Early version. Transcripts and tags are labelled by accuracy tier. A position is shown only after two independent reviews have found it in his own words.
Mufti Abu Layth ArchiveBeta

Recordings › Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth

Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth 153

salaah namaz salaat namaaz as-salah al-salah salawat ahadith ahaadeeth hadis ahaadith saheeh saheeh hadith sound hadith authentic tafsir tafseer exegesis tafasir tafaseer malik ibn anas malik bin anas imam maalik imam malik ibn anas sahih bukhari saheeh al-bukhari saheeh bukhari imam al-bukhari rak'ah rakaah prayer unit rukoo bowing tashahud tashahhudh takbir takbeer takbirat takbeerat imaam prayer leader udhiyah qurbani qurbaani udhiya udhiyya kurbani sadaqah sadqa sadqah voluntary charity ka'bah ka'ba kaabah masjed masaajid masajid mosque khutbah khutba khutbas maaliki malikite malikiyyah maliki school hanafite hanafiyyah hanafi school fatwah fatawa fatwaa fataawa legal opinion haraam forbidden mubah mubaah wajib waajib wajibat sunnat sunan prophetic practice dalil daleel adillah adilla evidence riba ribaa sood usury hasan hadith hasan li-ghayrihi hasan li-dhatihi hasan sahih rawi raawi ruwat rijal saheeh muslim imam muslim muslim ibn al-hajjaj iman imaan eemaan eeman sihr sihar jadu jadoo kala jadu sorcery akhirah akhira aakhirah akhirat hereafter janna jannat paradise jahannam jahanam jahannum imam mahdi mehdi koran quraan al-quran sura soorah surat suwar soora chapter aya ayat ayaat aayah aayat wahy wahi wahee sahabah sahabi sahabiyyah sahabiyat hijrah hijrat hijri ahl al-bayt ahlul bayt ahl ul-bayt ahle bait ahlulbayt ahl-e-bait ahl al-bait khalifah khalifa khulafa khilafah khilafat khilafa makkah makka mekka madinah madina al-madinah madeenah yathrib ahl al-sunnah ahl as-sunnah ahlus sunnah ahl al-sunna shiah shiite shi'i twelver ithna ashari salafism wahabi wahhabism aalim ulama ulema ulamaa shaykh shaikh sheik shuyukh shaykhs umma ummat madrasah madrassa madaris madrassah religious school nikah nikkah nikaah nikah nama nikahnama walee awliya awliyah alhamdulilah al-hamdu lillah alhumdulillah alhamdulillaah ma sha allah masha'allah mashaa allah as-salamu alaykum assalamu alaikum assalamualaikum salaams salam alaykum wa alaykum as-salam peace greeting niyyah niyah niyat niyya niyyat duaa duas duaas supplication tawbah tauba taubah repentance al-din ad-deen ad-din ibadah ibada ibaadah ibadat rahmah rahma rahmat

live stream · 2:30:30 · 10,000 views · 25 Feb 2020 · Open on YouTube

Press play to load from YouTube. Nothing loads until you do.

Transcript

machineauto-transcribed, may contain errors · source: youtube auto · click a time to seek · dotted terms open the glossary
1:06

all right people are we is live let me just bring this up here Allah Akbar Allah Akbar share it out from here just sharing the love people I've gotta keep this low just in case you can see my password not not it's the

1:39

mail right so on memento moment tick Oh Damas Y Caballeros just hang on almost done there is I can see what actually that's a good point to check the audio look at that people is the audio clear some people were complaining that it was a bit low last

2:14

time is that loud enough or do it's not loud enough obviously get your ears tested to start off with right but I mean if it's not loud enough let me know our biggest save our Kalia to Yahweh away you know up get shipped in tech [Laughter] alright so let me see that's almost done this is so awkward having to work around

2:52

this mic I tell you [Music] the lil Lil Hamed awry in al hamdulillah wa kafa all I can hear is gibberish and him of the uh oh I thought audio is fine in al hamdulillah wa kafa salat wa salam o allah rasool mustafa ala I've a delayed in October woman be who da who mr.

3:28

da wah be a sorry a little Martina tava bad for Salaam allahi allah o allah wa salim become marhaban running lights bienvenidos a todos Pajaro Valley who Shama deed people and swagatam swagatam so esta pasando me gente que lo que what's going on what's going on I haven't actually had a hater I need haircuts over to you Kaka you know this life I ha ha wait wait wait is the time

4:04

go I think it just all goes in TV series and sleep and can you tell us who needs to be Mufti on a serious one must be on a serious one yeah yeah why are these people straight away so serious why so serious you know so let me do the usual people those of you I was about to say I'd say her armies that haven't still liked my page have a kiss can't Azhar

4:44

carry like it here so that's my my different social media outlets people Facebook Yahoo so stole gam that's my Facebook public page a recent clip I put up for those of you interested in Maliki firket still there and as always people are somebody had said about the naughty naughty so naughty naughty I thought I'd share that what are I some people had sent that to me I don't really watch sports but that's meant to

5:21

be an incredibly famous footballer Pogba I think so well I'll share that moving on to what I am very interested in movies of dokuro

6:00

barrows Garbutt this this is it this is what happens you know when when a person is so so immersed trying to find this romance you know and then life is passing by so people will be taking a look at quite a few things today I want to look at the issue of father a more deep slightly more detailed overview I know a lot of people had been asking me I thought chello yeah be it's a good opportunity to do

6:39

that look at this Abdul Alim says I'm it's the first time I'm giving I'm watching Mufti Abu layth so I know Mossad lambic marhaban o Shah Mardan and what on earth were you doing up until now why were you wasting your life right so somebody said Arthur Decker again again I don't know what again right so we'll be taking a look at the further issue that's something that's also I'll be

7:18

taking a look at the a Jawad eights revisiting that showing some more detail on that and people my beloved be lowered Hazrat has wrapped you know hazrat hazrat sahib o sahib or rat poison has chef s RR will be discussing his his amazing methodology on proving the validity of islam wah wah

7:58

Banzai this is the amazing 21st century 2020 edition on how to prove demonstrate your faith is 100% intact not so much your liver of course after attempting this where beloved drinker drama drank a rat poison to prove his islam is supreme so we'll be taking a

8:37

look at that in the multiverse ala segment but let's take a look at what is it that is bothering me sent a look at this eres is salaam of T I'm watching 150 third episode tonight you're doing it mind you doing it that's what I'm talking about Lucy greetings aramis TAS how's it going how's it going Portugal people Porto girl mystique and two people get married ha over the phone in here naughty

9:15

naughty order over the phone what kind of hanky-panky is going on over the phone oh it's a video call I don't understand the Chesky people get by just these are kind of like just you know just not substitute real thing you know this one but I suppose each to their own huh

9:49

cada uno s cada uno right so a cerrar is thinking his Holly bin walid hazrat as there are we gonna come to him right let's take a look at what my facebook my gente on Facebook or saying let's see

10:21

mm-hmm carry on peoples where are you there you are this is a bit slow sometimes I'm bringing up the Facebook people obey it says how are you daya and Jim regimen Allah going right somebody shams estoy cansada porky porky hermano porque what have you been doing is the question multi sub is Mike a chacha chaudhary leads I have Imam kasi you're doing it you're doing it people right so mostly talk about Mota okay you know I'm gonna

10:58

have to end up making like a at demonstrating demo video on muta from A to Z but the nominee Kelly this is how to oh that reminds me at this paper yeah people speaking on poetry while some people are still tuning in those of you that haven't heard of Ahmed ferry's legend legend of recent passed away not so long ago from Pakistan an amazing author poet who's he tantalizes such

11:36

intellectual boundaries at times wait a minute how can my phone not be on silent tawba tawba ya Tobit Oh Pato Pato - but over you know the the indo-pak way of touching the ears tobert Oberto Oberto right so this was a poem of his some parts of it reminded me I mean some themes motifs from callebs poetry this line he begins with about being removed

12:14

from Jenna yeah Adam and obviously the whole story the Garden of Eden and where Holly besaid Nikolina whole say Adem Qasim ti helican Bobby Abreu hooker Terry kucik he's saying that was a tragedy coming up getting kicked out of heaven but the way I got kicked out of your house he says this was another level of tragedy but here Hamid Feroz says I'm holdin hold they

12:52

refer to Jinnah hum holds a nickel toga hamper yahuda eat nice a vaca Hasan abort [Laughter] he says it's true that we got chucked out of you know we got removed from Jenna the whole the biblical version eating an apple or whatever it was but he says it in a save our [ __ ] you know this incident so much drama over this one little incident up hum here sorry

13:32

Zamani kaduche many who says our us erupted but hon about that now the only relation I have with this world is one of animosity to increase it beyond that like to have any other level of relationship with this world is just too difficult now AB kunas in the GEEP a Maha but Govardhan that should we not now sacrifice love over life as a sacrifice love now over life it's a

14:06

Shakima John say John about Dukey autumn ah this is the man had suffered some tragedy I tell you he says that you know now we've lost enough it's you know people say you die a thousand deaths in in love he's saying we've lost that as it is so it's about time now we sacrifice love for life that Keanu Hammurabi who a McGarry Adil a yard a yard erotic on Abarat loop here Terry

14:46

Labonte who CBO FACA seeker mad for us to say Kahana bah I really do poetry has I don't know it's it's magic you know in the hadith in nominal by any lacera that from some of speech is magic and to me that that's kind of poetry that's what it means so what else is going on Mufti foes Mota BIA is saying hey Muftis Hedra

15:24

obligatory upon a Muslim to a Muslim country and why do some al Ahmar say it is you've gotta be crazy to do hydra hydra means migration where on earth would a person might and why would you want to migrate let's be honest these countries are the best countries in the world like let's just be honest about it i mean no you know why why why blog would you I mean there may be some difference between them some may be better slightly in some legal perspectives rights but I would say

16:01

Europe by and large especially Western Europe is really the kind of it is I'm not sure it's by no means perfect but it is definitely in at the peak of the human hierarchy in human civilization and the development of civil society you can't really you know even America really isn't because America there's some parts of America that are incredibly advanced

16:39

and civil and you know like there's so many facilities and the whole thing and some parts of it which resemble the third world and so Western Europe by and large with its blows with his human rights with its and it's this this doesn't mean that it's action it's definitely not in this plenty of room for improvement that said it's why would you want to leave this and go to somewhere like Afghanistan well if that's the case then

17:15

good luck mate because that's what Darwin would call natural selection anyway let's let's take a look at some of the questions what are me Facebook sent they're saying somebody's asking about a jawad eights doesn't since C Rajal happy saying since placebo effect can heal too so doesn't our agitates and honey and things like this could help heal with medication of course you see this thing on a jawad eights I actually

