay there is no Messiah so how can car the enemy of Messiah doesn't make any sense oh god the anything is the first thing to fall flat so look and then you know some of the he says look people are embarrassed by miracles and how can I'm just trying to see some of the notes I mean look the thing is that it's a matter of perspective it's not people are embarrassed but people see

1:40:53

how God operates in this world and they don't want to understand religion as a mythology they want to be real with it so everybody accepts miracles as what they disagree on is how they actually were did they have causes to them did they have like was it a phenomenon that fits within God's world why does it have to be something that goes against the laws of God why would God do that it doesn't make sense to people but if it had thought if it had sources as bad

1:41:32

reasons causes within this world it makes sense with God's laws so I don't think that's necessarily an embarrassment that's an understanding right so these are the kind of things he went on to hadith it's interesting he once again mentioned about motiroti going on and then it's interesting because he himself rejects the moto a theory Wyeth of the Shia right he rejects that himself why not accept the she as she I motivate every one of them you know and he says anybody who says old wire about the moat so he talks about my claim and he says oh that's

1:42:10

just a stupid question I'm not gonna even answer that because anybody with knowledge would never answer that why not porque you know pork hermano porque why not answer it like you accept all the motor water of anybody he says well then I ask them how would they prove that Oh Bakr was the Khalifa because it was historical now record was the Khalifa I don't worry me nobody even the Shia historically recognized he was in control after the Prophet

1:42:50

how would they recognize him now it was a historical thing but then he says yeah but how would you prove that he was rightly guided what that's a value judgment that's a value judgment look he himself said that motor water can't be on opinions opinions like what I think of somebody can't be motor water but then he's saying how would you know that Ali was rightly guided this is our opinion of of Sedna a leader of the elan we do believe he was rightly guided but

1:43:28

that's a value judgment like what's I don't get what what the point is I'm bringing this up but what is the purpose so I find these things really absurd and once again I find them to be a diversion tactic to avoid the actual thing he says there's all motivated hadith motivated Hadi refuses to include the extol of the diversity what did Abner headband say the great Mahad did who has his own collection of sahi he says that all Haditha hobro are had why not why not be only sweet people teach people many people have said this other people have opposed it you see this is what happens when you teach people everything is

1:44:08

black and white and somebody comes along and puts coloring everything then falls to pieces be honest from the get-go and then there's no surprises and he says look this thing about bring me the Christians that convert that converted look let me clarify something please watch my preload again I said that there were many complex issues taking place after the prophet many complex issues and hadith don't get documented till at least a hundred years after the Prophet

1:44:47

so there's many intricate things going on politics is going on sieges attacks on Muslims physical attacks the capital gets attacked Muslims move their capital huge civil wars take place thousands and thousands of companions and and tabah in died all this is happening within a few decades of the Prophet the the capital gets moved all together - you know - to Damascus he I mentioned all these kind of things are happening many which was under the Roman rule many comforts do embrace Islam you've got to

1:45:27

remember people carry baggage even he mentions Abu Hurairah of the LA on in sahih hadith in in we have this transmitted Abu Huraira would learn from Kabul Allah who was a Jewish person Jewish scholar who embraced Islam after the Prophet I delight in the Salam who was in the prophet's time became Muslim once again a Jewish person abhava Raider would learn from these people that's on record it's not something in fact there's a hadith that Abu Huraira visited Mount Sinai spent the whole day at Mount Sinai and spent the whole day

1:46:07

studying from Kabul a bar and telling him and he would tell him look a lot was going on there was huge Islam had massively expanded Islam all these tragedies were taking place corruption had come in so much wealth came into the Muslim world a lot of enemies came in propaganda was going around people were making up hadith non-stop this is a fact they were making up hadith nobody can deny that they were making up hadith and then you've got things like false memories people alive at that time thought honestly that the world was gonna end within a few decades

