Reply to Sunni (Wahhabi) Defence Pt. IV -Mufti Abu Layth

right so some people have asked me to respond to they've asked me to respond to Sony defense right so I'm going to give a slight summary and then just respond to them and then move back to some of the questions we've got here just to summarize suddenly defense or Wahhabi defense as they are a back again our good old friend Baba Farid Oh Dean

Gangu Teli is back those of you who tuned in previously and so my reputations of him well Gangu Teli is now back that's freedom Baba Farid Dean Gangu Teli of a hobby defense and some people said look in your previous reputations trying to defend him they said that look you know how do you say these things about them they never really have said anything disrespectful or blasphemous against the Prophet and that's not true and they said that you need to justify this kind of claim that

you said and I'll play look the first thing that they actually said this was their first refutation against me right so they I mean what's wrong with them getting sick and getting sexually impotent really is that like a criteria for him being a prophet this was the Sunni defense first refutation against me not what's wrong with the Prophet being sexually impotent that is it a criteria of his prophethood that he has to be sexually active this

is the ridiculous blasphemous Wahhabi nudge the kind of attitude that we're dealing with so you can already see so that's not you know when somebody said to me that oh you know you're you're you know you said this about these people and they've never anything like that that's not running around naked so people could see his testicles maybe and you know what he said is that the profit he said you know you guys believe that the profit was so

incapable that you put black magic and and then he has this other one as well where he's saying they that they use you that he's attack like he's criticizing that I'm criticizing these hadith that in bihari that prophet that the prophet Moses run around naked so people can see his testicles and they're defending like they're saying like what's his problem criticizing that light and then they go on to say and this is on YouTube this is the thing on YouTube it isn't even my

thing this is the kind of ridiculous blasphemous kind of a hobby defense that they are that and they then coming and attacking obviously they were attacking and attack people like me so this guy one of the key people amongst them Fareed who I referred to in one of our previous sessions as Baba Farid Athene Gangu Teli so Gangu Teli saab the iranian person is back now and look i

want to make something clear Gangu Teli sahib no cemaat if you can inter bail of cemaat right if you can just pay attention right instead of going on about me being a juror he'll me not knowing this me not knowing this even though i first of all all those criticisms are refuted because they do a cut-and-paste job they're just stupid I'm trying to say oh look a slip of the word here oh he said Oh

he leads a day he must be Antichrist must be at the jail ha ha stop running away this same topic that he's trying to defend marital rape he's trying to say that the Prophet said that a woman has no right to refuse sex to a husband this hadith only comes down predominantly the chains I've quoted come down through our mesh through Qatada metallocene stop running away with this nonsense bring me

one sahih hadith one sahih hadith that cannot be criticized one Jah Jah stop this I'm if I'm such a jackal then you should be able to bring one hadith bring one then we'll talk bring one hadith forget all this trying to distract Nana na ma I know these tactics is nudge the tactics of yours blaspheming people hateful carry hatred against the prophets stop all this nonsense bring me one saya deed since I'm a

jackal since I'm at the jail I'm a jockey llama know what I'm talking about bring me one at ease about this that justifies this rape from the Prophet that cannot be criticized I will rip and show you where that hadith carries weakness and Ilyn bring me one do not run away from this question do not change the topic bring one hadith one hadith and if you need if you need help go go to you or am i of nudged get them together compile them get them gather

them together and tell them to help you bring one hadith that justifies this marital rape going back to the Prophet that cannot be criticized then we can speak bring one since I'm going on about me being agile me be Jah heel or not is irrelevant this kind of blasphemy is not attributed to our prophet salallahu alayhi wasalam you bring me one hadith one hadith that I can that cannot be criticized the chain the chain I'm talking about show me one hadith stop trying to change

the discussion change the topic oh he doesn't know so look man allotment I use his name son Emmanuel homage and the point I was making there was actually about Shah Baba and yes if trying to distract this topic by saying oh by posing a video my point in that clip he brings this clip and saying oh he doesn't know Salman my point in that was simply to say because Shah Baba if somebody who claims that lease is Haram he claims that leases around people might say oh sure but is in this chain so this ought to be ok but the person transmitting from him is problematic

that was the point which he conveniently pauses by the way forget all of this oh yeah I am added earlier he'll I don't know these anybody who studied hadith you know I must Allah Allah Hadees for one week knows more than mostly abu less well well fine bring one hadith 101 hobbies one don't change the Tauri don't run away Marah well that's a little key lap like this don't touch like round and round

like these dogs do right that's an Arabic Ibarra don't do that bring one hadith ok don't distract either you dirty knob article yeah but our cake offal oculata Mucha resinous a colonic eatery referee Kesava don't tell me about this so that or whatever you explain how this Caravan got robbed huh it's not about the thieves or the robbers or the bandits how are you a leader of this caravan that is

what the poet says so either order keen about the car here but our kickoff a lacuna you bring me one hadith and then we'll talk and if you've got if if you've got the nerve to tries to my challenge after that this is a challenge by the way Chilean brother my nerdy brother is a challenge so if you can first of all rise to this bring me one handy that should be easy that cannot be criticized bring it bring it hard to