17:53

brought this up because in the past I've been asked on a jawad eights so there is a hadith which is in it since I Muslim and other books and things like this that the Prophet said whosoever eighth Manta Sabah in some whosoever in the morning or man achelous about tomorrow what is it oh so actually let's go through the actual this narration that is in Sahih Muslim

18:27

this one is Sergeevna because that the messenger of allah salallahu alayhi wasalam said those of you can see this this is sorry muslim that he says man Akeelah sub our tomorrow team in medina la vieja Hina you spell Emir Dora who's someone hot I am see that whosoever eats seven of these dates there are between these valleys when he wakes like as in in the morning even poison will not harm him and throughout that day okay until

19:05

evening now I've mentioned that in the past that look these things this is not a literal interpretation this is just hyperbole it is an kind of the the dates in the time of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wasallam I mean they did have smaller dates but they had the huge kind of their dates were huge as well they weren't just these kind of regular dates we get now that you can still sometimes find in the Arabian Peninsula and that very large dates and this was their staple diet and a certain quality of

19:43

them is was obviously was the hallmark of nutrition and and kind of good health just as people might say today you've got bread in common household here within you know throughout the west and people might say well whole-grain whosoever eats whole-grain bread so you have this kind of very healthy option from amongst it and the prophet sallallaahu I leave salam is emphasizing that this is so wonderful that it's even poison won't harm you it didn't it

20:22

wasn't a literal expression it was just saying that you know this is so amazing you know if you've had this like it's like a person says you know if you take this supplement you can bend steel it doesn't really mean that it is like that so that this is hyperbole in speech now there are other hadith with the prophet of Allah Salim said Darin Latimore Rafi Darla Tamra feeha or Baton Latimer Rafi he G on a lo that this is the house in

20:57

which there are no dates its occupants will always remain hungry now that isn't that's not true by a it's not to be taken literally the Prophet was not speaking from a position of prophethood when he said that he was speaking as a person living within that Arabian context so you have to remember that scholars this is why I say the Maliki method the school of Medina is so awesome that the skull is really worthy you know stemming right from Imam Malik

21:35

that thus the dawn of Medina the voice of reason they've really kind of held on to that so you see people like Al Abbar Salafi now karahi is a great Maliki scholar around 800 he highlights that the prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is when you eat when we read about him he is in three different states of mind okay he has a state of mind which is the Prophet he is the Prophet and he's speaking as the kind of head of state of

22:14

of Medina okay and the Muslims by extension so as what is the root button abou why he's coming from that angle then there is another state of mind where he's speaking as a judge where he's judging between two people this is not something necessarily generic it's not for other people it's not a fatwa it's a Kaaba this is the what the scholars call a distinction between a banal abar evil foot here between a fatwa and a judgment is that a fatwa is arm it's for anybody and a judgement is specifically for the people at Honda are being kind of judged

22:53

it's not for anybody because you know the specifics may vary so and then thirdly the profit as a man as a resident of Medina and sometimes we don't know what that hadith it's stemming from which state of mind we have to judge that by the context so you and even the Sahaba sometimes so you have the example when the Prophet is telling them what to do but at the Battle of Badr and let's lay let's set up camp e and then somebody says to the

23:32

Prophet is that on why is that revelation or is this your opinion and the prophecies liable who are ye it's my opinion and then the person says in that case I would like to suggest that we set up over there because it's closer to the well and the Prophet says very good idea let's do that you see so and then there's the example of Barrera who divorces her husband she leaves her husband married and he's obsessed with her not in bihari as well and he's following her around the streets of medina he's pursuing her and the companions and on one occasion he really was obsessed with her begging her to

24:10

take him back this also goes to show that that kind of you know that dominance hierarchy the way sometimes it's presented that was it was a patriarchal society but the way they present it as women were oppressed it kind of contradicts that whole narrative so we've got here that Barrera was going through the streets of Medina and Malik is kind of he's pursuing her and he's saying please please and you know and the Prophet sees that and the companions are looking and the Prophet says isn't it strange the more he obsesses in love over her the more she resents him and

24:49

and this is a psychological phenomenon that the Prophet is highlighting here now later the problem arethe asks him please if you have a word with her and the Prophet goes and asks her he says look why don't you Marie melis again you know he really loves you so she says to the Prophet that is this you know I'm rural is this like a command or divine commandment is this religion are you speaking from Revelation the prophecies laughs I'm just saying this has a normal resident of Medina I'm just saying this and then

25:29

she says no in that case never and you see so this is an interesting phenomenon so when the Prophet is saying these things like oh who ate this whosoever had seven dates this is not some kind of cure from magic or some kind of cure from poison that would be absurd this is simply a great kind of prayer like just a praise of that nutrition and to prove this as well here like this is a commentary on Sahih Muslim this is a double commentary this is a tag team

26:06

effort so you've got the great Maliki scholar who is right who's in Missouri and then you've got called the yard doing a commentary on his commentary so and then there's so masteries is called al mualim and then how the yard is called Akmal al mualim and then there's actually another Maliki who comes several centuries later called OB who does acknowledge Molly but anyway we digress so here look at this hadith that I just read out to you now look at what Imam as early one of the greatest scholars of this Ummah from he's around

26:46

the fifth century of Islam so we're talking over 900 years ago he says Hallel Imam and within the Maliki method he's known as el Imam obviously my Malik is known as Ali mom but if they just use al imam referring to a scholar they're often referring to Missouri all I had am in my logical manner he said this Adi this is why what is irrational and unlike unintelligible the SSV terracotta element tip from what we know of current day medicine and in his time let alone our time and he says well o Saha a yahoo german fanatic

27:24

Tamra fearsome watch immediately Lemieux Kedar Allah Allah Allah mr. Allah what he left a sermon who Allah had al added the Saba he says even if there was some cure that we came to understand from dates that was like an antidote to some poison the seven whosoever ate seven makes no sense and this is one of the greatest scholars and then he goes on to say he says look Islam yes behind Eastham rod wahhabis are like fish I'm Annina he says and then he says maybe somebody may claim to have been cured by but Harley been by

28:02

and large we don't find that today in contemporary medical practices he's saying and this is 900 years ago so now and what is called the yacht's a he says maybe that was a particular date that had some kind of antidote to some poison in in Medina but he says look come on would you - a file about the LAT Wafi but the ad reality takuna FIBA they'll be led to nutella college in spheroid and he mentions like sometimes you find that in some countries they have certain the kind of foods they have very in their nutrients and maybe a particular thing you can cure however he goes on to

28:41

say look most of the things this doesn't really make sense so we're gonna just leave it as maybe that was just something the prophet knew about a particular date in medina referring to their context but in this day and age he says no not from a perspective of tip of and he says as to the number 7 one methoxy so hosel added for Amran job eve fischeri free hustle bob kathy holy he a superelastic Horeb carob well and he says well can I had added mobile Everton

29:19

this number is just exaggeration like when you're trying to say loads like in English people might say we use certain numbers like we'll say you know what just give me two minutes now is often used people say that they wouldn't just say like give me four minutes now that's very precise whereas if you said to somebody you know what just just hang on two minutes that's understood by that just a little while now he's saying the word seven in Arabic like sub asana Biel and Serena mara and these things 70 and 700 is just used as for exaggeration

29:58

I like to kind of mean loads that's all so this is what I'm showing you guys here this is my lucky scholarship showing exactly a very similar line of thinking you know some of these people our beloved Hazrat they say that oh you know Mufti Abu layth when he says things he has no methodology he doesn't he's not in line with the scholars of Medina I give you the scholars of the school of Medina so sit yourself back down [Laughter]

30:35

sientate enter the thing is it's just that you don't actually know how this method and the school works now this is a good example in sahih muslim there's a hadith just before that with the Prophet prohibited is that you if you were eating dates with somebody to pick up and eat two together to get two dates and eat them together and he says it's called electron right to combine two now the Prophet says that lot Aparri knew for in the Rasool Allah he knew her an electron in Lannister dinner rajul ahoo

31:14

unless you take permission from the host now this is Asahi hadith okay it's in as Sahih Muslim and is transmitted by abnormal now what does call the yad transmitted later on he transmits in that and he's quoting from kitabi hatha canif is M&E him he says this was in the time of the Prophet only he says lemma can wali him in a B if they will Massa because what they because they didn't have much food and he says for a million-mile mighty sir I'll hurl as to today when there's

31:53

abundance in food and that's in daytime like all the yards and hot Bobby who are about 400-500 he tree he says filet at Arjuna a little steamer so he says that as to today they do not need to kind of seek permission to kind of do this they don't need to ask the host because today it's understood what I'm trying to show you thee is that these scholars saw these hadith and the teachings of the Prophet exactly how I tell you that it's based on reason it's

32:29

just over time a kind of dogmatism seems to have taken over and there seems to be this mob mentality right so let's move on people are right your questions you can send you autumn what have I done here that's better you can send your questions to Facebook or YouTube you can send if you want to really be supportive you can send some super chats as well why not you know why not you know so right alright let's take

33:09

some of your questions now people do say yeah oh yeah you know BoBoiBoy see this is people are gonna say that's see God's making me forget as a punishment somebody Abdul Manan has asked it most Aslam does have an objective why was the Prophet sent was it just to get more people to worship Allah what do we do in relation to this that's a very awesome question Adam Mira's asked bro do you shape your eyebrows

33:48

[Laughter] the concerns I don't if I'm surprised they appear that way but I suppose it's had I mean fondly Robbie huh it's the Lord and His blessings he showers them on whosoever he wills Verena suppose a bit of DNA in jeans since maha my mom and dad weren't related to each other [Laughter] not that this not that there's necessarily anything against incest oh

34:28

sorry i mean cousin marriages thank god I mean nobody in my immediate family did things like that cousin marriages and I'm so glad I just think sometimes that these things are just must be just so incredibly awkward it's like sometimes you must be looking at them at the other partner and thinking wow I mean I can literally see my granddad in you I mean

35:07

I can literally see my granddad and grandma because they also your granddad Engram oh god I Benjy oh sorry sorry sorry but in easy I'm just joking obviously those of you that are married to your sisters I mean sorry cousins no offense no hints you know just joking joking it's okay yeah what oh that's a

35:41

bit of intimacy between cousins huh now let's let's take a look what is going on man what is bothering me sente can one get married without a Wally I do believe I do believe that you can get married without a Willie and I've got a whole video detailed on that where I showed the hadith and how the hadeeth are not sahi awry somebody said didn't

36:19

your prophet get married to his cousin no not like that right okay so there's a difference between and like that you're related somehow but everybody is so different by and large that I suppose is slightly different to actual you know within the Pakistani community sometimes they just keep it all within within within within like everybody's just cousins so I suppose maybe things are different if everybody's always different you know the mother's different father's different all these people are always different than one person through the