1:46:45

I'm estrodial Mohan in a hadith that is in sahih al-bukhari he transmits and he lives up until a hundred he tree right right he lives up until a hundred hit early he says right now check this he transmits that the Prophet pointed at a boy who was barely ten years old and said this boy will not reach old age except the world will have ended now can you see these people really like at the time all this is happening wealth has come in leadership corruption

1:47:24

the capital of the Muslim is ransacked it's it's kind of attacked the head of state is murdered like pious people left on the street you've got all these kind of Romans are entering Islam all these people Persians are entering Islam people with hatred are attacking Islam the grand some of the prophets but all these things are happening right before Muslims right you've got all of this stuff going on people thought the world is gonna end it was a fertile mind set for the Messiah concept so the Messiah concept was a

1:48:03

perfect fit that you think this is bad yet there's gonna be this kind of devil child that's gonna come with one eye and then this great showdown of good and evil will happen and this whole in fact Jesus will come back and this and then the world will end it was I know I want to bring your attention to something it's interesting that whenever this happens that the Muslims get into so much attack because later on during Bonnie omegas rule later on in the decades that followed you know Muslim saw this so suddenly becoming like a

1:48:41

world power money power connections you know like influences wealth opulence corruption oppression all this going on within their lifetimes think about this now whenever suddenly things happened notice that the Messiah concept comes back right now the sorry somebody saying about my belly the belly's bouncy okay right so the thing

1:49:15

is look right now notice all of these books to do with the Messiah madly coming back that I've been written in the last 300 years maybe 400 years as a stretch like most of them written in the last two to three hundred years that is the books like by hamari Kotani show Connie unruhe shaka Schmidty all of these collections even going to by stretching all these collections on the mat they will come back they all came

1:49:54

they will mainly written under colonial rule all when the Muslims were heading downhill because at that time people started to once again look around and think why are we suffering but there is no way out they're losing hope so all of a sudden people start writing about the Messiah again is that a coincidence is it so I'll leave that to you so my message to share the sorrow I'll leave this for now in Charlotte is that look if you can kindly and he is asked me in

1:50:34

my video to mention these seven companions narrations through them shall are mentioned in relations I was hoping I'd said to him can you read the chains and I would correct them and show my perspective on them but he chose not to do that he's now said look he's gonna respond only in writing so look I'm just disappointed because I thought you know all this hoo-hah mazzani I you know and it just will live up to the hype that's all I'm saying you know all this kind of like lie on all this and then yeah I had

1:51:13

all this and so I'm kind of disappointed but nevertheless maybe I'll still extend this if Chevron watches this sure happy that a lot if you can maybe in the next two weeks if you can answer my questions are highly appreciated you know both what Daniella both what Daniel Prabhu if you can please are really appreciated I think more than me you owe it to your followers and people who you created this hype about if you can respond tackle my narrative don't just tackle this hadith II think and

1:51:53

don't look don't do please as a request Prabhu as a request don't do kind of sideline digs like let's just let's put that aside let's just tackle what we've got at hand okay tackle this issue don't kind of go off you know this is the problem with reformists they say Oh what about that hadith why they don't take the splitting of the moon they don't stay focused focused focused okay stay with me stay with me huh look into my eyes right so stay focused stay focused look the thing

1:52:31

is tackle my narrative please what I will then do is I mean as I mentioned I did have at the end of this month some pre off preoccupations as soon as that's over I will then do a detailed video hopefully I will incorporate whatever I can from what you have said from what other shoe have said all these other people who some who tried to say this is qu far careful from believing this other who said others who've said this doesn't make any sense because of whatever evidence they share silac mean Sigma other people who by the way she Seligman Sigma I responded to him it's on YouTube

1:53:08

from my last week's session and it's interesting now the comments the feedback from other scholars in California was they were saying well oh he made a mistake they said that he made a mistake about saying that when Jesus comes there will be no more tech leave liability that was a mistake they go you know to sell more he kind of like slipped up it was just it was a it's like a it's it's an innocent trip up I was like a cha-cha-cha don't extend this innocence my way you know when I do it it's only