burhanakum in kuntum Saudi team sitting right here as Mawlana units no money said amazing person may Allah have mercy on his soul Aman artheon from Pakistan said either they are we sitting right here yeah yeah yeah not going in you bring one honey and then rise to my second challenge prove to me that soil Bihari can be traced back to its author prove it this this one above your paygrade

my friend this on you and all you can you can gather the whole of war ha be dumb and put it together and ra won't you be harmonical take this one big challenge this one big problem you know Gangu Teli see big problem problem you know so I'm waiting so first bring me a sahih hadith secondly prove to me how

can you prove to me beyond reasonable doubt sahib hari going back to its its author but go back Imam Bihari can you prove it can you prove it hell no you can't what my new scripts are you gonna prove it from hmm Sylvania based on the Uni Nia oh ho ho the Sun Tanya which is people for your information which based a lot of what it did on the Sun on the Uni Nia of you've

gotta have between you Nene and barley and humbly from the 788 century he passes away but we don't have a manuscript even of the Union here we have a phone from his somebody who copied it from him did he make a mistake is that what we're going by and then the Union ear which disagrees with the others Murray Wyatt and what is he going through a homily is he disagreeing with most family is disagreeing with the other ari Wyatt of surrogacy is disagreeing with I'm terribly what about

February I mean why didn't nobody consider him reliable in hadith up until hundreds of years after him based on big problem why does Muslim Ellie say that for every had a copy of Buhari which was incomplete and he hadn't part of it was somewhere I were incomplete and we used to move them around which was endorsed by a Berber Lidl bhurji and pastelon e s muy interesante and what is up will either body say about a little body says that it's interesting Muslim Lee says canna in the whole Auslan and toss a

human he had one copy we all used to copy from and yet they all very different and then the interesting case of Salani Oh Marty that you may see sir Ernie's another person comes hundreds of years after who claims to have the actual copy of robbery ha ha ha ha honey so Ernie was born in Lahore he was actually sir he was a Hanafy scholar born in Lahore and he claimed to have found an actual copy hundreds of years after for robbery by the way nobody else has seen this copy

he claims he obviously loved lot and he goes he goes ma I found an actual copy and then his copy has rara it which none of the other copies of Bihari have la salle on Eva and so this one big problem you know where is this where is this what how do we prove this one you know how do we prove this movie so I still eagerly await a eagerly await so these are challenges first of all to the Wahhabi defence team and then by

extension to anybody who wants to play Sahil Bihari as a god and to make Allah and His Messenger revolve around Saahil Bihari they need to prove this actually belongs to him and Bihari to start off with can see what they didn't tell you is they told you from Imam Bihari to the Prophet what they didn't tell you is how this book then comes to us because all of the transmitters of Maharis the copies seem to disappear mystery one person remains for a brief who seems to

be unknown by his contemporaries but 200 years later somebody says what a guy somebody 200 years later besides some Hani says this for every great but before him no news we don't know you know who this Ferrari we know who but we nobody validate nobody vouching for him so we got so this one big problem and then the copies that go throughout the world all disagree with themselves hadith missing hadith les patched together we've got

cut and paste job going on how many hands are copying we've got no idea his own probably student saying by the way he his copy was incomplete we used to move things around in it we used to place chapter headings all this nonsense about Bo Hardy's fifties in his chapter headings more suddenly says we used to make some people somebody might ask here what is that why am i opening these kind of worms to do with body and

this isn't just Bihari the other books as well by the way Sahib Muslim and these have problems as well because I saw Muslim is based on the Istanbul transcript which has its own problems but right now we want to focus on body because the reason I'm doing this is to show we need to return to the methodology that was taught to us by Imam Malik and Imam Malik tortoise in his motto he taught us through faith this was the practice of Medina he taught us that we will never be sound in this Deen until

we learn to accept and reject honey so you must accept some and you must reject some this is the way this is the balanced path of this Ummah in my Malik places and Ethan is more tough and says we don't accept this hadith Imam Malik himself says if you start accepting everyone after one of these isolated narrations he says the entire Dean will be snatched from me this is the teaching of Imam Malik the other interesting thing is that the

Dean who was already preserved through that how you practice Islam was already preserved and is this an attempt somebody may say well why don't we just get rid of all of Hadi the question is hadith contain a lot of useful detail that add color to this theme and they are important and we know through corroboration that not all hadith are false we know that because they corroborate through independent sources and they fit in with the Quranic teachings with the

principles of Islam so if hadith come to us and the hadith are about simply about rules and things like these or how to practice Islam if they do not go against reason as if nor Josie and all these scholars before us in hadith had said if nizam that they do not clash with reason they do not go against the Quran they do not go against are the clear sources that have been transmitted the corroborated sooner sooner that has come through like the Amal of Almudena and Imam Malik oh that has been preserved through faith or

through corroborated hadith and they do not approve a principle of Islam then they have no problem okay they have no problem otherwise it is a problem and we need to take them with a pinch of salt okay because some of these Deen in some of these hadith insult Islam and they cannot be authentic so okay so