36:58

mother she's related like this but everybody else her father's different and I think you're talking about Zeinab in Josh who through her mother was related to the Prophet at there but through the father and the entire tribe and everything was different so in that sense I mean that's that's not what I meant when I was saying that but okay let's take a look Mufti did you see a cerrar Rasheed's lecture on reservoir tool hint would the Prophet really have talked about India in his lifetime capping GD I've got a video on this this unless were told hint is fabricated I'm

37:36

telling you wallah this is made up there was never a la soie tell him the Prophet would never have it makes no sense that the Prophet in his lifetime who is in he jars and just about gets the allegiance of the Arabian Peninsula the next most important thing to him were the Arabs of the Middle East the Nabataean kind of post Nabataean Arabs were you've got you've got who were now living under the Byzantines and the others who were living under the Persian Sassanid Empire there were a huge you know they outnumber

38:14

the Arabs of the Arabian Peninsula by and large so this is why by the way when Islam spread to the Middle East you're probably wondering some of you who've actually thought about this may be wondering how come in early Islam there's questions like you know can you read Salah in Farsi yeah because people spoke Farsi because a lot of those Arabs sometimes and some of the converts both odyssey but why is there not the question about Greek because surely they spoke you know there was the Byzantines that in the time of Omar collapses so why and they're millions of people there

38:52

so why why were they never these questions about Greek and that's because all those Greek residents most of them were Arabs genetically so they actually spoke Arabic with a slight variant but they could understand what is it general Arabic so this is why the Quran when it came to them they could understand it so yes so this was the primary concern we you have the Prophet speaking of other countries like China like seek knowledge Oh terrible Allen we'll all be seen this hadith is is is weakened made up the

39:29

Hadees may have a nice meaning to it but this thing of us were told hint I'm telling you this hospital hint was only a major propaganda you know at the time and the it's it's omayyad and abbasid it depends which kind of hadith you're looking at but it's during that era when hadith are not documented and had judge even the use of sends Muhammad bin Qasim to synth now the story they tell people is that one lady got attacked and that's a nice story

40:07

I mean if it's true alhamdulillah but I really doubted that that's true honestly I doubt it I sincerely doubt it because you know anybody people forget that they were just as human as you or me they honestly didn't care about these things like these like I think we give them way too much credit like we think they were like these kind of super devout mashallah mashallah ha we've got sometimes fair challenge it 11:30 you

40:44

guys must be drunk if that's what you think they were terribly Youssef is the guy who bombed he catapulted and destroyed the Kaaba you know nobody was prepared to attack Abdul Leibniz obeyed because he had his capital was Mecca but he was seeking he kind of like refuge within the Kaaba he was inside so the armies of Marwan and so on the Omega the armies when they would go they'd they they've refused because they said look we're not gonna how can we obviously he's inside the Haram is inside Mecca now what do you want us to do you want us to throw stone like not stones catapults into the mean

41:22

to Mecca into the Kaaba so they kind of backed off and they said that these can be like bad luck and we're gonna get sins and we don't want to do this who rose to it who said who said uh-huh uh-huh I will do it hi Jay Jubilee Yousef he said he said Kaaba what's that he went there he bombed the cab like I mean catapulted the Kaaba with with balls of fire and they burnt the kaepa a huge part of it was burnt he didn't care he had Abdullah bin Acevedo as a companion he had him hung up stripped naked had his body attached there for three days

41:59

the Asma who's what is it the daughter of Abu Bakr he was about to slap her up do you really think this guy some Indian lady from traveling in a boat said oh I've been robbed ya Salam where is the where are the Muslims and hi judge got up and so far I'm gonna dispatch an army yeah if that's what you think I'd say you know if you can pass me some of what you're drinking it definitely seems more fun than this tea come

42:40

on man that's I I do I wish it's true I I would like that story to be true that had judge did do that but it's it's you know in all honesty it's very unlikely the truth is that there was a lot of politics some people say that some of the Shia kind of followers had migrated towards India and as they had towards Horace on so you have to remember the Abbasids they when they did overturn the Umayyads they came from Horace on modern-day Afghanistan and they managed to build a major stronghold you know abu muslim and all these people

43:17

now you've got on there are some days reports that some of the the imams of the shia that kind of who remember the hash means are the or the opposition to the amides the some of them escaped to india now there was a fear that they may build a kind of support mechanism and they boy later become a threat some people have said maybe this is why had judge dispatched an army that you know and then these are the reasons obviously

43:55

maybe the riches of india why not and things like this and but it's all politics man you know even later on Muhammad bin Qasim who killed him a judge on what pretext oh he was sleeping with the the Queen Rani Maharani Sahib ah Malik I Hindustan so apparently I think her name was Sita Sita ji is Sita GK her beauty was body sundar T's Muhammad bin Qasim no control according to this narration so so when he comes back and had judge kills it come on

44:34

really her dad kills him over sleeping with this lady come on do you think they weren't sleeping with so many people anyway with slave girls what difference does it make if he slept with the the good I mean what difference does make to a judge who's all the way thousands of miles away in Baghdad he come on like let's be real like that it always comes down to things like money and power it doesn't come down you know oh you by the way that captive lady you slept with her like they were doing this all the time I mean so I I just say if we're being realists these things are difficult and it's

45:12

impossible that you know Haddad in my perception but I do still like to believe that story that he did it out of kind of to help a damsel in distress yeah have a seat over a sucked alone but yeah Harper Biggles you know it's like Oh a damsel in distress all right so what is going on Salaam Abu layth Mahmud I know silent I know sullen musty how is Farid Gangu Teli I haven't

45:49

heard of Gangu Teli Sahib in a good while I've got no idea what he's up to somebody said the riches of India yeah of course women of India of course the the beauty of India is is known but I'll be honest with you I'm sure the beauty of Arabia and wherever they were was was equally you know if not had its own but I don't I think it's more olam of the espero que estas be stressed me Ange shukran shukran Perez explicar Alberto

46:25

in Elko was in Ankara swati Lesotho Hamir yeah I mean this was it muchas gracias muchas just miss the name of the person asking Sam just gracias hermano muchas gracias right for the question I mean what this verse or in Ankara or Swati Lesotho a mere the the kind of braying or the sound of the donkey that it makes it a very

47:04

distasteful sound to humans by and large and that's I don't know what that's not necessarily an issue because that is true right yep so that is that is true somebody said had Josh didn't kill Muhammad bin asked him I believe he was behind his his death he's the one who had him brought back had judge did and he is the one I believed that had him I don't I mean where the soul a man killed him or who did the actual execution but

47:43

I believe from what I've read that's a judge played a big role in having him killed whether he had died before him actually getting killed or not maybe the case may not but I mean that's irrelevant but he played the role I mean he was kind of behind it from what I've kind of come across right right somebody saying would I yes I'm going to be addressing the estrade thing towards the end in the masala segment of the masala so war is going on people Mufti can you comment on the background of the prophet's marriage

48:22

- very huh that's we'll do that another day I'll go through the whole background I'll bring it up I'll go into some other details some people are saying her judge was his uncle and what they used to have their own children kill their own parents killed I think he you know it didn't mean what it it means the uncle is a distant relationship people had their own you know you Joe hung Kirsten

48:57

whom Behar kareha tamati many get on he it the husk it that's a quote from how are they Irfan Khan one of his movies all right so why were the Umayyads against a debate it's it's pure politics about who it's a long outstanding disagreement maybe someday I will do a course on it why not huh the Umayyad don't get me wrong I I don't believe

49:36

they work our fears and things like this I just believed they were human or too human really Sid Masha Allah Allah look see Ya Allah oh [ __ ] okay may Allah keep you smiling sugar and Zeeland for your kind words Islam stay bless Islam needs more honest Muslims like yourself right I'm deeply touched and and much grateful shukran right so mostly sob what's your view on share a Syrah yep I'm going to be discussing that a lot of people want to know about the poison Sivaji what

50:16

does Allah who demean the one as significant other is the word ebody used over eighty five times in the Quran used for spiritual sexual worship it shall teach I'll take a healthy sexual worship I'm now intrigued Mufti Kapil I'm gonna come to your question as a bhaji well mostly I thoroughly enjoyed your Noah's age video do you have your own theories on which specific ancient

50:55

civilizations each prophet was sent to you a couple I I mean I think that's not so enigmatic prophets were sent to the regions to the people by and large like so shape most likely the biblical Jethro was in Midian Moses to the Israelites a lot of the prophets were just to the Israelites David Solomon you know these so Jesus to the Jews I think I don't think that's so much of an enigma or so puzzling I think the

51:34

prophets were just sent to their people there was a question asked earlier on about what was the purpose of the Prophet coming and calling people to God and and I feel that they see the whole message of the Prophet was to reconnect creation with the creator or to to kind of you see human beings we really struggle with with true monotheism like because we can understand that there is one God we can get that but then we

52:12

think like really if there is one God then how can this be happening and you know what maybe that God isn't really interested in me so to bridge the impersonal God with the personal God this is really a difficult task honestly and to kind of break free the shackles of superstition I tell you people's superstition destroys human beings as not as an absolute kid but as as as a young person

52:50

as a kid I suppose but probably when I was about thirteen fourteen like that I remember there was a time I became really superstitious and and honestly you know when I think back now it was kind of crippling it's amazing now when I think back I mean I was a kid but and it began with what happened is I I can't remember something happened and they was like he said like a good omen like something good is gonna happen that day and then I remember all that that's funny you know didn't it say in this thing and and then the next time it said

53:29

it again and oh and Wow something could happen and I thought you know this affirmation this confirmation bias began to happen and I know so and then this one time something bad happened then it was said you know like I don't know like I can't remember now whether it was to do with the number of birds you see or was it to do with I can't remember what kind of omen but there was some kind of omen or did I read it some way or something I can't remember but I remember that something kind of this streak of like let's say something bad happening began and I started to get really superstitious and

54:07

I started to think that oh you know this also this good luck bad luck and I've got to kind of be weary and I was just like maybe 12 13 maybe going into 14 that kind of age so and I remember at one point it kind of really bothering me and and as a young person of course and but these grown-ups like this and I'm telling you it's crippling and I'm so you know one of the greatest things Islam did for me when I did I started to pray and practice probably when I was around maybe a 16 17 something like that

54:46

was to really read me of all superstitions and I found that so you know empowering and so because even though it's such a long time ago but because I've had some experience of that I can relate to it like a black cat or the number 13 or whatever it is but somebody said John Lewis said Mufti you're waffling bro Wow is that the brand John Lewis on my show ah right