1:53:45

inspired by the devil you know when these Messiah do it haha what's what's that thing golly who's URI kitto legate around is he uh you know when who's usui's it sounds like a dois Allah God Lee who's Rudy people let me drown Jessie huh that's that but when I do something had there's a so coming to this so that's my message

1:54:21

to to all these massage especially primarily surface or are and these were shocked by the way I generally shadow start made a point and this is I'm saying this from my heart look I'm being genuine he said that you know I said he refused to use my name now now we're on this no name basis hi he had I'm confused confirmed IDO it's 3 confirmed diesel I'm a bit confused here okay it's a mystical can on there what name shall we

1:55:00

give this relationship that we've got I'm confused I stay pondering looking into the Stars what can I call this relationship so the thing is now we're on a no name basis he doesn't like to use my name I'll still use his name shares a cerrar sahib huffy the hot mama protect him and bless him he made a point at the end he said that look this person this person now not multi Abu layth this person he said that

1:55:37

he he wasn't offended at the end of the thing and now you know why is he acting like this I'm being genuine when I say this I genuinely in my heart for none of you have a harbor any hatred honestly well la he from my heart I don't yes why am i spotting your mistakes out like this and stuff like this because you began like this and I'm being honest like I actually do think that your tactics are these kind of typical I know you don't like this but typical bril V tactics but you don't like being called a brave you understand that I appreciate that but then hey you can call me a

1:56:16

modernist which I say I'm not a modernist place but we're just being honest this isn't like tip Fatah this is these are textbook Brill V kind of typical tactics you know like I think these kind of tactics that you played making polls taking digs when you came to see me trying to get me to apologize doing all of these then making this talk going away not even addressing my issues it just does to show that it was all as you said it was all drama so hence I feel that yes I will spot

1:56:54

your mistakes I will still say to you do this but well lucky I have no hatred in my heart against you there's very few people in this world that I actually ever have hatred for I try to always keep like a clean heart so yes I may not like some people but I don't hate them and I'm being honest and that's the same thing for all these other machines I definitely don't hate them may be disappointed with some I'm being honest I may be disappointed but I don't have hatred and I'm being honest like I would host them I would take accommodate these people I would pay out of my pocket for you know to kind of like serve these people I would do that still even now I

1:57:31

actually extended I sent a message via some mutual people to shake doctor shadi al-masri who called me a probable kaffir for a probable apostate for rejecting the second coming of Jesus and I said to him that in that message I said that look I'd like to have a polite dialogue with you so it's an exchange dialog and you can record it we can code it doesn't need to be live we can have a media if you like a mutual person and we can just have a discussion but it's got to be a

1:58:11

discussion I'd like to discuss it because you're calling me a probable kaffir don't you think you owe that much to me and then I said to him because I heard he may be coming to Birmingham this year I offered wallahi I said to him in that message I sent it as a recorded message like a voice kind of message I said that I have no ill feelings towards you yes I am disappointed but I've heard by the way that you're coming to Birmingham I would like to holds to you as in maybe not I know you're not interesting talks and stuff but your accommodation at my expense I would like to pay for all your whilst you're here you know your food and everything that includes your family and

1:58:49

I will see to it that you get adequate transportation and everything somebody to drive you around I will do all of that whilst you're in Birmingham so I extended that to him offer that still stands for him and his family and that's you know because I don't have any seriously I don't have ill feelings towards these people I'm disappointed that's different that why would you call me why would you call me a kaffir and stuff like that wouldn't you rather talk to me but anyway so the same goes for for these colours cool that so with that our message on this discussion ends okay

1:59:29

so I'll take the other question moving on to the question about Steven Hawkings I'm still kind of recovering with this dam you see sometimes I bring too much to drink and in the stasium and sometimes I bring too little why is life like that huh between extremes why is my life like that it's either always crazy or woods there's nothing kind of systematic about it hmm right so there's Stephen Hawking's thing