55:24

let's take some do you do roughly then I personally do a raffle II then sometimes I don't but I mean there have been times that I've left it out but I personally kind of like it it's before you kind of go into ruku and get up from Rocco and things like that he said on YouTube Sid where he said actually I don't know eivin's SIDS usually on facebook multi sub the sub Saba Arif still exists and how is it different I'm gonna go through that on one occasion in detail but very

56:03

briefly I think now there's a huge misunderstanding around that okay there's question coming in I'll just take this but just briefly I feel that all of whatever reading fit in with the earth manic script was in essence permissible but some of it kind of became more widespread and accepted so we should go with that that's the way I see all of this is really just one way of kind of reading it's not Sebata roof and that hadith isn't even really sound but I've actually got it here but I just

56:42

don't you know I've got other things to go through today I have got it out there's an amazing discussion between some Maliki scholars some from North Africa and in Spain where they end up in this huge argument and some people are calling other people kaffir over this and even in loops at the head of it and but I want to discuss that on one of my maybe next week I'll go through in much detail okay right Oh zebra had asked a question about worship and sexual worship I you see that's interesting I'm not within Islam is there this notion of sexual worship i I think in some ways

57:19

you can kind of see it but it's not the way some religions have really kind of emphasized like Hinduism I think traditionally really kind of venerated sex and intimacy as and and I think in a way that that was quite amazing what they did you can see some glimpses of that in the Islamic legacy so things like when the Prophet said Wafi boday I had to come Sadako and so on you know this is like it's a virtuous act and stuff like this but I think the Arabs generally saw intima sexual intimacy as just very

57:59

natural like to them it wasn't the way people see today and it wasn't necessarily when it wasn't a bad thing at all they had notably around it at all in fact by their standards we we would consider the standards rude we as especially indo-pak Muslims would consider how they speak about it in the hadith as unacceptable we would actually treat it as Ahmadi speak because our culture is very sensitive now which is ironic because India kind of came up with the whole Kama Sutra and so I don't know why in you know India now has this

58:37

and by India I mean Pakistan as well Hindustan by and large has this whole you know sensitive culture to it and that's really inherited by the British Victorian era and then the British moved on but we kept it and what we did is we stuck a label of Islam on it so it's amazing but yeah so that's because in the hadith you have things like the Prophet speaking about sex in such open ways that we would be like even when we read it we're like you know because this story's like like some of the Companions will come in and and they'll say oh you

59:17

know they'll ask something about sex and the Prophet will just say oh yeah we were just having sex and when we did this is like but it so casually said that people today would be like huh like especially Muslims today I don't know about maybe other people but they'd be really kind of like wow that's a bit you know a bit too forward unlike the other hadith which I've quoted before when the profit goes to call on a companion and he doesn't open the door and then the Prophet he kind of walks off and the guy comes running and he's tying his kind of sarong his art and the Prophet says old sorry did we disturb

59:56

you he says yeah yeah he says I was just having sex can you imagine that today happening would be like her can you imagine the Maulana South coming out because I almost would like it with there be you want to see how I was that it you wanna know the exact the formation the structure I don't know my usual routine during it so this is how and then the pro in that hadith the prophets like oh I'm sorry did you did you mad you know did we interrupt you did you finish and he's

1:00:33

like no actually I didn't finish this is this is so interesting right so from how they perceived Islam it's amazing and how they they saw it so natural but back to the question I don't think it's really seen as a kind of worship thing although it could be but for some reason as the Muslim institution of institutionalized version of Islam kind of developed people didn't really take it down that road and they just became

1:01:09

more and more sensitive right Holub Norah's asked i want to know if right sorry in i is asked a question as well let me just before i where did it go a Holub noir if health is eternal for non-muslims and is hellfire being eternal fitting for a loss mercy harley but i've got a more detailed video on the afterlife and imagery in the quran and the etymology of things like the Hellfire I've got a few videos on how the the kind of concept of the Hellfire evolves right from the Greek idea you

1:01:48

know mythology of Hades coming right you know initially beginning with Mount Olympus and the whole things and these figureheads Hades is a figurehead then coming to represent the underworld that creeping into kind of Christian heritage where Hades is now the afterlife the dark underworld and Jesus referring to Hades when he says to the people of Capernaum or where he says to Peter you are my rock upon you I will build my church and Hades will not overcome you or where he's saying or in the in the Book of Revelations with his behold I

1:02:28

saw a pale horse the of which was death and followed with it and within all of Hades followed and Hades then becomes substituted with the word hell later on and and Jesus using the term hell as ke naam the Valley of Hinnom people and then this is then further taken up by Islam and moved forward with its imagery I've said that I don't believe that this imagery has to be literal although many Muslims do feel it's literal I feel that this imagery is more symbolic okay it's not necessarily

1:03:07

a literal kind of thing but people can believe it I mean I'm not here to kind of control people to believe so tell them what they should or should not be believing I'm just saying that in my understanding the imagery even to do with God himself in the Quran is simply symbolic like Allah who knew Rossa Marwat evil art this is God himself and it's symbolic it's not you know he's not the physical light he's not the photons and that in the so it's symbolism and the imagery of Jannah is sim sim bollock about you know it's it seems to be really an oasis a garden which is appealing to 7th century

1:03:46

Arabs now if Islam was revealed in I don't know in let's say Greenland or some way we're you know much colder kind of places would have it being different the the description of the afterlife I believe it would have it would have reflected the needs of the people so saying things like rivers of milk for example doesn't really mean much to people today so this kind of imagery was because the primary primary recipients of the Quran who were the make-or-break deal were the Companions so it had to it

1:04:24

was revealed in accordance with the orientation of the world and the rest of humanity just by extension that's so that's my but I've got some detailed videos do you watch them because I haven't really done justice here in explaining right there was a question moving to the next question there was Anaya Dineen you do any in are you doing it a new convert just asked about the Quran ayah on those whom your right hand possesses ah this is I have got some I've got a a kind of detailed video on this because I won't

1:05:03

be able to do that justice right now in Barry but where I go through where I explain what the collective consciousness is and the social consciousness and how that has changed with time but I do I do explain in it that they were they were captives they were these things slavery did exist although Islam doesn't encourage slavery and it does encourage freeing slaves but it does acknowledge it I want you know there's no point trying to deny that it did acknowledge it because it was part and parcel of human society when Islam

1:05:38

was revealed so keeping that in mind yeah that's that's what I would say yes so let me just boost this up slightly hello hello just checking the I felt that the volume was slightly let me just boost it up a bit right so yes I won't be able to really do that much justice just here and now so what I'm going to say is that I've got a clip where I go through and actually show you this a certain experiment in showing how consciousness becomes altered and things like this and I think I do much more

1:06:17

justice there in that clip because I go into much detail break it all down and why sex was there I'm not denying that but the perception of sex were slightly different to how we perceive sex today it's still sex I'm not trying to kind of be around the bush but I'm just saying that it is different still and how and what does that mean and I go through a lot of kind of examples and analogies so do check that out please

1:06:55

it's BA Kalani not be found but eonni watch your mouth what is going on right so Z by your question doesn't make too much sense okay so but I mean each and all to their own questions anybody can ask what is somebody said I want rivers of Rojas aha damn Hussein and such you will be granted right let's kill armed people let's take a look man what's

1:07:35

going down what's going down can you elaborate on the minority of today against this dogma mob and morality so I'm not sure I understand the question had I'm saying he's saying do movies get kinky do movies get kinky I don't think you've you've quite studied with live the Dervish lifestyle you know when the maulvis table comes with these wooden

1:08:11

slippers the bottle but these mattresses and what what kind of what debauchery and film goes on over there so what is going on me Cynthia what is going on right at the thought right so you are a

1:08:50

Kaffir and a kill a bit grease of jayjay Yura cafe who's JJ I don't know have you seen the Netflix series who killed Malcolm X no I actually did begin it though I've watched I think just one episode and one off did Imam Hari used to pray 2 rakaat or is it pray before travelling to Medina and did research I think you know I this thing of Imam Hari used to pray 2 rakaat before each hadith he puttin me

1:09:25

in his book I this is what I call nice speak nicely and it's are nice you know this on I mean it's it's very unlikely I think maybe maybe before he began writing each day he prayed to raka that's more believable but I you know every hadith he got up and wrote to her car and then he's got like about 8,000 hadith in his book would have taken him forever if he was doing that but I mean I don't know maybe maybe maybe maybe but

1:10:04

I don't think so I think there's a lot of exaggeration that they maybe they do it with with good intention moral v's are some of the kinkiest people on the planet teruki movie Eric Eric this is what we call that Eric this is the terminology the nomenclature rather tarik is full on it's on nitro boost with the movies right so the difference of his minority view in the mob mentality Islam why is the distinction between a hora and an Amma in clothing I

1:10:44

don't believe there was I think that the slave killed so to speak that they're saying I think that a lot of these things are post occurrence kind of institutionalization so people have put them in the books but I don't think really the world was like that it is true that the in Arabian society early Islam covering the face one was done out of whatever but 2 was also sometimes a status symbol that they had that culture and you know maybe in that case some women who felt that they were of a

1:11:22

higher status kind of covered their face as part of their culture but it's not really and and yes obviously slaves wouldn't be walking around kind of like dressed or like they would obviously unfortunately be slaves so you can imagine their clothing wouldn't be of that standard and maybe kind of scantily dressed and whatever but I don't think it's quite the way people pretend you know like they act like all these women walked around bare breasted in Medinah and all this kind of stuff I really doubt that after all you know men are men you know I really doubt that they

1:12:01

bothered them about the social status they like oh yeah yeah she's sorry what social status is she oh that's okay then as many of the Salafis to say about the you know about the about the other fella the fella down south buh-bye they used to say in the sahi be am i awesome you know they say my companion they talking about he's blind and and deaf you know he doesn't listen to anyone he doesn't see whatever he

1:12:39

wants he just does this this one out of control so I really doubt that I think these things are all people making up stuff later on yeah the covering the face status I don't think it always persisted but there was a culture that some people did do that for status and you get that sometimes the queen of Bhopal and certain other Queens and of certain empires did used to do that as a status symbol as well [Music]

1:13:12

did the Prophet read salat Ibrahim in the third person no no no he didn't like that he didn't say Allah Allah Allah Muhammad like that I think most likely the Prophet wants the Shah hood is done at ahia to Lilla then they just said a door and said Salaam so this is things that we've kind of put in into Salah that we feel are still part of Salah like they kind of like because in that you say you know assalamu alayka a yuna be so you're kind of giving Salam anyway and this is an extension of that and then you add a

1:13:52

door okay car same show Quran much love much love did what else is going on what are some of the questions Mufti Saab have you heard of the famous beer known as chief beer chuff-chuff I have I have and I'm I think really the wh old you know from the United Nations are really trying to look for him right now with coronavirus beer sobs our chief chief Khadijah chief

1:14:30

Jeff and the coronavirus is like ah this is ne this is where you know how religion turns people in like it really just makes certain people dumb you know in the name of you know these things that you would never be able to get away with but you stamp religion on it and it's amazing how people get away with it you know like this chuff-chuff i can you just imagine this like but in some ways I feel you know my theory is in some

1:15:08

ways fair play you know to chuff-chuff sup you know when you look at that chief to feed you can see that nutty nutty I mean you can see it though he's he's got a bit of that kind of charisma and a bit of that I I feel in some ways fair play because look this world is the law it is the jungle and it's not the fault of people trying to con other people because I think it's by the law of the jungle there will always be people out there trying to con you

1:15:46

it's shame on you for being deceived you see it's not like I don't I blame the people that that actually get deceived by as opposed to the deceiver because I think look because if chuff-chuff Saab didn't con them somebody else would con them you know a fool and his gold soon you know they soon part ways it's not you know you can't really it's like I think people who are just stupid they deserve to be kind of like conned because somebody's got to do it so you think look somebody's gonna call him anyway

1:16:23

chello I might as well call him a survival of the fittest I guess that's that's what it is so same Allah Akbar hey Yakima lammott look at that cross him D people Qasim right mostly I've been following you for a while your mark has been pulling a girl on chat what he swore at her dad who has passed away last week and for no reason putting her on mute constantly for no reason please

1:17:00

sort out your moderator right uh I don't know who that is that that but do you send me a message please I this but about the moderator kind of just kind of muting people who are asking genuine questions can you please not do that okay so bars are Yahoo otherwise I'm right I'm gonna have a word with the moderator do not under no

1:17:37

circumstances can you be can anybody really be bullying on my chat or generally you shouldn't be doing it but definitely not on my chat it's utterly unacceptable on his or whoever done that I mean the girl that's gone through whatever I have shall is our ally apologize you've had to suffer this but I will look into it I will look into it I mean well said we are all given uncle as a gift to use mostly why not discard hadith totally I don't believe in discarding hadith totally I've got

1:18:16

several you know if you go to my YouTube thing I've got this a set of videos which address should we reject hadith altogether Buhari gate what do we think of mihari how should we approach do check those out people because I do answer this Theon why I don't Mufti can you draw a principle to get money of money of out politics from shoes from surah Baqarah verse 1 a what can can you draw as a principle to get money of out politics

1:18:52

from surah Baqarah mark I'm sorry I don't understand what that means maybe make take money out of politics can you make money from politics is that the question if that's the question I suppose you can make money from politics it's now you can make money I suppose politics is a mean as well as a body can you could you shed light on understanding of experience of surah Najam had a dream that was exactly like the verses of surah Najam surah Najam is an amazing surah in the Quran it's you know it's it's kind of rhythmic nature

1:19:32

it's a mucky muck in surah and it's not that long and and it has it touches upon mainly it's trying to affirm to the people that this messenger brings to you a message and how you know like just think about it you know could he really be making this up do you really believe just look at the message and and then look at the things that you're making up you know in here in last mount summit Omaha and tomorrow come this is from surah Najam and you said that you saw sort of Najimy new dream sure I mean

1:20:09

that's that's that's good I mean seeing the Quran in your dream it's I do think you know I think it's a age but happy me oh yeah yeah but I feel that you know now I think more and more that maybe like I'm really intrigued by the realm of dreams and I do feel that it has maybe some connect with the greater consciousness and I feel that in the past humans maybe were more fine-tuned to stuff like this and in our current society we do brush them off in psychology up until today the general

1:20:47

kind of the activation theory and the other theories on explaining dreams don't really quite cut it and I do you know I know Freud said in fact Freud maybe in some ways because he's at least saying it's the unconscious mind I'm saying that what if it is that that kind of consciousness but also part of the collective consciousness and and I feel that's what the hadith in Bihari is saying that Allah Janu Doom agenda that I say the raw his consciousness that this is connected as a social network of

1:21:24

consciousnesses if you like yeah but uh hmm what else is going on is it okay to charge to teach the Quran right this is an issue of debate amongst the scholars traditionally the the Hanafi scholars didn't agree with that so they generally felt it was impermissible although the school of Medina the molecule amar felt that it is permissible to teach to charge to teach things like fear or to teach Quran or to teach hadith or to teach Arabic or whatever is that they felt or to do as

1:22:04

an in fact one of the early one is a classical book written on this by an andalusi scholar from Granada on the imam the mother thing taking a salary and for doing the other and and the Imam and things like and I think that there's no harm really because you know if you don't value these things the problem will be that you're not gonna get the creme de la creme that rise like it's like today because knowledge and scholarship is a redundant faculty that once you become an imam there's nothing

1:22:43

to do you know you can once you become an alum nothing to do like you can either teach in a local masjid where you get paid a hundred pound a week which is ridiculous i'm not even sure if that's legal but you probably get paid something like that or you know you could teach at some basic madrasa and but there's nothing to do so people with talent are not drawn to this field people with talent one of them become doctors and dentists and lawyers and whereas if this feel genuinely paid well you would draw talent naturally people follow the money

1:23:22

there's nothing wrong I think so if you want really talent you have to pay well you know that's unfortunately the the thing so so I don't believe in this and then I suppose if somebody's taking his time out to teach the Quran or do ammama in a Masjid then he should we shouldn't expect them to do it for free I do think that's a bit you know taking the make but yeah so right people shall we write

1:23:58

right just trying to right so right okay people I tell you what let's take a quick we are gonna come to the rat poison thing let's take a look at this fadak issue I want to explain that it's

1:24:32

right so on momento momento people right so I've explained previously that which was quite brief but I've been asked to go over it I have looked into this in much more detail now gone through you know the entire hadith involved a lot of the history I also had the opportunity to go down to within Birmingham this just weekend gone really just Saturday there was a kind of symposium held on this at a Shia Institute which was

1:25:08

looking at the further issue from a Shia and Sunni perspective and just highlighting the case at hand obviously I mean the the Institute was Shia but it's it was kind of with regard to the Sunni perspective as well and the Institute was called al Mahdi Institute it's in Selly Oak in Birmingham I have to say first of all just as a side note for one I was so mesmerized by the actual building and Institute that they've got honestly I've I totally loved it it's I think it was part of Birmingham University or something

1:25:48

before it's like a university hall or a separate kind of a unit almost which has all its own Suites and everything and very modern amazing kind of landscape just I I was wowed mesmerised by it as a Islamic faculty I mean I've been in faculties like that before the or when I'm going to things like psychology courses at universities and stuff like this but I've never seen anything to do with Muslims like that and it was incredibly organized up to date you know kind of take know I was just wild one with the building

1:26:27

two days I think it's under the I think the principle share the sheriff very kind of balanced she asked Allah I was the first time I met him but somebody who's he's quite very controversial within the Shia circles he's challenged a lot of controversial she appoints and I think there's a lot of the Shia I've actually boycotted him but I am a very hospitable person I loved that the way they welcomed me there were many Sunnis there by the way some great traditional Sunni scholars like like trained in back home

1:27:05

Pakistan etc people like a lama holid Mahmud Saab made and I was overwhelmed with the amount of love he was showing me because I was thinking come on I mean I cuz I really did not expect it from somebody so traditional looking at me I mean because you know I mean just the way I look and things like this and my views are sometimes very kind of challenging but so hospitable he was a llama holitzer band Mufti Farouk's are both these are Sunni kind of scholars from Birmingham old school and they

1:27:43

presented their things in or two but it was an amazing opportunity so I thought I'll just mention that they did really enjoy the visit they and I think we need to collaborate so much more you know Sunni Shia this whole thing we need to really we really need to kind of go through this Vera you are busy but if you get a bit of time please do answer my question oh yes said shukran much love I definitely will I'm just trying to see what the question was right I've

1:28:21

got to if you can repost your question please and he doesn't need to be he could just be a standard post I I will get to it I'm just as soon as let me just go through fadak I can't see the question right so all right so I can't see Mesut I can't see his question can somebody post his question please right so I wanted to discuss so we went through this whole thing a bit about Frederick so fadak is to do we're it's a

1:29:00

piece of land I'm going to bring it up let me just see here so for people asking this as you can see I've got it highlighted there fadak and in the center in the kind of rectangle is is Medina so you can see that there right so that's footik and to the top left of it is Hebert and it was in the outskirts

1:29:37

of Heber for the croisé and it was kind of given to the prophet sallallaahu listen as part of faith okay now faith is that land which the it's that land which the Prophet is given mm-hmm it's that that land which the Prophet receives through without war fee

1:30:14

so it's a kind of truce but as part of the truce people sometimes they would say things like especially in in old times they would say things like look if you they will they would say things like look okay we don't want war tell you what we'll do this sometimes they might say look what I tell you what we'll all leave this region will move to that region you can have these or they might say something like you know what just take this particular thing and let's have a truce let's do this that whatever it was a kind of compromise that people would do so during the Battle of Haber there were a lot of surrounding

1:30:53

territories and and some of them were taken as a truce they weren't actually taken as as you know with actual war and there is the verse of the Quran we're looking at is in surah talha sure and so if we take a look at it begins with verse 5 market autumn so also we lemon Shaitaan regimes are losses mascutta to mean lenity no tractor moo-ha-ha imagine allah will surely have a be evening level yourself a sapling so allah is speaking about them this as you go into

1:31:31

warfare and so on huama afar allahu allah rasool allah he and that which Allah gives as faith and faith is this land or whatever comes as a truce allah rasool e he min home farmer al jerf tamale him inhaling villarica or like in the law you sell it arose allahu allah ma yah and you have not had to kind of Wade you oh you know war with your horses or do things like this Allah has given allah has allowed the messenger to kind of preponderate and subdue and control the situation here and it

1:32:11

mentions wa llahu an Akula shayin Qadir ma affair allahu allah rasool e so what Allah gives us fakemon a little paurav ala llahi well Rasul then it is for Allah and his rasul walid el Korba so walid el corba well yatama well Misaki web Nessa bill kala hakuna do Latin banal agnya minkum wama adraka ma rasool allahö do woman huh come on - Tahu what dark Allah in a la Hache edita now this is from that for seven in suratul huh sure now in this

1:32:50

verse Allah mentions these five categories of of who the who benefits from the faith for losses lillahi wa Rasul so people generally can't align his rasul as one you know it says well is ill horrible well your terma so the relatives of the messenger while your timer orphans and Allah mentions robinus a woman is Sabeel and people who are travelers that kind of need this and stuff so the issue is here we're dealing with this land and this particular land that we're looking at is is called fadak