2:00:03

people so those of you that know all right so this Stephen Hawking's thing is so Stephen Hawking's passed away and I made a post and if other Muslims did where they said something like like like a nice word like rest in peace or they said something like like I said may Allah have mercy on him so okay right so now

2:00:45

sorry I was just trying to read some questions now people really you know threw a fit and said oh my god oh my god you know this car filled eyes and people are making dua for him he was an atheist and he didn't even believe in God first of all let's clarify this question I'm not saying but I'm not saying that he's who's gonna go to heaven nobody can say that my belief and that of the majority of Muslims a Dina Rousey say states in and many most I mean

2:01:24

you'll find this in the I shared our books you'll find this in in most Muslim books that Allah can send anybody to heaven he can send anybody to hell he can reward anybody can punish anybody be them a Cara field be them a Muslim he can do that with anybody that is a loss Audra he has that power nobody disputes that and I never said Allah you better do this or you have to do this and I never said in my DA oh I hope Allah gives him an elevated mom engine now something like this I never said that I said that may Allah have mercy on him asking for mercy this

2:02:03

masala of what they call a Tehran in Arabic seeking ramen okay Tehran llq far seeking or alive ladle muslimeen seeking Rama on non-muslims is this problematic and many people jump to this is you can't do this you can't because in the quran this this verse and this this and they and they quote the verse of the quran that will make honest FR o Ibrahim Ali ABI he alarm or editing wadda wadda ha year that and Ibrahim did not seek forgiveness for his father except for a

2:02:41

set period which he promised and then they used and mu so they used the verse of the Quran that were mark on Alina bijon McConnell in Nabil ladina avenue and yes tell Farrell Aleutian Akina it was not it's not befitting for Allah and his and the people who sorry it's not befitting for a lost messenger the prophet salallahu alaihe salam and those who believe to seek forgiveness for the mushrikeen member dmattia Anela home after it becomes evident and manifesting clear 2

2:03:17

billion Lihue unknown mean establishing that they are from the people of their of the Hellfire now people were using this these verses to say that you cannot seek forgiveness or you cannot seek mercy for people like Stephen Hawking now this is not true because look yes I accept that can be an interpretation I accept that an interpretation I accept the interpretation I believe it to be wrong

2:03:55

I believe it to be inaccurate you ask me why we know from the Quran that yes the father law uses the word father of ibrahim ali salam now some people say wasn't his father wasn't Allah uses the word father that his father disbelieved and opposed him and was a sponge kind of opposition during his time now in this surah allah says when i canna stefarr o Ibrahim on the erbium Oh either he only did this for a promise time he sought forgiveness for him that's it

2:04:31

was this during his lifetime of the father or after his death now I would argue and I'll show you in a moment from the Quran that that was during his father's lifetime why do I believe this because the priority of the prophets was to prioritize their that one they were not to kind of get sidetracked in just seeking forgiveness for people who were opposing lead our especially key figures who were then told men ting the followers because that confuses

2:05:11

and compromises the dawa you see it's different like like let's say in the prophets time abu jahal he's one of the key figures who is standing and opposing the Prophet but whilst opposing the Prophet he's also punishing Muslims these weak and poor Muslims is having them tortured he's encouraging that people should kind of torment them for the Prophet - now focus for the Prophet - now focus on Abu jahil and stop making dua for him start making doll for him

2:05:47

would compromise the message of Islam with its believers just as it would for Ibrahim Al Islam right those of you just tuning in if you can click share I'd like you to share this we're discussing the Steven Hawkings thing about Iman right now people I'm gonna take you to the Quran people mention ibrahim alaih-is-salaam i think that's beautiful that they've mentioned ibrahim ali sana why because ibrahim is the perfect example alayhis-salam right guys those of you just tuning in if you can click

2:06:25

like and click share right now let's go to surah Ibrahim the surah Ibrahim in surah Ibrahim which is dedicated to ibrahim alaih-is-salaam and he speaks about many things but in the ibrahim making dua okay ibrahim says ali salam wa is honor Ibrahim and when Ibrahim said and this is later on in his age when he's an old man now look he's moved to Mecca this is much later he's moved to Makai he's re-established the Kaaba with his