1:33:28

that i've shown in the map now what's happened is during the lifetime of the prophet salallahu alaihe salam I want to give you a synopsis in some in more detail that during the lifetime of the Prophet Allah whom he had this this land and he was very fertile they say that further was incredibly fertile so he had a lot of produce you know produced things like whether it was barley or dates and things like this now the Prophet would use it and in summary Wyatt he would use it for travelers that were coming he would kind of have that a lot aid and he would have a portion from it summary why I'd say you'd splitting in two or sometimes in three and use a

1:34:07

portion for this and a portion for that he would set a certain amount aside as a reserved for crises like sometimes there was you know low food availability there were things like this they may have been armies going out so this is how they were organized now the issue at hand was there's two key issues after the prophet's lifetime could this be inherited by his offspring who in this case is for tomorrow day low on her now what we know as a fact is that for tomorrow the allow on her approaches Abu

1:34:47

Bakr to ask for inheritance but she doesn't receive it she asks for this now she asks for the Sadaqat the Sadaqat as in the the land which is around Medina which was born in Adalind she asks for Haber and she asks for for that she asks for not just further quite she asks for a large claim that is made or a claim for a large quantity is made and better to word it better now I work all day long on response by saying the Prophet said land north we as profits

1:35:25

do not be quit we do not leave things in inheritance matter akina's sadaqa right so whatever we leave is is a charity the question on reincarnation I'll come to that in just a moment as soon as I just finish this topic of verdict all right so I will I will discuss that I'm just gonna let me just finish this right so the the issue here is that we know that happened okay that she's denied this now

1:36:02

the question is was who was right here right Khalid sheriffy I'll come to your question as well just on momento momento all right so I'm chakra and much love right so I really want to explain this in some detail so now we have these reports we have an embody that for tomorrow the Allahu Allah comes she asks for this in fact I'm going to bring the hadith in front of you so you can see this hadith iya that Fatima is asking a worker she asks for the souther cart of

1:36:40

medina and she asks for also further and haver now and then this goes on to mention it gives a kind of story in a worker saying know that look I'm just going to leave it as how the Prophet had it and that the Prophet kind of oversaw think he kind of oversaw it but not as a as his property but as a guardian as a manager of it basically and he actually belongs to the Muslims and then it mentions that and then this went on to Omar and then Omar kind of allowed the guardianship or the managing

1:37:18

of it to a lien Abbas and then but that's of the Bani nadir land but father can labor he kept control of under the state and then it mentions that in other narrations it does go on that this in the time of Osman is then given to Marwan now I want to highlight here there's some important points right and that is it's a really important question this land of Adak of fate fate what we're calling faith we're spelling it as FA why and then with an apostrophe for

1:37:58

the hamza fate now they do you does one own fate or is he simply managing it because this is what allah says that you have obtained without having to struggle for it so it belongs lillahi wa li rasool volatile core bajalia time I will my sake Nawab Mississippi now does it belong to the general public is this an endowment or is this personal property here there is a difference of opinion among scholars on what they should and

1:38:37

ought to be now this really if one can understand that they understand the whole debate Abu Bakr or the Lewan denies Fatima this based on his understanding that this is really not personal property this belongs to the state belongs to the general Muslims so her for tomorrow de la on her her perspective was that this belonged to the Prophet himself now we do the Shia sources seem to indicate

1:39:14

they claim that fatima of the law on her during her lifetime was gifted this by the Prophet and she simply came to Abu Bakr to just kind of state her claim and a worker denied it so this is why some of the Shia then go on to say so this is he usurped he kind of snatched stole her land from her now some of them claim that they go to that extent then within the Sunni sources they like in Abu Dawood is a hadith that the Prophet in his lifetime Fatima asks her for Fattah

1:39:53

and these lands and the Prophet said no he doesn't give it to her now one might say well that doesn't sound like you know is that the case the Prophet would have surely given it to her but actually in the Sunni sources you do see this another very famous hadith in which in the sigh inside Hari I believe we the way thought they must see is that there's many more servants have been brought in by the state and she comes to the Prophet and complains about her struggling with household work and asks for a a slave a servant to kind of help her and the Prophet when he finds out that this is what she came for he comes to visit her and he tells her that shall

1:40:33

I tell you something better than that and that is to recite this dua every day but he doesn't give her the slave now my point is that it's within the Sunni sources it appears that during the lifetime of the Prophet Fatima was not given this was not gifted this although the Shia sources claimed it was so that changes the kind of debate slightly from the two perspectives we all agree that during a workers after the Prophet Elias and Fatima comes to a worker she asks for it she isn't given it she is upset with a worker that much is kind of true and I

1:41:12

do think from an inheritance perspective for tomorrow deal on her was right I feel because looking at it and looking at these arguments from the Quran but this is the thing I kind of now feel both were right in their own way and I want to explain this that Fatima in the sense that in the Quranic mentions that the prophets do inherit like what what is the Suleiman Dawood and Solomon inherited from the hood and we know that was in profit just prophethood we know that the kingdom of David goes on to become the kingdom of Solomon it becomes one of the most powerful kingdoms in its day in age

1:41:50

and one of the most wealthiest kingdom of Solomon so we know that was wealth we know that the you've got Zakaria saying Ali Salaam in the Quran were in Egypt on Mali I mean healthy I I fear these people after me that Robbie Hubley that grant me a child he says to Allah Jerry Thani that may inherit from me we're assuming a yahoo so we know that this inheritance thing does seem to see is the Quran seems to suggest or inclined that they do inherit and when Allah says

1:42:27

to the Prophet fit you see Camilo Feola dekum Allah tells you about your children that inheritance is like this and a girl gets this much and a boy Allah or to have them said by the way we don't mean you we are so low we mean normal people rest of the Muslims not the Prophet but here the Prophet is being revealed on to like this verse but yet it doesn't include him and there's no mention of this I do feel that that is a weak argument from that perspective so I do agree with for tomorrow the Allahu Allah in that sense about inheritance however

1:43:05

after looking into this in a lot of detail I do see that the debate if not about inheritance if about Fame makes more sense that PHA belong because it was so much wealth it was something the state needed to support the general Muslims like travelers times of Christ times like these things can't become personal properties that the Imam whatever he gets as an imam is not really his personal property so if today an imam went out on war and he got a certain landing truce and that becomes

1:43:44

fee then that really is not his personal property to say okay you know what I'm gonna give this to my nephew that's not how I mean that would upset a lot of Muslims because they'll be like no this is Muslim general kind of welfare property it's an endowment so I see that angle of a worker is more correct although the line of arguing of myrath seems to not then make a bit of sense that because they're discussing inheritance whereas they should have been really discussing faith so that's the thing one thing that definitely gets quite I think after fought after Abu

1:44:22

Bakr Omar Odilo on in sahih al-bukhari mentions that he gives the guardianship of it to Ali on a bus and then they start arguing over it and what happens in fact Mahadi seems to use his words that they insult each other and actually swear at each other and it mentions the sways as well this is Ali and Abbas to each other and and then it mentions Omar saying to them that look I didn't give this to you as your personal you know property I gave you to just manage it but as by the way those who manage it do you get to benefit from it they can keep the benefits but they don't own the actual thing so here it mentions in

1:45:00

re-wired that Ali overcomes a bus and manages to keep it now this is what some of the rewired mentioned now then in the time of Earthmen and I'm not quite sure I think here there is a question mark it becomes hazy because earth man seems to give it to his cousin Marwan I'm not quite sure what was going on there maybe earth man at that time felt that you know people don't really need it or whatever or maybe I'm gonna you know I have since as I'm the Imam I can do so he gives it to Marwan does he give

1:45:39

it to him as ownership or does he give it to him as just managing I would think he gives it to him as managing why because otherwise it would have been the inheritance of marwan's kids but you see my one son after him Abdul Malik who becomes the king the Caliph and then his son you get Walid and Suleiman they ought to have inherited it but in the time of Omar ibn Abdul Aziz after them and he's not from Abdul Malik he's from Abdul Malik's brother Abdul Aziz he says I'm giving this back I'm returning it to how it was in the time of overcurrent Omar and he says that this was wrong you know I I disagree should be like how it was so he

1:46:18

he gives it restores the guardianship back to the family of the Prophet and then what happens is in the Abbasids time because they felt that I li na snatched it from a bus as the hadith says they snatch it back someone soo snatches it back then Mamun gives it back then what overkill snatches it back and it just becomes a kind of a toy really but there was something really interesting that needed to be highlighted here and I mentioned this by the way in the symposium I went to that I said that look if this was such a key

1:46:56

issue one thing that you there's a huge kind of a pothole in this argument and that is during the reign of Ali after us man when he becomes Calif he never takes it back and then some of the the Shia Imam said to me that look here but that's because Ali you know it's he didn't want to because like they gave me a few answers one was because no land is given to you you don't demand it I said look come on that sounds that isn't really mm you know that's a weak response because truly speaking he comes to her mod asking for it demanding it so

1:47:34

we know he was passionate about he even overcomes a bus on it so we know he was passionate about it so the other argument they gave was that I lira deal on at that time for the sake of unity but that was a weak argument as well because during a year of the law on whose time he actually goes to war gained several companion of the profit including the wife of the Prophet and other people so I don't think unity was it doesn't make any sense and since Frederick was so fertile it would have been an excellent resource for his army the kind of supplies and things like this because he a little deal and spends most of his Calif all

1:48:12

rule you know the four or five years he has in civil war so he would need resources and the fact that it's so close to Medina and the Omegas he was fighting against later on or the Huaraz were up north in Damascus or Iraq he could have easily taken for dark but yeah he never even mentions further he doesn't really you know and so I feel that this is a huge kind of it's a huge question mark that why did I leave this is such a big deal why did I literally alone not take it in his in his lifetime

1:48:48

as a Calif and and I feel that none of the Shia responses seem to make sense of one of the Shia kind of students of knowledge did say to me that this was a metaphor photic it was never about further it was a metaphor about the Kaylee the the caliphate so when for tomorrow Dylan came to a worker she really came saying that he ought to be the Imam I found that a bit weak as well because one it just doesn't really sit right - if she's coming to Abu Bakr then she's kind of acknowledging that he's the Imam and I don't know but so I wanted to really go over this and sum

1:49:25

this up that the key issue here I felt that for tomorrow the LA on just in the argument of inheritance I felt that she was kind of right that prophet to inherit and you can't really use that as an argument that's my personal understanding however from the argument of faith the lands are an imam gains during non-combatant kind of war that I would feel doesn't doesn't become his personal property it becomes the property of the general

1:50:03

public the wealthy so I would fall in line with that I so I think that would really be the crux of this issue I did have a little theory as well and I don't mean to this is just coming from you know we were just discussing this and so this this could be completely off but I'll just share it with you I did feel that maybe because for tomorrow the law on her in her claim asks for so much the quantity so much maybe that was overwhelming which led to an instant denial because she asks for the southern art of Medina opening a lead of Hebert a father she