2:07:02

children and he says what if allah' ibraheem arabic al-hattal Valletta a mannan oh allah make this land Makkah a safe haven watch look Bonnie Majnu boniva Bonita and nevertheless not and save me I'd say right guys if you can stay focused please do not digress in the comments otherwise you will get blocked those of you just tuning in if you can click share get this out they were discussing the Stephen Hawking's issue and saying

2:07:40

and seeking mercy for non-muslims is that permissible or not he says oh Allah and protect me and my offspring that we should worship idols a rugby in na hoona of the lung like a theorem in earnest Oh a lot they have misled many people ferment ever I need for in the home in me whosoever follows me then he is from amongst me woman Hasani for in nutella for a ride whosoever disobeys me and look what he look what he goes to whosoever disobeys

2:08:18

this now ER in a car for a ride you are most forgiving most merciful let's not stop here people will say yeah but that's only during their lifetime he never said that but I never said that but let's read on he says Rob bana India's kuntum in the real TV world invaded easier and in the vertical Muharram Rob Benaglio famous Olaf Ajay a determiner Sita we lay him was open - a Marathi long yesh karoon he speaks about a live settled my offspring here you know make people's hearts kind of come towards the city McCann

2:08:58

it makes Doha father then he says that you know Allah what we hide and what we express alhamdulillah the wobbly our little Kimberly is my lowest hug in arabela Samira all praise be to Allah who gave me now listen this is old age how do we know it's old age listen to his dog alhamdulillah lady why but all praise be to Allah who granted me Ismail and his heart at this old age he's saying that indeed Allah responds to the door rock-beetle me mochi masala

2:09:35

women do dat oh allah make me somebody who establishes the fray and my offspring rub inevitable tire rub enough fiddly our love forgive me Wally Wally there and my parents he's making this door it's in the Quran in his old age well little mummy Nina you may have come Eliza I'm for the believers on the day that the judgment shall be established he is saying Rob enough fiddly Wally

2:10:12

Wally they yeah people say oh he must have said that when he was young the verse before it says al hamdulillah the wobbly smile always have a little keeper that all praise be what Hibernia a little keeper who gave me despite my old age is myelin his Hawk in Arabella Samira indeed My Lord he is the praise rubbish al límite masala make me and my offspring he goes to his offspring and then his parents his parents had died a long time ago this is the Quran I show

2:10:51

you I'm not making this up this is the Quran Udina Razi when doing a trial commentary on that mentions as the first point he gives three interpretations he says oh this initially it is a problem because Tim wasn't his father a careful he says well there's three responses the first response he says because maybe it's Ibrahim Ali Salam then understands that's not Haram then you can do that you can do that he says that's the I'm not making this stuff up and then he gives other interpretations oh they say

2:11:30

maybe he was making dua for Adam and Eve come on look guys and then Adam officer in say he was making dua for Adam and Eve Adam was a prophet we need to get off this thing of Adam being sinful either sinful why do we keep thinking Adam was sinful Adam was a prophet for God's sake he was a prophet of God you know like we don't need to keep making dua for Adam ELISA Lam he was a prophet of God so you know we don't have this first original sin concept from Christianity this now these are I've shown you clear proofs this is from the Quran people and people

2:12:10

say oh what about Abu Talib Abu Talib yes you know about abu talib radiyallahu anh if you want to accept that he was a Muslim I personally in my understanding feel that like I I feel it isn't convincing that he died a non-muslim right if you look at the hadith that that they bring in Buhari they bring three hadith about a believer been passing away as a non-muslim all Muslims agree that Abu Talib was the source of strength for our prophet now once he was alive Islam was

2:12:48

protected with his death the Prophet was deeply troubled because the Muslims became vulnerable and they were attacked now look I'm not I accept that most Muslims sorry most Sunni Muslims generally accept that he didn't he wasn't a Muslim but I feel that that is debatable why because look when you look at the hadith that they bring they bring these hadith saying that look oh there's a verse of the Quran they say things like in that there's a hadith in sahih muslim by abu