1:50:41

asks for all of that maybe I just thought I mean and this is just this is pro spec this is pure speculation but I felt maybe because it was so overwhelming and in the time of a record is that this social distressed is the masala Malekith herb this you know there's all these things people bunny hanifa saying we're withdrawing our resources we're not gonna pay anymore we're not gonna give the card we're not gonna give funds what do we do there's an army of osama already being dispatched where did they get the resources from and all of a sudden for tomorrow the allahu allah comes and she doesn't just ask for a particular asked

1:51:20

for the medina resources she asks for the table resources for further so i felt maybe it was kind of overwhelming quantity you know from a quantitative approach and that's why maybe a worker or the law and just instantly denied it and if it hadn't been that much maybe he won't have dinner i don't this is pure speculation i don't mean to you know this is with the utmost love for all of these companions i absolutely I do love them I'm not somebody I disagree in that sense with the the Shia approach I do

1:51:59

you know believe and I've got a video that look all the Companions I kind of love that I I do feel that they were human and the absolutely human it's not that they were kind of angels or anything and and naturally they would have had disagreements and made mistakes but but I just feel that this maybe that's what led to that each the hardy response that immediate response because you see the other companions do disagree with overcurrent later on but I hope that's of some help I just want to sum that that there is no you can't resolve these issues but at least you can have some clarity on them

1:52:37

guys I hope that's of some help let's move on we've got the masala to get to as well I've been asked write about somebody said just to follow up on that somebody said so what he did was wrong you see I believe I'm in line with al-baqarah de la on he's thinking in terms of faith so the argument from Fay I feel a worker is right the only problem is in the hadith it doesn't mention that it mentions the argument from point of inheritance now inheritance I feel far tomorrow Delano

1:53:17

was right so I feel that Fatima was entitled to inheritance but this land I do personally feel was fate and oh maybe most of you if not some of it well maybe wasn't but most of it was the general Muslim it belonged to the general state not to a personal property it wasn't a so but the only kind of confusion is in the hadith it doesn't mention PHA it mentions me earth like the Prophet said we don't leave inheritance I so it's all muddled up so I feel there kind of both right but from different perspectives and then I was deciding the human element of maybe that

1:53:56

was just pure speculation that's just me thinking you know I may be wrong so you know and it's not too by the way insult and I don't want people to think that oh my god he's thinking oh Bakr wasn't thoughtful or something like this I do feel that you know when we're asked things that I do feel that our Bakr was one of the closest people to the prophet sallahu salaam to the extent that in the sahih hadith when the Prophet is asked by a lady that look I need to settle some financial affairs and and I got to do this and I'll come back and the Prophet says he had come back and she says for inula Majid what if I come back and I don't find you and he says

1:54:35

and can hurt Annabel mote she intends by what if you no longer live by the time I finished these things and come after a few years and he says fatiah rebbekkah come to Abu Bakr and I do feel that you know he has his an amazing maqam in Islam radi allahu anhum Jimmy on KU people let's move on with that right so is it permissible to perform what to purchase loans and by turning them into performing ones and foreclosing properties are paid by borrowers look I do feel that the whole I've got a

1:55:14

detailed video on interest and mortgages and I feel that these things mortgages and whatever are not Haram I've got a very lengthy video explaining it that said I'm not quite sure I fully understand this question Khalid but if it means kind of doing people over then I'm against that oppression and things I don't think it's fair to just kind of exploit people because they don't have money and to kind of chuck them out of their homes but if you mean just buying property and using it as business and buying more than I feel that that is permissible right so reincarnation had been asked yes reincarnation I don't believe in

1:55:52

reincarnation in that sense if that's what reincarnation means to to what it generally is understood as your soul kind of comes out and comes back to this world as another soul but I feel that the Roar is connected right so I feel that the raw is connected the aura are connected and because of that connection maybe people this consciousness being collecting the social consciousness maybe people feel as though they have been reincarnated so I feel that they you know it's the reincarnation theory

1:56:30

from some perspective if we're talking about our wire being connected and then ultimately connected to God then the Quran also does mention things like that but not why in the way that like in Hinduism or Buddhism it's being mentioned so I would say that this is almost like this the store really you know the blind men and the elephant and having to describe it and people have grasped a different you know part and then describing accordingly right so so in that sense the Arwa they are connected I feel and then ultimately they're connected to God so I do feel in

1:57:08

that sense one could think or experi there because of this connection they think they've been here before or they've had a past life or I don't believe that they have had a past life in this dunya I believe that in this world our lives are just limited Yolo in this dunya and then we move on I do feel that what we will move on as will be more consciousness related but yeah so I hope that makes some sense what I meant mark Lanza what I meant earlier on should we as a principle have only public funding of Elections compared to corporate bribery of

1:57:48

politicians that exists today to not bribe the judges yeah I I understand what you're saying mark and that is a an interesting question the issue will be I think there should be some regulation I think it's fair to say that people can kind of invest but then you're right I mean people with more money than get to tip the elections because they've got more funding but then at the same time if you control it then you're kind of not allowing people to exercise their liberties it's a really tough one really but I do agree that you know you get multi the multi millionaire and

1:58:26

billionaire corporations are gonna fund people that support the elite and then they're gonna get more funding and then they can advertise more and do stuff and and we've all watched that you know the Netflix kind of documentary on it which was really scary by the way somebody asked what my thoughts on emiram are we are ordeal on I do I see cinema I adored Iran has a great figure in Islam I do highly respect him I understand that he they they had disagreements amongst the Companions I actually kind of like the the statesmanship of mahalia's he was

1:59:05

incredibly astute and really knew how you know some people are cut out to rule and I would feel that Mario was one of those people that was cut out you know he's cut from that cloth like he knew how to rule and you can't deny that I mean in his 40 years of rulership he never within sham had an uprising against him like that's just amazing isn't it and I quoted the story once where he went past this he was going past this place and this lady was complaining and she's saying oh and she used to be really pro eilean auntie Maria and he said that I've heard your crops or

1:59:45

whatever and she said she was complaining that she didn't have the crops and things like this and he said so you want me to would you like me to assist you from the state fund to give you some and she said yeah okay and he said okay I'll give you and then he said to her he said you know if if it was ally he wouldn't give you because he would say no you know there's a certain system and I'm not gonna give you and and she says yeah that's because he's more just somehow he just laughs you

2:00:23

know you gotta love it though he kind of laughs and he says to the guy he says give her the crops and I just love that narration like the way I don't know it's it's it's amazing right people let's I think I've answered all the questions I know some people had sent some super chats and I did want to make sure I definitely obviously serving my cause I want to make sure I did respond to them well that's all it's letting me go back to and this here I've definitely answered Mark's question cool people I think let's get to the masala segment

2:01:03

people those of you that are aware right our beloved beloved so first of all those of you that don't know Chickasaw has had a debate people and he decided to debate a Christian and for the sake of Islam Allahu Akbar Allahu Akbar right and so first of all he really surprised me because in this debate he says things which he's kind of been trying to really have a go at me about and then just because he gets embarrassed in front of this Christian

2:01:41

he says the same things it's like it's so shocking so this Christian basically kind of bashes him a bit with all these insulting ridiculous hadith in Bukhari oh your child marriages are allowed this is allowed that is allowed and what is our beloved our beloved response look if you notice in the presentation not a single the Quran was quoted individual my interlocutor went straight on to the hadith that's like me not quoting the Bible to Christians and moving on to extra religious literature because

2:02:18

hadith is not above criticism even Sahil Bihari there is like you have criticism about even Sahil Bihari hadith literature when I report is solitary in its nature the text can be criticized by scholars even though they say sorry what they mean by Sahih is that the overall work is Shaheed Obama table you'll notice child marriage is prohibited in the Quran even though Hanafy allows it

2:02:50

but mashallah Bimbo's is speaking right I will come to that as we go on even is Hart's book is open to criticism like that the text of Buhari is open to criticism there are texts the text of Bukhari

2:03:30

yeah I know I know Kelly I honestly do not get what is going on why has he been criticizing me all this while for criticizing Buhari gets in front of a bunch of Christians and says what's wrong with criticizing Bihari gustaría Baba no no so people I'm really intrigued by the Lion of Allah Sunna and what the Lion of

2:04:08

Allah Sunnah did is to prove his claim that Islam is Islam is always a lease LOM ya lo Allah Allah Allah Islam is always on top people therefore to prove it what you're gonna bring some arguments oh yeah you're gonna write some books no yeah you can do some detailed analytic refutation I'm gonna drink poison huh I'm gonna walk

2:04:42

I'm gonna drink poison to prove it just drink the poison get a date it should help you rat poison people Allah Akbar Allah Allah rat poison people rat poison to prove

2:05:21

[Music] now we know that Islam is definitely the Huq Islam can only be the hub now because we're drinking rat poison Allah Akbar this we've now found it people

2:05:41

look here it is this is who can it be this rat poison this is how we prove the

2:06:18

validity of Islam from there I honestly honestly I cannot believe this is how ridiculously absurd people have become first of all I want to say that I mean that by the way this was nothing but drama that wasn't actually real rat poison and what's happened is sharehouse are are didn't realize this was gonna go viral and then when he went viral you had some idiots praising him so he felt too embarrassed to backtrack so he's now just pretended to go with it without kind of fully affirming he just said look we shouldn't really concern ourselves let's talk about the debate

2:06:57

don't worry forgetting the fact that one it's Haram to drink poison to as an influential figure who many people follow including many young people to drink rat poison to prove the veracity vert ability and truthfulness of Islam so tomorrow some other idiots are gonna say that mashallah mashallah I have got the proof the proof is here Allah Allah and then you're gonna get some idiots

2:07:36

that are gonna either cause near-death experiences or die natural selection I guess but this was so irresponsible I mean what kind of proof is that anyway that Islam is the the strongest religion why because why because we're going to drink rat poison so this were some of the tweets and

2:08:08

Kalandar always I love his is posed as rat so from now on Hazrat ass are are right and there was this one may who Qadri Sunni Ratatat right so people this by the way so this is those of you who don't know my beloved Millau head has a rat this is a cerrar rat visa rat Rattus

2:08:46

I've got visa up a cha-cha-cha today all rata a cha-cha lettuce it'll look like they're at Busan Eagle Nagano Busan again so this is the what we've got here what this has come to people so this so today to prove the vertebrate II of Islam to prove people which denomination within

2:09:24

Islam uh as what we saw him obviously I'm taking into me the spirit of Ezra has wrapped a sorority rat we Sahib I'm gonna have a debate today right here I want to know I want to prove which denomination so as a representative of Wahhabi Islam