2:13:28

hurayra that in the Coolatta demon are baptized you cannot guide who you want to love allah says this and abu huraira says this was revealed about abu talib but that's problematic first of all the chain has a problematic Rahui and they are seeded mackay son but put that aside abu huraira wasn't even a Muslim when the incident of Abu Talib happened and this verse was revealed so it doesn't even make any sense so he's obviously telling this from somebody else so and then there's another hadith that and this happens why the way you know these a spot they bring these verses and they say you know us Bible knows all the reasons for Revelation but the reasons for Revelation are highly disputed look I'll

2:14:07

give you one in Buhari there's a hadith in Bukhari that from the story of use of a lease and I'm sure he - ah he don't mean I I mean shy he - I need Amin alia that a witness testified from it's from her family now in Buhari they say this was to do with our - likeness Allah who was a Jewish person became Muslim that's inside Bukhari shall be rejected that so harshly and he said that how could that be he became a Muslim in Medina this verse was revealed in Makkah and he said that this rewire of abdomen of me who by the way is one of the people who transmits

2:14:45

Jesus and second coming he says that this is unacceptable because this person became a Muslim in Medina this verse was already revealed in Makkah now my point of saying this is that look even the hadith in Sahih Muslim in sahih hain showed this a hadith in Sahin in body and Muslim that the Prophet said 11:40 yoneyama that maybe my maybe my intercession will help him on the day of judgment so his punishment is lessened it becomes less that since I'm Muslim it's inside a body but when you look at the Quran Allah says now you have the four uncommon either be her that the adapt cannot be

2:15:24

lessened that it can't be reduced voila after oh I'm home it does not be reduced for them and then another hadith let's and for whom the kuffara and found chef's are - chef I'm the people who intercede for Kafar II will not be accepted now you're saying that Abu Talib's punishment is reduced because the Prophet interceded well that shows that it worked now all I'm saying is look I'm look whether a person wants to believe that Abu Talib was a Muslim or not a Muslim it's up to them I'm not saying that people have to believe this I have to believe that I'm not you know forcefully kind of pushing this I myself I'm not

2:16:03

convinced that he was not a Muslim like I think he most likely was because why would he so passionately spend his life defending the profit and defend you could say because it's a relative but he defended Islam to that extent that it had so much strength and his famous poem even the Prophet would have it recited that that but I mean he's kind of support for Islam so I'm inclined towards the understanding that I think he did have faith and I think his last words when he said I died upon the understanding of Abdul Muttalib is because after Muttalib was from the people of Fatah Abdul

2:16:43

Muttalib is not from the people of hellfire I think that look but I this more importantly if people want to they can believe what they want I'm not imposing my understanding on anybody but what I would say is that look let's stop obsessing with heaven and hell for other people judgment is for Allah judgment is for as long okay we need to kind of chill out with this out and asking for mercy for somebody doesn't mean God has to grant it's up to God may Allah have mercy Allah my Allah might not we all every you know the creatures ants anything

2:17:22

animals we all belong to God what Allah can't have mercy on us a lot kind of mercy on us if we are alive can't why not if we're dead people say yeah but Stephen Hawking's never accepted God of course he didn't let's be honest well lie let's be honest for a moment we would not accept Islam if we were were not born Muslim let's be honest like if I wasn't born Muslim if I wasn't born in a Muslim family that's what I mean by being born Muslim in a Muslim family and brought up as a Muslim would you really accept Islam and I had this awesome conversation this day with with dr.