2:09:54

this is a different note we Sahib what we type right we've got a rat V a chef at Lee let's share a rectory is here he'll helter culo and the Hadiya here beta or Haram or silk lack ma'am we're gonna have a debate who who is upon the hawk so how are we gonna answer this whoa wait a minute people what is release I'm saying I found it you know this wasn't easy this was not easy

2:10:31

people but the infamous guidelines to having a debate the famous text The Lost text of the Rashida that everybody's been looking for the right sheedia people the rat CD I found it this was it all along you want to debate with the Rasheed no not the Rasheed ear not the Rasheed ear I can't debate using the Rashid er you must debate with the Rashid ear

2:11:05

oh yeah this is why she has rod oh this rat Lisa I've wanted the Rashidi it was so hard finding this honestly I eventually found it in Zara's bedroom amongst her books it was the rat she dear people I found it but it doesn't stop there I can't I'm sorry I cannot debate with the Ratched not anything but there a idea please it must be I've got a better

2:11:42

method people I've got a better method for this Wahhabi rat Lisa hip it is poison we will whoever is upon the hawk must drink the poison no I want the right Indian know the true claim is with

2:12:07

poison Allah I'm not gonna die alone you bet this this is the ridiculous nature [Laughter] that's this is what Islam has got - this

2:12:47

is my my little counterpart right we saw him somewhere at least I was sitting back there is the napkin it's come off right beside you sit right there so look look how preposterous this has got people it's come down to this has come down to how do we know something is the truth will drink rat poison can you imagine the armies in the past if they

2:13:25

had her to be sahibs logic it would be like oh no guys they've got a huge army it's well-prepared and the army comes and they go we are right in our claim and you're like well no I think we're riding they like to prove it we will all drink rat poison and you go oh wait what ok then half an hour later the Army's dead and you're like oh thanks well well

2:14:04

right guys ok I guess I guess intelligence common sense isn't as common as we thought [Laughter] right so the thing is this look so some people have said what about harlot bin walid robbie lon first of all there isn't a single Sahih hadith that holid bin Walid drank poison not a single SIA DEET there's these few nations in tabarani and a few of the text the Muslims of Ahmed and others and what do they mention who is transmitting them you've got them from who's

2:14:42

transmitting them Abu suffer and and people who never they've never met Holly bin Walid in their lives all the narrator say these are more cell rewired these people transmitting never met holid Khalid ib'n Alwaleed in his entire life and the other narration that they present it comes through Sophia Anna banana and ananna it comes through a smile who's actually been slated and then they say there's a Rabi Pi Sigma B has him who has met Holly bin Walid allegedly described as Mukul hadith among Carol hadith this person is unacceptable in rewire rewired

2:15:21

so many people have problematised him from the Maha thene these chains are not sahi so you bring about an incident that okay people have just used it to praise Halloween Walid over the past and as a story folklore it's kind of come down fine and if it were true if it were true that in his time somebody presented any drunky first of all that's his action maybe he drank something which he knew wasn't and and somebody but these things are usually just stories Holly's bin Walid Roddy Alon was much

2:16:00

more intelligent than that okay he wasn't somebody like you know just absurd or somebody that was irrational had no knowledge wasn't strategic he didn't have you know to say I know the way we'll settle this is here's your poison I'll drink it then I'm dead or in this case I'm not but I could have been dead even though the skull is all say it's Haram to drink poison so this rewire of a boo surfer of Halloween really is not sorry it is not sorry bring me and a chain

2:16:38

that has not been criticized that is SIA stands up to the test it doesn't exist it's not in any of the major books of hadith right not in not in the sahi hain or whatever and things like that it there is a rewire in most of our but then I've shown it's not even connected and it's problematized and in tabarani who brings all kinds of absurd narrations secondly even if even if somebody in the past did something like this let's say they did let's say let's just say hypothetically eight hundred years ago there was a man who with a Christian said you know if your religion is the true one let's jump into this

2:17:17

fire and they call this mobile Allah and they used to do this with cardi unease and other people as well so they would say whosoever you know whoever's religion is the truthful one God save them you let

2:19:50

me just hello hello you hello hello is that back is that back people can you hear it I think what happened is I is that okay no sound is the sound back audio gone audio gone still gone

2:20:20

still no audio it's working okay damn so what I was saying is I was saying that there was the poet who says that ba da da ba da that alcohol is still alcohol hum to say her BP giant eel I would even drink poison shirt oh yeah hey hey honey ba home is symbolically the condition is that

2:21:01

it's in in her arms and I was saying that in our 3 subs version that would be people are saying there's still no sound it's coming a sound from here now damn what is going on this still no sound it's showing me a

2:21:34

sound output right now it's showing me a sound output I don't seem to it's saying I'm definitely having sound output here I can even see the we can't hear you it's okay some people are saying from the mobile holla jumping it's fine okay are a-okay shukran so I was saying about the mubahala that look this whole thing about in the in the past you couldn't you know even if somebody did jump into

2:22:12

some fire right this doesn't mean that today you would do that that's just stupid even if there was a figure 500 years ago he said you know what if whichever religion is correct what we're gonna do is both of us are gonna go out there and face this I don't know volcano erupting even if somebody said that that's absurd for you to do it because this Deen is one that is built on reason is that how people will outdo each other improving the variability the truthfulness of their

2:22:50

religions that I know will drink poison whosoever survives survives that's just crazy and and that's what I was there I was saying in that poem that the shark tak ba home is some holic we that I would drink alcohol Bushido others--is k ba de Tejada Z her BB Janka sorry cat else's cattle Jeff I am there BP giant cat ill that our rat we sobs version would be like his version would be that ba da to her body her BP giant cattle shot oh yay hey hey Rashida go Sam

2:23:28

Holloway somebody must just take care of the Rashida attacks that's all and I was mentioning that you know really this this book he so right it's really it's changed my life it's everything has just changed since I've got the regime blimey I'm a new person you guys don't know what you're missing out on I mean this rat CD a book ah I mean is is life even worth living

2:24:06

if you haven't read the rats idea I mean just it's it's it's I mean there you can see this this rocker meerkat kind of entertaining the hyena it's just

2:24:29

emotional this is I write so people I think this this it's been amazing it's really gone on so long I really was I just found this this how drinking poison things so absurd and I'm shocked at individuals who are really celebrating as he's a true Wally of Allah why

2:25:04

because he has drank poison and so he didn't die the warrior ah there's the little sword huh sword you you you so I think this this is the and now you're gonna get some idiots who are gonna actually try this probably you know so as a responsible person seriously that that this safeguarding concerns how can a person who is a figurehead do something like

2:25:43

this live because there's so many you know pretend and it was drama honestly he was lying I'm telling you and this is even worse because now the Christians will say that oh this is all your religion is it's just full of charlatans you know all you do and they're gonna say that's what your prophet did as well and this this is my point is so stupid and a sorority Sahib just didn't think this was gonna go as viral as it did and now he's kind of stuck and so he's pretended to without directly saying it just pretend that it was real

2:26:21

so yeah what's the the poet says that her more familiar to him her more familiar to him Dada Hazara shiet marry busty Madhukar body and this is all it was people Norton key that's all it was ah hi or at Wiess I've know tanky not anchor [ __ ] not nice you know this is

2:26:59

no tanky I am naughty naughty no tanky guys I think you know what all right so I think all we allowed planned childbirth through IVF planned childbirth birth you I believe IVF is permissible and things like this are permissible hey Shar maybe not Ottawa as a transmitter is problematic you have to be a bit weary of him right what do I reckon about hasanat and

2:27:36

sister Sarah I've seen those videos that have gone out kind of I mean so much drama I don't get honestly don't know what's happening with them I people share these viral clips I see it on one of them discussing we're back and she's back and then they've got I think he's exposing her because he's got a video of a clubbing you know just so we can see your Rupe this this Roop Sunohara it so just in case people think he our quadruple e ya

2:28:13

pyaar ki so he's made of he's made of clip which I'm I I don't know whether he's liek the clip himself they've had some teeth or not I don't know they trauma yeah I can't keep up with it but but yeah so sista yes sister I don't know why people call I don't call women sisters anyway I mean it's not it's not my and I'm not really the incest thing ain't really my thing people love you and leave you I think this we've gone on so much we've discussed today taking a look at the a droid a to take a look at

2:28:51

some other complex issues we've gone over the the commentaries by scholars like Al Missouri Missouri we've taken a look at the further issue what was the history what is faith the verses of the Quran the disagreements between the companions we've looked at our sorority sahib and his bravery improving al hamdulillah you know i had a bit of doubts about islam but once i saw him drink poison III isn't there isn't a single doubt left now I mean atheism destroyed guys

2:29:30

it's been awesome so with that I think we'll wrap it up if there are any issues any questions do reach out to me Instagram you can message me I do get back to people's messages I haven't there's a log on Facebook I've got a backlog but on Instagram I do usually respond quite quickly so do reach out to me if there's anything I'll try and respond other than that remember mean your kind eyes take very good care of yourselves people Salam aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakato sugar and for really hanging out all this for putting up with these two hours

2:30:08

of my mania whatever is much love mashallah salam o aleikum wa rahmatullah wa barakato and and those of you that haven't yet subscribed I'm at a loss of words right so

Something wrong here?

Tell us what is wrong and it will be checked against the recording. Nothing changes until a person has reviewed it.

Sending a note needs JavaScript, which is off or unavailable in this browser. Nothing has been sent.

No name, email address or account is asked for or stored, and the inbox does not store your IP address. For rate limiting it keeps an unreadable fingerprint of your connection for 48 hours, and our database provider's own logs record connections as every website's do. Only your note, its kind, the page and the moment in the recording are kept, for review.

Cite this recording

Stable id, transcript version and tier are part of the citation. Every change to a transcript is logged.

Mufti Abu Layth Archive, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/doopcx2-5zs/ (accessed 1 November 2026)

APA 7
Mufti Abu Layth. (2020, February 25). Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth 153 [Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors]. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Retrieved November 1, 2026, from https://muftiabulayth.org/r/doopcx2-5zs/
Chicago author-date
Mufti Abu Layth. 2020. "Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth 153." Video, auto-transcribed, may contain errors. Mufti Abu Layth Archive. Recorded February 25, 2020. Accessed November 1, 2026. https://muftiabulayth.org/r/doopcx2-5zs/
BibTeX
@misc{abulayth-DOOPCx2-5zs,
  author = {Mufti Abu Layth},
  title = {{Monday Nights with Mufti Abu Layth 153}},
  year = {2020},
  month = {2},
  date = {2020-02-25},
  howpublished = {\url{https://muftiabulayth.org/r/doopcx2-5zs/}},
  url = {https://muftiabulayth.org/r/doopcx2-5zs/},
  organization = {Mufti Abu Layth Archive},
  urldate = {2026-11-01},
  note = {Auto-transcribed, may contain errors}
}