2:17:57

Imran from Birmingham Metroflex Jim and it was really Slim's behave like let's say it's Juma they block all the roads like let's be honest if you were a white person growing up in this country who was not privileged you would probably be part of the EDL you probably be Islamophobic and racist because you think look every time I try to drive past when it's Friday they blocked the roads what uses that jamar if you're gonna cause inconvenience to people but my point I'm not trying to attack a single point of Jim I'm trying to say let's be honest we seem to have this kind of Baptist culture that just because we've said la ilaha illa-llah

2:18:36

wait God save children we can do whatever the hell we want Muslims have got huge problems in this country we've run a huge part of the drug industry in this country in the UK Muslims they've run huge parts of the kind of sex garden gang grooming kind of things they are heavily involved in whatever usually recently recent times acts of terrorism and stuff like they are of a huge crime rate massively kind of unjust amongst ourselves like I'm just being honest like we do massive tax evasion we do massive claim benefits we steal were massively unethical I look I'm not

2:19:14

saying I'm so epical I'm an angel I'm just being honest for a moment right we're all about you know just living that life and Muslims the we're a small proportion yet we make a huge proportion within prisons disproportionately Muslims now the the question is why would you be Muslim it hasn't you know like we've got this kind of Baptist culture like you baptize a child now he's saved it doesn't matter he's definitely going to heaven now because they baptized him as a child oh he said Allah Allah Mohammed or solo he's definitely going to heaven this cafe who helped humanity did all of these things they're definitely going to hell and I think another reason we do

2:19:53

this is to make ourselves feel better right guys I think I'm running out of battery so I'm gonna have to kind of cool this to an end the reason we do this is to make ourselves feel better because we think that it's not fair other Muslims who are practicing thing why did I have to quit doing all of this and this Muslim God non-muslim you got to chill out go around have all these sexual liaisons or do this or drink alcohol or chill and he gets to go to heaven hmm I never got to do that hmm you know and it's not fair well guess what right you haven't been shortchanged you still get your reward why are you angry for other people if Allah is merciful to

2:20:32

them in a widely matobo year for worse and as the Prophet said why do you hold true something that I sold out and this by the way what I've is the fatwa of that lifestyle mr. riah if you go to their website the great Darla's star of egypt and he is allyl Jeffrey is on YouTube we can go they sharing a platform with Osama say it and these are grown kind of scholars and Muftis within Egypt today and the world they are saying the same thing you can say may Allah have mercy on them as an you don't pray their janazah of course they want Muslim but you can say that it's up to a life he chooses to do that people with that I'm gonna have to call this to a name do stay in touch

2:21:10

like my page send me any messages I will try to respond inshallah till next week take very good care of yourselves people Salam o aleikum or I've meant to lie to Allah or butter cattle

Something wrong here?

Tell us what is wrong and it will be checked against the recording. Nothing changes until a person has reviewed it.

Sending a note needs JavaScript, which is off or unavailable in this browser. Nothing has been sent.

No name, email address or account is asked for or stored, and the inbox does not store your IP address. For rate limiting it keeps an unreadable fingerprint of your connection for 48 hours, and our database provider's own logs record connections as every website's do. Only your note, its kind, the page and the moment in the recording are kept, for review.

Cite this recording

Stable id, transcript version and tier are part of the citation. Every change to a transcript is logged.

Mufti Abu Layth Archive, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/hb7d-viloko/ (accessed 1 November 2026)

APA 7
Mufti Abu Layth. (2018, March 20). Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 70 [Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors]. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Retrieved November 1, 2026, from https://muftiabulayth.org/r/hb7d-viloko/
Chicago author-date
Mufti Abu Layth. 2018. "Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 70." Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Recorded March 20, 2018. Accessed November 1, 2026. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/hb7d-viloko/
BibTeX
@misc{abulayth-hB7d-viLOko,
  author = {Mufti Abu Layth},
  title = {{Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth: Session 70}},
  year = {2018},
  month = {3},
  date = {2018-03-20},
  howpublished = {\url{https://muftiabulayth.org/r/hb7d-viloko/}},
  url = {https://muftiabulayth.org/r/hb7d-viloko/},
  organization = {Mufti Abu Layth Archive},
  urldate = {2026-11-01},
  note = {Auto-transcribed, may contain errors}
}